Risca Colliery Disaster
Extracted from the Annual Mines Inspectors Report for 1860
Report of Lionel Brough (page 73)
As already explained in my evidence the ventilating medium at the Black Vein pit
was not the furnace method now so thoroughly understood, and so appropriately and
justly employed in nearly all the best managed coal mines of Great Britain. On the
contrary, it was a machine power, depending altogether on the integrity of its various
parts, and on its own continuity of action.
In fact, it may be said, that "Struve's aerometers" are nothing more nor less than air
pumps of most gigantic dimensions, whose capabilities are simply proportionate to their
internal diameter, to the extent of travel of their pistons, and to the number of strokes
effected in any given unit of time.
There is no question that as long as all the parts hold good, and the numerous valves
fit close and open freely, that an extraordinary amount of exhaustion can be arrived at
with these remarkable machines ; in proof whereof, I may instance the mine that is the
present subject of this memoir as a case in point ; for, taking into consideration the
superficial area or extent of fresh face exposed, and also the quantity of coal daily
excavated, I hardly know of a panel of work either in this or in any other colliery that
received a larger or fresher proportion of air than that very part where the gas fired and
caused such lamentable mortality. At the time I was of opinion, and do now also
entertain the belief, that the quantity of air passing through the No. 3 cross heading and
its corresponding group of stalls, was, under ordinary circumstances, sufficient to comply
with the first general or government rule in the then existing Act of Parliament.
The greater the volume of air the quicker of course will an outburst of gas be diluted
and swept harmlessly away. But, as I have already stated in evidence, 200,000 cubic
feet per minute, or quantities of even greater magnitude, would have been altogether
insufficient to have saved this pit, or caeteris paribus, any other colliery from explosion,
under the fearful conditions that a defective lamp and a sudden emission of inflammable
gas were simultaneously found in juxtaposition.
The preceding evidence delivered before the coroner and jury made allusion to an
entire new shaft to the deep. Had this opening been timely and duly effected, in all
probability the explosion would never have been heard of; because, in such case, a
different arrangement of levels and cross headings would naturally have resulted ; that
is to say, the whole of the work would have undergone a distinct and different distribution.
But, even by this superior mode of winning, all skill and ability would have been defenceless
against open or injured lamps, or those which had been in any possible manner
tampered with.
In the reports of the Coal Mine Inspectors during the last ten years, it may be read
that pits have fired in various ways ; some from actual deficiency of air ; others in consequence
of a door or doors having been left open ; others again are surmised to have
met with that calamity from the ignition of foul returns at the ventilating furnace. But
there is no evidence to show that the Risca explosion resulted from any of these causes;
one hundred thousand cubic feet of air per minute would, no doubt, have been better
than the thirty-six or forty thousand feet that usually descended the slope ; still there was
air enough to satisfy the law, and unquestionably a sufficient supply was allotted to the
No. 3 cross heading in the No. 4 east level (19,000 cubic feet per minute). No door
was left open ; no furnace was in existence for loaded returns to catch fire at. It becomes
therefore most needful that some reliable exposition should now be entered into,
to approximately and reasonably account for that explosion which was accompanied with
so terrible a slaughter of our fellow creatures.
There was no lack of concurrent testimony at the inquest, that the actual calamity arose
from a sudden effusion of gas coming into immediate contact with a damaged or defective
lamp, or other naked flame. In fact, the evidence of the viewers was unanimous to that
effect. The close investigation of the two government inspectors in the pit itself goes
far to establish this view of the case, and according to my own opinion clearly reduces
it to a confirmation ; but, which particular lamp, or the name of its unfortunate owner,
is information that in all probability will for ever be hidden from our knowledge.
There was a straggling length of travel of the air to the extreme east, and the management
is blameable for not having long previously laid in those useless and profitless
workings. By cutting off all that portion of the mine straight to the upcast shaft, (as I
have shown on the plan by a dotted line from the No. 3 cross heading in the third east),
a very considerable drag would have been avoided. Such shortening of the district had
been advised, and the viewer well knew how much it would have eased all his returns on
that side of the slope. It would even have superseded the necessity of another eastern
split ; indeed it was so self evident that it is surprising it was never carried into effect.
