Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mine & Quarry Engineering - Main Index
Mine & Quarry Engineering - Subject Index
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Title Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Title
 
Masthead
September, 1954

Lead Mining in the British Isles — can it be revived? — Part 2

by W. W. Varvill, M.Sc., M.I.M.M.

A full and detailed discussion of the geological conditions affecting the lead-ore deposits of the British Isles is impossible within the limits of space of these articles*. Nevertheless, some account of the geology must be given to describe how the veins occur and the reasons for believing in the existence of extensive unworked reserves of ore.

Mention has already been made of the existence of two main groups of ore deposits namely those in the Lower Carboniferous rocks and those in the older Series of Devonian, Silurian, Ordovician and Cambrian rocks. Of these the Ordovician has been the most productive. Some veins occur in igneous rocks, but they are not nearly so common as those in the sedimentary rocks.

In all the sedimentary rocks the distribution and shape of the ore-shoots are controlled by the texture and composition of the different members of the strata, and this is especially true of the veins in the Carboniferous series, where the alternation of relatively hard and firm rocks such as sandstone and limestone with soft shales or (in Derbyshire) lava, has given rise in the harder rocks to ribbon veins whose longitudinal extent greatly exceeds the vertical.

Similar control of the ore-shoots by the strata can be observed in the Ordovician rocks, notably at Llanrwst, but it is not so conspicuous owing to the greater thickness of the different beds and the absence of soft shales which, in the Carboniferous rocks, acted as "blankets" and confined the vertical extent of the ore-shoots to relatively small dimensions.

It is a generally accepted belief that the ore-bearing solutions which originally filled the veins derived their origin from deep-seated igneous sources in much the same manner as the tin-copper lodes of Cornwall, but the granitic source is not seen in the Pennine lead-fields probably because the zone of lead deposition is further removed from the source than the tin-copper zone.

There are, however, notable exceptions elsewhere as, for example, at Glendalough in Co. Wicklow, where lead veins occur actually in the granite itself, thus providing evidence of its source. Lead veins also occur at Strontian in Scotland where they are found in gneiss, and near Newton Stewart in Galloway where lead-zinc bearing veins can be observed in Ordovician strata very near the metamorphic aureol which surrounds the granite mass of the Cairnsmore of Fleet. At Foxdale in the Isle of Man the vein is in granite.

In most districts, however, the veins have been filled from emanative centres or vents up which the primary solutions flowed to invade the receptive fissures in the harder members of the overlying sediments, where they spread out laterally and more or less horizontally.

The existence of these vents has not been proved definitely, although in several places in the Northern Pennines vertical ore-shoots which cut across the usually non-productive strata have been followed by mining to considerable depths without finding the bottom.

This extensive lateral migration of ore solutions from the emanative centres, has been responsible for the remarkably widespread extent of the lead veins in Britain — in fact there are very few counties in England where lead has not at some time been worked west of a line drawn from Teesmouth to Bournemouth.

With such a combination of circumstances it is clear that the horizons where ore is most likely to be found are in rocks where open spaces occur under an impervious blanket of shale or lava. This has long been recognised by miners who gave the name of the "bearing bed" to the stratum where ore has been most abundant. The first task of any prospector today is to find the "bearing bed" of the old miners.

Frequently there are several "bearing beds" either superimposed or more frequently en echelon as if the ore has flowed up a series of steps on a staircase, breaking through to a higher step at some point where a cross fissure has left a weak point in the shale blanket.

In the Northern Pennines the limestone beds are numerous and relatively thin — the Great Limestone, which was responsible for more lead ore than all the other beds combined, rarely exceeded 66 ft. in thickness — but they are interbedded with shales and sandstones at short intervals, and the impervious nature of the shales gave rise to superimposed "ribbon" oreshoots in the receptive limestones and sandstones.

There is, however, a strong tendency for the upper limestones and sandstones of the series to be the most productive whilst the lower beds, which are well exposed along the western escarpment of the Outer Pennine Fault, have proved to be unproductive.

In the Middle Pennines of Nidderdale and Wharfedale, the limestones are interrupted by shale beds of much greater thickness and the ore concentrations are restricted to the part immediately below the shale cover. In this region, however, there have been important workings in the overlying grits — for example at Grassington Moor — and it seems probable that this was caused by the Upper Limestone being brought against the grits by faulting, and thereby enabling the solutions to by-pass the impervious shales and enter the receptive fissures of the harder sandstones at higher levels.

