|
October, 1954 Lead Mining in the British Isles — can it be revived? — Part 3by W. W. Varvill, M.Sc., M.I.M.M.Although the veins in the Carboniferous rocks have provided the largest part of Britain's lead-ore production in the past, the pre-Carboniferous Series have also made important contributions. It is not proposed to describe the numerous districts in detail because this would take too long, but when reviewing future possibilities of a revival, consideration must be given to the essential differences between the veins in Carboniferous rocks and those of earlier age. Geologists believe that most of Britain's ore deposits were formed in late Carboniferous times during what is termed the Hercynian Epoch, although there is some doubt regarding the North Pennine orefield, where some evidence points to a Tertiary Age. Nevertheless, most of the older fields are believed to have been formed during the same period of earth deformation and igneous activity as the tin-copper lodes of Cornwall and Devon ; that is to say, the Hercynian Epoch. This theory is supported by the fact that lead mines have been found in all the series up to the Carboniferous limestone. The reason why the Ordovician Series has been the most productive of the pre-Carboniferous series arises from its having been itself a period of great igneous activity, especially in North Wales and, being thereby much fissured and contorted, it afforded more numerous openings for ore deposition than other less disturbed areas. Provided the covering rocks above the emanative centres or vents were sufficiently tough and hard to provide fissures which were not plugged, their age or the period to which they belonged did not matter, subject, of course, to their being in existence before the eruptive period. In addition to belonging to a period of great igneous activity, the Ordovician rocks cover a much larger surface of England and Wales in the vicinity of igneous centres than any other of the pre-Carboniferous series. In Cornwall and Devon, the Devonian series is more widespread around the granite bosses and contains many veins, but the bulk of them belong to the tin and copper zones. From a practical mining standpoint, the main difference between the ore deposits in the Carboniferous rocks and their predecessors arises from the fact, already mentioned, that the ore-shoots in the latter are more often of the steep-pitching type and gain depth rapidly when worked. This is due to the great irregularity and unconformity so often produced in Ordovician sediments by local igneous activity, and is in contrast with the uniformity and gentle dip slopes of the Carboniferous rocks. The receptive fissures which formed the veins in the former often had their wider parts pitching in conformity with the steep dip of the strata and thus formed steep oreshoots. A conspicuous exception which supports this belief can be found in the Llanrwst field where the strata are fairly uniform, flat and conformable, although much broken by small faults which have formed the veins. At Llanrwst there is considerable longitudinal continuity of the veins, as in the Pennines, and a form of ribbon ore-shoot occurs, whose vertical dimensions are controlled by structural features in the country rocks. Elsewhere in Wales, and in Shropshire, the Lake District, Leadhills, Cornwall and Devon and the Isle of Man, the ore-shoots generally pitch steeply in the plane of the veins and appear to become progressively shorter in depth. This can be observed if one inspects the old mine sections which still survive. But it must not necessarily be inferred that the oreshoots are pinching out in depth because, as a mine extends deeper, the cost and difficulties of working increase and the lowest levels are often shorter than the upper ones, not being driven to the limits of the ore-shoots when the cost of deep-level working became excessive. Furthermore, when the vein becomes nipped in a horizontal ribbon ore-shoot, it is easy to drive the level until it becomes wider, but it requires considerable optimism to sink a shaft deeper when the vein has nipped all along the lowest level in a steep pitching ore-shoot, in the hope that it will widen out again before too great a depth has been reached. Future ore reserves in the pre-Carboniferous rocks If the mines now producing lead ore are excepted, it can be said that there are no proved ore-reserves in any district in the United Kingdom. No doubt there are places where old records may indicate the existence of remnants of ore which did not pay to work at the time the mines were closed down, but such records are generally incomplete and unreliable and they cannot be checked without reopening old workings-this will generally involve unwatering, because the intact ground will be below the level of the adits or of the natural drainage. Such reserves cannot be described as proved in the accepted sense of the word. Although there can be little doubt regarding the existence of substantial potential reserves in some of the districts, the problem of discovering them without excessive expenditure on prospecting is more difficult than it is in the case of the mines in Carboniferous rocks. In mines where there are reliable records of the existence of unworked reserves in the old workings, either in the form of a payable ore-shoot remaining intact in the floor of the lowest level, or in the ends of drives on the veins, the cost of re-opening and unwatering may be justified provided the mineralisation has been on a scale likely to be large enough to supply a modern mine. Before undertaking this uncertain and costly task, it is better to make a thorough geological examination of the surface to see if additional proof can be obtained by drilling. This may be more difficult than it is in the Pennine orefields with their gently dipping ore-shoots and the great continuity of their veins, and will be especially so when it is desired to prove the continuity in depth of a steeply pitching