|
November, 1954 Lead Mining in the British Isles — can it be revived? — Part 4*by W. W. Varvill, M.Sc., M.I.M.M.In areas where lead-ore deposits occur in the form of metasomatic replacements of the country rock, the proximity of ore may in places be detected by systematic analyses or examinations of the country rock in its vicinity. Replacement deposits in limestone are often associated with dolomitisation of the limestone and their proximity is presaged by an increase in the magnesia content of the country rock. The method is by no means precise because there are large areas of dolomitised limestone which are quite devoid of ore, nevertheless there may be local opportunities to apply the system. As a rule, it can only be applied where underground development is in progress. Traditional methods of prospecting underground Although there are not many opportunities for employing the traditional methods of surface prospecting such as stream examinations, shoading, hushing and costeaning, because the surface of our land has been subjected to these for centuries and new discoveries are unlikely, it will still be necessary to employ the time-honoured methods of locating and following the ore underground. These need not be discussed at any great length because they come within the experience of most mining engineers who have had to deal with the mining of narrow veins. Some of the more important may be mentioned, as follows :— (1) Rich deposits of ore are often found at the junctions of veins if they meet at an acute angle, and belong to the same period of fissure formation. Such deposits often form steep pitching pipes. (2) A change in the angle of dip of a vein is often accompanied by a change in the grade of its contents. (3) In limestone, enrichment and enlargement often occurs where the vein fissures make contact with a soft rock such as shale, lava or clay. (4) The effect of fault displacement on the continuity of ore-shoots must be closely observed, in order to decide if the faulting preceded or came after the mineralisation. In the former case, the ore-shoot may not be found to continue beyond the fault. (5) The presence of a continuous flow of water from the face of a working being driven in vein provides a valuable guide and enables the correct choice to be made of fissures in the event of the vein splitting. (6) At some mines it was found that water issuing from fissures connected with rich ore, had a temperature a few degrees higher than normal, and may be accompanied by a discharge of carbon dioxide or sulphuretted hydrogen. Knowledge of indications such as these and many others, were the stock-in-trade of the old-time tributers who took pains to conceal them from the agents and captains when the bargains were being let, and discussion of them, often wrapped in a good deal of mystery, provided an endless topic at the local inn. Such local knowledge was generally based on scientific facts which can now be explained, but those possessing the knowledge are now dead and the modern scientifically-trained engineer lacks experience of the various phenonema. This branch of the "art of mining" will have to be learned afresh. Diamond drilling The diamond drill provides the most valuable tool in the hands of the modern prospector although there still remains a certain amount of prejudice against its use for short holes where there is the alternative of exploration by actual mining. This arose because the cost of exploration by short crosscuts, shafts and winzes was not a great deal higher than that of drilling and, although slower, the information gained is far more reliable and the excavations made can be used for exploitation when the exploration is successful. This argument was sound when exploration was being made from the workings of an active mine where there was already a fairly accurate knowledge of the probable existence and whereabouts of fresh ore deposits, but when the search is being conducted from the surface of a derelict mining area where such knowledge is absent, the risk of failing to find ore is much greater, and the additional cost of diamond drilling, as a preliminary to mining, is fully justified by the reduction of the risk factor. Fortunately, in the Pennine areas which, as already stated, offer the best opportunities for the successful use of the diamond drill, the "ribbon" or banded nature of the veins produces a high degree of continuity and fewer holes are required to obtain satisfactory proof of the existence of unworked ore. It is true that the recovery of satisfactory cores of galena presents a difficult problem, but even without these there will be valuable information gained of the existence of vein fissures and the nature of the gangue with which they are filled — experience of the type of vein which has proved productive in the past will enable the examiner to judge whether the vein is likely to be ore-bearing. It is probable that wider experience of drilling for British lead veins will lead to better appreciation of the significance of the cores than is now the case, because very little core drilling has so far been done in Britain for this purpose, and we do not know what kind of core recovery can be expected under normal conditions. Drilling carried out during the past four years has already made important contributions, not only by the discovery of veins but also to our knowledge of the problems involved and how to solve them, and it is possible to give some details concerning the more important features. The main difficulty in recovering cores of galena lies in the fact that it is