Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mine & Quarry Engineering - Main Index
Mine & Quarry Engineering - Subject Index
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Title Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Title
 
Masthead
December, 1954

Lead Mining in the British Isles — can it be revived? — Part 5*

by W. W. Varvill, M.Sc., M.I.M.M.

The development of the electric mine pump which has taken place during the past 50 years provides what is probably the most important aid to the revival of Britain's lead mining industry. Other mechanical aids to mining such as compressed air drilling, electric locomotives, etc., have greatly increased the output per man/shift, but the advantages so gained have been more than balanced by higher rates of pay.

However, our lead miner's greatest enemy in the past was water, which brought so many ventures to a standstill.

Since the days when pumping by power was first introduced, whether by hydraulic or steam power, the labour cost has always been relatively small compared with the power cost and this condition is accentuated with electric power. Furthermore, the modern electric pump is not only more efficient mechanically, but far more mobile than the massive and ponderous reciprocating mine pumps of our forebears, and the capital cost of installing a modern electric pump is probably actually less than was required 50 years ago to produce the same results even when making allowance for the reduced purchasing power of the pound sterling.

Its main advantage lies in its mobility which allows its use in any part of the mine where a cable can be laid.

Formerly when the workings extended deeper and departed from the main shaft, they could only be drained by pumps driven by reciprocating rods, compressed air or steam pipes. For example, an 80 h.p. waterwheel driving 1,000 ft. of horizontal and 120 ft. of vertical rods would not deliver more than about 30 per cent. of its theoretical power in useful work by raising water. Compressed-air-driven pumps were not even as efficient as this, although they could be employed at much greater distances from the shaft.

An alternative system was to install steam boilers underground with pumping engines and reciprocating rods working in "blind" shafts. The smoke was led up through old stopes or rises to the surface where a smoke stack was built, but this method was not suited for mines where the thickness of the overlying unproductive rock was great, because it required another shaft to be sunk for providing an upcast.

The majority of our British lead mines were closed down, not because they had lost the veins, but owing to the cost of draining exceeding the economic limit.

Deep drainage adits are a conspicuous feature in many orefields, especially in the Carboniferous areas, and the remarkable distances to which some were driven provide proof of the anxiety of the mine owners to extend their workings to deeper levels without the cost of pumping.

Outstanding examples of the deep drainage adits are the Halkyn Tunnel in Flintshire, the Blackett Level in Northumberland and the Hillcar Sough in Derbyshire; besides these there are scores of others less well known. The more important adits were started in the valleys at the lowest possible point above sea level where additional depth could only be obtained by driving excessively long distances, under circumstances where the natural gradient of the tunnel would to a large extent cancel out the advantage gained by the additional depth.

In a number of cases, the adits were made before the days when iron rails were used for mine transport and wooden rails were customary. These required a steep gradient in favour of the load and consequently, the gradient was unnecessarily steep for a drainage channel. For this reason the oldest adits were driven at a very slight gradient and the water was dammed to a depth of a few feet at the entrance so as to make an underground canal, and boats were used to convey ore and waste rock to the entrance.

As a rule they were not used for working the mines because the ore was drawn up the nearest shaft to the surface.

Of the above-mentioned deep adits the Halkyn Tunnel is the most recent and now has a total length of about 7 miles. The Blackett Level was started in 1855 and was driven for nearly 4¾ miles at a cost of £120,000 — several veins, previously unknown were discovered by this level. The Hillcar Sough is far older, having been started in the middle 18th century; it is 3¾ miles long, and has some long branches and is reported to have cost £50,000 — it now discharges about 15,000 gallons per minute in the wet season.

Many of these deep adits were driven by the owners of the minerals or (in Derbyshire) by drainage companies, known as soughers, who levied royalties from the mines whose working they drained. They were not often a financial success because they drained the mines before they reached them and, before connection was made, the veins had been worked out down to the drainage level. In some cases, however, they enabled working to be continued below adit by pumping, as for example, at the Alport Mines. In this area hydraulic pressure engines were installed to raise the water to the level of the Hillcar Sough — the pressure water was brought down shafts from the surface streams and the tail water escaped through the sough. By this means, it is recorded that as much as 6,000 gallons per minute were pumped from a depth of 20 fathoms below sough level.

In limestone there is always danger of water from the discharge channel leaking through crevices and short-circuiting the pump. This probably accounts for the above very large pump capacity. At the Mill Close Mine this difficulty was experienced and it was necessary to convey the delivery water long distances through steel pipes laid along the floor of the level.

It has already been explained that the ore reserves of the future must be sought generally below the level of the natural surface drainage of the rivers in the valleys and there are not many districts remaining where drainage by deep adit has not been attempted.

