Swaithe Main Disaster
Extracted from the Annual Mines Inspectors Report for 1875
Report of Frank N. Wardell (page 281) continued
George Beardsall, who, in addition to that of the previous day, said that he went down the jinny,
where he found a horse which had been blown almost to pieces. Two stoppings had been blown out
in the slit above the benk level. They did not, however, interfere with the passage of the air, so he
continued on his way down the jinny, and found the body of Thomas Bullock, who was lying about
10 yards below the body of the horse. Nearer the bottom was found the body of George Sykes,
the horse-driver, but the after-damp was so thick that he could not see whether he was burned or not.
He then became overcome and had to be assisted to the pit bottom. He did not explore any more
that day. None of the bodies were brought out by him. He went down at 12 o'clock the following
day. He conducted William Ward, of Manvers Main, round the "rise" workings. No bodies were
found there. Through the boundary doors they found the bodies of two brothers named Allan. They
then proceeded forward to the "return," thence to the pit bottom, and out of the pit. He could not
say whether the bodies were burned, inasmuch as they were covered with dust. The return air was
going all right. At six o'clock the same evening he went down again, accompanied by William Ward
and others, and the object of their journey was to fetch out the six bodies he had previously named.
The following day (Wednesday) at noon he again went down the pit. Wm. Washington was with him,
and they went into Briggs' sidings. They found a horse lying at the bottom of the jinny. At the top
of the jinny they found three bodies, but he did not know any of them. The bodies were removed
from the pit by a party under the charge of John Sugden. They were burnt. Further on a body
was found lying across the "slit" top, and it was also very much burnt. Through the bankgate he
found three bodies — a collier and two hurriers. He knew two of them, John Bailey and John
Partlett. They were all much burned. A "chock," which appeared to have been blown down, lay
near Bailey. Went forward into another benk, and found the body of Benjamin Bennett lying close
to the face. The next place visited was the Buff's siding levels into the "dip" where a fall of roof had
occurred, and pardy buried the carcass of a horse. Proceeding down the "dip" board some 50 yards
down a large fall of roof had taken place. Seeing the horse buried they came to the conclusion that
the driver, John Semley, was buried underneath, and they set men to work to find him, and after
having dug the dirt away for some time the body was found. The body of Cawthorne, alias Bailey,
was found 500 yards away from the place in which he worked. Bullock, who was Cawthorne's
assistant, was found nearer the pit bottom; Sykes was about his working place, the Allans were about
120 yards from their working places; and Bailey, Partlett, and the hurrier were at their working
places, as also was Benjamin Bennett. On Thursday, at six o'clock in the morning, witness again
went down the pit, accompanied by about a dozen people. They went to the stables and were
engaged for some time clearing the dead horses from the stables. The divisions of the "standings"
were blown down. Then they proceeded down the boundary jinny, down the engine plane to the
"slant" level into Board No. 5 in No. 2 district. They were going to fetch the body of George
Woodhead, and close where he was lying a fall of roof had taken place. They brought the body out
of the pit at six o'clock in the evening, having been in the pit 12 hours. He went down the pit again
on Friday morning at six o'clock. He first visited the slant drift. Two bodies which had been found
and removed to that place were brought out of the pit. Their names were James Green and Isaac
Bullock. He then assisted to remove two horses from the slant level, and then came out of the pit.
He went down again at nine o'clock that evening and went to No. 4 drift. There they found the
bodies of Charles Taylor and Pharaoh Bostock. Taylor was found at the back of the boundary board,
and Bostock was found near the second slit, and his hurrier, Hall, was found near to him. They then
went to Briggs' siding, and at the top of the jinny they found the body of a hurrier named John
Nicholson, but he was not much burned. Crossland, a collier, was lying in the "benk." On Saturday
morning he assisted in lighting the furnace, and came out of the pit having again been in 12 hours.
On the Monday he again went down at six o'clock in the morning. He went along the slant drift
level and the far rise boards. The bratticing was down, and there had been a fall of roof. After
propping up the roof he came out of the pit. The following morning he again went down the pit and
visited the slant level and Briggs' siding, and set men to work there. At midnight he again went
down, and assisted in the removal of John Philips and William Maltby from the slant drift to the
pit bank.