In the Southern Pennines of Derbyshire, the limestone is exposed as an anticlinal fold or dome with its major axis running north and south. It is flanked on all sides by the shales and grits of the Millstone Grit Series at the base of which there are the Edale shales (formerly termed the limestone shales) generally about 401) ft. thick and lying directly on top of the main limestone series. These shales provided an effective barrier to the uprising mineralising solutions and it is to be noted that in Derbyshire there are very few lead veins in the overlying grits (as there are in the Northern Pennines) owing, probably, to the fact that the soft shales were too thick to provide passages for the minerals even when they are faulted against harder strata.

The total thickness of the limestone is unknown in Derbyshire, although estimates varying from 1,500 ft. to 2,000 ft. have been made. But once again it is the uppermost limestone next to the shale cover which has proved the most productive stratum, and the richest part has, in most places, not extended down for more than 150 ft. below the top of the limestone.

Nevertheless, the Derbyshire dome differs from the more northern regions by the inclusion of interstratified beds of contemporaneous volcanic lava and tuff which separate the limestone into zones. These are named "toadstones," a local corruption of the German word "todstein" (lit. deadstone) which is evidence of the influence of German miners about 300 years ago.

The toadstone lava flows are intermittent and vary greatly in thickness, appearing at different horizons which cannot always be correlated. They provided effective barriers to the upward flow of the ore solutions in the same manner as the shales, because they consist in part of lava and ash which has decomposed to form clay. But owing to their lack of continuity the orebodies found beneath them are not so continuous as those under the shales although they may locally be equally rich, as was found at Mill Close.

The presence of the toadstone beds at various levels has had the effect of creating ore-bearing zones at a number of deeper horizons, although it is doubtful whether any ore has been discovered in payable quantities at greater depths than 600 ft. below the shales.

In a geological assemblage of this kind, it is obvious that the most widespread and effective barrier has been the shale which, to use a cricket analogy, has provided an infallible "longstop" to catch the ore which the intermittent toadstone "wicket-keepers" missed. In the course of geological time the ore solutions have by-passed the toadstones and "piled-up" under the shales and for this reason veins are more plentiful under the shales than they are under the toadstones.

In addition to damming the uprising solutions the toadstones have had an important effect in controlling their lateral flow or migration along the vein fissures. With a soluble rock such as limestone lying above an insoluble and impervious bed of toadstone, conditions were conducive for caverns being formed along the line of vertical fissures or minor faults at the top of the toadstone beds. These caverns were formed by migrating waters or steam before the arrival of the ore solutions.

The ore solutions followed the ready made channels provided by the caverns and precipitation of the ore minerals took place under relatively quiet conditions with the ore adhering to the limestone walls and floor of the caverns, especially the floors, owing to the greater weight of the galena classifying it to the lower layers of deposition.

There were not always enough ore minerals to fill the whole open space of the cavities and it is usual to find an open central space lined with calcite crystals, often of large size. The calcite which thus forms a covering for the ore minerals was of later date and possibly was formed by water flowing under artesian pressure in recent geological times.

This type of ore deposit was very well developed in the lower workings at Mill Close where the flat development of the caverns on the top of the toadstone, or one of the thin beds of volcanic ash locally named "wayboards" gave rise to very rich orebodies.

In Derbyshire the veins usually occur in bunches or "swarms" which branch off or run parallel to the larger faults or the anticlinal axes. They tend to become impoverished as they are worked away from the anticlinal axes, although they may persist with payable values for distances running up to thousands of feet from the master vein of the swarm.

In the past the limestone strata in the Upper series have been very closely prospected where they outcrop below a shale or toadstone cover, and the prospectors were helped by the fact that these favourable horizons often occurred on the high ground where they could be explored by shafts and adits without serious drainage trouble.

Prospecting was assisted by "hushing" or directing a stream of water down the hillside to wash away the top soil and expose the veins.

The whole of the Pennine range has been very closely prospected during the past 2,000 years or more, and it is unlikely that much will be found in areas where the "bearing beds" lie at or near the surface. The size of any remnants that may exist will not be sufficient to justify the capital investment necessary to develop a modern mine.

In spite of this there still remain large unworked areas either (as in the northern areas) where the veins have not been followed through from valley to valley under the intervening cover rocks or (as in Derbyshire) where the "bearing beds" have dipped so far below the water table that the miners of the past could not follow the veins owing to the volume of water being in excess of their pumping capacity.

Such areas as these offer the most promising fields for discovering intact reserves in Britain, because the downward pitch of the ribbon ore-shoots was controlled by the dip of the strata which is in many places slight. Consequently, there are places where the bearing zone is not more than a few hundred feet below the surface and this makes possible the discovery of ore deposits by a combination of geological study and diagonal core drilling.