Exceptions to this may be found in the steep-sided valleys of Wales, but as a general rule it will be found that the possibilities of adit drainage in the lower hills and gentle slopes of the Pennines have been exhausted.

There is, moreover, the serious handicap that a mile of drainage adit nowadays might well cost £200,000 and it will be more economic, and far quicker to follow the veins down with electric pumps.

Regarding the volume of water which is likely to be met in the Ordovician rocks or the Northern Pennines where the limestone beds are not thick and surface exposure of this rock is small — the volume of water encountered is not large. It is to be noted that in these districts steam pumps were rare in spite of the low cost of coal compared with say, Cornwall, and the usual power for pumping was derived from waterwheels.

In the massive limestones of Derbyshire or the Halkyn district, as the workings extend the volume of water is liable to become heavy; at Mill Close Mine it was necessary to pump over 4.000 gallons per minute towards the end of the life of the mine, and some of the sub-adit workings at Halkyn were very heavily watered. But generally the head will be relatively small and the power consumption correspondingly low.

Ore dressing

As a general rule the problems involved in concentrating the various mineral products are not difficult and it is not proposed to discuss them at any great length.

A typical flowsheet cannot be said to exist nowadays although in the past the accepted practice at many mines followed the same lines.

Crushing was easy and the common type of jaw breaker was universal; it would generally be followed by rolls and trommels arranged to make a closely sized product or products for jigging in Harz-type jigs, with as little sliming as possible.

The bulk of the concentrate was recovered from the jigs and these were followed by buddles for the treatment of the sands and slimes. At a later date shaking tables and vanners were substituted for buddles.

An advantage of this arrested crushing system of coarse concentration which has caused its survival into the age of froth flotation is the production of a large proportion of gravel-sized tailings for which there is a ready market either as fluorspar gravel (when this mineral is present in sufficient quantities) or for road dressing or as concrete aggregate.

The fine grinding necessary for flotation concentration, results in the production of nothing but sands and slimes, which are not in such demand as by-products.

Finely ground fluorspar has a limited market provided it is of exceptional purity and for this purpose the flotation method can be effectively applied, but the bulk of the demand for fluorspar is for the gravel for metallurgical purposes.

Metallurgical fluorspar can be jigged from quartz, calcite and barytes, the minerals with which it is most commonly associated, and consequently, when an important proportion of fluorspar is present in the crude ore, the jig is still likely to survive as a useful machine.

When treating ores whose minerals do not command a ready sale, the flowsheet is likely to follow the lines generally accepted as suitable for a complex pyritic ore, namely, rock breaker-cone crusher-ball-mill-cum-classifier, flotation cells and the vacuum filters for the concentrate. This system is simple and economical in labour and maintenance costs.

The "all-flotation" process of this nature is well suited for the treatment of a mixed galena-zinc blende-pyrite ore of the type commonly found in Wales where marketable gangues are rare. It will produce a good quality blende concentrate with a low iron content which was not easy before the days of flotation, when this class of ore was the subject of endless experiments with gravity plants, or a combination of gravity with roasting and magnetic separation.

It is nowadays often forgotten that the earliest practical application of the oil flotation process was carried Out in North Wales, and just as Cornish mining methods in the 19th century were so largely adopted in metalliferous mining throughout the world, so were the ore-dressing and smelting methods of the North of England and Wales.

To conclude, it can be said that the concentration of British lead-zinc ores does not present any problems not easily solved by modern technique and on this score they are fully competitive with conditions found overseas.

Labour

Anyone contemplating the revival of a derelict lead mining district in Britain will generally meet objections about the lack of suitable labour. He will be asked: "Where will you find the labour? The old-timer is extinct and there are no young skilled miners to fill their place and mining districts are not depopulated."

These appear to be sound objections until one probes deeper.

Firstly, the "skill" of the old-time metal miner was, with the exception of a few specialists such as pumpmen and timbermen or sinkers, largely fictional. He required endurance rather than skill.

Any man possessing the necessary physique (nothing like the standard of coal miners was required) could soon learn the simple tasks of the old-time miner provided he was willing to endure the wet, dirty, dark, ill-ventilated and at times, dangerous conditions. Those best suited were those who had been brought up to it from childhood and knew no other life — from this arose the tradition that mining is necessarily a hereditary occupation. As a matter of fact, the degree of craftsmanship demanded of a good metal miner was far less than that of the agricultural labourer, the fisherman or the coal miner.

The average young man of today who has done his National Service and grown up in an age of petrol engines and radio, takes more readily to the handling of modern mining equipment such as rock drills and loaders than the old time "rough neck" navvy.