It is incontestable, that by splitting judiciously, the quantity of air passing through a
mine can be greatly augmented, and there is no doubt that one of the errors of the Risca
colliery, consisted in not more effectually adopting this very system, as by so doing the
drag would have been considerably diminished.
At the inquest much was said and discussed on the subject, and this is the proper place
to record that the greatest amount of actual drag was that which the air underwent in its
tortuous passage through those eastern workings.
All collieries are more or less subject to that frictional action which is known as "the drag,"
and no extensive mine is worked without being subject to this inconvenience; hence the
skill of the viewer is exhibited in reducing this class of obstruction to its minimum amount,
and generally speaking this can only be performed by dividing the main column of air
into a certain number of separate currents. But, I am bound to repeat that this mode of
diminishing the resistance, was not carried out in the Risca Black Vein to that extent
which the exigency of the case required. Nevertheless, I do not consider that the immediate
cause of the explosion is by any means to be thus accounted for, inasmuch as
the particular district where the gas fired had the advantage of the first and sharpest
impulse of the fresh intake air.
Over the laying out of the workings of this pit, I, of course, could exercise no control,
as they had assumed their existing shape long before I came into the south-western
district of coal mines. The total absence of a new shaft to the deep no doubt induced
the present wide spread distribution of slope and levels — of cross headings and stalls.
I have already spoken of one of the errors committed in the Risca black vein colliery;
but the greatest of them all was the postponement to an indefinite period of a new shaft
to the deep and the endeavour to obtain a certain maximum quantity of coal without the
aid of such essential grand new winning.
The attempt to perform too much with restricted means is almost invariably attended
with unsuccessful results. All experience tends to prove the truth of this assertion. It
is, indeed, a serious complaint, and one of long standing in the coal-mining world, that an
insufficiency of shafts is too often put down. In the present instance I consider a new
opening most essential, and I reproduce my opinion, that if it had been timely performed,
we should never have heard of the terrible loss of life that ensued.
If, then, this omission be considered as connected in a primary degree with the explosion,
endeavour should be made to account for the immediate or actual cause of the
ignition of the fire damp.
It is well known that some mines are far more liable to sudden outburst of gas than
others ; it is a condition or event that occurs much more frequently than may be supposed,
and no super-introduction of atmospheric air can prevent it. If the lamps hold
good, but little is said on the subject, and for the most part the public know nothing at all
about it.
The transactions of the Manchester Geological Society contain the statement of Mr. Higson,
one of Her Majesty's inspectors, that in 1859 a quantity of gas was given off with
enormous rapidity whilst the men were at work in the Arley mine, and it was so abundant
as entirely to overcome the ventilation. This certainly was an immense effusion, and
though there were more than 350 persons at work at the time, no explosion took place ;
if it had, most likely all would have perished. Mr. Higson attributes their safety to the
lamps throughout the colliery being in a state of perfect repair, and to the general maintenance
in the pit of severe and strict discipline.
It is not long since that Mr. John Brown, of Lundhill, published a similar instance of
terribly rapid throwing off of gas, and of all lives being saved by steadiness and sound
safety lamps. In both those cases it is evident that the quantity of carburretted hydrogen
gas discharged was infinitely more than at Risca, nevertheless, the grand principle
of order and of discipline prevailed, and explosion was avoided.
By searching the annals of coal-mining operations, it will be found that such sudden and
dangerous eruptions are not altogether uncommon ; but, happily, it often occurs that the
lamps hold good, and the people preserve their presence of mind, and no explosion
follows. Under these circumstances, for the most part, all knowledge of the event is confined
to those who are connected with the pit. Occasionally, however, instances are made
known and described, as in the two praiseworthy cases just quoted. The details of such
startling incidents act as most useful warnings, and afford very valuable information to all
those who are occupied in coal-mining pursuits. But at intervals (mercifully rare), the
very converse of escape takes place, and we become shocked with the fearful details of the
destruction of our fellow creatures.