ore-shoot which has already been worked at higher levels. Assuming that a steeply pitching ore-shoot in a vertical vein has been worked out to a depth of only 100 fathoms and is reputed to be intact in the sole of the lowest level, then it will require a borehole sloping at 60 deg. to be drilled for 900 to 1,000 ft. in order to intersect the vein at a point 200 ft. below the lowest level. This may be quite possible where the rock is of uniform texture and not likely to cause excessive deviation of the drill, but it must be remembered that a hole 1,000 ft. deep may cost £3,000 and it may require several holes to secure sufficient proof to justify a decision to start underground exploration. Opportunities for proving the extension in depth of ore-shoots which have not been worked deeper than 100 fathoms below the surface, will not be common in the Ordovician and other pre-Carboniferous districts, because the largest and richest, and thereby of the greatest interest to the prospector, will probably have been worked out considerably deeper. Nevertheless the pre-Carboniferous districts, especially the mountainous Ordovician country, possess certain advantages which are not so commonly found in the Pennine Carboniferous districts, as follows: (a) The Ordovician orefields, through their close association with areas of igneous activity, generally occur in steep mountainous country where the contours are better suited for drainage by adit levels. The long, deep, drainage adits which are so conspicuous a feature in the Pennine mines, and often extend for miles, are not usual in the Ordovician mountains where the steepness of the mountain sides obviates the necessity for driving long distances to reach the objective, which is generally a steep pitching ore-shoot. Consequently, there may still remain promising fields for development by adits, or the extension of adits already in existence, in order to intersect known ore-shoots at lower levels. (b) Mines in the Ordovician strata are not as a rule troubled by excessive inflow of water to the same extent as the mines in the Carboniferous Limestone. (c) When prospecting by drilling there is a better chance of recovering satisfactory cores of the vein-stuff owing to the harder texture of the ore minerals and gangue. (d) Owing to the fact that the lead mining industry developed later in the remote and mountainous Ordovician districts, there still remain some areas, notably in Scotland, which have not been so closely prospected as the Carboniferous, and occasional outcrops of unworked veins can still be seen. In such areas, it seems likely that prospecting with the modern aids of geology and geophysical and geochemical methods, may lead to the discovery of virgin veins even in areas where the recognised productive rocks are exposed at the surface. Basic rules for prospecting in the pre-Carboniferous rocks (a) As in the case of the Carboniferous rocks, the first step must be to identify the type of rock which formed the "bearing bed" in the old mine workings of the neighbourhood. This was a well recognised duty of the mine captains of past generations, the best of whom were very expert in recognising the variety of slate or "killas" which was most favourable for the production of ore. This faculty was the essence of the "art of mining" and it has to a great extent been lost, because the modern geologist has had little practical experience in this type of mining and no opportunity to learn how to identify at a glance the most favourable strata for finding good ore-shoots. In the writer's experience, the grade of any oreshoot is profoundly affected by the texture of the wall rocks. In the Carboniferous rocks the essential differences between the productive rocks and the non-productive are obvious to anyone — as, for instance, the difference between shale and limestone — but in the Ordovician, for example, there is often not much difference in the appearance of a favourable slate and an unfavourable. There may be small differences in colour and texture which are peculiar to each district and this is where local knowledge is necessary. Small differences in rock texture should not be regarded as directly connected with ore deposition but, by affecting the characteristics of fracture and cleavage, they influence the nature of the fissures and so, indirectly, the shape and distribution of the oreshoots. Nevertheless, once the favourable type of rock has been identified, it should be possible with the aid of modern laboratory technique to recover, and perhaps, improve on, the skill of the old captains, and thereby reduce what was an art to the status of a science. (b) Having discovered the positions and directions of the master veins and the attitudes of their oreshoots, the possibilities of their extending into unworked areas of the bearing beds must he studied. (c) In order to provide sufficient tonnage for a modern mine, preference should be given to areas where there appear to be a "swarm" of veins. (d) The foregoing conditions being satisfied, search must be made for suitable sites for diamond drilling. To sum up, it can be said that although good opportunities will be found in the pre-Carboniferous rocks, where prospecting can be conducted with a fair chance of success, they will not be so frequent as in the Carboniferous and to some extent less attractive, because: (1) Their ore-shoots are generally steeper. (2) The average grade of the ore is lower, (3) The veins are less continuous. (4) Marketable gangue minerals are less common. (5) Close spaced groups of veins are less frequent. (6) The mining districts are more remote from industrial areas. In their favour, it can be said that they are less likely to be heavily watered and their pumping costs will be lower than in the Carboniferous districts and as already mentioned, in the more remote areas there are still chances that virgin vein outcrops may be found. The possible extent of unworked lead orefields in England This subject should