Swaithe Main Disaster
Extracted from the Annual Mines Inspectors Report for 1875
Report of Frank N. Wardell (page 281) continued
Robert Miller, said he lived at Strafford Collieries, near Dodworth, and was a mining engineer and
manager. He had not been down Swaithe Main Colliery until the explosion. He first went down
shortly before one o'clock on the morning of the explosion. Mr. John Mitchell and some of the
deputies had already been in the pit. He went down with Mr. James Wilson, of the Oaks, Joseph
Sheldon, deputy, and 15 or 16 men. When they got within about eight feet of the bottom it was
"made up" with wreck and water falling down. Broken conductors and broken corves chocked up
the bottom, and the occupants of the cage scrambled out over a man's shoulder. The first thing
they saw was a man named Crossland, who, when they touched him, said, "You are killing me," and
they had to send him out of the pit by main force. He appeared to have been much knocked
about, but he did not look as if he had been burned. The party then examined the "returns," and
found the separation doors all blown down. They appeared to have been blown inwards. They
thought they traced a smell of fire in the north return, and after going in its direction about 20 yards
they returned to the pit bottom. After that they all went down the engine plane to the end of the
slant level, and there found a man alive. He was unconscious, and unable to move. His name was
Brown, of Stairfoot, and he had since died. They then divided themselves into three parties, under
the command of witness, Mr. Wilson, and Jas. Sheldon. Wilson's and witness' party proceeded on
Briggs' siding, and Sheldon was to explore the slant level, the drift, and the slant drift level, as far as
he could get, because he knew the district. The next day witness saw Sheldon's dead body. After
coming out of Briggs' siding, where a large number of dead bodies were found, and 20 yards from the
group of bodies, one of the party picked up a human foot, they went down the engine plane, where
four more dead bodies were passed. At that time the engine plane was free from after-damp.
After going a little way beyond the slant level, they heard a human voice. They listened and found that
it was a man screaming. They hurried on towards the sound, and found that it was Pickering, who has
since died of his injuries. He was not conscious, and was jammed against the post. He was sent out
of the pit. Mr. Wilson, with Schofield, the deputy, and two or three other men then went to No. 3
district, and witness, went along to No. 4 level in No. 3 district up to the drift level. He was accompanied
by three or four men. There was a fall of roof which barred the way about half-way through
the drift level. They passed several dead bodies and dead horses. When they reached No. 4 level
they again met Mr. Wilson's party. Wilson then agreed to go down the engine plane, Briggs'
siding, to the boundary board, and witness was to go along the No. 4 level to the boundary board,
where both parties were to meet. One of the party was taken ill, and had to be sent out of the pit.
Just there was a heavy fall of stone from the roof. In No. 4 level a dead body perfectly naked and
badly burned was passed. Two dead bodies of boys beyond him were also burned, as were all the
other bodies in that part of the pit. The party then proceeded up the engine plane, where they met
a man with an extincteur, who said that Mr. Wilson had discovered fire. After again examining the
returns he left the pit, after having been in about two and a half hours. Shortly after 3 o'clock witness
had a long consultation with Mr. Wardell, Mr. Mitchell, and others, and in the meantime Mr. Wilson
and party came out of the pit. He went down again next day, about noon, and was placed in charge
of the pit, owing to the illness of Mr. Mitchell, junr. He went to the bottom to see how things were,
and then by his advice a number of men were sent down the pit to repair damage, and to search for
bodies. He and his party then proceeded to No. 4 drift level. On his way down the drift, he passed a
broken lamp, which had been picked up and hung on a prop. There was no fall near where the lamp
was hanging, nor did he find any marks of fire on the prop. The bodies were 20 yards away from the place
where the broken lamp was found. There was a small quantity of after-damp. In the first benk in
No. 4 level they found a man without his shirt, badly injured. A shot had been fired in that place,
but it had only partly blown down the coals. They satisfied themselves that after the shot had been
fired a corve had been loaded with coal. The man's lamp was found the following day covered over
with coal, but it was not broken. Mr. Beaumont, one of the party was taken ill, and witness and his
party left the pit. On Wednesday, witness went down the pit several times to give orders, but he did
not go far away. Messrs. Thompson and Pearson brought to him a can of powder, which had been
found in Eyre's place in No. 4 level. They found two dead bodies lying near the gate, and a heavy
fall of roof had occurred close to them. They got over the fall, and examined the place beyond it,
and they found another fall almost connected with the first. They got over that, and found at the
other edge a corf driven into the fall and a dead body, face forward, driven in after the corve, and
another body a few yards off, which had apparently been driven from the goaf. The face had been
driven violently against a rail, and was completely smashed in, and it was apparent that that blow had
been fatal. When they reached the right side they saw several props lying about, and two other bodies of
wood-takers, and they came to the conclusion that the men had been taking props out of the goaf, and
that in consequence a heavy fall had occurred. The bodies of the two wood-takers were found about
20 yards from the goaf, in the board. On making their way to the pit bottom, they particularly
observed which way the blast had gone. They came to the conclusion that the blast came out of the
goaf, as if that had been the centre, and then it had taken two directions.
