Risca Colliery Disaster
Extracted from the Annual Mines Inspectors Report for 1860
Report of Lionel Brough (page 73)
Mr. Lionel Brough, of Clifton, having been duly sworn, deposed as follows :—
I am Her Majesty's Inspector of that division of coal mines known as the western district of
England. Having been apprised of a terrible catastrophe by explosion of fire-damp in the Risca
Black Vein, I proceeded on Sunday, the 2nd day of December, 1860, to that colliery, which is situated
about seven miles from the harbour of Newport. A few minutes after my arrival I descended the
pit, and from that time I have been more or less occupied under ground in search of the bodies of
the sufferers ; and, latterly, in conjunction with my colleague, Mr. Thomas Evans, of Cardiff, in
making an official examination of the workings, in order to ascertain, firstly, how so large an accumulation
of inflammable gas had taken place ; and, secondly, if possible, how it became ignited. The
seam of coal called the Black Vein varies from six to eight and a-half feet in thickness, and is
remarkable for a dangerous roof and for a bad pucking bottom. The present working portion of the
colliery is dependent on an engine bank of about 650 yards in length, and possessing an average
sectional area of 59 superficial feet or thereabout. The direction of this slope is about a third to the
deep, in a cardinal direction of nearly north-west. From it proceed main levels, both to the right
and the left, known as "east and west levels," or rolley ways; cross-headings then start at right
angles from those levels ; finally, stalls are turned from those headings in a level course direction
— that is to say, parallel with the main levels. The work is so set out as to maintain a distance of from
100 to 150 yards between the levels, and about 80 yards from one cross-heading to another; and the
intention appears, generally, to drive the stalls about 60 yards from mouth to face; in fact, the
method adopted is not dissimilar from that in use throughout Monmouthshire. The mode of airing the
colliery approximates to the custom of both this county and the adjoining one of Glamorgan, with
the very remarkable exception that furnace power is not made use of, but instead thereof mechanical
exhaustion, a method in use in about half-a-dozen places in this part of the kingdom. The air
descends the winding shaft, and is at once conducted to the slope, down which it goes in its full
stream, less a portion of about 3,000 cubic feet per minute, which is scaled off to keep clear a feeder
in the turn out, and also generally in aid of the foul returns. At about 100 yards from the bottom
of the slope the air splits right and left — to the right into the No. 4 east level, and to the left into the
No. 3 west level. Then by the usual contrivance of doors in the cross-headings and stalls, and
stoppings in the spout-holes, the air is made to circulate throughout the entire work, and is always,
(when in advance of the spout-holes), supposed to be carried to the extreme faces by means of brattice,
either of canvas or of deal boards. There are six sets of main doors in the various levels.
The cross-headings, for the most part, have double doors, and in every stall is a frame door likewise,
and between every double door is a canvas sheet. In most instances door boys go with the hauliers,
in other cases regular trappers are stationed ; thus they do not depend on self-closing doors. The
aerometer pit is oval, 16 feet by 10 feet, and 70 yards deep. The downcast (winding shaft) is also
oval, 16 feet by 10 feet, and 148 yards in depth ; the distance between the two shafts is about 480
yards, as measured in the returns. The diameter of the ventilating cylinders is 18 feet each, and the
stroke is six feet — equal to 12 feet, on account of its being a double displacement ; the speed in the
cylinders is eight strokes per minute, and the total quantity of air resulting from these measurements
should be 48,858 cubic feet per minute ; but owing to valves not always acting with due effect, and it
may be also in consequence of drag under ground, and the old works to the rise, the real quantity
has seldom exceeded 40,000 cubic feet per minute ; indeed, it is more than likely that the average
supply of air has been found to be 36,000 feet per minute. It is true that by increasing the length
of the stroke to eight feet, the usual mode of calculation would show that 65,144 cubic feet of air
could be obtained per minute ; but the general arrangements would not probably, with safety to the
machinery, permit any long continuance of such an augmentation. Again, if, with the same increased
length of stroke, the piston of the large cylinders were to undergo a speed of 10 strokes per minute,
the result would be 81,430 cubic feet; but I apprehend in this case the liability to fracture would be
too imminent, and any serious breakage of these machines, or the power that drives them, would be
very nearly tantamount to the loss of the entire colliery, or its lengthened suspension. Under these
circumstances, I presume the managers have found it prudent to maintain a length of stroke of six
feet, and a speed of eight strokes per minute, as already described ; at all events, such has been their
measured and regular action whenever I have been at the pit, and that is certainly a great
number of times during the last year and a half or two years. With regard to the manner in
which the air is sent through the workings, I have one observation to make, which I at once offer,
viz., that more splits would have been desirable ; indeed, I have, on more occasions than one, mentioned
that to Mr. Harrison. In other respects, the distribution of air was tolerably well contrived.