one of the heaviest of minerals and also one of the most friable — every ore dresser knows how easily galena "slimes" and floats away after very little abrasion — so it is necessary to study the behaviour of galena when it is penetrated by a diamond core drill. When the drill bit enters solid galena and a short length of ore enters the reaming shell, it is gripped by the core lifter and tends to break off at the point where there is a junction between the galena and the gangue — the vibration of the core barrel rotating at high speed will contribute to this — and the galena will start to rotate rapidly with its lower end rubbing against the harder gangue which projects as a stump from the bottom of the hole. The galena rapidly disintegrates and is carried off by the water and is eventually trapped in crevices in the sides of the hole and so never reaches the surface. It requires only a few minutes of abrasion to grind away all traces of the galena unless it is protected by an admixture of harder gangue to take up some of the wear. In veins where the galena and gangue form bands parallel to the walls, it has been found that better recovery of galena core is made when the axis of the drill makes an acute angle with the wall. Under these conditions the joints between galena and gangue are diagonal to the core axes and the galena survives abrasion longer owing to its obliquity, the drill bores in galena for a longer distance and fragments of the ore mineral are more likely to be recovered. For these reasons the angle of intersection should not exceed 60 deg. to the plane of the vein walls, if this can be arranged. If on the other hand the drill intersects the vein at a wide angle (approaching a right angle) the galena gets little protection from the gangue and is mostly lost by abrasion. This is contrary to normal diamond drilling practice which aims at making the penetration at an angle as nearly normal as possible to the plane of the vein, in order to get as true a picture as can be obtained of the width. This standard practice has evolved from drilling for coal or other bedded deposits where thickness is a matter of paramount importance. In a lead vein, however, the width of the valuable galena portion is generally only a small fraction of the stoping width, so the width of the fissure is not of vital importance provided it contains sufficient galena to pay for working over the minimum stoping width possible. In the absence of some new drilling device specially devised to recover cores of pure galena, the best remedy is to drill deflection holes by wedging from the first hole which cuts the vein, at a point situated a short distance above the intersection. With the knowledge of the exact position of the vein walls determined by the first hole, it is possible to drill the deflection hole with extreme caution at the critical point of entry into the vein and to withdraw and recover the cores at very short intervals. This avoids subjecting the cores to abrasion for prolonged periods and it is probable that some galena will be recovered and provide evidence that the vein is lead-bearing. Frequent withdrawals are tedious but are fully justified if the core recovery is improved. Drill operators are accustomed to assess their efficiency in terms of feet drilled per day and cost per foot drilled, neither of which is of the first importance to the prospector who values a hole in terms of the information gained. Unfortunately it is not easy to assess the value of information in terms of money, and comparative cost statistics cannot be prepared. Even the practice of paying bonuses for the percentage of core recovered is not satisfactory because the loss of as little as 2 per cent, of the full length of the core recovered in crossing the vein will, when the part lost is solid galena and no more is found in the recovered cores, result in a payable vein being classed as barren. The difficulties arising from the loss of galena core by abrasion are less serious when the principal gangue mineral is quartz because in such veins the galena is often disseminated through the quartz and so protected from abrasion. Consequently, the cores of veinstuff from holes drilled into veins in the Ordovician rocks are likely to be more truly representative of the vein than those recovered from Carboniferous veins, because quartz bearing veins are more common in the Ordovician. The quality of a vein cannot be assessed with any degree of accuracy by the assay results of one or even several borehole intersections but they provide valuable incentives for continuing the exploratory work when they give clear proof of the presence of lead-ore even in small quantities and show that the vein has sufficient width to ensure a fair continuity. Core assays alone obviously cannot be relied on for the purpose of estimating the grade of ore reserves and undue emphasis should not be given to abnormally high results, but, at the same time, it must be remembered that the odds against recovering rich cores, even from rich veins, are so great owing to their patchy nature that any such discovery may be considered to give good reasons for optimism. Apart from the problem of recovering galena cores, diamond drilling for lead veins in Britain does not present any difficulties which are not encountered in the normal run of drilling in other fields, so it is not necessary to go into further detail concerning its technique. General policy for prospecting A few remarks on the basic policy for prospecting can be added: No programme of geophysical or geochemical prospecting, or of