V. — Examination Of The Fire Area
As soon as conditions allowed, a careful and detailed examination was made of the area covered by actual fire. The No. 1 belt was burnt through. The burnt end of the top belt was found 48 feet from the outbye end of the centralizing hopper where it had apparently continued to burn or smoulder until it was extinguished at a set of idler rollers. The burnt end of the bottom belt was found underneath the chute structure of the No. 2 transfer point about 5 feet from the outbye end of the hopper. The coal-carrying side of this bottom belt was burnt in several places for a distance of 7 feet from the burnt end and part of the rubber cover was stripped for a distance of nearly 95 feet from that end. When the two burnt ends were brought together on the surface they did not match. Nevertheless, although some part of this belt had been consumed by the fire, there seems little doubt that most, if not all, of the distance between the burnt ends could be accounted for by the fly-back when the belt burnt through whilst under tension.
The casing of the chute and centralizing hopper showed signs of heating, as all the paint was burned off except for a little at the outbye end of the centralizing hopper and underneath the sloping-chute plate. The roof and sides over most of the chute-unit were supported with steel girders resting on wooden-end props, with wooden lagging. The props, though charred on the surface in places, had continued to give adequate support to the roof, but the lagging had burnt and charred remains were found. Two pieces of charred lagging were found resting on idler rollers. The possibility that this wood, heated by friction against the rollers, might have started the fire, was considered, but was ruled out because, among other reasons, it seemed certain that the wood had fallen out of position after the fire had started.
Up to slightly above the level of the No. 2 belt delivery roller, and sloping downwards outbye, the chute was found filled with debris which extended down between the idler and impact rollers of the No. 1 belt below. All of this material was carefully collected, sent to the surface and weighed, and then dispatched to the Safety in Mines Research Station at Buxton for sieving and a more detailed examination. It was found to comprise: stone-dust and powdered-charred belting (passing through ¼ inch mesh), 2,010 lb. ; lumps of stone, 464 lb. ; unburnt and partly burnt belting, 254 lb. ; charred-wood lagging, 35 lb.; old nuts and bolts, 1 lb. 13 oz. ; and white metal from idler rollers, 10½ lb.
When most of this material had been removed from the chute, it was seen that, between the top edge of the sloping-chute plate and the No. 2 belt delivery roller, a quantity of torn belting was very tightly wedged and looked as if it had been pulled in by the moving No. 2 belt. The chute plate was dropped and the wedged pieces of torn belting more closely examined. The surfaces in contact with the remains of the No. 2 belt and, at the side, in contact with the metal surface of the delivery roller, were found to be worn by friction. The piece of No. 2 belt still remaining in contact with the delivery roller, and conforming to its curvature, was unburnt. It was full width and not grooved, but the rubber surface was severely worn and showed an imprint of the trapped belting.
After the chute and the piece of No. 2 belt still adhering to the delivery pulley were removed, the pulley itself was rotated and found to be undamaged. There was plenty of grease in the top of each bearing which had not been hot enough to melt the grease. An examination of the, surface of the pulley showed no indication of slip between belt and pulley.
Altogether, 43 pieces of belt longer than 8 inches were recovered from the chute debris. Of these pieces, ten, varying in length from 12 inches to 54 inches, showed a cut through one surface rubber and through all seven plies of canvas, but in no case was the cut through the last layer of rubber. The cut was consistently 5½ inches from one edge of the belting. Fifteen of the other pieces were 5½ inches wide. On the No. 1 conveyor, with its outbye end torn, another piece of belting 43 feet 8 inches long, was found.
This evidence suggested the possibility, indeed the probability, of a fire having started at the top of the chute plate by frictional heating between the wedged torn belting and either the No. 2 delivery roller or the No. 2 belt, as it passed round the roller.
The top of the chute plate was found to be bowed downwards with a maximum deflection of 5½ inches about 15 inches from the left side looking inbye. When the chute was disconnected it was found that, at the point of maximum deflection, there was a gap of 1¼ inches between the chute and the 2 inches by inch iron strip by which the belt wiper was fastened to the chute. The wiper was found to be worn away until it was level with the edge of the chute, which was about 1 inch from the face of the No. 2 belt delivery roller. One of the eight bolts, by which the iron strip had originally been fixed, was found to be missing at the gap. Pieces of torn belting in this gap had pushed the belt wiper away from the edge of the chute and had also bent the strip of iron between the second and fourth bolts from the left-hand side. Whether this missing bolt and gap had been of long standing or were the result of the happenings immediately before or during the fire, can only be a matter of conjecture. In any case, I do not consider they had any material effect on the course of events.
A heap of stone was found on the floor near the delivery end of No. 2 belt. This suggested that there had been at some time a "pile-up" in the chute due to No. 1 belt being at rest while No. 2 belt was delivering stone. All the belt rollers and their bearings of both Nos. 1 and 2 conveyors in the vicinity of the No. 2 transfer point were examined in great detail. Several were found to be damaged, usually by the melting out of the end alloy discs containing the ball bearings, but this damage was considered to be the result of the fire. In no case was there any suggestion that heating at a roller bearing was a probable or even a possible cause of the fire. Nor was there anything to suggest that either the tensioning gear of the No. 1 belt, or the driving gear of the No. 2 belt had anything to do with the start of the fire. On this gear-head were found two small pieces of belting, neither of which showed the signs that would have been expected if the fire had started at the gear-head by the friction of a jammed belt. On the floor, just inbye of the chute, was a heap of coarse coal dust which had taken no part in the fire. It was covered by a white deposit which appeared to be the remains of the charge of a foam extinguisher.
