|
Swaithe Main Colliery Explosion.Report of Mr. Frank N. Wardell.Wath, 7 February 1876. Sir, I have the honour to transmit, in accordance with your instructions, my report of the result of the inquest on those who were killed by an explosion of gas at the Swaithe Main Colliery on the 6th December last. On receiving information on the morning of that day that an accident of considerable magnitude had occurred at Swaithe Main Colliery, I at once proceeded there, and found that an explosion of gas had taken place, resulting in grievous loss of life. When I ascertained the character and probable extent of the disaster, I communicated with you, and you directed my colleague, Mr. Evans, to assist me in making the necessary investigations, and, further, instructed Mr. Maule, Q.C., to attend at the inquest and watch the proceedings on behalf of the Crown. The colliery at which this explosion occurred is one of three contiguous to each other, all belonging to Messrs. Mitchell & Co. Between two of these three — Edmund's Main and Swaithe Main — there is direct underground communication, although the ventilation of each is almost entirely separate and distinct. The seam which is being worked is the "Barnsley;" Swaithe Main Colliery is ventilated by means of a furnace, a tube or chimney from which passes for some distance up the shaft, the return air not being taken directly over the flames, but ascending the shaft outside this tube. The difficulty in restoring the ventilation, and recovering the bodies, the necessity for extinguishing the furnace, and subsequently re-lighting it, all furnished strong proofs of one of the superiorities of mechanical ventilation where an uniform current of air could without danger have been maintained. I was accompanied in my inspection of the mine, which was made so soon as practicable, by Mr. Evans, my assistant Mr. Gerrard, the manager Mr. John Mitchell, and several mining engineers, also by the president and secretaries of the South Yorkshire Miners' Association. The explosion had not affected the workings on the "rise" side of the pit, between Swaithe and Edmund's Main, but was confined to the lower or "dip" side of the shaft, and in this district were evidences of at least two explosions. It seemed to me that the gas was first ignited in a district known as the "slant drift level" district, that it had thence passed along the "slant level," across the engine plane, and fired more gas in a large "goaf" in "Briggs' siding," causing a second and very violent explosion. From this point the direction was upwards to the "boundary bord," and also through the large "goaf" to the low workings in "No. 4 level" and "No. 4 drift level," where another explosion may have taken place, evidences of violence being around here also very apparent. The direction taken by the blast along the "boundary bord" was to an "overthrow," which was blown down, and hence through the stables to the shaft, doing considerable damage to the cages and conductors. All the evidence I saw led me to believe that the direction of the explosion was as I have thus described, and the descriptions given by witnesses at the inquest confirmed my opinion. Blasting was allowed in certain parts of the mine, and locked safety lamps were exclusively used. For many days after the explosion it was impossible, owing to the uncertainty which existed as to the exact number of persons who had been in the mine at the time, and to the difficulty in recovering the bodies, to ascertain correctly the full extent of the calamity ; it is now, however, known that the total number of lives lost is 143. The inquiry held before the Coroner, Thomas Taylor, Esq., at Barnsley, was of a most searching and full character, and I do not believe that at its close there could have been a particle of evidence adduced which would in any way have thrown light upon the cause of the explosion, or its consequences. The exceptional measures, taken by your instructions in order to insure a complete investigation into the causes of the calamity, helped to lead to this result; and these measures were ably seconded and supported by all who were engaged on the inquiry. It is to be deeply regretted that beyond the main facts of an explosion of gas having taken place, and a certain number of persons having been killed, nothing could be elicited which actually proved where or how the explosion occurred, so that the actual cause of the disaster must remain a matter of conjecture and opinion. All who might have been able to afford any positive information were swept away. Much, however, was brought to light which indicated a marked laxity of discipline in the mine, more especially with reference to the use, or abuse, of gunpowder; and because all such matters as inattention to rules and absence of discipline, one and each contribute to produce disasters such as this (and minor ones as well), such defects as were pointed out may be remedied in the future, and the lesson, though dearly bought, may not be without its salutary effect throughout the district. It is not my opinion that in this instance the gas was ignited by the firing of a shot; but this does not in the least weaken my convictions, so repeatedly expressed, that gunpowder should not be used in the Barnsley and Silkstone seams. I prefer to express myself so, rather than to say, in mines where safety lamps are used, for it has been suggested to me that were such a regulation enforced at some mines where safety lamps are now used in conjunction with powder, the former would be removed ; but I am very unwilling to believe that any owners or managers of such mines, with the experiences we have had in this district, would incur the enormous responsibility of taking such a step. Although, then, this explosion may not have been directly caused by the firing of a shot, my opinion as to the increase of safety by discontinuing the use of powder is strengthened, for, with gas in the mine (and whether the gas was given off suddenly, or whether it had been gradually accumulating in the "goafs," still at the time of the explosion, it was there), and at the same time a naked light (which when produced by shot-firing is of a specially dangerous form), there are the two elements necessary to produce an explosion co-exist, and only waiting to be brought into contact. Whether, then, the firing of a shot at Swaithe Colliery caused the explosion or not, there, at all events, was existing such a condition of affairs as that this might have so resulted, and therefore it is in the highest degree important that by the discontinuance of blasting in those mines where gas is known to exist, one source of danger, at all events, would be removed. The Barnsley and Silkstone seams are well known to be of a fiery nature; gas is constantly being given off. Sometimes, it may be, liberated suddenly, as has been the case at some of the