The intake was ample, even that part of the slope which appears narrow, inasmuch as that portion of
it is doubled on the east side. The main levels are six feet by seven feet, and the cross-headings are
of the same dimensions. The level wind-roads and the spout-holes are sufficiently large, and the
main returns are of horse-road size, and generally as large as those I have seen in the district. The
faces were said to be always bratticed close up, and blasting by gunpowder was rarely resorted to
during the last 12 months. Naked lights were allowed down the slope, but with the searching wind
that descended into the lowest levels (where it split east and west), it would be impossible that explosion
could originate there, unless the ventilators ceased action for a short time. As far as I have
observed and been informed, no smoking stations were permitted throughout the entire colliery ; in
fact, that custom was strictly prohibited. Most of the coals have to be brought up the slope by a
steam engine, and placed near the bottom of the pumping shafts. This arrangement robs but an
insignificant portion of the intake air, but from its necessarily confined space and high temperature
renders the stoking a painful process. However, the fact of having boilers underground has had
nothing whatever to do with the frightful calamity that has occurred. The stables were so situated
as to get only return air, and the result was the loss of several valuable horses. The position and
ventilation of these stables might have been better contrived. The workings on the east side were
too distant, so much so, as to produce a certain amount of drag on the air. This extension, and the
hope that it would be curtailed, had been mentioned to Mr. Harrison long before the explosion.
Sending air down an engine plane and then gradually bringing it up again through all the ramifications
of the mine, is not so good a method as distributing it upwards from the bottom of a deeper
shaft, but there are many collieries throughout the kingdom where this mode of ventilation is practised.
In the present instance, the constant passage of loaded and empty trams in the winding shaft
(the downcast), and in the slope also, would, no doubt, partially check the full and free intake
of the air, but without a fresh winning, by means of a new and ample shaft to the extreme deep, this
objectionable process could not be avoided. I tender evidence now that such a new pit and new machinery
has been recommended by me, even from the time of my first visit to the colliery. Having
now described the mine in all its particulars, it becomes my duty to make a statement of how, in my
opinion, the inflammable air came out in quantity so great as momentarily to overpower the means of
ventilation; the point in the pit where the calamity originated; and, finally, how the gas was fired.
I consider that there was a rapid, if not a completely sudden, elimination of gas in that part of the
pit shown on the plan as six stalls belonging to the No. 3 cross-heading, proceeding from the fourth
east level. The rippings there had constituted one of the newest small goaves in the colliery, and
every investigation I have made induces me to believe that in that very part of the pit the fire-damp
had accumulated so quickly as to render the then current of air unable to cope with it — that is to
say, to cope with it as rapidly as it would have done under the ordinary circumstances of the mine.
