Proceeding into No. 1 Pit, on the south side of the shaft, a number of tubs showed signs of great force having passed inward to the south. The upper parts of some of these tubs were sheared off the trains and carried in-bye, and the angle irons at the corners were, in most cases, bent in-bye. At (2) there was evidence of great force passing off the haulage road towards No. 1 boilers; the regulating doors were blown towards the boilers, and the dampers of the boilers were forced into the flues. At (3) doors were blown to the return. The air crossing here was blown up; bricks from it and from a fall of arching were mostly blown to the north or out-bye. Unburnt hay was also scattered along the road here, evidently from the stables further in. At (4) near the engine house part of the cover of a large wheel was blown in-bye. At (5) tail rope sheaves blown down afforded evidence of force having passed over them as shown by arrow. At (6) the main intake was doubled, one road being used as a haulage road and the other as a travelling road for men and horses, part of the air passing along each road. These roads united again at (7). The passages driven between the haulage and travelling roads in this case, as well as between two such roads in the Maudlin Seam, were stowed close, preventing any force passing between them except at the junctions. The explosion had not traversed the travelling road; at each end, at its junction with the haulage road, disturbance was observed extending a short distance along the travelling road ; a blast had shot into each end of it. At (8), about half way along the travelling road, doors leading from it into the return were not moved. Near (9) the wrecks of two cabins by the side of the road showed signs of force passing in-bye. At (10) the out-bye end of a wall of loose stones was swept in-bye. Near (11) five stoppings were blown towards the return ; nearly all the other stoppings which were examined were so strongly stowed that they had not been moved. At (12) doors were blown to the return. At (13) a prop was forced in between the hauling rope and a binding sheave, showing force as indicated by arrow. At (14) doors were blown to the return. At (15) the return wheel, at the Third East way end, was moved in-bye. At (16) and (17) tubs were forced in-bye. At (18) the return air road was directly above the intake and haulage road, a brick arch separating them. This arch had been blown up for a length of about fifteen yards and a very large fall of stone had taken place, which was roughly estimated to amount to 400 tons. This fall completely closed the road. The explosion had ceased on this road less than 300 yards beyond the fall; doors there were not blown out.
Returning to the downcast shaft and proceeding into No. 3 Pit; from the shaft to the commencement of the curve, the timber was blown out and some of the roof stone fallen. At (19) was the road leading to No. 1 furnace and upcast staple; the doors here were blown towards the furnace and staple. In the curve no timber had been required, and there was nothing here to afford indications as to the passage of force. At (20), the west end of the curve, timber was displaced on the Maudlin haulage road at its junction with the curve From this point, passing into No. 3 Pit for a distance of about 100 yards, none of the timber, of which there was a large quantity, was blown out or displaced. At (21), about the centre of this undisturbed portion of road, blasting tools were observed standing upright against the side of the road, not having been blown over. The only sign of force on this length of road was a slight disturbance of one or two sheaves carrying a haulage rope near the roof and of a wire rapper rope. The rapper rope was coiled round the haulage rope, and a few yards of it were drawn or shoved in a sort of knot against a sheave. As this was close to the undisturbed blasting gear it appeared probable that the force was transmitted by the ropes themselves when they were disturbed by falls of stone or timber at some point outside this length of road. After passing over this undisturbed portion of road the timber was again found blown out, and this displacement of timber continued up to the limits of the explosion in every direction ; heavy falls of stone being caused in many places by its removal. At (22) is the road leading to No. 3 or the upcast pit; doors here were blown towards that shaft, and nearer the shaft tubs had been traversed by force passing to it. At the upcast shaft (23) the scaffold and wire rope guides were displaced, and doors beyond the shaft were blown to the return. Here also doors leading to No. 3 furnace were blown towards the furnace. At (24), on the other road off the main intake to No. 3 shaft, timber was blown towards the shaft; the doors which stood on this road had completely disappeared.
Returning to the main road at (22) doors were blown northward towards the North Main Coal. The explosion did not extend into the North Main Coal. On the main road at this point stood an engine, the pressure gauge pipe of which was bent towards the west. At (25) a wall was displaced westward. At (26) a large wheel was broken, and part of it carried to the west; the cleading or fencing of this wheel was blown in the same direction. The air crossing near here was displaced. At (27), to the east of the South way end, the sheet iron guard of a sheave was bent over to the east, and within the South way a similar guard was bent over to the south. At (28) was a staple, down which coal tubs were lowered from the Main Coal Seam; timber in the staple was displaced and doors near it were blown into the return. Passing along the South way at (29) tubs and sheaves had been traversed by force passing southward. At (30) two air crossings were displaced. The explosion ceased a short distance beyond the crossings. Returning to the road going west an abandoned way known as the West incline was examined. At (31) a loose coil of rapper rope was driven eastward on to a loose rail. At (32) bricks from a wall (built at side of road in order to make a definite area for measuring air) were blown eastward. Near (33) two rope rollers, partially torn from their framework, showed signs of force passing west. At (34) the incline wheel, seven feet in diameter, was torn from its framework and carried thirty yards westward. This wheel, with its brake attachments, would probably weigh half a ton. Further up this road five pairs of doors were blown to the returns. The explosion ceased a short distance from the face, and next the goaf a light wood fence was undisturbed.
