|
Swaithe Main Colliery Explosion.Report of Counsel on behalf of the Crown upon the Result of the Inquiry before the Coroner.5, Crown Office Row, Inner Temple, January 1876. Sir, In pursuance of your instructions in the matter of the inquiry by the Coroner into the cause of the deaths of the miners killed by an explosion at the Swaithe Main Colliery, on the 6th of December last, I attended that inquiry and watched the proceedings on the part of the Crown in concert with Mr. Wardell and Mr. Evans, and assisted in the endeavour to elicit the real facts of the case and the true cause of the accident. The evidence given before the Coroner as to the nature, extent, and cause of the explosion in the Swaithe Main Mine, which happened about half-past nine o'clock in the morning of that day, was commenced on Thursday, 16th December, and continued for five days. An adjournment at the end of that time became necessary, that the underground workings of the mine might be more thoroughly cleared, and the inquiry was resumed on the 13th January and ended on the following day. 2. A thorough examination of the mine has resulted in proving that the principal force of the explosion was first exerted in the lower or dip side of the workings, and was expended upwards and outwards towards the rise or top side. 3. It caused the deaths of 143 persons, whose destruction, with the exception of two or three, was instantaneous. The persons killed who were nearest to the full force of the explosion were severely burnt, those more remote from it perished only by suffocation. 4. In consequence of this loss of life, the direct evidence of any one who may have witnessed the origin of, and circumstances immediately accompanying, the explosion, could not be procured, and circumstantial evidence only, of what shortly went before or closely followed after the disaster, was all that remained as a guide to arrive at any conclusions. 5. The workings of the mine were divided into four districts, each one under the direction of a separate deputy during the day shift of eight hours, from six o'clock in the morning until two o'clock in the afternoon. 6. The duty of each of these four deputies was to examine his district twice during this day shift, and observe its safety as to ventilation and the presence of gases. These four districts were under two deputies during the night shift, each of whom examined two of the districts once during that shift for the like purpose. 7. The number of men and boys employed by the proprietors of the mine for the underground workings was 380 at the beginning of last December. 8. On the morning of 6th December 244 of the number went down into the mine between five and six o'clock, five of whom returned up before the explosion took place, 96 remained alive after it occurred, and 143 perished. 9. The second general rule of Section 51 of the "Coal Mines Regulation Act, 1872" (35 & 36 Vict, c. 76), requires that in every mine in which inflammable gas has been found within the preceding 12 months, once in every 12 hours if two shifts are employed during any 24 hours, competent persons, who shall be appointed for the purpose, shall, before the time for commencing work in any part of the mine, inspect with a safety-lamp that part of the mine and the roadways leading thereto, and shall make a true report of the condition of thereof, so far as the ventillation is concerned, &c. Every such report shall be recorded without delay in a book which shall be kept at the mine for the purpose, and shall be signed by the person making the same. 10. In accordance with this rule a book was kept at a place called the boxhole in the mine, in which reports were made by the deputies. These reports for the night shifts were entered each morning at five o'clock ; and during the three weeks immediately preceding 6th December last they record "gas as having been found during the night examinations in three places in which the coal had been worked out, described in these reports as 'abandoned places.' In the last six reports for the nights ending Monday morning, 6th December, gas is also reported to have been found in a working place described as 'North B., No. 4 working place.'" 11. The reports of the day examinations for the same three weeks show that in the above "abandoned places" gas had also been found in the daytime, and that gas had been found in the above-named working place during the six days ending on and including Saturday, 4th December. 12. When this condition of the mine is found, the general rules of the statute above mentioned have provided that the use of gunpowder or other explosive or inflammable substance in a mine underground shall not be allowed during three months after any inflammable gas has been found in any such mine, except it be in cartridges, and be only thus used in the mine when a competent person appointed for the purpose shall immediately before firing the shot, examine the place where it is to be used and the places contiguous thereto, who shall not allow the shot to be fired unless he finds it safe to do so, and then only under the direction of a competent person appointed for the purpose. 13. By these rules also, gunpowder is prohibited under any circumstances to be taken into the mine except in cases or canisters containing not more than four pounds weight, and no workman may have in use at one time in any one place more than one of such canisters. 14. Powder canisters were found by the explorers shortly after the explosion of the 6th December in several parts of the mine, including those in which the explosion had immediately and most violently exerted its force. 15. Of these canisters 14 had loose powder in them varying from three and a half pounds to half a pound in each, and three others were capable of holding five pounds each, and one other six pounds, and which last did actually contain five pounds and a half. 16. The miners obtained the gunpowder for blasting either at the stores of the colliery kept by the proprietors for the purpose, or from shopkeepers at Barnsley. In the last case they are induced to procure it on account of the price being lower than that charged at the colliery stores. 