Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
Index

Part IV

Should Anyone Be Blamed For The Aberfan Disaster? (cont.)

Section A — History

2. The 1944 Slide of Tip 4

83. In 1933 the Welsh Associated Collieries started Tip 4. This was a conical tip, created by a conveyor taking waste to the tip apex and there depositing it by a MacLean tippler. This entailed erecting a steel tower in the place intended to become the centre of the proposed new tip. An engine wound the trains of coalrefuse to a parting and they were then hauled by a winch at ground level to a see-saw tipping device which rotated and tipped the refuse and so built up the tip in the form of a cone. We heard no evidence as to whether any investigation of the site was carried out before it was started, but it seems that no drainage work was done, despite the fact that, once it had been decided to erect the steel tower where it was placed, it was inevitable that the tip must eventually spread over the source of a stream were it to grow to any substantial size. In 1935 the Merthyr Vale Colliery was acquired by the Powell Duffryn Company. The two-year-old tip was probably not of any great size at that time, and the new owners continued to work it for the following nine years, during two of which (1940-42) Mr. Geoffrey Morgan was the Colliery Manager.

84. On 27th October, 1944, a large portion of Tip 4 slid down the mountainside for a considerable distance, Prof. Nash estimating that some of it travelled as much as 1,800 feet. This was an incident of considerable significance. Its effect was plainly visible right up to the disaster of October, 1966. The extremities of the slip stopped only some 5-600 feet from the disused Glamorgan Canal and the concavity in the face of the tip is to be seen to this day and is similar to that left in Tip 7 immediately after the disaster (see Plates 3 and 6). The events leading up to it are of importance despite the fact that they occurred in the pre-nationalisation era.

85. There are good grounds for thinking that Tip 4 gave rise to trouble even before the big slide of 1944. An aerial photograph taken in August, 1945, discloses features indicating that before the big slide it had already assumed a most unusually irregular shape, running south-eastwards at its foot and showing that it was beginning to bulge in the same direction as that later taken by the big slide. This has led Mr. Lawrence Scott, a chartered surveyor, to wonder ". . . whether there had been a previous collapse of Tip 4 before the (1944) collapse". Professor Nash is in no doubt about the matter and expressed the view that, "It is evident from . . . (the) photograph taken in August, 1945, that Tip 4, which had suffered a major collapse the previous November, was not a perfect cone prior to the slide, i.e. a movement which distorted the base had already taken place". The result would have been that a slip surface was created over which material was subsequently tipped. As we shall see (post paragraph 128), the same sequence later took place in Tip 7, a slip surface being created by a big slide in 1963 upon which material continued to be tipped and which played a fatal part in inducing the disaster slide. Thus in the case of Tip 4 as well as Tip 7 the ultimate failure was along a pre-existing shear surface.

86. The foregoing goes far to explain the report rendered in January, 1944, by the then Merthyr Tydfil Borough Engineer that:

"The [No. 4 Tip], which has assumed rather large proportions, is situated between two streams flowing down the mountainside, but there does not appear to be any interference with the free flow of the waters therein. I have, however, ascertained that owing to some cause — probably heavy rainfall — one or two large movements of the tip have occurred, but not sufficiently severe to cause any damage. The site of the tip in question is undoubtedly water-laden to some considerable degree, as I observed in a few places what appeared to be surface water emanating from the toe of the slope, which would indicate that the land, before being tipped upon, was of a boggy nature . . . I consider this matter is sufficiently important for a Sub-Committee to be appointed to visit the site with a view to making an examination of the conditions as they exist, and at the same time requesting the Colliery Committee to appoint . . . representatives to discuss the matter when they meet".

87. Accordingly, in February, 1944, a Sub-Committee met on the site representatives of the Powell Duffryn Company, including Mr. Geoffrey Morgan, who had left Merthyr Vale two years earlier to become Colliery Agent and who in due course became Production Director of the South Western Division of the National Coal Board. The Colliery officials then assured the Sub-Committee that there was no immediate danger, but that they felt it necessary to take certain steps to obviate risks. These involved digging a trench to the south and south-west of Tip 4 and laying, higher up the mountain, the foundations for a new MacLean tip (which eventually became Tip 5). The work was indeed carried out, but, as will appear, it proved useless to prevent a slide in Tip 4 or the development of a degree of instability in Tip 5.