In the metal mining districts, which are generally wholly rural, there are many young men who prefer to get work locally where they can help on the family farm, rather than "drift" to the towns, which is the normal fate for the surplus male (and female) population of our hill country where the mines are mostly located.

The young countryman will take to mining provided he can earn more than he can on the farms and conditions underground are not too arduous or discomforts too great. Machines can reduce the manual effort required and metalliferous veins are far easier to work under conditions of comfort than coal seams. The ease with which rock can be mined under modern conditions removes any excuse for keeping the mine levels down to the narrow dimensions which were the rule in the past.

The provision of decent washing and drying facilities and arrangements for transporting the men to and from their work by bus are amongst the important advantages of mine work today, which did not prevail in the past. The writer remembers how in the Northern Pennines, the miners often walked for six miles or more from their homes to work and back again after their shift, in addition to a three-mile walk underground to and from their working place. it is to be wondered they had any energy to work at all — at one well-known and successful mine, the average time spent at the working face doing useful work was about four hours per shift. The rest of the shift was spent in walking, talking farming and politics, eating and smoking.

The managers were mostly recruited from men who had been through the same school themselves and made little effort to remedy conditions, whilst the tributing system of underground employment resulted in wages being closely related to production. "Welfare" in the modern sense was practically unknown. In the absence of old age pensions it was customary to allow old men to go to work long after they were past the age when they could do much, and they used to be found sitting and smoking in comfortable corners of the mine where they dispensed words of wisdom to the younger men who were not allowed to forget their inferiority as miners.

At none of the mines recently revived in Britain has there been serious difficulty in securing sufficient labour and there have generally been more men than jobs. The same applies to the technical staffs, because there are large numbers of British engineers and technicians now working abroad who are glad to work at home at lower rates of pay than they can earn overseas. The reasons for this are firstly, their native country is better suited for family life and secondly, because in spite of heavy taxation and difficulties in making two ends meet at home, the average Briton with long overseas experience still knows that his own country is the best place in the world to live in. In any gathering of the British who work abroad the main topic of conversation is the next home leave and, with civil servants, their approaching pension date. It is pathetic to see young men looking forward eagerly to their old age and is only too common amongst exiles, and is not confined to the British as a race.

For these reasons, the metal mine at home will always have a pull over the mine abroad when it comes to staffing.

Conclusion

The introduction of these articles stated that their main object would be to review the past records of British lead mining in the light of modern conditions and to discuss the degree to which a revival may be possible if fresh reserves can be found as good as those worked in the past.

It has been made clear that fresh discoveries of ore are essential for a serious revival and the main theme has been directed at the most promising methods of bringing this about, because there can be little doubt that substantial reserves of ore remain to be found and worked and this opinion is shared by many geologists who have given close study to the subject.

The task of finding these reserves is not easy, especially in the early stages, but we are better equipped with geological knowledge than before, and the diamond drill gives us a means of supplementing this in a manner denied to our predecessors.

The electric pump now allows workings to be extended far beyond the limits imposed on the old workers and modern metallurgy permits the economic recovery of the various products of the mines to a degree which was impossible when the industry was at its peak.

Our country's economic position is likely to become increasingly unstable because it is only the elimination of our most serious competitors in trade, since the Second World War, that has prevented the pinch being felt far more seriously than has been the case. It only requires a few years of settled peace for the full blast of foreign competition to be felt and we shall then find ourselves faced with the problem of feeding a very large population of city dwellers crowded into a small island.

Under such circumstances, the saving of only a few millions a year by producing more of our metals at home will leave that amount more to be spent on the necessary food imports, and the sooner our rulers realise that the production of raw materials is as important as television, the better.

These articles have consisted mainly of a one sided discussion which expresses the belief that the lead-mining industry of Britain can be revived and the answer to the query in the title is "yes." Some readers, however, influenced by the gloomy record of failures during the past 60 or 70 years, may take opposite views, and for that reason they may be interested in a few details which summarise the results of recent attempts to bring about a revival; an inch of practice is worth a yard of theory.

At the end of the Second World War the only mine producing lead-ore on an appreciable scale was Greenside, but after the war ended a few veterans, which had not been dismantled, resumed production.

Since 1949 examinations and trials have been made by several mining houses of the highest repute and experience and in no way addicted to the pursuit of "wild cats" — this activity has already resulted in an appreciable increase in the production of base-metals in Britain and Ireland.

The preliminary work involved in reviving a long abandoned mining field may last for years and requires great patience and ample funds. Nevertheless two new ventures have been producing on a steadily increasing scale during the past three or four years. Both were started on properties which were completely derelict.

