|
11. Theories As To The Cause Of The Explosion.It is often difficult to state the exact place of origin and the actual cause of an explosion even when inspection can be made of all the workings traversed by that explosion, but when, as in this case, no inspection is possible, the place of origin and cause become matters of conjecture not capable of proof and, as Mr. Joseph Hall rightly indicated in his speech, it is not possible to state the cause of this explosion. Inspection was impossible because of the inability to overcome the fire in 142's Deep and the consequent temporary abandonment of the mine on the day following the explosion and, although part of the mine has been reopened, the Dennis Section has remained sealed-off because of the danger of admitting fresh air and so fanning in to flame any incipient heating which may still exist. That such heating has been present has been proved by analyses of samples of the atmosphere taken regularly from beyond the seals. It is expected that this heating will subside in time and that then it will be safe to re-enter the Dennis Section. Until that time arrives, I deprecate any attempt to enter that Section. From the evidence given during the Inquiry and from an examination of the plan of the workings, certain possible causes of the explosion were suggested by the two Counsel and by Mr. Charlton. These theories are briefly outlined here; fuller statements of them in the words of those who put them forward will be found in Appendix V. Sir Stafford Cripps said that when one sorted out the whole mass of evidence and read it through, it became perfectly clear that the two danger points were 95's and 14's. In regard to 95's, because of the probability of a shot having been fired in 142's Deep at 24's airway and the possibility of that shot having ignited gas which had issued from the airway. And in regard to 14's, because of what he regarded as the clear evidence that there was present in the top end of the face a few hours before the explosion a large quantity of gas which he suggested might have been ignited by some mishap to a safety lamp or a coalcutter or some other mischance. Mr. Charlton thought that, for reasons which he outlined, firedamp had come into and filled the drift which was being driven beyond the "Clutch" and on top of goaf laid down after 1918. He thought the gas had come out of the drift and was present to some extent next the roof in 142's Deep as far as a canch where the Deep crosses a fault; that the lamps of the men working in the drift and those at the "Clutch" had been extinguished by that gas; and that ignition was at the telephone, when it was about to be used for warning those inbye of the influx of gas in the drift. Mr. Hartley Shawcross suggested that the explosion was one of firedamp alone and that coal dust could have played no part. He submitted that the explosion must have started somewhere in the neighbourhood of the "Clutch" or of 29's Turn and he supported Mr. Charlton's theory as a very probable one. Alternatively, he suggested that the explosion might have originated from spontaneous combustion at a pillar of coal lying in the goaf up against the 45-70 foot fault. In support of the latter theory, Mr. Shawcross referred to curious evidence which was given by several witnesses as to the odd smell that they had noticed for some day or two before the explosion". I have not hitherto mentioned this evidence about a smell but, as some importance appears to have been attached to it, it may be mentioned that the two deputies, J. H. Thomas and N. Parry, said that when on their way inbye on the morning of 20th September, at a point 40 to 50 yards on the inbye side of 61's junction, they smelled what Thomas described as "an unusual smell, but not what I should call a dangerous smell"; he called Parry's attention to it. Parry described the smell as being like that of dead mice. The shotfirer, Arthur Jones, said that when he was in the cage at the Martin Shaft at 8 o'clock on the night of 21st September, the onsetter, Frank Gibson, "passed a remark and said there was a peculiar smell, and I said ‘ Yes, someone has got their trousers down ‘". Gibson, the onsetter, said that after he had got the men away, he noticed a smell unlike anything he had smelled before or since and that it was still there when he finished his shift. Robert Roberts, who was working with Gibson from 2.30 p.m. to 10 p.m. on Friday, 21st September, said he did not smell any strange smell during that shift and Gibson did not say anything to him about one. It will be remembered that the Under-manager, after he discovered the smoke in 29's return, said there was no smell of gob fire. I cannot say positively that this evidence in regard to "smell" is of no importance; I have not so regarded it. Although the Main Coal Seam does heat spontaneously at the neighbouring colliery — Llay Main — there was no history of heatings or gob fires at Gresford. I do not propose to discuss the arguments for or against the several suggestions made as to the cause and the point of origin of the explosion, but it is right that I should say that for reasons already stated in the earlier sections of this Report, I look with grave suspicion upon the circumstances existing in connexion with 24's airway in 95's district.
A copy of this report was kindly donated by
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||