drilling should be started until the local geological details have been fully grasped over the entire area under examination, and all available old plans and records have been exhaustively studied. Expenditure on geophysical surveys and drilling is far heavier than that required by the preliminary field work and historical research, and it should be delayed until the most promising targets have been selected. The art of prospecting does not lie in making brilliant discoveries by intuition, but in step-by-step reduction of the area of search by the elimination of the less promising points of attack in preparation for the final proof by drilling. In this respect prospecting for minerals has considerable resemblance to the detection of crime. Prospecting for a new venture — new in the sense that it is not being undertaken on a property already in active production — should be conducted with all the more caution (because the risk of failure is greater and more likely to result in the abandonment of the venture) than is the case where the work forms part of the routine exploratory development of a mine already in production. In the latter case there may be many trials which can be undertaken as current mine development and charged against current profits, but are too risky to be undertaken by a company with no revenue and limited capital. In brief, the first attacks by drilling or actual mining should only be made at the most promising targets, and the engineer must beware against dispersing his forces by attempting too many attacks at the same time. Mining methods Prospecting has been discussed at some length because, as has already been stated, the lead-mining industry of Britain cannot be revived until fresh orereserves have been found. Once they have been found, their extraction is unlikely to present abnormal problems and low working costs are to be expected. Compared with lead mines abroad, British mines will not be deep; 1,000 ft. in the Carboniferous rocks and 2,000 ft. in the Ordovician are not likely to be exceeded for many years. Depths of this nature are small by modern standards and make for low working costs for winding, ventilation and drainage as well as less capital expenditure on shaft sinking. Underground haulage may extend for considerable distances, possibly several miles in the Pennine mines, but the modern diesel mine locomotive has solved this problem at a lower cost per ton-hauled than was possible in the past when horses provided the tractive force. Stoping the veins and driving development headings does not present any unusual problems. The veins are easy to drill and their walls are generally strong and nearly vertical and stand with little support and small expense for timber. Their steep dip lends itself to the employment of "rill" and "shrinkage" methods of stoping, whereby handling costs are at their lowest. It is not as a rule necessary to fill the empty stopes for support and, consequently, the whole of the ore mined can be sent to the mill and a higher overall recovery of the valuable contents is made. The old system of raising the grade by hand sorting in the stopes, generally by candlelight, may have improved the head values and thereby given the mine a fictitious reputation for richness, but it was at the expense of leaving behind a large proportion of the ore which by modern standards would be well worth tramming out and milling. Barren development rock also is often worth sending to the surface where it may bring a good price as road metal if it is of a suitable type. The use of compressed-air driven face-loaders of the rocker-shovel type has now become so general that hand shovelling is rarely practised — in fact there are few men in our metal mines who can use a shovel properly. At the Llanrwst Mine where both rill and shrinkage stoping is practised it has been found possible to break over 30 tons per machine-shift from a stope 6 ft. wide, using a hammer drill with jack-leg and tungsten carbide bits. In development drives the rate of progress is about 5 ft. to 6 ft. per machineshift. These rates are the general average of day-to-day practice and do not represent the results of special efforts. It is difficult to compare present day working costs with those of, say, 50 years ago when many British mines now closed were still at work, because so many variable factors have to be taken into consideration. At that time drilling both in the stopes and the developments was done almost entirely by hand hammers, with hand shovelling and hand or horse tramming. Underground wage rates are now roughly ten times as high as 50 years ago, but the effect of the use of machines has been to raise the output per manshift in nearly the same proportion, so that the cost per ton mined has not increased very much for actual wages. But this makes no allowance for the cost of providing and running machines, or the greatly increased cost of all stores and overheads. The ultimate result is that the cost of producing lead is now several times as much as it was 50 years ago, this state of affairs being the same the whole world over. The present day market price of metals is a reflection of this trend. As a very rough and ready comparison it may be said that lead mining in Britain today with the metal at £90 per ton is equivalent to mining it 50 years ago with the metal at £18 per ton. Development methods When developing veins in the Carboniferous rocks advantage should be taken of the high continuity of ore deposition found in the "ribbon" ore-shoots. Exploratory crosscuts should, whenever possible, only be