Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
Index

III. — Narrative Of The Explosion And Subsequent Events

The First Explosion

Shortly after 9.30 a.m. the deputy, H. Williams, in the course of his duties, had gone outbye along the supply gate, and all other persons were in the positions shown on Plan 2. The cutting machine had reached the return end of the face and had just been stopped by the operator, and the conveyor had been temporarily stopped by the conveyor attendant. A coal getter, V. Lewis, working near No. 8 pack, required a Schloms bar for setting at the face and went to withdraw one from the back row in front of No. 8 pack. The steel wedge was in position and he used a sledge hammer to drive it out. As he struck the first blow on the end of the wedge, a flame appeared at the wedge; a tongue of flame shot out a few feet towards the face and then receded into No. 7 waste, from which a large volume of flame immediately gushed out onto the face. This sequence of events is corroborated in every detail by two other getters who were watching Lewis from a distance of only a few feet.

The flame of the explosion travelled against the air current down the face as far as No. 3 pack, some 30 yards from the loading gate, and with the air current into the supply gate. Flame barely reached the men at the boring machine about 45 yards back from the face of the supply gate. It would appear that the flame travelled partly on the face and partly inside the waste edge, because several persons who were within the limits of travel were unharmed. Of the 32 persons who were in the path of the explosion, 17 sustained severe burns, seven sustained slight burns and eight were uninjured. It is remarkable that, of the three persons who were close together in front of No. 8 waste, two were severely burned and yet the other was only singed.

Overman G. Thomas, who was examining No. 6 pack, was one who escaped injury. He was between two steel chocks when he heard a thud and then shouting. He saw flame travel past him towards the loading gate and then go back towards the return. Men immediately came running down the face, some with their clothing on fire. When he had seen these men safely off the face, he went to the loading point and telephoned for assistance and for the machinery to be put in motion for summoning rescue and ambulance services. He then organised first-aid treatment for the injured and took steps to ensure that all persons in the district were accounted for. He was assisted by the deputy, who was in the supply gate when the explosion occurred and had come out behind the men who took that road from the face.

Mr. Evans, assistant manager, and overman Thomas explored the face from the intake end. They found articles of clothing on fire, which they extinguished, and reached No. 7 waste, where they were forced to retire on account of intense heat although they saw no signs of active combustion.

The Second Explosion

Before noon another exploration of the face from the intake end was attempted by a party which included the Agent, Manager, H.M. District Inspector of Mines and the Superintendent of the Brynmenin Rescue Station. They found conditions. normal until they reached No. 7 waste. Conditions here were now much cooler, but on looking into this waste, which had caved to a height of about 6 feet, they saw the flame of gas burning near the roof thus formed. Whilst they were considering the possibilities of extinguishing this flame, a rumbling noise was heard followed immediately by the issue of flame from Nos. 6 and 7 and possibly other wastes. The flame was of momentary duration and no-one was injured, but it was wisely decided to leave the face forthwith. When the party returned to the surface the decision was made to seal off the district.

The Sealing of the District

The sealing of the district necessitated the building of three stoppings, one in each intake roadway and one in the return. It was decided to build these with sandbags. The sites were chosen and the preliminary work started on the afternoon of 13th January. Although the organisation was excellent and the work carried through without a hitch, it proved a long and arduous task, particularly in the case of the return, or No. 3, stopping for which all materials had to be carried down two ladders in a steep drift and then a further 90 yards to the site.

The Mobile Laboratory of the Scientific Department, South Western Division, National Coal Board, reached the colliery at about noon and was functioning perfectly in the early afternoon on the day of the explosion. It remained at the colliery constantly available for the analysis of air samples until the mine was ready for the full resumption of normal work, and the service rendered proved of the utmost value.

While the work of building the stoppings was proceeding, air samples were taken at hourly intervals at the site of the No. 3 stopping in the main return airway from the workings in the Six Feet Seam. The first sample taken at 4.0 p.m. on 13th January contained 0.009 per cent. carbon-monoxide; by 8.0 p.m. this had dropped to 0.005 per cent, and by midnight to 0.0035 per cent. Thereafter the carbon-monoxide content varied between 0.0008 per cent. and 0.0017 per cent. until it rose to 0.003 per cent. at 5.0 a.m. on 16th January, when the stoppings were nearing completion and the flow of air was considerably reduced.

It was known from the results of analyses of air samples previously taken by the Scientific Department that the atmosphere of this mine normally contained no trace of carbon-monoxide, and it was agreed by all concerned that the samples taken at the site of No. 3 stopping showed conclusively that combustion was still taking place. These sample results could, however, be reasonably interpreted as showing that combustion was confined to the gas jet which had been seen burning in No. 7 waste, and hopes were raised that it might be practicable to extinguish the flame and thus avoid the necessity for sealing off the district.

Without interrupting the work on the stoppings, two explorations were made by a rescue team wearing self-contained breathing apparatus. On the first occasion they saw light which appeared to be reflected from gas burning at the face side of No. 7 waste cavity. On the second occasion they saw the flame of this gas burning as it issued from a bed-separation break about 15 feet above the floor. The team captain gave it as his considered opinion that any attempts to extinguish this flame could only be made by men working inside the fallen waste in considerable danger from falls of ground. It was accordingly decided to abandon the idea of extinguishing the flame and no further exploration was attempted.