17. When the colliery storekeeper sells powder to the miners their canisters are left with and filled by him, and he can thus limit the amount in each canister to that permitted by the above rules. When, however, a miner purchases from a shopkeeper, the storekeeper has no means of checking the amount taken by such miner into the mine. 18. The deputies of the underground districts have to see that the workmen when in the mine have no more powder in their canisters than is permitted by the rules, but there is no one whose duty it is to see that the rule respecting the introduction of gunpowder into the mine either in canisters or cartridges is obeyed by each miner just before he goes down. 19. It was expressly stated at the inquest on behalf of the manager, that he could not see to the observance of this rule by enforcing a system of search of each miner or of his canister immediately before his descent into the mine, as the workmen would refuse to submit themselves to this discipline. 20. Obedience to these important precautions in the use of powder was thus left entirely to each miner, subject to penalties that follow the detection of having disobeyed them. 21. Cartridges are not made up at the colliery stores ready for use in the mine, but cartridge papers are sold to the miners who are expected to make their own cartridges when that mode of introducing powder below is exclusively allowed by the general rule above referred to. 22. The storekeeper of the colliery had served out gunpowder in canisters on Saturday morning, December the 4th, to nine miners, amounting in the whole to 22 pounds, and again on Monday morning, December the 6th, before the explosion, 19 pounds of powder loose in canisters had also been served out to miners from the same stores. 23. The Stephenson safety lamp has, with a few exceptions, been solely used in the mine, the exceptions being a few Clanny lamps, which are modifications of the Davy lamp. The Stephenson lamp is a combination of the gauze wire cylinder of the Davy lamp, with an inner glass tube of equal height, both surrounding the flame, but the diameter of the gauze wire cylinder in the Stephenson has to be greater than that of the Davy to afford room within for the glass tube. Neither this wire cylinder nor the glass tube is moveable in this miner's lamp. But a variation of it, used only by the deputies, consists in the glass tube being one inch shorter than the length of the outer wire cylinder, by means of which difference the glass can be raised one inch and the flame thus uncovered by it. When so uncovered the flame is exposed to the outer air with the wire cylinder only interposed, of a diameter too large to make it a perfect protection. The object of thus uncovering the flame is to pass a wire through a mesh of the gauze cylinder and heat it for the purpose of shot firing. All these lamps were locked. Much difference of opinion was expressed by experienced witnesses as to the actual and relative degree of safety of some of these and of the Davy lamps, but a general opinion was held with regard to the deputy's short glass lamp that it was decidedly imperfect. 24. One of the special rules for the Swaithe Main Colliery made by virtue of the "Coal Mines Regulation Act," and which has the same force as if contained in that Act, provides that no person shall smoke tobacco, or take tobacco pipes or matches down pits which are worked with safety lamps ; or shall have in his possession any lucifer match or any apparatus of any kind for striking a light. 25. An instance was afforded by the evidence at the inquest, of the security depending on the uncontrolled discretion of the miners in observing these rules, in the fact that in the pockets of the clothes of three men killed in the mine on the 6th December, were found three lucifer matches and three fusees, and on clothes of a fourth body were found a tobacco pipe and a small quantity of tobacco. 26. A similar instance was also given in relation to the special rule which directs that any person discovering a dangerous feeder or accumulation of gas must immediately give notice to the men and boys in that part of the mine, and to the underground viewer or the deputy, so that speedy measures may be taken to remedy the evil. It was proved that two miners, working in a dipboard of the part of the mine called the slant level, observed the presence of gas in that board on the 1st December last, from the effect produced by it on their lamps, about noon. Having removed their lamps to a distance, they shortly finished work, but neither of them gave notice of this appearance of gas to any one until the next day, when only they mentioned it to their deputy. 27. When the very serious dangers, which certain rules seek to avoid, can be prevented by a system of search of those persons for whom these rules are made, there is no sound reason to warrant the rejection of such a system. 28. It is well known that a like system is carried out in warehouses, docks, and dockyards in which valuable property is stored, but exposed to the depredations of workmen. How much more needed does this system become when applied to enforce rules, the violation of which may involve not merely loss of property, but the destruction of hundreds of human lives. 29. One of the special rules for the colliery generally provides, that the manager, underground viewer, and deputies, shall have control over all persons employed, and the latter must obey their lawful commands in accordance with the Act and special rules, and reports are to be made to the manager by deputies of violations of rules, that steps may be taken to insure discipline throughout the works. 30. It is further enacted by the 31st general rule of the "Coal Mines' Regulation Act, 1872," that every person who contravenes or does not comply with any of the general rules in Section 51 (including the manner of using gunpowder), shall be guilty of an offence against the Act, and in the event of any contravention of, or non-compliance with, any of the said general rules in the case of any mine to which the Act applies, by any person whomsover, being proved the owner, agent, and manager, shall each be guilty of an offence against the Act, unless he proves that he had taken all reasonable means by publishing, and to the best of his power enforcing, the said rules, as regulations for the working of the mine, to prevent such contravention or non-compliance. 