Whether or not the Risca Colliery possessed the advantage of that chance of escape
which we find recorded in the two instances already referred to (those of Messrs. Higson
and Brown), is a question for the gravest consideration.
Some of the evidence given at the inquest tended to the effect that the discipline was
not such as should prevail in a fiery mine, and it further showed that the lamp department
was not managed in the scrupulous manner demanded in a pit known to be liable to
sudden outbursts of inflammable air. The viewer certainly had exerted himself to put an
end to the dangerous habit of smoking underground. But we find, notwithstanding, that
tobacco pipes were taken below, and that false keys were known to be in possession of the
men ; indeed, one was actually found in the pocket of a sufferer on that melancholy
occasion. Lamps were also brought up not locked, though with their gauze cylinders
attached and uninjured. The locking was performed both at the top and the bottom of
the pit, even when the same shift of men proceeded to their daily labour. One witness,
(William Thomas), deposed that his lamp was locked at the top of the pit, whilst another
of the same name swore that his was locked at the bottom ; both cases on the same
morning. I may further state that during the time I was occupied underground (nearly
five weeks), it could not escape my observation that the lamps were not always well
supplied with oil and wicks, and on different occasions I remarked on the quality of both
to those who were then employed with me.
Men who had never worked in fiery mines, and who were ignorant of the mode of
handling lamps, had been known to be put on to work, and not many years since this very
circumstance had given rise to something like a strike or stand out amongst the more
experienced colliers.
George Hemmons, the lamp man, deposed that on the morning of the explosion he
"gave out about 200 lamps in a fit and proper state for working, but that he did not
examine the gauzes, because the viewer had authorized the firemen to do so!" If this
man did not examine them, he could not safely testify to their being "in a fit and proper
state." It appears the men took the gauzes with them, and cleaned them in their
own houses. This is the custom in some mining districts, and is, perhaps, in them,
perfectly safe and reliable ; but the security and effectiveness of the practice may be
questioned as regards the Risca and neighbouring collieries, inasmuch as it is not the
prevailing custom throughout all Wales.
The No. 41 special rule provides that "the lampkeeper shall see that every lamp sent
out of the lamp room for use in the workings is in proper condition and repair, and
that it is securely locked ;" yet this man admitted in his examination that "he did not
even examine or lock them." It is true that other persons were deputed to do so, and
for his non-compliance with his duty, as laid down in the special rule, he was certainly
not himself to blame. But taking this and the other circumstances altogether, they
exhibit a departure from that exactitude which so important a department demands.
Thus, from the general evidence tendered, I should form an opinion that it was scarcely
conducted in such a manner as to be a complete guarantee against danger ; under, for
example, those very conditions which appear in the two most fortunate instances I have
already quoted. To take an imperfect lamp into a fiery pit is as dangerous as the introduction
of a naked candle into a powder magazine.
With regard to the general state of discipline at the colliery, I can only make the
remark, that though divided authority is not conducive to order and regularity of action,
the absorption in too great a degree of all power and direction is equally dangerous.
Where there is no amount of practical knowledge to guide and control the operations of
a fiery coal mine, any undue interference in the actual working details is replete with
perplexity and danger.
My own opinion is, that the viewer was entirely equal to the development of the
mine; but, I should judge by the evidence at the inquest, that he was not vested with
sufficient power to carry out his own views. There were several distinct departments
to the conducting of which each individual chief and he only, was especially confined,
whereas the viewer of a colliery should invariably have every branch completely under
his own direction and command, and should never be unnecessarily interfered with by
the head manager, or any other person in authority.
The head overman could neither read nor write, but as he lost his life in the discharge
of his duty, it would now be want of proper feeling to call in question his merits or
abilities. Of the deputies (firemen) I may speak in a more decided manner: — One of
them lost his life in the explosion ; another proved by his own evidence that he was
altogether an incapable person; a third (called an assistant fireman) was too young and
inexperienced ever to have been placed in the responsible position of watcher over the
lives and safety of his fellow workmen ; of the fourth I do not find it needful to make
any special comment. Officers of this class are, I think, but little likely to exercise
salutary control over the workpeople of the mine.