88. Despite the Company's assurance given in February, on 21st November of that same year a substantial portion of Tip 4 slid away right from the top of the cone and ended up some 5-600 feet from the canal bank, carrying away growing trees and tearing away at least 4 feet of the subsoil. The Colliery Manager, Mr. Titus Davies, had never seen anything like it and was so troubled that he called in the Colliery agent (Mr. Geoffrey Morgan). The latter was "greatly concerned" by what he saw. He nevertheless informed the Borough Council in the following month that the drainage works he had had carried out earlier in the year had "prevented the tip movement from assuming serious proportions", that the slip had been due "to the very abnormal rainfall" (a view which Mr. Morgan has since abandoned in favour of subsidence as the probable cause), and that there would be no further tipping on Tip 4. Nor, indeed, could there have been, for the slide had rendered impossible any further use of the MacLean tippler. Apparently, no-one troubled to investigate why it had slipped, but a completely adequate explanation was to hand. In the opinion of Mr. D. P. Davies, a chartered surveyor, before it slipped the wholly undrained tip had so grown that it covered about 400 feet of a totally unculverted stream. No further explanation need be sought.

89. It is difficult to exaggerate the importance of this slide in 1944. To all who had eyes to see, it provided a constant and vivid reminder (if any were needed) that tips built on slopes can and do slip and, having once started, can and do travel long distances. Mr. Geoffrey Morgan, while denying (in common with the vast majority of the witnesses) any appreciation of the possibility that a tip slide could ever reach Aberfan village, conceded that". . . once a tip of considerable proportions on a mountainside does slip, it is impossible to predict how far it will reach". And, as Mr. Philip Owen Q.C. (for Powell Duffryn) rightly observed:

"The mere fact that it did not come down into the village, although that is of course of importance, does not dispose of the position (sic) at all. Had somebody been upon the mountain, or indeed upon the tip when this happened, the fact of its having moved at all inevitably and obviously is a matter of seriousness."

With this constant reminder of what had happened, ordinary prudence demanded that, while the precise cause of the 1944 slide remained unknown, it would be folly to tip on the same mountainside (and a fortiori even nearer the village) without first making a thorough site investigation. As Mr. Gareth Jones, Divisional Civil Engineer said:

"I would want to know why Tip 4 slipped. I would want to know what the soil was and the depth of the boulder clay, and possibly the water table in the area. I would not approve of tipping on that site unless the results of such an investigation were all favourable."

Yet, as we shall see, that is precisely the folly which was later perpetrated — to the knowledge of the Colliery Agent and many others. The truth is that the lesson of the 1944 slide was brought home to very few. Although the broken shape of Tip 4 is to be seen to this day, Mr. Leigh, H. M. Inspector of Mines, had no knowledge of the 1944 slip until after the disaster. And although Mr. D. L. J. Powell had frequently visited the colliery and naturally again went there when the disaster occurred, he actually told the Tribunal that it was not until after our sittings began that he first learnt that there had been any slip in 1944.

90. As well as acting as a warning, the slide of 1944 is important for its physical results. "I think there is no doubt that the slide of Tip 4 did cover an original stream" said Mr. Geoffrey Morgan, and he agreed that, as a result, for "some hundreds of yards . . . an essential natural drainage watercourse of the mountain was destroyed". Furthermore, it is a matter of almost common agreement that it was unwise to tip any material on top of that which had slipped from Tip 4. Had this consideration been observed, it would have severely limited the use of Tip 7 and would virtually have prevented its proceeding beyond the southern extremity of Tip 3. Yet tipping proceeded on Tip 7 regardless of the fact that the material was being deposited on and across the material which had slipped away from Tip 4 in 1944.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page


mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z