|
Part IV Should Anyone Be Blamed For The Aberfan Disaster? (cont.) Section B — Conclusions as to Liability 3. The Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council 244. We have seen that as early as January, 1944, the Borough Council was concerning itself with the stability of the Merthyr Mountain tip complex (see ante, paragraphs 86-88). It has also been observed that in September, 1950, in response to an enquiry by the Borough Engineer, the Board gave the assurance, "We are . . . constantly checking the position of all these tips" (see ante, paragraph 92). Again, in 1959, just a year after Tip 7 was begun, the Town Clerk sought a meeting with the Board regarding ". . . the potential danger of the above tip at Aberfan". In 1960 he informed them that, "Concern has been expressed that the Tip could slide after heavy rainfall" and the Board again gave assurances that no danger existed but undertook to consider the matter and write later. 245. On July 24th, 1963, there began the correspondence between the Borough Engineer's Department and Mr. D. L. Roberts headed "Danger from Coal Slurry being tipped at the rear of the Pantglas Schools", which continued up to March of the following year (see ante, paragraphs 112-127). We have considered at length elsewhere the contents of these letters, the circumstances which gave rise to them, and the manner in which they were regarded by author and recipient alike. Mr. Wien, Q.C., rightly conceded that the language employed in the letters sent by the Council was such that they should have led to some investigation by the Board. On the other hand, as we have said, we are satisfied that when they were sent their author, Mr. Bradley, entertained real fears that Tip 7 might slip for a substantial distance and that there was even a risk that it might invade the village. On March 11th, 1964, at a meeting of the Town Planning Committee when the question of a projected aerial ropeway was discussed, the fears expressed by Council representatives that tipping higher up the mountain might induce instability in the existing tips was met by the ridiculous tier-tipping plan there and then advanced by Mr. McInnes for the National Coal Board which we have felt it right to denounce elsewhere in this Report (see ante paragraphs 148-151). And it must not be overlooked that the Committee was insistent that no further tipping of tailings would be permitted. 246. The Attorney-General invited the Tribunal to consider three questions in relation to the Borough Council:
247. Mr. Ackner, Q.C., urged upon us that each of these three questions should be answered in a manner adverse to the Borough Council. He submitted that, apart from a couple of letters during 1965, they did nothing after the "Danger" correspondence ended on March 19th, 1964, to keep in touch with the Board over the question of stability of the tip. He sought to explain this alleged failure of the Council by saying that, ". . . as the tips overshadowed, towered above, and indeed dwarfed the village, so did the National Coal Board the Council. Those whose function and duty it was to look after the welfare of the inhabitants of Aberfan no doubt discharged that function admirably in all other respects, but in regard to this matter, in relation to the National Coal Board, they were not big enough for the job". Assuming that further action was called for from the Council, there can be no doubt of its capacity and ability to take it. This is in no sense restricted to the power of prosecuting and defending legal proceedings for the protection of the interests of inhabitants conferred by Section 276 of the Local Government Act, 1933. Without ever resorting to law, a Borough Council has an enormous capacity to express itself in effective protest in a wide variety of ways if it considers that the safety or health of its inhabitants is endangered. 248. We are not here concerned to consider the respective attractions or defects of proceeding by way of a relator action, or by invoking the Town and Country Planning legislation, or by a summons for nuisance, topics which took up much time during the Inquiry. We repeat, if more were indeed properly called for by the circumstances than the Council did, there was more that it could have done. Indeed, this was to an extent conceded by Mr. Alun Davies, Q.C., in saying: "Naturally, the local authority can make representations to whomsoever it pleases, but in making those representations it is governed by the fundamental character of its being, namely that it is an elected body. In doing so it mirrors the feelings and expressions of the people it represents. If there is no further demand for a certain course of action not prescribed as a legal duty, the local authority takes this course at its peril, and particularly when such a course may — or may not — jeopardise the daily bread of its people". But the absence of popular demand for action, or the fear that action might lead to economic hardship, cannot either singly or in combination justify inaction if thereby health and safety were, in the opinion of the Council and its officers, imperilled. The only relevant questions are: In all the circumstances as they were known to the Council and its officers, ought they to have done more than they did about the Aberfan tip complex? And, if they ought, did their inaction contribute to the disaster? 