for the present be regarded as being mainly of academic interest, because making trials by boring or shaft-sinking in search of lead ore in areas remote from proved occurrences would be hazardous to a degree which could not be faced by private mining enterprise. Moreover, there are sufficient promising trials awaiting the adventurous in and around the margins of the known orefields, where the hazards do not exceed what is termed "a fair mining risk," to keep us busy until some new method of locating deep-lying ore has been invented. If and when such an invention becomes of practical use, it is probable that an old industrial country like Britain will be the first to benefit on account of the proximity of its mines to the centres of population. Nevertheless the knowledge that ore exists in areas now remote from the proved mining fields affords additional confidence in the future of the industry. That the ultimate development of entirely new orefields is by no means impossible is shown by study of the history of the development of many of the world's great mining fields. Their history generally follows the same lines-first the discovery (often accidental) of a solitary outcrop of a vein or reef. This leads to closer search in its vicinity and the discovery of more outcrops. Active mining follows and the outcrops are linked together geologically, whilst underground operations discover new orebodies which have no visible outcrops. Conditions are then set for geological surveys and drilling from the surface over wide areas guided solely by the experience gained in the active areas. The great goldfields of the Rand and the O.F.S., provide a classic example of the evolution of a mining field which has taken place within the span of a single lifetime. In our Pennine orefields the veins are of a type which originated with the filling of fissures already existing, but, as we have seen, the conditions conducive to the formation of ore deposits of economic value only occurred in definite and restricted stratigraphical horizons. The "bearing beds," to use the old term, are far more widespread than the known orefields, which are restricted to areas where the favourable strata are exposed at the surface or at no great depth around the margins. The whole extent of the "bearing beds" is not mineralised, because areas of mineralisation are localised around emanative centres and these occur where there are lines of weakness or fracture caused by folding of the rocks during periods of earth movements. For the prospector who is searching for the most promising ground on which to explore below a non-productive cover rock such lines may provide him with a course which is likely to lead to successful discoveries. The mining developments now proceeding at Matlock appear to provide an example of this because the repeated occurrence of mineral deposits of economic importance along a well defined line can hardly be accidental. The veins now being explored near Matlock Bath follow the axis of a very well defined anticline whose crest runs from west to east, varying in parts to ENE. Following this line from the River Derwent to the west we find, within a mile, the prominent Masson Hill which is a limestone dome crowned with a mass of intrusive dolerite. Close to this dolerite there is the Masson Fluorspar Mine which is a replacement orebody and probably the largest fluorspar deposit in Britain. Following the line westward for about 12 miles of exposed limestone where there are indications of an E-W anticline, we come to the Ecton dome where the richest copper "pipe" deposit of Britain was worked in the 18th century. Two miles further west there is another inlying limestone dome at Mixon where there was another lead-copper mine. Four miles to the north-east of Matlock Bath, there is the Ashover limestone inlier which in the past was very rich in lead. This also takes the form of a dome and it is recorded that bitumen was found in the shales there. Incidentally, liquid bitumen has been found recently in the Riber Mine where the Matlock developments are proceeding. Six miles east of the Ashover Inlier there is a dome formation in the coal measures at Hardstoft where oil drilling was done in 1918 and two wells have produced a little oil ever since. Twenty miles further east near Eakring in Nottinghamshire borings for oil were successful during the recent war and are still producing. The total distance from Mixon to Eakring is about 45 miles. It is significant that the discovery of fluorspar and galena was reported from the oil borings at Eakring. From the evidence provided by this line of domes and mineral deposits along an anticlinal ridge in the limestone where this rock is exposed at the surface, it seems probable that there is an important line of folding and probably emanative centres are located along it. A line of this type should deserve the attention of the prospector. Outlying occurrences of lead ore have been found in several parts of England at places many miles from the nearest known orefield, but probably associated with them. For example in the Durham Coalfield galena has been found fairly frequently in fault fissures where they intersect the coal seams and, as has already been mentioned, barytes is worked on a considerable scale from more than one colliery. The veins of barytes and witherite which are found in several collieries in Co. Durham appear as branches or extensions of faults which can be traced for many miles westward into the lead orefields where they are mineralised with galena and fluorspar. It appears reasonable to believe that these barytes and witherite veins may form important lead veins in depth, and although this has never been proved in England, it is a fact that in the Ruhr an important output of lead and zinc ore is derived from mineralised faults which intersect the coal seams. Modern prospecting methods Search for undiscovered outcrops on the surface of Britain, where the value and appearance of lead ore