The positions in which the bodies of the men from all the working faces were found showed that they had been killed by after-damp, and not by the force or fire of the explosion.
As the indications clearly pointed to the vicinity of the shafts as the place where the explosion had originated, attention was naturally directed to the furnaces near (19) and (23), as the return air carrying off all the gas issuing from the plane of the explosion passed over these furnaces. In addition to this, there were, at Seaham, large goaves within a comparatively short distance of the shafts. The possibility of the explosion having had its origin at one of these furnaces was carefully considered. It was quite evident, however, that the explosion had passed from the intakes to the furnaces. In both cases, doors separating the intakes from the returns near the furnaces were blown towards the furnaces, and in all other cases, doors, regulators, air crossings, and stoppings were blown from the intakes to the returns. In the return air ways there was satisfactory evidence that no explosion had passed to or from the furnaces by that route. In both cases the caution boards, about 50 yards from the furnaces, were unmoved, and a miniature wind-mill near one of them was not blown down. At no point was any disturbance observed in the return air ways, except at points where the explosion had blown into them from the intakes. The considerations applying to the furnaces apply equally to the boiler fires fed with return air near No. 1 furnace. The regulating doors leading to the No. 1 Pit boilers, fed with fresh air, at (2), were blown towards the boilers, and this, with other evidence, negatived the idea that the explosion had originated at them.
There was nothing whatever to show that the naked lights at the shafts or the open lights or lanterns carried by the four horsekeepers could be selected as a point of origin.
The workmen in No. Pit, to the west of the road leading from the intake (22) to the upcast shaft, had been traversed by the explosion, passing into the West and South ways. Two shots had been fired near (27), between the air crossing and the South way end, but apparently some time before the explosion.
There remain now for consideration two men working on the undisturbed portion of the main road to the west of the curve. From the position in which these men were found, and from facts observed at the point where they were engaged, it was evident that they had fired a shot in the stone either immediately before or simultaneously with the explosion, near the centre of the undisturbed portion of road. The road here was in stone, and these men had been engaged in enlarging a refuge hole by blasting. Part of the end of the drill hole was visible, and the stone blown down by the shot had not been removed. The blasting gear was standing near, set upright against the side. A broom was observed near the place.03 One of the stonemen was found in a refuge hole 20 yards to the west of the shot, and the other was 40 yards to the east, these being positions they might naturally assume after lighting a shot. These men had safety lamps. In lighting a shot they did not unscrew the lamp top off, but inserted a thin pliant wire through the gauze into the flame, withdrawing it quickly when heated and applying it to touch-paper; this touch-paper took fire and in turn ignited powder in a straw in the pricker hole of the shot.
The writers assume an issue of flame from the shot as the ignition point of the explosion.
The indications of force strongly point to the undisturbed section of the main road as being the starting point of the explosion, force radiating from here in three directions.
It was ascertained that the explosion, in passing from the Maudlin and No. 1 Pit into No. 3 Pit, or vice versa, must have traversed this undisturbed length ; the only other routes available were examined, and it was clear no explosion had passed along them. If, therefore, the point of origin lay outside this length of road, the difficulty presented itself of accounting for the absence of disturbance on it; no other examples of force dying out for 100 yards and resuming again its full strength were observed.
If, however, the explosion originated in the undisturbed length of road it did not appear unreasonable to suppose that in some way the force increased in each direction, and this is what the writers assume took place. It will be observed that the existence of flame is proved in the undisturbed length of road.
The next factor to be considered is the explosive material. The only substances which have ever been regarded as contributory to colliery explosions are fire-damp and coal dust, and until recently the influence of the latter was practically ignored. The explosive nature of mixtures of fire-damp and air is well known, but in attempting to account for this explosion, on the assumption that it was caused by fire-damp, there are difficulties which appear to the writers to be insurmountable. These difficulties, moreover, are independent of the precise position of the point of ignition, and would apply with equal force to any point selected. The chief difficulty is to account for the extension of the explosion for long distances over the main intake air ways; roads constantly swept by large volumes of air, separating into three main currents at the downcast shaft. It is incredible that the air on all these roads was in an inflammable or explosive state, due to the presence of fire-damp. The absence of alarm amongst the workmen on them, at the time of the explosion, goes far to prove that it was not. To account for the air passing along any one of the intakes, being charged with fire-damp, it is necessary to assume a sudden discharge of gas at some point, of which there was no evidence whatever. All these roads were old and spacious galleries, along which large currents of air passed direct from the downcast shaft, and the tendency of the air was to pass from them into all side openings. Naked lights were used on them daily, and at the time of the explosion some such lights were in use on them.
It was very improbable that there had been any accumulation of firedamp in any place out of the direct current of air, and any possible accumulation of the kind must necessarily have been too small in amount to account for the effects observed.
Apart, however, from the difficulty of accounting for the presence of fire-damp at any possible point of ignition, greater difficulties present themselves in attempting to account for the large extent of the explosion, and the fact that it had been confined to one particular class of roads the haulage roads. Indeed, a consideration of these phenomena appears to negative the possibility of any gaseous body having carried the explosion over the mine.
