Swaithe Main Disaster
Extracted from the Annual Mines Inspectors Report for 1875
Report of Frank N. Wardell (page 281) continued
Mr. John Mitchell's examination resumed. In reply to questions by Mr. Maule, he said: An
abandoned place means a place which has been worked out. The miners could get the powder for
blasting where they liked. They could not absolutely prevent a man taking more than four lbs. of
powder into the pit. The deputies, as a rule, ascertain whether a miner has a can that will hold more
than four lbs. of powder or not. If gas has been found in the pit within three months the rule
provides that powder shall not be taken in the pit except in cartridges, but they had no means of
ascertaining who takes the cartridges into the mine. In the slant drift level shot firing was prohibited
until after two o'clock, but it took place in other parts of the mine during working hours, subject to
the control of the deputies. The intake of fresh air into the mine was 76,630 cubic feet per minute.
By Mr. Hopwood : Before I was certificated I was assistant manager in the mine. I am 30 years of
age, and son of one of the proprietors. I have no interest whatever in the mine except as certificated
manager. The mid-day shift ends at two o'clock. About 25 men go down the pit at half-past one.
Mr. Hopwood : Is that in your opinion consistent with Rule 8, that persons ordinarily employed in
the mine should be out of it at the time of shooting? — Mr. Rhodes : Excuse me, sir, you are referring
to a rule which does not exist, so far as this inquiry is concerned. Witness: Not if they were going
into the part prohibited. I take the words "out of the mine," to mean out of the part prohibited. If
a shot was to be fired in a deputy's district, the whole of the men working in that district would be
withdrawn. Supposing a shot was to be fired on the confines of both districts, the men in both
districts would be withdrawn. By Mr. Mellor : Allen had been underviewer of this mine for four
years, and was in my opinion an able and efficient man. Not only myself and the proprietors, but the
men had confidence in him. He had the general supervision of the workings. The deputies were
persons in whom I and the proprietors, and also the men, had confidence, and they were efficient men.
The night deputies examined each workman's place, and if there was anything the matter they told the
men working in that particular place. It was Fletcher's duty to have reported the gas if he found any,
but it was not until it had gone that he mentioned it to anyone. When I was away in London for a
day or two, Allen and the deputies had charge of the mine, but if I have been away for longer than
that, my brother, Mr. Joseph Mitchell, mining engineer, has acted in my place. By Mr. Rhodes:
The night deputies examined each workman's lamp before he went into the pit, and if they found a
man in possession of anything that he ought not to take into the mine they would stop him. The
workmen are allowed to inspect the Gas Report Book at all reasonable hours, and also, if they choose,
the workmen may at intervals of not less than a month make an inspection of the mine on behalf of
themselves. By a Juryman : That rule has been carried out on two occasions at the Swaithe Main Pit,
but not for some time. By Mr. Maule: The manager appoints the deputies. By the Coroner : I
know that a boy named John Waller worked at the place with another boy named Gibson as his
"nipper." By Mr. Maule : I don't recollect any of the working men waiting upon me and requesting
me to put an end to blasting. I can recollect many times being asked to let them blast. I wouldn't
say that they never asked me to stop blasting, but I don't think they have ever done so.
Joseph Frederick Thompson said : I live at Wath, and am the general manager of the Manvers Main
Colliery. I have been down the Swaithe Main Colliery twice since the explosion, but not before.
The first time I went down was early on the Tuesday morning after the accident. I went into the slant
level and up the slant drift to the No. 7 fargate, where we were stopped by the after-damp. The
explosion seemed to have come with a terrific force down the drift. We got the horse-keeper and
another young man out. I went down again on Wednesday, the 8th, at twelve o'clock. We went
along the No. 4 level in No. 3 district, and found a man near the pump there. I think his name was
Edward E. Glover. His lamp was No. 41, and his mottoes were No. 90. — By Mr. Maule: I did not
see anything that would lead me to discover the place where the explosion originated. I have had
about 21 years' experience in the management and the ventilation of mines. We are always supposed
to try and ventilate goafs as far as we can, and let any gases that might accumulate have any chance of
getting out. You cannot ventilate a goaf properly. We have practised shot firing at Manvers' Main
Pit until this explosion, but we have now left it off. I daresay the men started that idea, but I started
before them. — By Mr. Badger: I am of opinion that there have been two distinct explosions, and
from what I have seen I should think the first originated in the slant drift level. — By Mr. Hopwood:
There was a very good ventilation in the pit when I was there. — By Mr. Mellor: In our mine we use
the Clanny lamps throughout the pit.