Basic rules for future prospecting in the Pennine Range

With the British lead-mining industry in its present state, by far the most important problem is the discovery of areas where the potential mining possibilities are sufficiently promising to encourage the relatively large capital expenditure required under modern conditions to start a new mine. In the Pennines there exist a number of important conditions which contribute to the possibility of locating new and intact orefields. These are as follows:

(a) The "ribbon" type of ore-shoot often has great longitudinal continuity within the limits imposed by the bearing beds. In the areas already worked they have often been followed by mining operations, literally without a break, for miles. They can be traced by the lines of opencut workings where the bearing bed lies at the surface and by lines of shafts where the bearing bed has plunged below the cover rock. It will generally be found that the line of shafts ceases where the top of the bearing bed has dipped below the water table or to a depth below it of not more than, say, 20 fathoms.

Naturally there are exceptions to this rule where the operations have been on a scale large enough to warrant the installation of heavy pumping plant; but it must be remembered that the great majority of our mines were abandoned before the invention of electric pumps which could be installed in positions remote from the bottom of the shafts. The old rod driven pumps or steam pumps have been quite capable of lifting the water for the past 200 years, but they required a vertical shaft for the rods at no great distance from the pump itself, which was generally sited in the shaft itself.

In Cornwall, where the ore-shoots pitch at steep angles, this type of pump was quite suitable and often highly efficient, and depths up to 2,000 ft. below adit were reached.

But in the Pennine mines, with their ribbon veins pitching at a small angle in the plane of the veins, development could only be carried out by a succession of shafts each deeper than the previous one, and each with a larger and more powerful pump. The alternative was a succession of internal shafts stepping down as the ore-shoot pitched deeper. This system was costly owing to repeated hoisting and pumping at each successive step, and could only be carried out by the use of compressed air (which was highly inefficient) as at Boltsburn, or with electric pumps as at Mill Close, which is the solitary example (and a successful one) where a Pennine vein was followed to a depth of 800 ft. below the water table.

Both these mines were rich and could afford the repeated handling of the output up a succession of steps, even when metal prices were very low.

There is no reason to believe that the continuous ribbon ore-shoots do not extend far under cover of the non-productive rocks — in fact, they have been proved to do so in a number of cases, for example:

Boltsburn — 2½ miles.
Sedling & Burtree Pasture Mines, in succession — 3¾ miles.
Red Vein Mines, Stanhope — 3¾ miles.
Mill Close — About 3½ miles.

All these distances were mined under cover of ground where no workable ore reached the surface and few, if any, traces of the veins come to the surface. At all these mines there were also considerable distances where the veins were worked at their outcrops.

In most of the above instances, the veins still persisted at the far ends when the mine closed down, but the combination of long haulage and excessive water prevented economic working and caused a cessation of operations when the price of metals fell to levels far below those now obtaining.

There must be many instances in the 150 mile range of the Pennines where working was stopped far short of the above instances, and in many cases where the dip of the strata has carried the bearing zone below the drainage system soon after passing under cover of the non-productive rocks.

(b) The stratigraphical position of the most favourable strata for finding ore can be found by examination of old workings or records, and the depth of this zone below the surface can readily be found by drilling vertical holes from the surface without the necessity of intersecting an actual vein. If this form of drilling is done as a preliminary to diagonal boring in search of the actual veins, the chances of intersecting ore-bearing ribbon ore-shoots are greatly increased.

(c) The veins rarely occur singly but as groups or "swarms" of parallel veins with branches, generally associated with a master vein whose greater continuity provides evidence of the existence of an orechannel which conducted the ore solutions and filled the whole assemblage. Flats and replacement deposits will also be found associated with a master vein, and it will generally take the form of a fissure whose sides have been faulted one against the other. Frequently the master vein runs along or near the axis of an anticlinal or synclinal fold.

Structural anomalies such as faults or fold can often be identified at the surface and when they have been confirmed by vertical drill holes the field of search for the actual veins themselves is greatly narrowed, so that the diagonal holes can be directed with good possibilities of intersecting a vein or veins of value.

(d) The intersection of a vein by the methods described above fixes its position and, in conjunction with subsequent holes, its direction.

It may also produce important evidence regarding the vein's actual contents, although undue reliance should not be placed on the assay results of core sampling owing to the loss of valuable ore by abrasion. Nevertheless, the recovery in the cores of sufficient galena to identify the vein as lead-bearing and being associated with the customary "indicator" minerals such as fluorspar, will give sufficient encouragement to justify the drilling of confirmatory holes and so set the course for exploratory development.