has been known for centuries, is unlikely to be successful, and future prospecting must be directed at the discovery of concealed deposits-this will require the intelligent application of geological knowledge (assisted by geophysical and geochemical methods where these are applicable). We are still largely dependent on the work of our predecessors who made the first discoveries, and thereby narrowed the field of search to areas where modern methods can be applied to the best advantage. Compared with the conditions prevailing 100 years ago, we are at a grave disadvantage owing to the abandonment of most of the mines, because it was in the underground workings that most of the new discoveries were made: nevertheless, we have some advantages not possessed by our predecessors in our possession of the maps and records of the Geological Survey and the collection of old mine plans now conducted by the Mines Department. Before the middle of the 19th century, the prospector had to rely almost entirely on local records which were often no more than traditions, or on plans which had been preserved by interested persons who often asked a high price for the privilege of inspecting them. Excepting the improved geological knowledge of the present day, the most important tool possessed by us, which was not available to our predecessors of 100 years ago, is the diamond drill which affords a rapid and relatively (compared with actual mining) cheap method of proving and amplifying geological theory. In the difficult task of selecting the most promising sites for testing by drilling or actual mining, the modern prospector has to rely mainly on his skill in the interpretation of evidence afforded by the geological conditions, old workings and old plans. To some extent he is assisted by the fact that only a small proportion of the numerous properties offered for examination appear to possess the qualities required for mining under modern conditions. Although there are many properties which might eventually develop into successful mines, they do not present the examiner with those features which he must find before he can recommend them for development by private enterprise. The development of properties which are at first sight unattractive should await the acquisition of better knowledge, resulting from the development of the attractive ones. Geophysical prospecting In their present stage of development the various geophysical methods of prospecting do not offer any positive and direct method of locating the average British lead vein. The veins are not large enough and their unworked or concealed parts generally lie too deep for discovery by the electrical methods. Moreover, these methods can only detect conductors which are anomalous to the surrounding rocks and such anomalies may be caused by the presence of other conductors than lead ore. The seismic, gravimetric and self-potential methods are only suitable for the location of large structural features. The lead-ore prospector must wait for the invention of a device which will indicate the proximity of galena in the way a Geiger counter responds to the presence of radio-active minerals, but in view of the fact that galena comes low in the scale of radioactivity, the prospect does not seem hopeful. Nevertheless, it may be possible at times to use the electrical methods for tracing the continuation of fault fissures beyond the limits where they can be seen on the surface. When there is a possibility of such fault fissures being ore-bearing, the detection of the course of the fault in advance would allow diagonal drill holes to be sited on the surface and aimed so as to intersect the fissure at the appropriate depth in the "bearing zone." At the same time, it must be clearly emphasised that a geophysical survey only detects the fissure and this may not be ore-bearing and too much reliance must not be placed on the discovery. Geochemical prospecting These methods depend on the detection of trace anomalies in the metallic contents of the subsoil or vegetation. They are still in the early and experimental stage and in Britain they have only been tried experimentally to find out if they respond to the presence of veins already known. Some interesting results have been obtained over ground where blind veins are known to have been worked at depths several hundred feet below the surface. The old lead-mining districts of Britain present considerable difficulties to this form of prospecting owing to the unintentional "salting" of the surface by previous workers. Apart from old mine waste dumps and the use of mine tailings on roads and footpaths, it must be remembered that before the days of centralised smelt mills, it was the custom to smelt the ore on the nearest windy hilltop. Old smelting sites of this kind were named Bale (or Bole) Hills and are very common in the older districts. The sulphurous and metallic fumes from these primitive smelting hearths were carried by the wind far and wide to the detriment of the vegetation, and the land was said to be "belloned" or poisoned. It seems probable that "salting" by this means would tend to mask or render unreliable any anomalies discovered by geochemical surveys. There is a well-known story at a certain rich West African gold mine to the effect that the fumes and dust from the dry roasting plant carried gold values up to 5 dwt. per ton in the dust which settled half a mile from the plant. Nevertheless, there may be scope for the use of geochemical methods for mapping surface anomalies in areas which are far removed from the scene of old mining operations, where the geological conditions are favourable, or perhaps an accidental discovery has been made by boring or excavations made for other purposes. Drawings and Photographs accompanying the article
Article reproduced from a copy of the magazine held at National Mining Museum Scotland, Newtongrange, Midlothian.
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 17 Jan 2023
|
Search |
|
|||