The meteorological conditions of the present year have been unusual, and the barometer during the
last six months has undergone remarkable oscillation. On the morning of the fatal explosion, it was
recorded as barely more than a column of 29½ inches of mercury even at the bottom of a shaft
of 148 yards in depth. I may state here that, at my sole recommendation, the manager had long
previously supplied himself with both barometer and thermometer, which he had collocated in a recess
at the bottom of the shaft in order to be prepared for any sudden emergency. Within the short
limit of time already specified, the number of explosions in Great Britain has been without parallel,
and I feel a conviction in my own mind that the quick outburst of fire-damp in the Risca pit is
entirely attributable to the late abnormal condition of the atmosphere. It would appear, then,
that if the ventilating power was equal to ordinary occasions, which I quite believe it was, it was
still too near a balance to be able quickly to clear the pit. Nevertheless, I am of opinion that
explosion would not have taken place if the lamps had been all in good order and had remained in
sound condition. I may here state that I agree with many of my professional brethren that the
Stephenson lamp is the safest that can be put into the hands of the colliers. It has been stated
that a blower of gas has been met with in the No. 3 stall of the group now under notice; but,
though from the second day after the explosion, up to the fourth of January, I have made frequent
visits to the No. 3 cross-heading and all its stalls, (being convinced from the first that the explosion
took place there). I have still been unable altogether to hear the blower, or to make up my mind
that it ever had existence in that particular stall; although, if it had, it would but be in corroboration
of the rapid accumulation I have already described as having taken place in those six stalls which
comprise that part of the mine under present consideration. At the same time, it must not be
overlooked that the circumstances which would bring about emission of inflammable air in this
particular group, would also not be unlikely to produce it in other parts of the colliery — either
in neighbouring headings and stalls, or even in the western division itself. The next evidence I
have to give is, as to the positive locality of the explosion. That is not so easy to determine; therefore
I can only express my opinion that the gas was fired in the No. 2 or No. 3 stalls in the No. 3
cross-heading, out of the No. 4 east level. It might have taken place in a spout-hole between Nos.
1 and 2, but notice will be almost immediately taken of that conjecture a little further on in my
report. What I have finally to speak about as regards evidence is the hand or the lamp that fired the
gas. Pipes and tobacco have been found in the pockets of a few of the sufferers ; a key for unlocking
lamps was discovered on another ; and, for anything we know to the contrary, matches — or other means
of obtaining light — may have been carried into the pit on the very morning of the horrible catastrophe.
Furthermore, it appears in evidence that four lamps were found unlocked, but with the gauze cylinders
unremoved. The explosion could not have been caused by any one of these identical four, for any
gauze removed and actually occasioning the calamity, would in all probability never have been screwed
on again by the hand that detached it. Besides, these four lamps were not found in the district now
clearly proved to have been the scene of the immediate explosion. In the absence of direct and reliable
evidence as to any particular lamp or person, I, as the Inspector of the district, have no right whatever
to make any specific charge against the workmen. In the spout-hole between the 1 and 2 stalls of
the No. 3 cross-heading, Richard Jenkins should have been that morning at work, but his corpse and
his lamp were found two or three yards from the face of the No. 4 cross-heading in the same level!
The remarkable circumstance in this case is, that his lamp (now produced) is perforated as if by the
blow of a mandrill! Now, if as his lamp was suspended from a nail or spike in his place of work, as
is the custom, he had by a back stroke of his pick suddenly struck it, and if at the same time the
portion of the mine where he was occupied was surcharged with carburetted hydrogen gas, as has
been already surmised, an explosion would inevitably have been the result. It may be objected that,
if so, his death on the spot would be certain, but that though most likely and probable, does not
invariably follow. The very man who is the chief cause of the calamity occasionally does escape,
inasmuch as explosion radiates from him as from a common centre, and exercises its utmost vehemence
at distances varying according to locality. Now, if the circumstances had taken place as I have
just described them, and it is my bounden duty to inform the coroner and his jury that they
are of a character entirely within the limits of probability, then the terrible event we have
assembled this day to investigate would be at once elucidated; but neither myself nor any
other person can swear to the positive fact, however reasonable and conclusive it may appear.
But, after all, this unfortunate man, if it really was him, wherever he fired the pit, was
unable to save himself, for both himself and lamp were found nearly 120 yards from his actual
place of work, and the inference is, that simultaneously with the explosion, or a few moments after
it took place, he might run for his life in the first direction that presented itself, and have even
reached the face of No. 4 cross-head before he fell overpowered by the deadly after damp.