249. These questions have been anxiously considered by the Tribunal. The Council would look to its officials for guidance and it is the conduct of the Borough Engineers which has mainly concerned us. Mr. Alun Davies, Q.C., goes too far when he says that, "To each criticism, however trivial, a full and proper answer has been made". With fears of a slide being expressed so strongly to and by Council members, with the impact of these fears upon Mr. Bradley (the Deputy Borough Engineer) being so weighty that he in turn shared them and therefore initiated in the name of the Borough Engineer the strongly worded correspondence with the Area Mechanical Engineer which we have already considered, it is to be regretted that neither he nor the Borough Engineer took the trouble ever to inspect the Aberfan tip complex even when the flooding problem was being discussed a few hundred yards away in the village. Their inactivity is to be contrasted with the activity of an earlier Borough Engineer, Mr. Marshall. When fears of tip stability arose in 1944, he not only corresponded with the National Coal Board but twice visited the locus, and so secured some action by the Board. Both the Borough Engineer and his Deputy are professionally qualified (Mr. Jones a municipal engineer, Mr. Bradley a civil engineer) and had they inspected at any time after the November, 1963, slide they could not have failed to see on the mountainside such stigmata of danger as fully justified the fears which had been expressed. By such an inspection they would have been reminded that nestling on the slope of the mountain just below the tip were the Hafod Tanglwys cottages, the very existence of which each of them in turn told the Tribunal he had overlooked, but which were later to contain the first victims of the disaster. Both are obviously able and conscientious men and doubtless each now bitterly regrets his failure to inspect. 250. But they must not be condemned on hindsight, either by themselves or by the Tribunal. Granted that they did not act with the highest diligence, did they fall so greatly and so inexcusably short of it that, in the light of the circumstances as they saw them, they should now be held to have played a blameworthy part in bringing about the disaster? Having reflected upon this question with the care demanded by its gravity (both from the public and the private points of view) the conclusion we have come to is that the question should be answered in the negative. As early as 1957 they had written to the Welsh Office of the Ministry of Housing and Local Government expressing the Borough Engineer's opinion "that both on the grounds of amenity and stability the tipping area should not be extended", and they received no enlightening help from that quarter. They gave strong and repeated warnings to the Board and they received assurances that all was well and that their complaints were being attended to. Believing, as they were justified in believing, that tailings made for tip instability, they secured a promise that the tipping of tailings would be stopped, and (though with some delay) it was indeed stopped. The continuance of the years-old flooding of Aberfan should have aroused their suspicion that all was not well, but again they had the assurances of high-ranking National Coal Board personnel that nothing was wrong with the stability of the tip. When asked whether he thought that the tips had been examined by anybody other than a mechanical engineer, Mr. D. C. W. Jones told the Tribunal: "I had assumed that they would be examined by people competent to examine tips and even the Inspector of Mines. I took it for granted that this was so". He added that he had it in mind that the National Coal Board were using experts, such as civil engineers, to inspect the tips. Of this assumption, Mr. Alun Davies, Q.C., had this to say: ". . . Perhaps the natural mistake made by the Merthyr Corporation was that it accepted the opinions of the experts of this organisation at their own valuation. Little did the Corporation realise how empty were the assurances given by their experts, but in my submission this cannot be blameworthy conduct as between responsible men". 251. Three elected members of the Council, Messrs. Tudor, McGinty and J. Williams, gave evidence about the complaints which they had received and the action which they and their colleagues had taken. We also heard from many witnesses of the considerable part played by the late Councillor Mrs. Gwyneth Williams and of the vigour with which she expressed the fears which she and her husband entertained of the tip's sliding down into the village. That their fears were somewhat allayed in the way described by learned counsel serves not only to underline the blameworthiness of the National Coal Board but also to indicate, as we think, the right attitude to adopt in relation to the Borough Council and its officers. In all the circumstances, we do not think that it should be said that by blameworthy omissions they contributed to the disaster.
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||