collieries in this district, when, owing to the exclusive use of the Stephenson lamp, and the absence of powder, terrible disasters have been averted; and sometimes, perhaps, through defective ventilation, or an improper judgment in the distribution of the air, allowed to accumulate, and gradually to become so diffused with the atmosphere as to render it ready for the first opportunity which may offer for its ignition; and this opportunity may be caused also, not only by a naked light (which includes defective safety lamps) being actually taken into the explosive compound, hut also by the gas being expelled from its possibly unobserved position by some circumstance connected with the ordinary working operations of the mine ; for instance, any slight derangement of the ventilation occasioned by a fall, or the opening or shutting of some door, or the concussion produced by the firing of a shot, may each and all effect this. In this last-mentioned cause another reason is apparent why gunpowder should be abandoned, for it may clearly, if it be not the primary cause, produce an explosion indirectly. I have for many years strongly advocated the discontinuance of gunpowder in these seams, and each year strengthens my conviction that I am right in so doing. The introduction exclusively of safety lamps also was, and is, a matter I have ever pressed most seriously on the attention of owners and managers, and I am thankful to say that at almost every colliery where these seams are worked safety lamps are now generally adopted, they having been within the last two years alone, introduced at ten or twelve of the largest and most important mines. The use of gunpowder is gradually decreasing, and there really seems to me to be no reason, beyond what would be matters of arrangement or contract between masters and men, why, if certain mines can be worked without it, the remainder, working identically the same seams, under similar conditions, cannot also dispense with its operation. I am convinced that the total abandonment of gunpowder in these mines would certainly remove one of the causes which contribute to produce such calamities as that at Swaithe, and hence we might fairly hope and expect, produce a proportionate diminution in the list of fatalities. The use or partial use of powder having been allowed at Swaithe Main, it simply then became the duty of all to see that those rules affecting its operation were stringently observed. This, however, does not seem to have been the case. Gas had repeatedly been found and reported in various parts of the mine, and for weeks before the explosion almost daily, and yet powder was taken down loose in canisters, and not, as required, in cartridges. Some of the canisters, too, were capable of containing more than 4 lbs., which is the maximum quantity prescribed by the Act to be taken into a mine by one person. There was also an absence of system as to the account kept of powder used in the mine. It was possible for the men to purchase it in Barnsley or elsewhere than at the colliery company's storehouse, and take it down with them without rendering any account of it at all, and in some instances this was done. Some of the districts which are assigned to the deputies are, in my opinion, too large. A deputy holds a most important and responsible position, and it is absolutely necessary that his district should be of such limited size as to be under his control. Physically speaking, it is impossible that a careful examination can be made when this is not so. The distribution of air in the dip workings is, in my opinion, capable of considerable improvement, and the mode of working all round large "goafs" is highly objectionable. The air, as at present conducted, passes from "No. 5," for instance, to the working places in "No. 3," taking with it any gases which may have been given off. And so in "No. 2" district as regards the "slant level" and the "slant drift level" workings, alterations could easily be effected which would give to each district a supply of fresh air, and the consequent improvement would be very beneficial. The lamps supplied to the deputies, or shot lighters, are Stephenson's, but are constructed so as to allow the glass cylinder to have an inch play within the gauze, so that by inclining the lamp the wire for firing the shot may be introduced through the gauze at the part which is then unprotected by the glass. This, in fact, renders it a comparatively unsafe lamp, it being then a "Davy," but with a diameter of gauze exceeding that which is considered to be the maximum compatible with safety in a "Davy" lamp. The most experienced and eminent engineers, I think, are agreed on this point, and I would mention two who, though now dead, their opinions are quoted as of the highest authority, Sir H. Davy himself and Nicholas Wood, Esq. I have to say that I am exceedingly indebted to Mr. Evans for the painstaking assistance he has rendered me, and likewise to Mr. Maule for his valuable aid. To Mr. Gerrard my thanks are due for indefatigable help, to the coroner for the able conducting of the inquiry, and to Mr. Sykes, the superintendent of police, for the way in which he assisted in obtaining and preparing evidence, and I may add, that all facilities were readily afforded my colleagues and myself in our investigations, by the proprietors and the manager. The verdict returned by the jury was to the following effect:— "The deceased came by their deaths at the Swaithe Main Colliery, on 6th December 1875, by an explosion or explosions of fire damp, but how such explosion or explosions originated there is not sufficient evidence to show. The jury are likewise of opinion that according to the evidence the Swaithe Main is a fiery mine, and that the general and special rules of the colliery have not been rigidly carried out, and that gunpowder had been recklessly used. The jury are also of opinion that in a mine where safety lamps are used, the use of gunpowder should not be allowed, except in stone drifts, and then only when all miners are drawn out. The jury desire the coroner to forward this opinion to the Secretary of State. They also regret that the miners have not carried out rule 30 (which gives them power to examine mines), and they think that this rule should be more directly adhered to." It is with much sorrow I have to add that the principal proprietor of the colliery, Mr. Mitchell, has died since the explosion, and also, that death has carried off Mr. Normansell, one of the miners' secretaries, who accompanied my colleagues and myself in our examination of the mine. It is more than probable that trouble and anxiety, occasioned by the deplorable calamity, hastened the end of both. I have, &c. (signed) Frank N. Wardell. The Right Honourable R. A. Cross, M.P., Her Majesty's Principal Secretary of State.
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||