Mr. James Wilson, resident manager at the Oaks Collieries, and living at Stairfoot, said that he
had been in the Swaithe Colliery once previously to the explosion. He went down the pit after the
explosion at half-past twelve o'clock. In addition to the evidence given by the last witness, with
whom Mr. Wilson acted, he said that when he saw Sheldon at the junction of double threes he was
suffering from after-damp and appeared to be very excited. He said, "It is very hard; my only
son is in the pit, and I expect he is dead." A note came later on for Sheldon stating that his son
had got home, but when it arrived Sheldon was dead. He left Mr. Wilson and proceeded down
the double threes. In the part of the pit which he had under his charge for exploration there was
very little sign of the explosion. Going along Briggs' siding in No. 1 dip board they saw a fire
burning right into the root of the coal. It was put out. It had been caused by something burning
on the ground, either colliers' clothes or bratticing cloth. It was six inches by four in extent.
Going lower down the siding towards the slit he found that some more burning cloth had been
blown into the crevice of the floor, where there was a small "feeler" of gas burning, which fire was
also put out. The crevice was 18 inches deep, and it was no uncommon circumstance for the floor
to divide in that way in the Barnsley bed. On reaching the back part of Briggs' siding the presence
of after-damp began to be felt. They went along the jinny, and then met two men with the fire-engine,
and they took it to the place where the fires had been discovered, and cooled the places.
Witness then left the pit. On the Tuesday following he went down the pit with Mr. Jeffcock,
mining engineer, of Sheffield. The scene of the explosion appeared to have been between four and
five benk in the slant drift level. It appeared as if it had divided, and gone in all directions.
Witness went down on Wednesday and Thursday with Mr. Miller.
Mr. Philip Casey, the managing director of the Shirland Collieries, said he was down the Swaithe
Main Colliery from five o'clock until half-past nine on the evening of the explosion with a party of
explorers. They went into the slant drift level, and found that the force of the explosion had been
very great. Corves were blown about, and he saw a number of dead bodies. He had been down
twice since; once on the 14th December, and the second time on Tuesday last. On the latter
occasion he was accompanied by Mr. John Mitchell and two men. They went into Akers' place
and examined it very carefully. He saw that the whole of the face had come down, and brought
the stone with it. It had been "holed" to a good depth. They examined the place very carefully
to find traces of a shot having been fired, but could not find the slightest marks to indicate anything
of the kind. And if Akers had been firing a shot, his body would not have been found in the
position in which it was. If a shot had been fired, the roof would have been detached from the stone.
There were traces of an explosion before they came to Akers' place, and it appeared as if the blast had
gone along the level towards his benk. At the top of the slant drift the explosion had been very
severe, and the bricks of the stoppings had been blown in the direction of Akers' place.
By Mr. Maule: He had had 14 years' practical experience as a miner, but he had not seen an
explosion on so large a scale before. He believed that it originated in the No. 1 dip board in the
slant drift level. He found symptoms of fire throughout the level, and in all the gates running off
it. They could see traces of the explosion in all parts of Briggs' sidings, but it had not originated
there.