This has the semblance of truth, as he would in such case have sought the fresh air ; and the way into
the No. 4 was directly against the current. Not very far from the spot where he died his partner or
butty was found, and it is not unlikely that the one had followed the other, and that the death of
both was almost at the same moment. Apart from the likely circumstance of ignition, by Richard
Jenkins's lamp, and separate, again, from the equally, probable, taking off a lamp top, to obtain more
light or to smoke, or even the use of a lucifer match itself, are to be laid before the jury, the following
modes of setting fire to inflammable gas, any one of which may, on the present fatal occasion, have
occurred in this very pit, as they perhaps have in past times taken place in many previous explosions
in different districts of the kingdom:— A colliery may all at once be pervaded by fire-damp, and it is
just at such a moment of danger that panic mostly ensues, from total loss of presence of mind, either
in any one individual, or by the whole pit's company. A lamp, may in fright be suddenly blown out
by its owner, or another man finding the gas, flashing on its inside, may throw it from him in his
agony of fear. I need not make the statement that in either case the flame may be passed outside,
and the pit fired. Again, some, of the people will commence to run, and if their lamps get red-hot (a
very likely contingency), the speed with which they are endeavouring to escape danger will be the
most certain method of bringing it on ; for with a hot lamp carried with accelerated motion through
an explosive atmosphere, the flame will be equally liable to pass the gauze and spread destruction
throughout the mine. I give evidence to this effect to show that when disaster is difficult of explanation,
it is not always justice to endeavour to fix the blame on the workmen by stating that some of
them must have broken the rules by removing their lamp tops. The present disaster seems to have
pervaded most parts of the mine, except, indeed, the extreme eastern workings, where, in fact, but
very limited operations were carried on, as that portion of the colliery was about to be laid in, most
likely in consequence of representations made by me to the viewer, although he states that it was done
on the score of economy. In the list which I now exhibit, many of the bodies are reported to have
been more or less burnt. Unquestionably a few were dreadfully scorched, but many of the reported or
entire number suffered but very little from actual burning, and a still greater proportion of the whole
were not even singed. With the exception of those who were killed under falls, the great majority lost
their lives by the after-damp. This, (the result of explosion), is a mixture of free nitrogen, vapour
of water, and carbonic acid gas. Life cannot be long sustained in so fearful an atmosphere; in fact
the almost (for a time) total absence of oxygen, produces death in a very few seconds indeed. Even
where fresh air may be got at, the enormous quantity of dust blown up throughput the entire pit is
quite sufficient, in many instances, to produce immediate suffocation. The state of the No. 3 cross-heading
belonging to the No. 4 east level, and the various indications therein observed in a great
measure proclaim that panel of work to have been the seat and origin of the disaster. From thence
the blast passed with terrific violence into the No. 3 cross-heading, out pf the No. 3 east level, where
the devastation was even more afflicting, still, by reason of its being a fast end without room for
expansion. In this entire district, in both these cross-headings and their stalls, the evidences of fire
are more clearly defined than in any other portion of the pit. In endeavouring to ascertain the
direction of the blast, the position of smashed doors and brattice is carefully noticed: the angle at
which props incline, and the scorching or charring of timber and of coal faces, or of hay or straw are
all observed, and they all become approximate signs, but it is not always prudent to trust entirely to
the whole of these indications. The tremendously rapid combination of the carburetted hydrogen
with the oxygen of the atmosphere, resulting from the act of ignition, and developing itself in complete
combustion, is followed for a short space of time by partial vacuum, and immediately air from all
surrounding parts of the mine rushes in with enormous violence, prostrating everything before it.
