59 In the late 1960's the National Coal Board made a critical review of auxiliary fans available for the ventilation of long drivages. The introduction of heading machines had increased airborne dust concentrations at the faces of such drivages and to contain these there was a change from forcing to exhausting systems of auxiliary ventilation. The adoption of dust extractors in these ventilation systems required fans capable of generating higher pressures in order to circulate the air quantities necessary for combating airborne dust.
60 In December 1971, following discussions with the National Coal Board, an in-line radial flow fan for underground use was designed by James Howden and Company Limited of Glasgow and manufacture was undertaken by a subsidiary company, Carter Howden Limited of Birmingham. The first prototype fans were tested at the National Coal Board's Research and Development Establishment (MRDE) in March 1972. The initial tests revealed unsuitable characteristics, and after modifications by the manufacturer, including the adoption of a bifurcated design, further testing was carried out. A report detailing the performance characteristics, the noise levels and the electrical input powers for the prototype fans was issued in September 1973 (NCB MRDE report 73/41 Performance Tests of Carter Howden 24 inches diameter 18.7kW and 30 inches diameter 37kW in-line Radial Flow Fans of the Bifurcated type).
61 After a further series of tests at MRDE in December 1973 to study the effects of fitting silencers and the tandem operation of fans sent from the Barnsley area, one of these was found to be defective due to the impeller rubbing against the inlet cone. Investigation by the National Coal Board and the makers revealed that the cause was a fault in the manufacture of the inlet cone. All fans with this defect were traced and the defective cones replaced.
62 Difficulty was experienced with a fan purchased for the South Wales area which would not start because the impeller and motor were incorrectly aligned. After a meeting held in South Wales, the manufacturer's representative agreed to a modification to improve location and alignment of the motor. The modification was included in the basic design and all the fans previously supplied to the South Wales area were subsequently modified by the manufacturer.
63 On 2 August 1974 the engineering manager of Carter Howden Limited attended a meeting at the Barnsley area workshops with the area ventilation engineer and the workshops senior engineering inspector. Amongst the matters discussed was the failure of a fan which had been withdrawn from service because the impeller was rubbing against the inlet cone. At this meeting the modification to facilitate motor alignment, following the South Wales experience, was discussed. The representatives of the National Coal Board thought that it would be impracticable to return all the fans in use at mines in the Barnsley area to the manufacturer's works for modification. Instead it was planned to modify the fans as and when received for overhaul at the area workshops to a design prepared by the workshop staff.
64 Swift, chief ventilation engineer for the National Coal Board, stated that although no National Coal Board specification existed for radial flow fans there was a specification for axial flow auxiliary fans which was adequate to govern most of the principles of construction of both types of fan. Carter Howden Limited were informed of the need to comply with this specification where applicable. Details of this instruction were not sent to the areas and consequently no check regarding compliance with the specification was made of the fans in use at that time. The chief ventilation engineer was not informed of the fan defects in South Wales and Barnsley areas.
65 Neither the manufacturers nor the National Coal Board issued comprehensive explanatory literature specifying critical clearances to the users of the Carter Howden fan.
66 Designers, manufacturers and suppliers of equipment for use below ground should recognise their responsibility under the Health and Safety at Work etc Act 1974 (Section 6): a responsibility which was not mandatory during the development of the Carter Howden auxiliary fan.