31. It might be very difficult effectually to bring this enactment to bear upon omissions imputed to the owner and manager, still it is a point for decision how far the manager may be held not to have taken all reasonable means, and to the best of his power, of enforcing the rules which have clearly been shown to have been disobeyed by the miners as regulations for working the mine, by his neglecting to adopt a system of personal search of the workmen directly before they enter the mine, to prevent their contravening those rules which that system would enforce with certainty. 32. If it be true, however, that the miners as a body will resist the manager's control, by which he seeks to anticipate the breach of vital rules for their conduct, nothing is more easy than that the miners should appoint for themselves some of their own members to carry out a system of search, by means of which the lives of all would be made less subject to the reckless conduct of those amongst them who defy obedience to essential discipline. 33. From the manner in which some of the rules framed for securing safety have been carried out, it would seem that they have overtaxed the ability of those in authority, to whom the duty of enforcing them has been confided. 34. The dangerous nature of the seam of coal of the Swaithe Main Pit, arising from gas, was known to the proprietors, and in one part of the mine, called the "slant drift level." this danger had been so manifest that 12 months before December last, it had been resolved by the manager and underviewer that no shot-firing should be permitted in that part before two o'clock in the afternoon, at which hour the workmen of the day shift left the mine. 35. In all other parts of the mine shot-firing was permitted and practised while the men were working below ; such a shot had been fired in a working place at the bottom of the engine plane half an hour before the explosion happened. 36. The places that have been worked out called goafs, are not subject to the system of the ventilation, and are not capable, as it is said, of being made so. Their atmosphere, however, is open to that of the rest of the mine, and they are liable to become reservoirs of accumulated gas. 37. Any disturbance within them by a fall of roof or like accident, or by the vibrations caused by shot-firing, may drive their contents into the neighbouring working places and passages of the mine, and in such an occurrence if they should contain gas, it escapes into the contiguous working places, where it comes in contact with lamps or lights employed in blasting. 38. With such conditions to which this mine has been exposed, it would have been wise to have prohibited shot firing in every part of it during hours that the shifts were down at work. 39. Adjacent to the place in the mine where the shot was fired, half an hour before the fatal explosion, there was a large unventilated goaf of 12 acres in area, from which by manifest traces observed, a very violent force of exploded gas had proceeded and spread destruction to life, and to the workings next and near it. 40. It is certain that a large body of gas must also have been collected in that part of the mine already referred to, called the "slant drift level," in which, close adjoining the working places, was a goaf, where gas had been reported from time to time during three weeks preceding the explosion, and here on the morning of the 6th December it had ignited. In this last district the force of the explosion had been exceedingly violent, and the traces of it indicated that here, most probably, was the seat of its origin. Within short distance of the centre of this force were found 10 out of 22 damaged lamps, brought out of the mine after the disaster, and near this same spot the body of the deputy of this district and his damaged lamp were lying. It is one not unlikely cause that may be suggested, that by some displacing of the short glass tube of his deputy's lamp, when examining this place, access for gas was given to the flame by which the explosion was produced that spread thence into the other districts of the mine. This is however but a theory consistent with the evidence of the explorers. 41. Of any of the ways, however, by one of which the gas must have been ignited, no evidence has pointed to which one the explosion can be attributed. 42. It can only have been caused either by some rapid rush of gas through a perfect safety lamp not sufficient to extinguish it at once, or by the flame of a lamp accidently broken, or by a lucifer match or fusee kindled contrary to rules, or by the flame of a shot fired, or by the slipping up of the glass tube, and exposing the flame of a deputy's lamp. 43. In the absence of any proof to point to which of these the disaster could be traced, the coroner's jury returned, on this point, an open verdict. 44. It is an obvious conclusion, to which this inquiry leads us, that the rules that exist to control the conduct, and secure the highest amount of safety to life, of those employed in the underground workings when a colliery is affected by dangers of a fiery seam, have been left for their observance too much to the independent wills of the many who have to obey them, without a stringent superintendence of a superior authority to all, exercised with very peremptory powers. 45. No slight penalties for disobedience serve adequately to enforce law, when its violation ends in disasters that lie beyond the reach of remedy or redress. Where dangers of the highest degree and gravest consequences are daily dealt with, there a discipline of the highest stringency should be put in force. 46. Such a discipline must be known and practised in powder mills, where otherwise explosions would be constant; yet these consequences can there be largely mitigated by restrictions upon the amount of explosive matter within the mills. In a mine, however liable to accumulation of gases, no such restriction upon the amount of such explosive matter is in the power of managers, and this greatest danger seems to call for so much the greater and more unceasing precautions. The government of a mine thus exposed to explosions should be as strict, and obedience as much exacted, as on board a man of war. I have, &c. (signed) J. B. Maule, Q.C. A. K. Stephenson, Esq., Solicitor for the Affairs for Her Majesty Treasury, Whitehall.
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||