By Mr. Hopwood: He thought that if the blast, after travelling from the slant drift, found any
gas or anything to feed itself upon in Briggs' sidings, a second explosion might have taken place ;
but if that had been the case, the explosion would have been seen and heard at the pit top. There
was no evidence of any second explosion. The explosion had not originated in a twelve-acre goaf
which was near the slant drift. He was certain it had occurred in the slant drift level, because there
the men were very much burnt, and the workings were blown about.
Mr. Hopwood : Have you formed any opinion as to the cause of the explosion ?
Mr. Casey : No, I have been unable to do that.
Mr. Hopwood : What do you think about the use of powder in a mine of this kind ?
Mr. Casey : I don't approve of powder being used anywhere where lamps are used. I think if it
is not safe to work with naked lights, it is not safe to fire a shot and send yards of flame to do the
very thing you keep a lamp to prevent.
By Mr. Mellor: They did not find much air in the mine in consequence of the stoppings being
blown out.
By Mr. Rhodes: If there had been two explosions together, and they had been so to speak merged
into one, there would not necessarily have been indications of both at the pit top.
Mr. John Mitchell, the certificated manager of the Edmunds and Swaithe Main Collieries, said he
had had the entire management of the colliery for the last three years, and was there four years before
that time. The method of working the colliery was the one generally adopted in the Barnsley district.
About 380 men and boys were employed in the Swaithe Colliery underground. The number of men
and boys who went down the colliery on the morning of the 6th was 244, and five came out before the
explosion. The numbers were ascertained by the banksman chalking them at the top, and the
hanger-on checking him at the bottom. The report of the numbers was usually given to the under-viewer,
James Allen, but he was killed in the explosion. Allen had been at the colliery about four
years, and was always very attentive to his duties. He (Mr. Mitchell) went down the pit three or four
times a week at least, and very often every day. The Coroner: Was powder used in the pit by your
authority? — Mr. Mitchell: Yes; anywhere but in the slant drift level, on the other side the fault.
Continuing, the witness said he heard the explosion. He had just gone to the pit, and was near the
offices. He heard a noise as if there had been a collision of coal trucks. He ran down into the pit
yard and saw Wm. Bellamy, the enginewright, with whom he went up on the pit bank. The smoke
which had come up the pit shaft was clearing away, but from the cupola a larger volume of smoke than
usual was issuing. He tried to get down the shaft, but was unable to do so, because one of the cages
was stuck fast in the shaft. He ordered one rope to be uncoupled, and, that having been done, the
rope was fastened across the pit top by a flange. He then went down the shaft, and was accompanied
by William Bellamy and Joseph Sheldon. They found no damage done in the shaft until they got to
the bottom, and there they found the conductors broken up to a level with the top of the perch. At
the bottom there were about 20 men, several of whom were injured, waiting to get into the cage.
There were also three bodies. One man, George Linford, was lying under the fastened cage, but he
had survived. The men were sent up the shaft, and he soon afterwards followed them. He went
down again with an exploring party, about half-past nine o'clock at night. By Mr. Maule: The pit
was divided into four districts, and in the daytime there was a deputy in charge of each. Every day
deputy was in the pit eight hours, and visited each working place twice. At night there were only
two deputies in the pit, and they only made their rounds once. On Sunday night, the 5th ult., two
deputies, Joseph Sheldon and William Midgley, went down the pit at 12 o'clock and made an
examination of the colliery ready for the men to go in at six o'clock. The practice of the deputies
was to enter the result of their examination in a book, and if everything was right they "signalled"
the men down. If anything special occurred the deputies reported to him. No communication was
made to him either on Friday or Saturday mornings to the effect that there was gas in the pit. The
use of powder was prohibited in the slant drift level, except in cases of necessity, such, for instance, as
the hardness of the coal. Then a deputy might fire a shot between two o'clock in the afternoon,
when the men left work, and six o'clock the next morning.
It was now half-past five o'clock, and the Court decided to adjourn until yesterday.