William Midgley, Ardsley, a night deputy at the Swaithe Colliery, said he was on duty in the pit
until six o'clock on the morning of the explosion. Before coming out he saw Allen and all the other
day deputies, except Waterworth, for the purpose of making his report to them. There was nothing
special to report to them, except to Beevors. His (witness') district was No. 1 at the top side of
Briggs' siding. He told Beevors that two men could not get to work until he had got a pair of
turn-plates cut for them. These were the two Allen's (brothers), both of whom were dead. He helped to
carry out their bodies on the night after the explosion. When he left the pit on the Monday morning
there was nothing the matter with it, and he did not hear that an explosion had occurred until about
noon the same day. By about five o'clock on the Monday morning he had completed the examination
of his district, and he made an entry in the night report book. The entry was — "All the working
places, travelling roads, air courses, and drawing shaft have been carefully examined by five a.m.
North B., No. 4 working place; North E., No. 5; North E., No. 2; South D." Witness explained
that he had omitted to insert the word "gas" after "North B., No. 4," and after the other districts
mentioned. He also explained that the North E. district and South D. were Sheldon's, and that he
wrote them down in his report at Sheldon's request. Sheldon signed the report
Mr. Mellor stated that the places mentioned in the report were all abandoned places.
Mr. Maule (to witness) : Were they all abandoned ? — Witness replied that No. 4 was a working
place; all the rest were abandoned places.
Mr. Chas. Beevers, colliery manager, Higham Colliery, Dodworth, said he was never in the Swaithe
Main until the day of the explosion. He then went down as one of the explorers about four in the
afternoon, and the party with whom he was went along the slant drift level. He was in charge of the
party, and kept in front. They did not feel the atmosphere very bad until they got to the bottom of
the drift. He noticed some broken corves on the slant level, and that one of the cages' at the pit
bottom was broken. From the bottom to the slant level there were no signs of the explosion having
caused any damage. In addition to the broken corves in the slant level, he saw the dead bodies of
both men and horses. After going up the slant level about half-way, they retraced their steps, and
went into the return air-way. They there found a good deal of after-damp coming through a slit from
the benks on the right side, whilst in the return air-way they found the body of Joseph Sheldon, one of
the explorers. About five feet off was the body of another man. The lamp was in the man's hand,
and was burning. Sheldon's lamp was also in his hand, but it was extinguished, being partly on its
side. He then came out, and went down again on Tuesday. On that day they went to the dip side
of the slant level, and there found Nettleship. He was lying on his back. Witness heard him speak
before he came up to him; he seemed to be conscious of what he was saying. Nettleship was about
six yards from his working place. Witness saw that he was badly burnt, and he complained very much
when his arms were touched. They gave him a little drop of tea out of a bottle. He wanted to have
his own bottle, telling them there was plenty of tea in it; but witness considered it was only wise
to give him a little drop, as he had been so long without food. Nettleship did not say how long he had
been in the pit, but he told witness and the others that he had been working some of the time. He
was then rambling in his talk. Nettleship was found about five on the Tuesday afternoon, and it was
after six before he was got to the surface.
The Coroner : You were a long time down ? — Witness replied that about two hours elapsed from
the time Nettleship was found until he was brought to the surface.
Supt. Sykes said there must be some mistake, as the notes made by the police stated that the man
was got out at five o'clock and died at half-past.
The Coroner (to witness) : Did you have any conversation with him ? Tell us what he said ? —
Witness : He said he was glad we had come, and that we had been a very long time in finding him.
He then asked if we knew how it had happened.
The Coroner: Did he seem to know whether it was an explosion. ? — Witness: Oh, he was quite
aware what had happened.
The Coroner: Did he see any blaze or smoke? — Witness: He did not say he had seen any
blaze.
The Coroner: Did he say he had heard any noise ? — Witness: No. He said he did not know where
he was for some time.
The Coroner: Then he wanted to know what had happened ? — Witness: He wanted to know how
it had happened; those were his words. He further said, "You will see there will be no more
shooting here."
The Coroner : Was that all he said ? — Witness: I asked him if he had been having any shots, and
he said no, but he knew that there had been some going on. Witness subsequently came up for the
purpose of having a consultation, and he and others afterwards went to the rise-side workings and the
slant level. There they found some bodies. In the drift level they discovered after-damp. Up to
this time they were unable to see any indications of fire, except that the bodies were burned. He was
in the pit again on the Wednesday, and then saw indications of burning in No. 8 neargate. There
were soot and black, but it appeared to be the timber which had burned, and not the coal. In No. 8.
