14 The Meltonfield and Newhill seams were ventilated by means of a main air current from the shafts. Twin intake and return airways were provided over part of this ventilation circuit. (See Plan No. 1).
15 The ventilation of B 04's district was antitropal, that is, the air flow was in the opposite direction to the coal flow. Auxiliary ventilation by an exhaust fan had been provided for B 05's return heading up to a time shortly before the accident. The fan, coupled to a dust extractor, was sited on B 04's maingate some 15 feet inbye B 05's junction. (See Plan No. 4). A bypass system of ventilation exhausting directly into the Meltonfield return was available to ventilate B 05's return heading during weekend shifts when the auxiliary fan was not in use. Some of the return air from B 04's tailgate circulated round B 02's district and enabled salvage work in the old maingate to be undertaken as and when necessary.
16 In the Newhill seam, E 21's district was homotropally ventilated by air from the Meltonfield main intake which rejoined this intake after ventilating E 21's face.
17 The ventilation plan for this part of the mine was described in detail by Widdowson the Manager during his evidence. From this it was apparent that it was the intention to work only one production face in this part of the mine at any one time and that it was not intended to commence production on E 21's face during the time B 04's face was being phased out. An additional intake airway had already been driven and a return cross measures drift known as 50's was in the course of being driven to increase the ventilation quantity. The manager said that 50's drift would be completed in late August or mid September 1975 and this would increase the ventilation quantity to about 40000 cubic feet per minute as estimated by Morris, the Area Ventilation Engineer. This would have enabled two production faces to be worked simultaneously in this part of the mine but it was not the intention to do this until the Beamshaw seam was nearing exhaustion.
18 There was some controversy as to whether E 21's district should have been put on a separate ventilation split from the time that a connection was made. I accept that it was Widdowson's planned intention to change over the ventilation during the weekend of 13 June 1975 after B 04's had ceased production and before production commenced on E 21's district. The temporary ventilation system adopted for this district during the commissioning period was acceptable providing no production took place. It would have been unwise to have curtailed the ventilation quantity unnecessarily on B 04's whilst it continued in production.
19 The notification of the introduction of electricity for E 21's district had been given to HM Inspectorate of Mines and Quarries. It was implicit that the ventilation should be changed over and the district ventilated by a separate circuit before production commenced. However, it became necessary to extract some coal from this face before the conditions of the notice were fully observed but the relatively small advance of the face was intended to improve roof conditions.