The building of the stoppings was completed at 6.0 a.m. on 16th January. Each stopping was about 18 feet long, reinforced with steel rails and girders; two tubes were set in each stopping for the purpose of taking air samples from inside the sealed area. Ventilation doors were re-arranged with a view to balancing the pressure on the stoppings. The sites of the stoppings and the positions of the doors are shown on Plan 1. As soon as the stoppings were completed all persons were withdrawn from the mine for twenty-four hours.

The Re-Opening of the District on 22nd January

Shortly after 6.0 a.m. on 17th January, the stoppings were examined and found intact, and samples of the air outside and inside each stopping were collected and analysed. The results showed fresh air inside and outside the No. 2 stopping, where there was a pressure inwards of 0.04 inch water gauge, and no appreciable change at the No. 3 stopping where there was a pressure outwards of 0.8 inch water gauge. In the case of the No. 1 stopping the results were most significant, showing a carbon-monoxide content of 0.0007 per cent. inside the stopping and 0.0008 per cent. outside. Water gauge readings showed pressures of - 0.04 inches on a long tube extending 50 feet through the stopping and + 0.08 inches on a short tube extending just through the stoppings. The only feasible explanation for the presence of carbon-monoxide at this stopping in the intake was that a further explosion had occurred since the stoppings were completed. This was subsequently confirmed.

All other districts in the mine were examined and found in order, and normal working was resumed in them on the night of the 17th January.

Regular sampling of the air inside and outside the stoppings was continued. There was no appreciable change at the No. 2 stopping or at the No. 1 stopping where the carbon-monoxide content remained between 0.006 per cent. and 0.0019 per cent. The samples taken from inside the No. 3 stopping provided confirmation that a further explosion had occurred. The carbon-monoxide content started to rise on the afternoon of 17th January, reached a peak of 0.0293 per cent. at noon on 18th January and then started to fall. This seemed to show that a certain amount of ventilation was continuing to take its normal course inside the sealed area, but there was a steady build up of methane and reduction of the oxygen content inside the No. 3 stopping.

By the afternoon of 18th January, a graph plotted from the sample results showed that the atmosphere inside the No. 3 stopping was approaching the lower explosive limit as defined by "Coward's triangle", and at the end of the morning shift the management stopped all further work and withdrew all persons from the mine. A rough calculation showed that if the build up of methane and reduction of the oxygen content continued at about the same rate, the plottings would pass through the triangle into an extinctive atmosphere in about 60 hours, and it was decided to re-enter the mine and commence taking further samples at 10.0 p.m. on 20th January. This arrangement was duly carried out. By 10.30 a.m. on the 21st, the atmosphere inside the No. 3 stopping had become extinctive with a content of 1041 per cent, methane and 152 per cent. oxygen. It appeared from the graph that the rate of change in the atmosphere had been constant since the afternoon of 18th January.

A meeting of representatives of all interested parties was then held, at which it was agreed that the following conclusions could be drawn:

 (1) 
A further explosion had occurred on 16th-17th January as indicated by the results of samples taken at Nos. 1 and 3 stoppings on the 17th.
 (2) 
The only igniting medium inside the sealed area at that time was the gas jet burning in No. 7 waste; it was therefore most probable that this third explosion had been similar to the two earlier ones.
 (3) 
An explosion on the Panzer Face at a time when the ventilation was checked by the stoppings would leave an inert atmosphere in which methane could not continue to burn.
 (4) 
The samples taken from inside No. 3 stopping gave no indication of any disturbance inside the sealed area while the atmosphere was passing through the full range of explosive mixtures.
 (5) 
The possibility of there being any combustible material at a sufficiently high temperature to re-ignite when the ventilation was restored was extremely remote.

Based on these conclusions, a decision was made to broach Nos. 2 and 3 stoppings, and this work was completed at about 5.0 a.m. on 22nd January. The ventilation doors were re-arranged so as to restore the ventilation to the Six Feet Seam and all persons were withdrawn from the mine for a period a 12 hours.

The Investigation after Re-Opening

An inspection of the district was made on the evening of the 22nd and a full investigation the following morning. On the first inspection it was found, as expected, that the ventilation doors on the length of road connecting the mouths of the loading and supply gates had been blown open, but when these had been closed the ventilating current took its usual course and atmospheric conditions soon became normal. Air samples taken at various points showed no trace of carbon-monoxide and thus confirmed that there was no combustion of any kind taking place. There was ample evidence that a third explosion had occurred of somewhat greater magnitude than the first two. There was now evidence of the passage of flame throughout the face and for about 150 yards outbye along the supply gate. There was no evidence of the passage of flame in the loading gate but explosion dust had been deposited throughout most of its length. There was no evidence of coal dust having played any part in the explosions, which had been of a very mild character. The face had stood remarkably well. Inspections of all other parts of the mine having revealed satisfactory conditions throughout, normal working of the whole of the mine re-commenced on Sunday, 24th January and continued without further interruption.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page


mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z