These two mines are at Abbeytown in Co. Sligo, and Llanrwst in North Wales. They started production in 1951 and 1952 respectively and their production up to date, in terms of the metallic contents of the concentrates sold, has been

  Lead Metal  Zinc Metal 
  tons  tons 
Abbeytown Mining Co. Ltd. 2,170 5,360
Llanrwst Lead Mines Ltd. 5,196 2,146
Totals 7,366 7,506

The above production has been achieved during the customary period of "teething troubles" which most new mines endure during their adolescence, nevertheless it represents the equivalent of saving about £l,400,000 which would have been spent on imported metals, and this was earned by the labour of less than 250 men.

Both mines have been working in ground from which the richest ore had been extracted by the old workers and as a result the grade has been lower than what is to be expected when really virgin ground is reached. In both cases good natural conditions have contributed to keeping the working costs per ton milled down to levels which compare favourably with any base-metal mine overseas. There are moreover substantial reserves of ore awaiting development at both mines and the revival is not likely to be short-lived.

In addition to these new producing mines, a number of properties are being explored and it is probable that additional mines will be added to the list of producers during the next few years.

As a fitting conclusion to these articles some details of the Greenside Mine have been generously sent by that company.

The Greenside Mine has already been mentioned as a healthy veteran, still going strong after a productive life extending without a serious break for 134 years — its ultimate origin is lost in the past.

From 1820 to the present time approximately 2,000,000 tons of ore have been treated for a production of 190,000 tons of concentrate with an average content of 79 per cent. Pb with 6 oz. of silver per ton.

The bottom of the mine is 2,600 ft. below the outcrop on the mountain and the workings extend for 4,000 ft. along the strike. Some of the old stopes were 50 ft. wide and even now some average 20 ft. The average grade of the ore being treated is 7½ per cent, to 8 per cent. Pb which is not far from the average grade of the past 134 years.

There cannot be many lead mines in the world to match this record. There are older ones it is true, for example the Rammelsberg in Germany, but their grade is much higher. Accordingly Greenside is nearly a unique example of a mine which is not, and never has been of very high grade, and does not produce any important by-product — nevertheless, by maintaining a modest scale of operations, it has weathered the economic storms for over a century.

Unlike Mill Close or Boltsburn, it has not depended on exceptional richness or a large output for its survival, but it is favoured with good natural conditions for economic working, and in this respect it can be regarded as a typical British lead mine. Possibly the modest grade of the ore has contributed to its survival. If it had been richer it would have attracted larger capital investment and a larger scale of operations.

An American mining engineer who discussed this mine with the writer said: "If that mine had been in the States it would have been 'torn out' in twenty years," thereby insinuating that it was due to our British lack of enterprise that Greenside has been allowed to live so long.

But it is easy to "tear out" mines and move on to others, leaving behind a trail of "ghost towns," only so long as there are fresh mines to move to. In an old country like Britain, is it not better to work the mines on a scale which may ensure steady employment to the local inhabitants for generations ?

The American outlook is not always suited to old countries.

Acknowledgments

Much of the experience which has prompted the writing of these articles has been gained in the service of the Johannesburg Consolidated In vestment Co. Ltd., and the author is greatly indebted to the directors of that company for permission to publish them.

The Geological Survey of Great Britain has been very helpful with advice and permission to reproduce certain plans which appear in their memoirs; Fig. 13 from pamphlet No. 46 "Barium Minerals for England and Wales," Fig. 16 from their Memoir on Fluorspar. Permission for their reproduction was obtained from Her Majesty's Stationery Office.

Certain drawings which originally appeared in a Paper presented jointly by Mr. J. B. Dennison and the author to the Institution of Mining and Metallurgy, entitled "Prospecting with the Diamond Drill for Lead-Zinc Ores in the British Isles," have been included in these articles. The author wishes to acknowledge his thanks to Mr. Dennison and the Institution for permission to use them.

For permitting the reproduction of those photographs illustrating their operations, the author wishes to thank the Abbeytown Mining Co. Ltd., the Weardale Lead Co. Ltd., Coldberry Lead Co. Ltd., Halkyn District United Mines Limited, Llanrwst Lead Mines Ltd., Greenside Mines Limited, and the Matlock Lead Mines Ltd.

* In the four previous articles in this series, published on p. 352, August 1954; p. 398, September 1954; p. 436. October 1954; and p. 488, November 1954, the author has covered the history and future outlook of this industry, past and present production, geology and the degree of frequency of veins, the possible extent of unworked lead orefields, modern prospecting methods and rules, diamond drilling and mining methods.

Drawings and Photographs accompanying the article

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

Article reproduced from a copy of the magazine held at National Mining Museum Scotland, Newtongrange, Midlothian.

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 17 Jan 2023

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print