|
Part IV Should Anyone Be Blamed For The Aberfan Disaster? (cont.) Section A — History 3. Tip 5 and allied topics 91. Although some preparation for a new tip west of Tip 4 had been made before the latter slipped in 1944, it was immediately thereafter that Tip 5 became the sole working tip. This was during the period of ownership of the Merthyr Vale Colliery by the Powell Duffryn Co. Higher up the mountain than Tip 4, Tip 5 again had no proper drainage system — indeed, it was tipped right over the single, open, drainage trench which Mr. Geoffrey Morgan, the Colliery Agent, had shortly before caused to be cut in the hillside, he being the person responsible for taking the tipping higher up the mountain. True to pattern, therefore, Tip 5 began to bulge to the South-East, just as Tip 4 had done. When exactly this bulging process began was not ascertained. It is not discernible in an aerial photograph taken in April, 1947, that is, just after nationalisation, but by May, 1951, the bulge had became very marked. It was, as one witness put it a very big bulge . . . due to a slip". Why this occurred is, like the far greater slip of Tip 4, not far to seek — as it grew, it covered the course of a stream for a distance of some 900 feet. 92. On 11th September, 1950, during a meeting between the Merthyr Tydfil Borough Engineer and Mr. D. P. Davies (the No. 4 Area Estates Manager), the latter said that tipping on Merthyr Mountain would cease in about a twelvemonth on the introduction of underground stowing. Reflecting upon this, Mr. D. C. W. Jones wrote on the following day in these terms: "Pantglas Tip I shall be glad if you will inform me what the present and ultimate position will be regarding the tip at the above. I should be glad to know also what routine inspections you propose undertaking ultimately after tipping ceases." On 13th September, 1950, Mr. Davies replied: "Pantglas Tip With reference to your letter of the 12th instant, I confirm that the present tipping is extending away from the old tips, and that we do not anticipate tipping will continue on this site for more than another twelve months. We are also constantly checking the position of all these tips." This correspondence calls for comment: (a) Mr. Davies, naturally vague after this lapse of time, thinks that his assurance regarding the constant checking of all tips was based upon what he had been told by Mr. Baker. Mr. Baker has no knowledge of saying this, but, whether he did or not, was quite clear that he personally never checked any of the tips for stability and knew of no-one else who did. No-one in fact made any check. (b) Despite the reference to stopping Tip 5 in a twelvemonth, it continued to be the active tip for another five years, i.e. until 1956. Why, accordingly, was there any reference to a time limit? Certainly there is no suggestion that any plans for automatic stowing existed which could be possibly implemented within a twelvemonth, or, indeed, at any time. Certainly there is no evidence indicating that the National Coal Board ever regarded it as a practical proposition (see post, "Underground Stowing", paragraphs 281-2). It looks very much as though this is yet another example (of which there are many) of National Coal Board officials fobbing-off "outsiders" who sought information from them regarding their activities. 93. On 23rd October, 1952 Mr. Baker sent to the Area Estates Manager, Mr. D. P. Davies, details of a proposal for tipping higher up the mountain beyond Tip 5. This new arrangement involved removal of an electric crane and extension of the incline and rail track, and the minute and plans were accompanied by an estimate of cost made up item by item and amounting in total to £7,185 12s. 9d. This scheme appears prima facie to be rather clumsy, though practicable and inexpensive, but, for some reason it was not implemented nor even further discussed. None of our witnesses (and least of all Mr. Baker) could explain why this was so, but it is obvious — and it may be significant — that the later decisions to tip on the sites of Tips 6 and 7 involved no capital expenditure, and were more economical of manpower. 94. About this time a Development Plan of the area was being prepared by the Borough Council for submission to the Minister of Housing and Local Government. Inquiries disclosed that the National Coal Board was seeking to extend the tipping area. Although the Borough Engineer was surprised by this, he does not seem to have asked what had happened to the automatic stowage project. But at a meeting between him and Mr. D. P. Davies on 15th January, 1953, he referred to "the high, huge mass of material, and I did feel that the stability of the tips could be suspect". The National Coal Board took up the attitude, as they were legally entitled to do, that tipping on the larger area which they contemplated was "permitted development". Nevertheless, the Borough Engineer sought an assurance that, if further surface tipping were to take place, proper precautions regarding methods of tipping and inspection would be instituted. 95. Reassurance came in the letter of 2nd March, 1953, in which Mr. D. P. Davies said: ". . . It is the intention of the Board's representatives at the hearing before the Minister's Inspector on the 18th instant to state that proper consideration will be given to prevent risks of further slipping when tipping extension is being arranged." There was some disputation as to whether the Inspector, in his turn, was informed that steps would be taken to prevent "future" (and not "further") slipping. But the distinction is of no importance to our inquiry. The simple fact is that, as hitherto, no precautions against slipping were taken during the remaining three years of the working life of Tip 5. Why in fact it ceased in 1956 to be the working tip is not, to our way of thinking, clear. We were told that it was because it had taken fire. But it seems that on December 13th, 1958, the Merthyr Vale Labour Party wrote to the Merthyr Tydfil Corporation complaining that "the tip had been on fire for months and the smell, sulphur and dust blew down the village when the wind was west", and Mr. Baker thought that this trouble arose in 1959 or 1960. Be it in 1958, 1959, or 1960, the fact that Tip 5 started burning cannot, it seems, be an explanation why it was abandoned. It may well be that the truth is to be found in the fact that when tipping was stopped there in 1956 it had become huge (containing approximately 706,000 cubic yards of material) and, in the words of an expert: "the toe was beginning to flow downhill and has remained just stable under fluctuating seepage pressures from the spring. Had the front of the tip been advanced downhill much further it would have failed in the manner (of) Tip No. 4. One may conclude that No. 5 has been standing and is standing at a very low factor of safety". Again, when Tip 6 was started in 1956 no plans were produced and no precautions against slipping were taken, and the same is true of the inception of Tip 7 in 1958. Before either of them was started, the big slide of Tip 4 and the big bulge in Tip 5 were clearly to be seen by anyone who was minded to look.
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||