The degree of frequency of veins

For a mine to be successful under modern conditions, it is necessary to substitute machinery for manual labour wherever possible — high wages and the unpopularity of the miner's life make this inevitable in a civilised country — and as a result preliminary capital expenditure is required on a scale far greater than in the past, when many large and successful mines worked at a profit "from the grass roots down" and capitalised themselves out of profits. In old mining fields this is no longer possible, and costly equipment and development are required before a ton of ore is milled, consequently the potential reserves of any area on which exploration is contemplated must be far larger than was considered necessary in the past.

A solitary vein without important branches is insufficient unless it is considerably wider than the average British vein, and examinations should in future, be directed to areas where a "swarm" of veins occurs in sufficiently close proximity to be worked as one unit.

This has been the guiding principle at Llanrwst, Matlock and elsewhere in the United Kindom where lead-mining revivals are now being attempted.

In the ancient mining field west of the River Conway, near Llanrwst, where a highly mineralised, but completely derelict area has recently been brought once more into active production, over three-score veins were identified by the Geological Survey within less than four square miles. The existence of these was confirmed by private examination and a successful drilling programme was conducted for additional proof.

At Matlock the workings are even older and more derelict than at Llanrwst and there is a complete absence of old mine plans. However, the ancient Barmote Court of the Soke and Wapentake of Wirksworth gave valuable aid in the form of the "Moletrap Consolidated Title with its Schedule of Rakes and Veins." This is a descriptive list of all the veins in the area of the Title which have been registered with the Barmaster. whose records go back for hundreds of years.

Within an area of about one square mile east of the River Derwent — about two miles long by mile wide — no less than 59 different veins are described. They have all been worked or they would not have been registered. Many of them have recently been identified by their surface workings.

All these veins occur where the limestone is at or very near the surface and many of them pass out of sight eastward under the shale cover rock. There is no reason to believe that swarms of a similar character will not be found under the shale cover as they have been where the limestone is exposed at the surface, and it is obvious that the tonnage worked from a typical swarm in past ages would provide a very attractive mining objective even by modern standards.

"Swarms" of veins are a frequent occurrence along the eastern flank of the main Derbyshire anticline close to the western margin of the shales. They are found mainly in the Upper Limestone, because this covers the greater part of the surface and was consequently easy to prospect. They must have been the scene of great activity in the past with hundreds of small working partnerships of miners equipped appear at first glance to have been sunk to work solely with picks, shovels and windlasses. No doubt bedded deposits, but a little study will show that they it was to settle disputes in such areas that the Derby- are generally aligned along parallel lines which shire Mining Laws and Courts came into being. In terminate on the line of a master vein. This indicates many places, the shafts are so closely spaced that they that vertical veins provided the objective.

Typical swarms occur at Crich, Ashover, Wirksworth, Bonsall, Winster and Youlgreave in the southern parts of the Derbyshire orefield.

The only example of a swarm being worked within living memory or, for that matter within the memory of local tradition, was at the Mill Close Mine, where for 2,000 ft. along the 103 fm. level there was a swarm of branches mainly on the west side of the Main Joint or the master vein. This swarm consisted of 30 to 40 branches ranging from 200 ft. to 1,000 ft. in length and these were crossed by numerous subsidiary branches (see Fig. 17). This assemblage produced over 200,000 tons of galena concentrate in about 10 years between 1929 and 1939. It occurred immediately below a toadstone or "wayboard" roof and the vertical height of the ore-shoot rarely exceeded 60 ft. It is about 600 ft. below adit (river) level and roughly 750-800 ft. below the surface. The depth below the base of the shales is about 350 ft. and it is nowhere exposed at the surface, where the nearest limestone is about 1½ miles distant. If it had been exposed at the surface, no doubt, it would have been worked out hundreds of years ago.

The subject of vein swarms has been discussed in some detail because, in the writer's opinion, the most promising area in Britain to explore for lead ore lies in Derbyshire, and the discovery of deposits like these which are so conspicuous a feature on the limestone areas, by exploration in the hidden areas, offers better opportunities for successful modern development than any other, because although they may not be large orebodies individually, they are numerous and sufficiently near together to be worked as one mine.

* The first article of this series was published in our August issue, page 352; in this section the history of the industry was discussed together with the outlook for the future, while details were given of past and present production and the grade of ore from British mines.

(To be continued)

Drawings and Photographs accompanying the article

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

Article reproduced from a copy of the magazine held at National Mining Museum Scotland, Newtongrange, Midlothian.

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 17 Jan 2023

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print