I am induced then to make the statement, that from all that passed under observation
at the inquest, the discipline of this, pit was unquestionably defective.
A fiery colliery should possess that system, and be in that state of order and obedience
that we find to prevail in a ship of war, or in a well regulated regiment of the line; if it
be not so, all the air that can be forced through its workings will be insufficient to
protect it from the danger of explosion.
The remarkable twist, or northern turn which the map shows on the eastern side, is
attributable to a bend or swamp in that neighbourhood. The leading or hauling of
the coals from this part had become expensive, therefore it should have been long
previously abandoned. By limiting these eastern workings to the dotted line on the
plan, or even by going as far as the downthrow fault and stripping all the coal up to it,
they would have greatly eased the ventilation, and would at once have reduced the
heaviest drag the air sustained in the whole colliery. This curtailment had been
recommended long before the explosion. Four miles (the entire coursing of the air on
the eastern side), is a long travel for one split, though in some of the best managed
collieries there are instances of still greater length even in the north of England.
A pit should be so laid out that fatal results should be confined to the panel of work
where explosion might take place, and not destroy three-fourths of all the people. A
grand new shaft to the deep would have enabled them to make ample arrangements to
this effect. Indeed it would have changed the whole system of ventilation, and given
them a vast command of coal without pressing on restricted openings whenever there
was a brisk demand.
Instead of as at present, facing the gas and breaking into its stores in the wrong
direction, a new shaft would have released it the contrary way, giving it a far more
natural and perfect drainage upwards through the slope, or through an entire new
windway altogether, if they had so determined ; in this manner the old goaves would
have been distant from all their operations.
I may here remark that there were no gobs or goaves near the part of the pit that
fired, nor could that panel itself be considered a goaf, inasmuch as it was at the time of
the accident a group of worked stalls where the pillars were being ripped or drawn back.
This operation exposed a considerable surface of fresh coal face, which, when the
atmospheric pressure became reduced, suddenly gave out a large quantity of gas. The
barometer, as explained in my evidence, was singularly low on that morning ; it had, in
fact, fluctuated for many weeks, and exhibited atmospheric disturbance to an extent far
greater than I had ever before observed. At my recommendation they had long
previously placed a good barometer not far from the bottom of the shaft.
In relation to these goaves, it is a curious fact, that in the black vein, as far as they
have ever been examined, inflammable gas is not found. But black damp or carbonic
acid exists in very considerable quantities. In a place which had very shortly before
contained fire-damp, I found that it was replaced by the carbonic acid gas, to such an
extent indeed as to have a serious effect on us all, one of our party nearly succumbing to
it. I do not myself believe that the old gobs had any effect whatever in bringing about
the catastrophe.
Mr. Thomas Evans in his evidence as to the cause of the eruption, offered a
practical opinion ; "that the roof over the rippings had fallen and suddenly liberated
the gas." This view may well receive corroboration on account of the loose and
dangerous nature of the top, which sometimes cuts up to the "big vein," a thick seam
that is known to be a vast reservoir of carburetted hydrogen, and unquestionably it does
at times send down its gas. But, however, my own opinion remains firm and constant,
that the gas which first fired was an effusion from the black vein itself, and that the
explosion brought down a great fall of roof so that there was a double concussion, or
rather a rapid succession of explosions ; in such case there will be an entire coincidence
in evidence between Mr. Evans and myself.
At the inquest evidence was tendered as to limited size of windways, and also of insufficient
timbering. I have already stated that the roof of the black vein is as bad as
bad can be, and I may make the same remark of the thill or floor; in one single night it
is liable to "puck" or heave up in a manner that is almost incredible. I was more in
the pit than most of the witnesses ; abundant opportunity was afforded me to come to
some approximate opinion as regards these matters, and I must say I am unable to allege
that the local customary dimensions of air passages had been at all departed from ;
nor in my opinion, had there been that remarkable scarcity of timber of which some of
the witnesses made accusation ; indeed, the black vein will not put up with or admit
of any such economy. After the explosion, the shattered and destroyed state of the
workings, required much practical knowledge and large experience to enable any person
whatever to offer reliable testimony as to sectional areas, or of the quantities of timber
set up.