Except for odd pieces of charred belt, and one piece of the top belt, 9 inches by 4 inches, which was found under a stone presumably carried by the top belt, the No. 2 conveyor belt was completely missing for a distance of more than 30 yards on the inbye side of its delivery head pulley. It was at this point that falls of ground began to be encountered. These falls had to be cleared to permit exploration and assist ventilation. A few pieces of unburnt belt were found underneath the falls. At a wet place a piece, 39 inches long, had presumably been protected by a pool of water. Some steel arch girders had become so hot that they had twisted under load. The loader gate of old 59's district showed signs. of heating for a distance of 60 feet but the fire had not travelled down it. Near the Timber Slit, two pieces of top belt, about 8 feet long, were found, having apparently been protected by small falls. At a point 500 feet from the Timber Slit two larger pieces of top belt, 16½ feet and 21 feet long, separated by a distance of 9 feet, were recovered. This was at the site of a large fall of roof and it seems likely that here the fire received a check and propagated only along the bottom belt which would be protected by the conveyor structure forming a tunnel through the fall. It was probably this "lull" which made most of the early recovery work possible just prior to the erection of the first stoppings to seal off the district. The fire did, however, pass this obstacle and there is no doubt that had the seals not been erected at the time they were, the fire would have spread much farther than it ultimately did. A short distance beyond this point and near the top of the drift through the Elmton Fault, the burnt ends of No. 2 belt were found. The end of the bottom belt was found underneath a fall of roof and the end of the top belt about 50 feet farther inbye. From this point signs of heating decreased down the drift and finally died away near the roof.
From its burnt end, the top belt was found to be practically undamaged for a distance of 257 yards inbye. For the next length of about 100 yards to the No. 3 transfer point and then back along the bottom belt outbye to its burnt end — a total length of 469 yards — -the belt was found to be torn or cut. Damage to the top belt started with three "sloughings" or "gougings" and a hole 8 inches long and ½ inch wide, about 5½ inches from the edge of the belt travelling road side. From the edge of this hole — and at the same distance from the edge of the belt — the belt was cut through for the whole of the distance to the No. 3 transfer point, with the strip of cut belt lying on the conveyor rollers alongside the remaining part of the belt. For a distance of 20 yards from the starting point, the edges of the cut showed occasional "sloughings" while other "sloughings" were seen on the 5½ inches wide strip. The cut was clean except that the rubber on the non-coal-carrying side had a generally jagged appearance. At distances of 8 and 10 yards from the start, the rubber on the under-side of the belt was joined across the cut for a length of ¼ inch. This cut strip of belting terminated underneath the chute of No. 3 transfer point, and one end of the 43 feet long strip — found (as already mentioned) on the No. 1 conveyor outbye the No. 2 transfer point — matched perfectly with an end of the strip found at the No. 3 transfer point.
A strip of the belt was found to be missing for the whole length of the bottom belt from the No. 3 transfer point out to the burnt end at the top of the drift. For the first 204 yards, a 5½ inches wide strip was missing, leaving on the remaining belt a clean straight edge, having all the appearance of being cut by some sharp object, except that the rubber on the non-coal-carrying side was jagged. The width of the missing piece then suddenly increased for a short distance, indicating that cross-tearing had occurred. From subsequent observations, it seems extremely likely that it was at this point, i.e. when fully 200 yards of torn strip had collected in the chute while the No. 2 belt was still running, that the loose belt jammed in the No. 2 chute. For the next 100 yards, the width of the remaining belt varied and the edge was jagged, with the strip of belt missing varying from 7 to 9 inches. It was from this length that the grooved pieces of belting recovered from the No. 2 chute must have come, as nowhere else was the missing piece wide enough. This gave a clue to the condition of the belt immediately before the fire occurred and indicated that there had been a cut through all seven plies of canvas but not through the bottom rubber.
For the next 50 yards near the top of the drift, the remaining belt showed a clean cut edge, with a 5½ inches wide strip missing. Then followed about 70 yards of jagged edge belting with a strip, 1½ inches to 4½ inches wide, missing. This portion of the belt did not show any indication of being grooved. A straight cut edge re-appeared on the last 10 yards of the belt before the burnt. end, except for a 12 inches length about 1 foot from the end.
At this point, the belt had apparently torn out to the edge, and there is no reason to suppose that it was other than full width from here outbye to the delivery roller at the No. 2 transfer point. Indeed, we have the evidence of Jos. Morris, that, from a point just outbye the top of the drift, the bottom belt was the full width to the No. 2 transfer point.
From the calculated area of missing belt, it was estimated that there must have been about 1,600 lb. of torn belting in the No. 2 chute at the time of the fire and that of this quantity, 1,350 lb. was burnt.