|
Swaithe Main Colliery Explosion.Report of Mr. Thomas Evans, Inspector of Mines.Derby, 7 January 1876. Sir, I have the honour to acknowledge the receipt of your letter of the 20th of January, requesting me to furnish a report in regard to the recent explosion of gas at the Swaithe Main Colliery. 2. On the 8th of December last, I received your instructions to attend and act in concert with my colleague, Mr. Wardell, at the inquest on the bodies of the persons killed by the explosion which took place on the 6th of December. 3. The Swaithe Main Colliery is situated about four miles from Barnsley, and is contiguous to the Edmunds and the Mitchell Main Collieries, all belonging to Messrs. Mitchell, Bartholomew, and Tyas, and all working the well-known Barnsley bed of coal. 4. On the 14th and 15th of December, I assisted the inspector of the district in making an examination of the underground workings, lying to the deep of the downcast shaft; in fact, that part of the mine where the violence of the explosion exhibited itself. 5. We were accompanied by Mr. Gerrard, the assistant inspector of the district, Messrs. T. Jeffcock, Mammatt, Thompson, mining engineers, several underviewers from neighbouring collieries, Mr. John Mitchell, the manager (holding a certificate), and Messrs. Normansell, Frith, and Capey, representing the miners. 6. I was present at the coroner's inquest during the whole of the seven days, rendering the best assistance in my power to Mr. Wardell and Mr. Maule, Q.C., in laying before the coroner and his jury all the evidence it was possible to obtain, which could throw any light as to the cause of this deplorable and very serious loss of life. 7. From my inspection of the mine, and a most careful consideration of the facts brought out in evidence, I am of opinion that there must have been two or more explosions of gas immediately following each other, the first taking place in one of the working places in the North slant level, and another at Brigg's siding at the top of the 12-acre goaf, and it is probable that the flame in passing along from extreme northern to the southern workings, ignited some gas which lodged along the gobs. 8. It is impossible to fix on the exact spot where the gas was actually fired, for in the slant drift level, and around the 12-acre goaf, all were killed, and the persons who witnessed the origin of the explosion must soon have been in the midst of flame, and instantly perished. 9. This is a locked lamp colliery, and with the exception of about 24 Clanny lamps (carried by persons employed on the main intake airways), Stephenson's were used. The glasses in the lamps used by the deputies and shot firers were an inch too short. They were purposely made in this way, so as to enable the shot firer to insert a fine wire through the gauze into the flame whilst the lamp was held in an inclining position. These I consider to be imperfect lamps, not so safe as the ordinary Stephenson or the Davy. 10. Stephenson's lamps are by many of the engineers of this district considered to be safer than any other, especially in the hands of the miners, as in most cases the presence of gas extinguishes the flame, and in this opinion I fully concur. One of the witnesses (Mr. Wilson, of the Oaks Colliery) went so far as to say that short glasses were as safe as proper fitting ones, and that the diameter of the lamp had little or nothing to do with its safety ; probably on reflection he will modify this opinion. 11. Whether the seat of the first explosion was in the slant drift level workings, or in Brigg's siding (at the top of the 12-acre goaf) is not a matter of much importance, but it is of vital consequence it should, if possible, be ascertained how it was that so much gas was present, and how and by what means it accumulated. There is not the smallest evidence to lead one to believe that any large quantity of gas was suddenly given off from the floor or roof, neither was there any "blower," but there is the fact that for weeks before the explosion the deputies report, day by day, the finding of gas in various parts of the colliery, and especially so in Brigg's siding at the top of the 12-acre goaf, and in the slant drift level workings. 12. The numerous goafs, or as they are locally called, "abandoned places" which are to be found throughout the mine, are large open cavities, unventilated, consequently in course of time the gas which is liberated from the floor and roof, lodges in these open places, and when unusual disturbance takes place, the falling of the roof, the firing of shots, the opening and shutting of doors, &c., the gas is forced out, and at the first exposed light, an explosion is the inevitable result. 13. The light, in this case, was probably a defective lamp. 14. It is true, tobacco pipes and a few lucifer matches were found in the pockets of some of the deceased, but there is not one bit of evidence to show that these things had anything whatever to do with the explosion; indeed the circumstances are wholly against such a proposition, for in the district where the explosion is supposed to have originated, the body of the deputy was found, and he most certainly would have prevented the use of matches, or the smoking of tobacco. 15. The discipline of the mine was certainly in a most unsatisfactory state. Rule 8, Section f, of the Mines Regulation Act, enacts, "That gunpowder shall not be taken into the mine, except in cartridges during three months after any inflammable gas has been found in any mine," and although gas was reported by the persons making the examination of the mine, yet they allowed the colliers to take loose powder into the mine; two canisters were found capable of holding a much larger quantity than the law directs. 16. The examination of the working places were not always made before the men descended the mine, and the report books were badly kept. 17. Blasting the coal was general throughout the colliery, except the north slant level workings, and shots had been fired on the south side not long before the explosion of gas. I do not, however, think they had anything to do with the immediate cause of the explosion. I must here state, that I quite agree with the observations made by my colleague. Mr. Wardell, that in the Barnsley and Silkstone seams of coal, which are said to be so fiery that they cannot be worked with naked lights, blasting the coal is attended with imminent danger, and the colliery owners, agents, and managers will incur a grave and most serious responsibility in continuing its use; there can be no good reason adduced in favour of the use of powder in a bed of coal eight feet thick ; it is simply a question of arrangement between the owners and workpeople. 17. The total quantity of air passing through the mine was probably sufficient, if properly distributed, for the safe working of the mine under ordinary circumstances. 18. I now beg respectfully to state that in my opinion the real cause of the explosion is due to the system upon which the colliery has been worked — goafs in the midst of workings unventilated, and discharging gas into the main roadways (as, for instance, in the slant drift level and Brigg's siding), and often into the actual working places where men are engaged at their ordinary occupations ; it is, however, right to mention that this mode of working has been practised in the district, I believe, generally. And although this explosion cannot be attributed to the use of powder, yet I think it absolutely necessary that in future the use of powder be discontinued, and locked safety lamps exclusively used; it is, however, more important that the system of working should be so arranged as that "so much of the mine must be kept ventilated as to render the working places and travelling roads safe." I have, &c. (signed) Thomas Evans, Inspector of Mines. The Right Honourable R. A. Cross, M.P., Whitehall, London.
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||