Had the explosion been due to the combustion of fire-damp, existing either as a fouled air current, or as an accumulation or series of accumulations, it is evident that in exploding it would extend indifferently over all the open roads accessible to it (other than that on which it existed) until the expansion ceased. This was not the case, but the contrary. On each of the three long lines of road, over which the explosion extended, it missed certain portions along which passed air split off the same current. These portions of intake air roads, all well within the field of the explosion over which it did not pass, were the travelling roads in No. 1 Pit, and the Maudlin, the North Main Coal, and the South way in No. 3 Pit. Neither had the explosion traversed any of the return air ways, along which pass all the fire-damp given off in the mine.
The apparent impossibility of accounting for the effects of this explosion, on the assumption that it was due to fire-damp and air, and the great difficulty in accounting for the presence of any fire-damp at any point at which the explosion could possibly have had its origin, directed attention to coal dust. There was coal dust on all the roads traversed by the explosion, and there was coal dust at the supposed point of origin. Seaham is a very dry colliery, and the haulage roads were the driest parts of it, The coal dust in the vicinity of the downcast shaft proceeded in part from the surface, being carried in the air from the screens and deposited in the pit ; on a sunny day the particles of dust could be seen glistening in the air, and going down the shaft. The chief source of the dust on the haulage roads was from the tubs of coal, drawn by engine power at the rate of 10 or 12 miles an hour, against currents of air moving in the opposite direction, The coal being dry and dusty, much dust was swept off the tubs and settled on the roads, and beyond what was thus swept off, both dust and small coal were shaken out of any holes there were in the tubs.
The return air roads were practically free from coal dust, no coal was led along these roads, and the chief source of coal dust was therefore absent. After the driving of these roads in the coal, a considerable amount of work was done in them from time to time in the shape of forming stone pillars, removing fallen stone, etc., and they were constantly travelled by the wastemen and officials. They were dry, and these operations produced a quantity of stone dust, grey in colour. No coal was led along the travelling roads in No. 1 Pit and in the Maudlin; they were used as doubling the intake air road, and as travelling roads for men and horses; the dust in them was principally stone dust. The inner portion of the South way in No. 3 Pit, beyond the point to which the explosion extended, was a horse road, and the dust on it was largely mixed with stone dust, caused by the grinding of the soft bottom stone by the feet of men and horses. The coal being led by horses did not travel at a high speed, and the current of air passing along this road had no great velocity. The North Main Coal, into which the explosion did not extend, was damp and free from coal dust.
It thus appeals, that on all the roads traversed by the explosion there was a plentiful supply of coal dust, while those portions of the roads which it had apparently so capriciously missed were, in comparison, free from coal dust, In the absence of any other means of accounting for the extent and course of the explosion, these facts are of striking significance. After the explosion all the parts of the mine, in which its effects could be traced, were covered on the bottom and on flat surfaces with a coating of fine dust, impalpable and almost like soot, which when examined under the microscope appeared to have been acted on by great heat. This fine dust covered the surfaces for a depth of from 1/8 to an inch, and under it, on the roadways, was coarser dust and refuse. Dust of this nature was entirely absent on those roads over which the explosion had not extended.
There was a marked absence of the coked or charred dust so often found after explosions, but that part of the volatile matter was expelled from the dust, was proved by the analyses of Sir Frederick Abel, undertaken at the request of the Miners' National Association. It would be difficult to estimate whether a sufficient amount of volatile inflammable matter had been expelled to consume all the oxygen in the air on the roads over which the explosion passed, but it would only require a small proportion of the total amount of such volatile matter to do so.
It will be observed that the explosion had been arrested at a considerable distance from the face in the Third East way in No. 1 Pit, and the West way in the Maudlin. The reason of this was not quite obvious, but it may have arisen either from the action of heavy falls or from the failure of the supply of dust. In the Third East way of No. 1 Pit, there was a small feeder of water near the place where the explosion ceased, issuing from the bottom and running to a pump further in, and so causing the road to be damp. This was about 300 yards beyond where the road was completely closed by the fall of the arching ; this fall would close the road as soon as the arch was lifted, and if this took place before the flame had passed the point it would prevent its passage. This, however, is conjectural, and it is perhaps more probable that the arrest of the explosion was due to the lack of dust, In the case of the West way in the Maudlin, there is some probability that the road was damp at the place where the explosion stopped, because water was led over it from a stone drift in the vicinity. The state of the road here had not been particularly observed before the Maudlin Seam was shut off on account of the fire.
It is necessary to account for the ignition of the dust. At the place, which is concluded to have been the point of origin, a shot had been fired, apparently simultaneously with the explosion. The shot hole had been drilled at right angles to the line of road, the outer end pointing slightly upward. The road at the place was in stone, and would probably be coated with the finest coal dust, and just above the shot, were large balks of timber set about 9 inches from the roof on which lodged much dust. It was not a blown out shot; the stone it was intended to dislodge being thrown. It does not follow from this that it would show no flame; many properly prepared shots show flame when they do their work, and if there is an overcharge of powder, or coal dust in the stemming, the flame is greater. The shock caused by the explosion of the shot would dislodge the dust and throw it into the air, and flame issuing, not necessarily to a large extent, would ignite it and fill the road with flame. Thus initiated the flame would extend along all the roads on which there was an uninterrupted supply of coal dust to support it.
03 Supposed to have been used for sweeping away dust before firing a shot.