Risca Colliery Disaster
Extracted from the Annual Mines Inspectors Report for 1860
Report of Lionel Brough (page 73)
Mr. Thomas Evans, of Cardiff, having been duly sworn, deposed as follows :—
I am Inspector of Mines for South Wales. At the desire of my colleague, and an order of the
Secretary of State, I have made an examination of the Black Vein workings of the Risca Colliery,
with a view, if possible, of discovering the cause of the recent explosion, that was attended with such
fearful loss of life. The arrangement of the shafts and the ventilation generally has already been
described by several witnesses, and I therefore think it unnecessary that I should dwell on it. I will
therefore at once go to what I imagine to be the cause of this explosion. To account for it, it will
be necessary to see how the gas accumulated or was given off, and by what means it was fired. From
the evidence of the witnesses, and from personal observation, I am induced to believe the explosion
did take place at No. 3 cross-heading, fourth east level, but the exact spot I am unable to define.
The marks of fire, the way in which the timber was blown, and other indications, all tend to this
conclusion. After the great explosion in the east level, I am of opinion there must have been some
others, for we trace considerable distances without marks of fire, and then again it appears with some
violence. The effect of the first explosion was felt by the timbers being removed or knocked down,
and heavy falls of roof. This disturbed the ordinary ventilation, and very many lost their lives from
after-damp. I believe there was some gas standing in the gobs about the stalls in that heading,
No. 3, around Sage's stall and others, that a sudden fall of the roof took place, liberating large
quantities of gas under considerable pressure. This, together with a very low barometer which at that
time prevailed, was too much to be diluted by the air passing, and to render it inexplosive. This
mixture came into contact with flame ; it might have been a defective lamp or one injured by a fall,
but there is no evidence to lead me to suppose it was from Richard Jenkins's lamp, as he and his
companion were found some distance from the explosion. I do not consider the system of coursing
the air a proper distribution, for it is clear that any gas going off in that east level must pass near
most workmen in that side of the colliery. Each level should have its own separate current, good
crossings made, such as would withstand the effects of explosions. I have known explosions most
violent in one district of the mine not in the slightest degree interfere with any other district. The
Cymmer pit, where an explosion occurred, when 114 lives were lost, was laid out upon the system
of one continuous current, and no one was saved excepting those near the shaft bottom. The firemen
do not appear to have done their duty. Places left six hours without examination in a colliery with
such a bad roof as that described by the witnesses, and giving off large quantities of gas, ought not
to be left without constant and regular supervision. Much has been said of the ventilation of goafs.
I do not think it is wise to attempt to ventilate old abandoned workings ; but I do not think it right
to allow gas to remain in the stalls drawing back. In the Risca pit the best plan in my opinion
would be to fill the stalls up with rubbish. The objection to splitting the air seems to be the limit of
the ventilator. Mr. Grey tells us he can work it to produce 60,000 feet ; and Mr. Struve, the
inventor, gives it as his opinion that the machine is not doing the duty it might. This, I think,
overcomes the difficulty of not having sufficient air for each split. With reference to a blower of
gas from Sage's stall, I went in with Mr. Brough and Mr. Harrison to hear or find it. On putting
my ear close to the roof, I at first thought I could hear such a noise as would be made by a blower;
but after several more careful trials, I believe it was nothing more than a scale of air. I do not
disbelieve Mr. Harrison when he says he heard the blower, for it is quite clear that the duration of a
blower depends upon the quantity of gas to be discharged. It might therefore have been the day
before, and not perceptible the next day. I do not agree with Mr. Morgan as regards double doors
in stalls, for already it is most difficult particularly to keep doors in thorough repair. As regards
safety doors, with a good roof and good floor they may possibly be of use ; but in collieries generally,
unless they are really used every day, perhaps at the very time they are wanted they will prove of no
use. Mr. Morgan gives the area of some of the airways to be about 12 feet. If that was the case
before, or at the time of the explosion, they were far too small. He also says that only a very small
quantity of the air went into No. 4 east, about 11,000 feet, and 10,000 feet to the west. If it was so
at the time of working, in my opinion it was insufficient ; for the extensive and long run of the air
on the east side ought to be considerably more than on the west. There is a loss in the ventilating
machine, and I almost think that some air is drawn from the surface through the old workings.