Returning to the shafts :— from each end of the curve, roads passed through a dislocation, which threw the Hutton and Maudlin Seams nearly on one level; these roads joined on the Maudlin side of the trouble. One of them passing direct from the downcast shaft was known as the travelling way, and the other was the haulage road along which the coal from the Maudlin Seam passed to No. 3 Pit. On the travelling way at (35) bricks from an air measuring place were blown towards No. 1 Pit, and the air crossing further along it was displaced. On the other road, disturbance commenced at its junction with the curve (20), where timber was displaced. At (36) tail rope sheaves on spindles, fixed in the side of road, were blown in-bye, and the spindles bent in the same direction. Near the junction of the two roads, through the dislocation at (37), a travelling road and second intake, similar to that described as existing in No. 1 Pit, left the haulage road, rejoining it at (38). This travelling road, like the other, had not been traversed by the explosion, but was disturbed only for a short distance from each end. On the Maudlin haulage road, near the East way end (39), a chock built of timber placed crossways was moved inward. Near (40) a balk was observed slewed outward, the prop under one end of it was blown out, and it had moved on the other as a pivot. The explosion ceased in here about the engine landing (41). In the East way of the Maudlin it had passed almost to the face.
It will be observed that all the indications of the path of the explosion are on the main intake air ways and haulage roads. The return air ways and those parts of the intake and haulage roads not affected by the explosion were carefully examined, and no difficulty was found in coming to a positive conclusion that they had been traversed by neither force nor flame. In all cases, doors, air crossings, and such stoppings as were moved, were blown from the intakes to the returns.
The distinct evidences of flame having existed over the roads traversed by the explosion were few at Seaham, beyond the burning of men and horses, and fires found burning after the explosion. There was a marked absence of coked coal dust, but a microscopical and chemical examination of coal dust from roads traversed by the explosion, made by Sir F. (then Professor) Abel, afforded evidence of the action of flame upon it. Unfortunately, no exact record was kept as to the burning of the bodies of the victims, but so far as observations were made, it was found that the bodies of men and horses, who had been on the roads traversed by the explosion, were burnt, and as traces of fire were found on these roads, far apart, it is concluded that the flame had passed continuously along them.
In No. 1 Pit, the onsetter was burnt near the downcast shaft (1). At (2) the coal was found burning after the explosion. At (4) the engine house was on fire. At (12) a man was burnt. Between (17 and (18) timber was charred.
In No. 3 Pit, at (20) and (21) men were burnt. At (22) burnt coal or dust was observed. At (28) timber on fire was extinguished by survivors.
In the Maudlin, the stables on the east side of the road at (37) were on fire. Near (41) timber was charred. At (43) the stables in the East way had been the scene of a fire, smoke and steam were seen by the explorers before this part of the pit was sealed off, and on re-opening the mine it was found that there had been an extensive fire in these stables.
At the time of the explosion there were on the plane of the explosion 169 persons; five of these survived, one being the onsetter at the downcast shaft, and four workmen from the South way in No. 3 Pit, who escaped to the shaft by the return air road.
There were the following fires and naked lights on the plane of the explosion :—
| Open lamps at the downcast shaft. |
| Open lamps at the upcast shaft. |
| No. 1 furnace and 2 boiler fires near it, fed with return air. |
| No. 3 furnace fed with return air. |
| No. 1 boilers fed with fresh air. |
Four horsekeepers carried naked lights. One of them was found near the stables in No. 1 Pit, near (6). One in the stables in No. 3 Pit, near (22). Two were found in the Maudlin; one in the west stables, near (37) ; and the other on the haulage road of the East way, at (42).
Each of the workmen, except the four horsekeepers, had a safety lamp.
There was possibly an open lamp at the bottom of the Main Coal Staple (28). One hung there, but it was not known whether it was lighted at the time of the explosion.
Shots were to be fired on the night of the explosion at three points in No. 3 Pit. One, west of the curve, at (21) ; and two, near the South way end, (27). These shots were all to be fired for the purpose of enlarging refuge holes.
The workmen on the plane of the explosion may be divided into three classes :— First, the survivors ; second, victims in the field of the explosion, or who had been traversed by force or flame, or both; third, victims outside the field of the explosion.
Of the survivors, one of them, the onsetter at the downcast shaft had been in the field of the explosion; the other four persons were outside the field. These men had been under no alarm up to the time of the explosion.
The workmen in those parts of the pit over which the force and flame of the explosion had extended, or victims in the field of the explosion, were all found at the places where their work required them, and there appeared no reason for supposing that any of them had been alarmed previous to the explosion.
Those of the workmen who had been outside the field of the explosion were found, in most cases with their lamps, at some distance from their working places, and they had perished by after-damp while coming out, or while waiting for rescue. There was evidence in the form of written records that some of these men had lived for some hours after the explosion.02 The oil in some of their lamps was exhausted, showing that they had continued burning for some hours after the explosion.
In fixing the point of origin of this explosion, the first consideration which forcibly presented itself was, that this point did not lie at or near any of the working faces where the bulk of the workmen were, but at some place within a short distance of the shafts. Thus, in No. 1 Pit, the indications at (1), (4), (5), (9), (10), (13), (15), (16). and (17) showed that the explosion had gone inward from the downcast shaft. In No. 3 Pit, the indications at (22), (25), (26), (33), and (34) showed it had gone up the West incline from some point to the east of the road leading to No. 3 Pit; and indication (29), that it had passed into the South way from its junction with the West way. In the Maudlin, indications at (36) and (39), showed that force had gone inward from the junction of the Maudlin haulage road with the curve.
It will be observed that there were on each of the three long lines of road, certain minor indications, at (1) and (3) in No. 1 Pit; at (27), (31), and (32) in No. 3 Pit; and at (40) in the Maudlin, which pointed to force coming outward. It is somewhat difficult to account for these reverse indications, but it would appear that in some, if not in all cases, there is a reverse current of considerable force succeeding the explosion, sufficient in strength to move loose materials or bodies already disturbed by the original force; and the writers conclude that these outward indications were due to this secondary action, as in all cases much stronger indications of inward force were observed.
02 See Note A.