Then comes reaction, and the blast takes that direction in which it can most easily fly, generally
against the current of air, leaving in its course the deadly gases which it has itself produced, thus
sacrificing many of the workmen, who, from local knowledge, are hastening to those parts where they
know the fresh air should be. Again, the very intake current of air, intended to become the means
of health and safety, will, after explosion, carry, along in its course, even to distant parts of the mine,
the after damp that has been generated by the chemical combination already described. The blast
must have flown in two directions from where it first fired, and so met in the far end of the No. 4
east level ; whilst again it split with still greater violence at the mouth of the No. 3 cross-heading,
and darted out bye to the slope, and right into the No. 3 west level, and so carried death into all
that part of the work. But, though that level shows indications of fire, there is little doubt that
nearly all the loss of life in the western district resulted from after-damp, or, more strictly so to speak,
from the insufficiency of vital oxygen. Even in the upper workings on the east side fire may be
traced, as an instance whereof Mr. Harrison's son was burnped in the No. 2 east level, and not very far
from the slope. But it is not to be supposed that the single reservoir of gas that ignited in the No. 3
cross-heading division of the mine was the source of all the burnings. Immense falls of coal and roof
immediately ensued, bringing gas with them wherever they occurred. Some very few of them cut up
so high as almost to reach the Big Vein, which seam of coal is not unlikely often to become a feeder
to this particular pit. Thus then, the blast in passing would set fire to any gas that hung in these
fresh falls above the collars, adding destruction both by burning, and by increasing the amount of
after damp. It is my duty to record that the Black Vein itself yields gas ; so does its roof and floor ;
but I desire to express my opinion that there are collieries both in Monmouthshire and Glamorganshire
more fiery than the pit which has occasioned the present inquiry. When I came into the district,
the air in the Risca Black Vein was insufficient ; but Struve's aerometers had been decided on, and
the excavations and masonry were far advanced. I am not an advocate for machine ventilation,
because I do not think it will conquer a drag like a furnace. The latter must have its air, or it will
itself give intimation or indication ; whereas a machine may be moving through its due number of
strokes and apparently doing all its work to perfection, whilst, all the same time, in consequence of
very heavy falls of roof, or other drag in the mine, it may be but pumpipg against an attenuated subterranean
atmosphere, though steam engine and air cylinders still continue in regular and measured
action. Nevertheless, I was extremely glad to get those cylinders as an instalment, for the colliery by
no means bore a good name for safety. After the apparatus had got fairly into its work, it was found
that they had the advantage of more than double the wind they ever possessed before, and confidence
became restored. But all this time, as in the beginning, I recommended new sinking and making a
new colliery of it. I have already stated that eight strokes per minute is about the safest speed they
can venture on, as regards the machinery itself, so that the maximum amount of air became 36,000 to
40,000 cubic feet per minute. It was to keep a watch on this quantity, and to preserve a register of
the equable action of the machine, that brought me so very many times to the Risca colliery ; for I
had measured the seam and found it lofty, and knew that it wanted all the air that could fairly be
sent through the workings with reasonable safety to the aerometers, and to the steam engine that
drove them. I have paid as much attention to this colliery as I was able. The necessity to do something
for the enormous number of pits in Staffordshire and in my own district, has imposed on me an
amount of duty beyond the powers of one man. From the beginning I concluded that the danger at
Risca, as in some other pits, would be found in a sudden accumulation of gas, and for that reason I
advised the use of the barometer already referred to, and I rarely omitted to urge attention to its
variations. This, with as many visits as I could afford, to ascertain how they were progressing, was
all that I felt called on to perform. Proper sectional areas underground being duly complied with,
the result rested with the management, not with me, in fact, in no case whatever is the inspector
responsible. I have often looked into the lamp-house, and recommended carefulness. From evidence
given in this Court, I should infer that due attention has occasionally slackened there. The lamp
department is a vital one in all fiery collieries. Underground workings should be so laid out that
danger should threaten those only who worked in that particular panel where the gas might fire, and
not destroy the whole pit's company, and this is but an argument the more for a new sinking. It
also affords me the opportunity to respectfully beg the coroner and jury to add their urgent solicitations
to mine, that a new shaft be put down as quickly as possible to the depth of nearly 300 yards,
so that it may become the main down-cast, and that the present winding pit be converted into an
efficient upcast, and be provided with two most powerful furnaces; for that description of ventilation
after all is, in my opinion, the only one to be continuously relied on.