fargate there was a large fall of coal, which was about 26 yards long, and he could not get over it
At this point it looked as if the power of the explosion had spent itself. He did not go down the pit
again until the following Tuesday, when he accompanied the Government Inspectors — Mr. Wardell
and Mr. Evans — and several other gentlemen. They first went down the engine plane, then into
"double three." He noticed the effects of the explosion there, and he described what he saw — doors
blown down, corves broken, and stoppings out. The debris was all blown in one direction. In
a dip benk in No. 4 fargate, he found a shot with the fuse in it, and ready for firing. There was a
large fall at the bottom of No. 4 fargate, the fall consisting of stone, coal, and bind. At the bottom of
No. 4 gate there was a shot hole in the coal ready for the powder. There were several indications of
the explosion right up to the boundary board, corves being smashed, and the jinny wheel broken, and
the debris blown in the direction of the return air. The party then returned up the engine plane
and went into Briggs' siding. They there found gas (firedamp) coming out of a benk on the dip side,
but it was only slight in quantity. He subsequently saw where there had been a "blower." On the
following day he again went down the pit with the Government Inspectors, and the remainder of the
previous day's party. They first visited the slant drift and the slant drift level. Down the drift incline
he noticed that pebbles, coal, and other material had been driven into the timber. They seemed to have
come in the direction of the slant drift level. Two corves were smashed to pieces at this point and the
woodwork was blown in the direction of the slant level. In No. 5 fargate (slant drift level) there were
severe indications of fire; the props were burnt and charred, and the force of the explosion from this
point appeared to have gone both ways. There was a "fall" in the immediate neighbourhood, but it
was not of an extensive character, and they had no difficulty in passing over it. There was every
indication of the fire having originated at this point. The timber showed that the blast had gone
northwards; that is to say, the south side of it was most charred.
By a Juror: He believed there had been two distinct explosions, one in the post between five and
six benks in this district (No. 2), and the other in Briggs' siding in No. 4 district.
By Mr. Maule: Whilst going along the "double three," in the drift level, I saw a canister of
powder found at the low end of No. 4 benk. It contained about 2 lbs., and was found by Mr. Normansell.
Another can was found at the bottom of the incline in No. 3 district, I believe by Mr. Evans.
It contained about a pound of powder. I did not see any more canisters of powder found, or any fuses
picked up. I have not been able to form an opinion as to where the explosion commenced in the
No. 3 district.
Mr. Hopwood: Carry your mind back to the conversation with Nettleship. I understand you to
say he said to you, "There will be no more shooting here." Is that the expression he used ? — Witness :
He said, "You will see there will be no more shooting here."
Mr. Hopwood : Then you asked him if he had been having any shots? — Witness : Yes.
Mr. Hopwood; Then what did he say? — Witness: He said no, he hadn't, but there was some
shooting going on. He did not say where the shooting had been going on. I am of opinion that a
goaf near Briggs' siding was a likely place for the accumulation of gas; and a goaf in the other district,
where I believe the explosion originated, was also a likely place to contain and to give off gas.
By Mr. Mellor : When I came up to Nettleship he could talk sensibly enough, and could converse
as well as I can now. I certainly did hear him talking to himself before I got up to him, and I at
first thought it was another party of explorers who had come from another district.
By a Juror : From what you have seen of this mine do you think it is a safe one to use powder in ?
— Witness: I don't believe in any mine in which safety lamps are used that blasting by powder should
be allowed.
By Mr. Mellor: No absolutely perfect safety lamp has yet been invented, and if a lamp gets too hot,
or if there is a quick current, the gas might light from the lamp itself. Gunpowder is used in many
pits up to the present time in this district.
Mr. Mellor: Although in your opinion gunpowder should not be used in mines of this sort, of course
accidents may happen irrespective of the use of powder? — Witness: I don't believe this accident has
happened from powder, as far as my investigation has gone. — In answer to further questions by the
learned counsel, witness explained how it was possible for large escapes of gas to take place without
shots having previously been fired.
A Juror: Have you seen anything that has caused the explosion? — Witness: I have only seen
indications of the fire; but what has caused the fire I cannot say, and in my opinion no one can say
what caused the explosion. My theory is that there have been two explosions; but whether that is so
or not I cannot say ; perhaps one caused the other.
By Mr. Mellor: I remember an explosion occurring in a mine on a day when only one man was in
it, the explosion being caused by some liberated gas coming in contact with the furnace. Powder or
some other equivalent power must be used in driving through stone drifts; but it should only be used
when the men are out of the pit.
At this stage the inquiry was adjourned until to-morrow (Tuesday). It is said the coroner will not
sit after Tuesday evening, and that the inquiry will then be adjourned until the second or third week
in January.