John Gerrard, inspector of mines, said he had acted as assistant inspector in this district for two
years. He read an exhaustive report, in which he described his visits to the Swaithe Main Pit, and the
condition of the workings after the explosion. He found the damage and loss of life to be confined to
the lower or dip side of the shafts. There were three localities where evidence of violent explosion
and heat were to be found, viz., the north slant drift level, No. 4 levels, south, and Briggs' south level.
He had no hesitation in saying that a shot was not fired in Akers working place on the day of the
explosion, and that therefore the explosion did not originate from a shot in that place. It was his
opinion that an explosion originated in the north slant drift level — in the dip side places, somewhere
between No. 4 and No. 8 banks. The blast set in motion split in the level, one portion spending itself
with much force in the rise boards, and the other sweeping down the drift, at the bottom of which it
divided, and passed along the three roads to the engine plane. The impetus it had gained then carried it
forward to Briggs' level, and the gas, which was known to be in the goaf there, was then added to the
blast, which passed through the goaf to the outlet, where the woodmen were at work. At No. 4 level
the blast split again, the main force passing into the boundary board up to Briggs' level, and joining
the blast which had travelled along Briggs' level up the boundary board, and the jinny to the air
crossing, which was broken down, and thus out by the up-cast and down-cast shafts. In the absence of
evidence of direct communication of flame to the gas to cause the explosion, as for instance a shot or
naked light, they were left to surmise as to the origin of the disaster. It might have proceeded from a
defective lamp being taken into gas, or from gas being thrown on to a perfect lamp at such a velocity
as to pass the flame. That the lamps used by the deputies or fire triers for shot lighting were defective
was his decided opinion. It was an undoubted fact that gas was known to exist in the mine, and in
each of the three localities which were affected by the explosion, and this for days previous to the
explosion.
Mr. F. N. Wardell, Her Majesty's inspector of mines for the district, read a report, which showed the
steps which were taken to restore the ventilation of the mine after the explosion, and to recover the
bodies. Upon ascertaining the character and extent of the calamity, he communicated immediately
with the Secretary of State, who at once directed that his colleague, Mr. Evans, should assist him in
his investigations, and further instructed Mr. Maule, Q.C., to attend the inquest, and watch the
proceedings on behalf of the Government; and he was personally very greatly indebted to both these
gentlemen for the most valuable and painstaking assistance they had rendered. It was the expressed
wish and earnest desire of the Secretary of State, as it was of all concerned, that the inquiry should be
most searching and full, that every fact might be eliminated which even in the smallest degree might
help to ensure a complete and thorough investigation into the causes of this calamity, and that the
result elicited might be the means of indicating some line of action which would at all events tend to
lessen the recurrence of these terrible and deplorable misfortunes. The restoration of the ventilation
to a sufficient extent to admit of an examination being made of the pit was a work of some considerable
time. Explosive gas and after-damp had both to be fought against inch by inch, the bodies of the men
and the horses being sent out at the same time ; but as soon as ever it was practicable, Mr. Evans, Mr.