It was also stated that the men habitually worked too far beyond the brattice ; and
here I am bound to say that one measurement we made showed that the face was actually
more then 12 yards from the last length, but I certainly consider that to have been quite
an exceptional case. The bad custom prevailed of the colliers setting up their own
brattice, but this dangerous practice was of long standing and had arisen from the high
price paid for cutting and filling the coal. It unquestionably carried with it the evil of
the hewers being occasionally tempted to neglect their brattice, and was, no doubt in its
general tendency subversive of discipline and carefulness.
That the workmen were not cognizant of danger I quite believe ; had they thought
the pit was unsafe, they would very quickly have sought my intervention, as it is quite
the custom in the district to call in my aid when anything is supposed to be the matter.
I now desire to state over again my own conviction, that this terrible event is attributable
to a sudden emission of fire damp in the rippings of the No. 3 cross heading of the
No. 4 east level, and that naked flame came into immediate contact with the gas and
caused the explosion. In all probability this naked flame was exposed by an injured or
imperfect lamp, and that lamp after all may possibly have been the one which belonged
to Richard Jenkins, and which was found perforated as if with the point of a pick or
mandril, though there is no actual evidence to confirm that supposition.
I furthermore state that the intricate workings to the far east should have been earlier
cut off as recommended by me long previously, and I reiterate my opinion that there
might with advantage to the ventilation have been more splits of air in the mine, though
the accident cannot justly be charged to the absence of these two precautions. Lastly,
and more important than all, a new shaft should have been sunk to the extreme deep,
and then most probably no such appalling catastrophe would ever have taken place. I
again record the expression of my opinion that the lamp department was not strictly conducted,
and that the general discipline in the mine was not equal to that which a fiery
pit demands. This double laxity may have much more connexion with the explosion
than any other supposition contained throughout the whole of my report.
The deaths were occasioned by burning, by falls of roof and sides, and by asphyxia
from after-damp ; by far the greatest loss of life arose from this latter cause, from which
indeed for many of the people there was no chance of escape on account of their
becoming completely imprisoned and locked in by tremendous and inaccessible falls
of rock and rubbish.
Finally, I have reason to entertain the belief that this calamity is not capable of other
or further solution than that which I have endeavoured to record in these pages.
As the leading enquiry was held on the body of James Hammond I append the
verdict of the jury, adding the remark that all the remaining inquests were attended
with a similar return :—
"We find that the deceased James Hammond died on the first of December 1860
from the effects of an explosion of fire-damp in the Black Vein coal pit at Risca, which
gas was given off suddenly in the group of stalls in the third cross heading in the
fourth east level, but there is no evidence to show how this gas became ignited. To
this we beg to affix the following recommendations :— First, that the present rules of
the colliery shall be revised. Secondly, that the working places in the pit shall be
more frequently inspected; and, thirdly, that the suggestions of Mr. Brough, the
Government Inspector, that the ventilation and underground workings shall be so
arranged, that in case of any future explosion unfortunately occurring, the disastrous
results would be confined to the district in which it took place ; and that a new pit
shall be sunk for the permanent improvement of the ventilation of the colliery, which
pit should be taken into the serious consideration of the directors and proprietors of
the works. We take this opportunity of remarking that it appears to us that the
Stephenson lamp is the best and safest."
The proceedings occupied 19 days, spread over five weeks, and the case was most
patiently and searchingly investigated by the coroner and jury.
It is most pleasing to record the prompt assistance tendered on this afflicting occasion
by the mineral agents and workmen from all parts of the two inspectors districts ;
amongst those selected were Messrs. Wales, Brown, Palmer, and Gwillim. With the
two latter I had most to act ; indeed they were with me constantly throughout the whole
anxious and protracted period. I cannot say too much in praise of the skill and courage
of them all ; I may, indeed, include all the shifts of men who lent their aid so willingly
and laboured on until the last body was brought to daylight.