directed along branch or cross veins, especially when these exhibit the same type of mineralisation as the master veins, notwithstanding that they may not be payable. By this means, there are greater possibilities of discovering subsidiary veins than there would be if the crosscuts are made in plain country rock. Crosscuts in country rock should only be started when they are intended to reach an objective which is definitely known. At intervals slanting rises should be made at a slope of about 45 deg. in the plane of the vein — this avoids the necessity of timbering and ladderways — and the rises extended until they reach the "roof" or top of the ore-shoot. The tops of the rises can be connected by stope drives under the roof and this made secure so that the whole of the vein can be stoped out without wall support, by underhand rilling from the rises. If the walls are not strong the shrinkage system may be preferred. Both systems result in low stoping costs. With the limited height of the ore-shoots it is advantageous to avoid driving two levels, one above the other in the normal fashion employed when the ore-shoots extend in depth, because when only one level is driven, the cost of primary development is halved, whilst advance information regarding the grade of the ore is secured from the rises. At Llanrwst, where the course of the vein is regular and well defined, the main development drive is made in the footwall country rock parallel to the vein and a short distance from it. Short crosscuts are turned off to cut the vein at short intervals and stoping is started from the ends of these where they intersect the vein. The system has a number of advantages over the normal stope-drive-cum-boxhole system which more than balance the extra cost incurred by driving in the country rock; these are as follows :— (a) The extra cost of making stope drives is avoided. (b) Timbered box-holes are unnecessary. (c) Loading is done with an Eimco shovel at low cost from the ore heap on the floor, with no spill and choking of the shoot. (d) The draw points do not get hung up by large lumps. (e) It avoids the locking-up of ore in the stope pillars which have to be left intact when the main drive is in the vein. (f) It explores the country rock on the side of the vein where the drive is made and ensures the discovery of branch veins which are often masked in the stopes on the main vein by slickensides or fault planes. To summarise on development in the Carboniferous veins, it can be said that the cost per ton should be low and the percentage payability high. Rock drilling Calcite and fluorspar are the predominant gangue minerals in lead veins in the Carboniferous rocks, whilst in the Ordovician and older series there is often a larger proportion of quartz, but not as a rule in excess of the softer minerals. The veins are frequently vuggy with open joints and this, combined with the soft ground, makes rock drilling easy and explosive consumption low. Drilling is generally done wet, although the dust is generally non-injurious. With the modern jackleg-mounted hammer drill, wet drilling is a less unpleasant job than dry, and the comfort of the miner is nowadays a matter of prime importance; furthermore, there is considerable advantage in having a supply of water under pressure at the working face in order to wash down the vein for inspection purposes. With an unwashed vein coated with dust it is very easy to miss important features which may lead to fresh discoveries of ore. A remarkable feature of recent exploration work in old workings is the number of places where the old miners failed to detect features which have quickly led to ore when tried. An explanation for this may be the fact that they had very feeble lights and no means of hosing down the walls and roof. It is not proposed to describe the rock drilling methods in any detail because they do not differ greatly from general practice. It is sufficient to say that in spite of modern developments in the use of jacklegs, tungsten carbide bits, compressed-air loaders and all the other accompaniments of breaking ground which have been developed during recent years, the cost per ton for breaking ground today is far higher compared with the cost of 50 years ago than are present day costs of ore dressing or concentration compared with those of the same period. The reason for this is the fact that the output in tons per manshift has not increased at the same rate as the cost, in spite of mechanisation. This is not due to the present day miner working shorter hours or less hard than his predecessor as the writer can vouch, having seen men at work both now and then. The modern miner gets more pay in terms of purchasing power than did his predecessor and what is more important he is assisted by power-driven equipment costing hundreds of pounds per man, compared with the simple pick and shovel, hammer and drill of his grandfather, who provided these things at his own expense. * In the three previous articles in this series, published on p. 352, August 1954, p. 398, September 1954 and p. 436, October 1954, the author has covered the history and future outlook of this industry, past and present production, geology and the degree of frequency of veins, the possible extent of unworked lead orefields, and modern prospecting methods and rules to be followed. Drawings and Photographs accompanying the article
Article reproduced from a copy of the magazine held at National Mining Museum Scotland, Newtongrange, Midlothian.
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 17 Jan 2023
|
Search |
|
|||