Gerrard, and himself, in company with the manager and others, made an inspection. This inspection was
confined to the dip workings, or that part of the mine shown on the plan before them, and he had
only therefore to direct their attention to this locality, leaving out the workings between Swaithe and
Edmunds Main shafts as having been unaffected, and as having in no way participated in any cause
which might have led to the explosion. In his opinion the explosion originally took place in the slant
drift level district, in the dip workings, somewhere between Nos. 4 and 8 banks. From No. 8 fargate
in an "in-bye" direction, indications of the explosion were less manifest, and apparently the force of
the blast in that direction had here expended itself. He thought it passed up No. 8 neargate, and
possibly one or two other gates, dividing itself at the level, and going both straight across to the faces
of the rise workings and along it outwards, rushing down the drift, and so straight to Briggs' siding,
where another and most violent explosion seems to have taken place. From this point the apparent
course was upwards to the boundary board, and also through the large twelve-acre goaf, to the low
workings in No. 4 level and No. 4 drift level, where very considerable damage has been done. The
direction taken along the boundary board has been to the overthrow described by some of the witnesses,
which was blown down; and hence the blast traversed through the stables to the down-cast shaft, doing
considerable injury at the pit bottom to the cages and conductors. There were very strong evidences
that the explosion originated in the district he had described. From a certain point on the slant drift
level everything was blown towards the engine plane, whilst men and horses throughout the entire
distance were more or less burned. Within the confined limits of the drift, where a greater concentration
of the force would exist, there was evidence of extreme violence, and pointing in the same
direction. The timber in and near the bottom of this drift was completely riddled on the "in-bye" side
with small stones and coal, some of which were driven into the wood. On the "out-bye" side no
extraordinary appearance presented itself. He thought that if the explosion had originally occurred,
as suggested by one or two of the witnesses, at the top of the twelve-acre goaf, and the flame had then
proceeded thence along the slant level, indications of violence would have been traceable on the "out-bye"
side of the timber ; it seemed also unnatural and improbable to suppose that the flame should have
travelled down to the bottom of the dip board gates in the slant level district without igniting gas at
the top of the goaves; and it must be borne in mind that in this slant drift level, distinct orders had
been given that no powder should be used whilst the men were at work, thereby indicating that it
required the adoption of special and extra measures of precaution. To discover how the gas ignited
or the actual place of ignition did not seem to him to be of such importance as to ascertain how or
why gas came to exist there. All this must be a matter of speculation and opinion. It was, of course,
possible that, owing to falls or other causes, a large body of gas might have been liberated, and driven
with such a velocity as to fire at a so-called perfect safety lamp. It was equally possible, if the goaves
contained gas, to account for the explosion by its displacement onto a naked light, which naked light
might have been a defective safety lamp; and that gas existed in different parts of the mine during
some weeks preceding the disaster, the report books, as well as the evidence, conclusively prove. With
regard to the ventilation of the dip workings of this mine, the distribution of the air should be so
arranged that each district might have apportioned to it a separate split of fresh air. As the air was at
present conducted, any gases given off and mixed with it in No. 5 must pass through the working
places in No. 3, and similarly in No. 2 district with respect to the slant level, and the slant drift level
workings. He felt it his duty to make the following observations with respect to the general
discipline of the mine. In the first place the 8th General Rule of the Coal Mines Regulation Act,
1872, expressly enjoined that during three months after any inflammable gas has been found in a mine,
powder shall not be taken into, or be in the possession of any person in any mine, except in cartridges.
And yet, though gas had been reported here for some time previous to the explosion, powder was taken
into the mine loose in canisters. Although his opinion with respect to the use of powder was well
known, and had been often repeated, still if powder actually was allowed to be used in this
mine, there ought to have been the most stringent regulations in force respecting it. He
referred more particularly now to the fact that colliers were able to and did purchase powder in
the town or elsewhere, and this, apparently, without any account being kept by those in authority
of the amount thus introduced into the workings. Feeling so strongly as he did on the question
of the use of powder in the Barnsley and Silkstone seams, he could not but advert once again to it.
Whether or no it had in this instance primarily led to the explosion — and in his opinion it had not —
still the all importance of the subject was self evident. It was marvellous to him that owners and
managers would in mines where it was considered necessary to use locked safety lamps incur the
responsibility of allowing powder to be introduced. The firing of a shot meant a naked light, and
one too of the most dangerous character. In the thick Barnsley seam surely powder could not be
a necessity. Reasons which might induce its adoption in a thin seam have no application here; and
it really seemed to him to be purely a matter of arrangement between masters and men. Special
exceptions might be made in the driving of stone drifts, but even then the firing should only be
allowed when the workmen generally were out of the mine. He thought it most important that
a careful examination of the mine should be made before the workmen descended, and such was
enjoined by the 5th General and 9th and 11th Special Rules. These rules did not appear to him to
have been rigidly enforced, for it seemed that in some instances the workmen proceeded to their
work with the deputies. It was his opinion also that the districts assigned to some of the deputies
were too large. It was quite impossible that such a careful examination of the mine as was absolutely
necessary, could be made when it must almost take the person upon whom the responsible duty devolved
the whole of his time simply to walk round his district. As regarded abandoned places, and the
ventilation of such, he would simply call their attention to the case of Brough v. Humfrey, when it was
decided that so much of the mine should be ventilated as might operate on the working places. It
was not enough only to ventilate the travelling roads and working places of a mine. In conclusion,
Mr. Wardell thanked the colliery proprietors, Superintendent Sykes, and all concerned, for the
manner in which they had assisted him in the investigation.
Mr. Mellor also wished to express, on behalf of the colliery proprietors and manager, the most
sincere thanks and great admiration they felt for the noble conduct of the volunteers, and to express
the deep feeling of sorrow that to their exertions two valuable lives had been sacrificed.
Thomas Evans said: I live at Derby and am inspector of mines for the Midland district. I
arrived at Swaithe Main on December 7th. I have heard the evidence of Mr. Wardell and Mr.
Gerrard. I went down the pit on the 13th and 14th of December and took a close survey of the
workings on the dip sidings. I have heard the evidence given during the whole of this inquiry, and
agree generally with the evidence given by Mr. Gerrard and Mr. Wardell. I feel tolerably certain
that the first explosion took place somewhere in the slant drift level workings, and that the second
explosion took place at the top of Briggs' siding. How the gas ignited it is impossible to tell.
I think the important questions to be inquired into are where and why did the gas accumulate ?
The twelve-acre goaf and some others were known to contain gas, and the gas escaping from these
goafs passed into the workings, both above the twelve-acre goaf and in the slant drift level. In my
opinion allowing people to work in this fiery Barnsley seam in this colliery, along the edges of a
goaf giving off gas, is attended with considerable danger. I do not want to confine my observations
particularly to this colliery, because I believe it is the practice of working the collieries in the
district, and I disapprove of the system. I think it is impossible that these goafs can be ventilated,
and any gas that is given off must of necessity pass into the workings. The gas accumulates in the
goafs where there is no air in them. I don't think the short glass Stephenson lamp is as safe as a
long one.
The Summing up.
The Coroner said before he proceeded to make any remarks on the evidence that had been given
respecting the unfortunate people who had come to their deaths, he must ask the gentlemen of the
jury to join with him in thanking the counsel and other legal gentlemen who had so ably and so
thoroughly brought before their notice the circumstances connected with this awful calamity. He
thought they ought also to thank the police, who had very arduous duties to perform because they
more than anyone else knew what was required, and they had to get things for their convenience and
for the proper elucidation of the facts, and he thought they had done so in a thorough and efficient
manner. He then read the law which bears on the management of coal mines similar to the Swaithe
Main Pit. In reference to gas and blasting it appeared that in cases where gas had been found
blasting was not to be carried on until the workmen were withdrawn from the pit, or from that
particular part of it. So far as the evidence was concerned after they had heard the very lucid and
explanatory evidence given by Mr. Gerrard and Mr. Wardell, and with which Mr. Evans agrees, it
would be presumption on his part to begin to trouble them with any remarks of his about it. He then
said that out of 143 unfortunate people who had come to their deaths there were different classes.
The majority of them met their deaths on the 6th instant, in the pit, either by the explosion or by
suffocation, and some were brought out alive and died afterwards, but he thought he might include
them altogether. He then referred to the few instances in which lucifer matches had been found on
the bodies, and said he must leave it to the jury to say whether anyone was answerable or not, and
whether the rules might have been more rigidly carried out or not.
Verdict.
The jury retired to consider their verdict at a quarter past six o'clock, and returned at a quarter
past eight with the following verdict:— "The jury find that Thomas Blackburn, James Allen, and
others, came to their deaths at Swaithe Main Colliery by an explosion or explosions of firedamp, but
how such explosion or explosions originated there is not sufficient evidence to show; we are likewise
of opinion that according to the evidence the Swaithe Main Colliery is a fiery mine, and that the
general and special rules have not been rigidly carried out, and that gunpowder has been recklessly
used. The jury are also of opinion that in all mines where safety lamps are used the use of gunpowder
should not be allowed except in stone drifts, and there only after all the miners are drawn out. The
jury desire the coroner to forward this opinion to the Secretary of State. We also regret that the
miners have not carried out General Rule 30, and think that this rule should be strictly adhered to."
The Coroner said he thought they ought to express their thanks to the Mayor of Barnsley, who had
personally superintended their comforts by having the place properly ventilated and warmed.
The jury were then discharged.