Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
Index

Narrative Of The Accident.

Operations were resumed in the heading on Thursday, the 22nd August, and were carried on by David Campbell, pit inspector for the Mynheer workings, and by Alexander Smith, an oncost man, who had been pit inspector in the west side Mynheer workings ; James Dick and James Rattray, roadsmen, occasionally assisted. A barricade was erected above the incline wheel to prevent the material worked going down the heading; this barricade closed the road entirely, and the stuff that accumulated against it was afterwards removed to the rib sides on either side of the heading. The sand and gravel was worked away following the hard pavement of the seam, and the bottom of the moss reached on Saturday, the 24th, and on that day James Dick probed it by pushing forward in a slanting direction an iron rod 17 feet long and ½ inch diam. Dick reported this to Thomas Rattray before starting work on the day of the accident and Rattray asked him if any water was got and if he required a spade to dig out the moss. Dick answered both questions in the negative, and added that as there was still 6 feet of sand to dig out a spade was not required. Operations were continued on the 2 6th, and about 1.40 p.m., while David Campbell and Alexander Smith were working at the face of the heading, the roof gave way, and was immediately followed by a rush of moss. The barricade appears to have prevented the moss flowing directly down the heading and forced it along the rib sides of the upper roads. On the east side it flowed round the two upper faces, but was prevented reaching the third face by a heavy fall of roof, and this road and its face remained free from moss except for a few yards from its junction with the heading. On the west side the moss had a free course and passed round the faces and into the air-way, cutting off in a short time all communication in the direction of the air shaft.

The barricade gave way an hour or two after the burst and was swept down the heading along with the wheel and its frame, the timber, rails, and sleepers, and thereafter most of the moss would flow directly down the heading, along the short level and down the second incline, and then flow in the direction of the drawing shafts.

Campbell and Smith, engaged at the heading face, were probably instantly smothered. Three of the miners on the west side of the heading escaped by the intake air-way, two of those on the east side escaped by the same route after crossing the heading.

The only miner who lost his life was George Herd Hutchison, who worked on the west side ; he was swept down the heading and his body was found in the level.

David Rattray, employed at the top of the second incline, was rescued from behind a stopping on the lower heading by his brother James Rattray and James Dick, who entered the workings by the day mine.

William Forsyth, the wheeler on the short level between the headings, seems to have attempted to escape down the lower heading, by the side of which his body was found, in a refuge hole 10 yards below the point from which David Rattray was rescued. James Dick and James Rattray nearly rescued Forsyth, but were beaten back by the moss.

The remaining six miners Nos. 1 to 6 in Table II., of whom only one, John Colville, worked on the west side, took refuge in No. 3 road on the east side, where they remained until rescued. The road was dry and the air was good, and except for the terrible risk they ran of the moss not getting away but rising and engulfing them, and the want of food, they might have been in a worse situation.

James Dick and James Rattray, the roadsmen, were underground at the time of the accident, but not in the Mynheer district ; the latter came up the pit and informed his father Thomas Rattray, the oversman (who was on the surface), of the accident, and went with him to the point of subsidence. Dick went into the Mynheer level and met the moss flowing out about 50 yards from the working heading ; he came up the pit, saw Thomas Rattray and let him know the position. Thomas Rattray, having returned from the point of subsidence to the Nos. 12 and 15 Pits, saw the manager and informed him of the accident, and then about 3 p.m., along with William Hynd, pit bottomer, James Bowman McDonald, incline bottomer, and Andrew Paterson, ostler, as a rescue party, descended No. 15 Pit, and were not seen again, nor have their bodies been found up to the present time.

It is surmised that they had broken through a stopping on the Mynheer level at the foot of one of the old headings, and endeavoured to reach the workings by the old roads.

It may be that Thomas Rattray's party found the moss not much further out than Dick had reported it, and thought it safe to venture through a stopping into the old roads to the rise, and while in them the moss had travelled faster, possibly owing to the giving way of the barricade in the heading, and their retreat was cut off.

The manager having been informed of the accident, about 2.40 p.m., by Thomas Rattray, who told him that the moss was 50 yards along the level from the foot of the incline, as reported by James Dick, visited the subsidence on the surface and saw what had taken place. He returned to No. 15 pit and went down to join Rattray and his rescue party, but could find no trace of them ; he found the moss had advanced 400 or 500 yards from the foot of the incline. He returned to the surface and again visited the point of subsidence, accompanied this time by Mr. A. H. Nasmyth, and found the moss still flowing into the hole. He then went down No. 15 Pit and caused a stopping, or light dam, to be erected in front of the moss in the level, and beyond this dam, shown on Sheet I., the moss never extended, nor did it exert much pressure on it.

Some time during the afternoon two square pits, A & B, Sheet II., were started in the moss, near the edge of the subsidence, to reach the workings, and these were pushed on during the night, but were given up on the 27th owing to difficulties arising from the soft nature of the moss and the presence of water.

A third round pit, C, Sheet II., was started, and an old boiler with the ends removed brought forward to act as a tub. This third pit was soon given up.

The plans of the workings were not in the office at the time of the accident, but were in the office of Messrs. Landale, Frew and Gemmell, Mining Engineers, Glasgow, who surveyed the workings, and had the plans away for the purpose of adding the last survey, which had been completed during the past week.

A telegram was despatched and the plans arrived about 10 p.m., and next morning a survey was made, and it was found that the positions of the three rescue pits were such that they would go down on solid coal in which some distance would require to be driven before the faces were reached. A fourth pit, D, Sheet II., round in section, was started in a more favourable position, but was not proceeded with, as it was decided to attempt to enter the mine by the hole in the moss.

The position of a bore put down to test the thickness of the moss, &c., is shown on Sheet II. The borers reported the following as the result

Moss 24 feet
Sand 7 feet
Rotten rock 7 feet
Coal  1 feet

As a preliminary step to entering the hole in the moss, two wire ropes, parallel to each other, and about 6 feet apart, were stretched across the hole; and made fast at the ends. On these ropes a carriage was fitted, which was pulled backwards and forwards by other ropes, see F, G, Sheet II.

The hole was examined from this carriage about mid-day on the 27th. A few yards of the heading could be seen ; it was free from any accumulation of moss which, however, continued to flow in and disappear.

Operations were begun to roughly secure the sides of the hole by timber, and eventually the bottom of the hole or pavement of the seam was reached, and signals received from the imprisoned men.

James Dick, roadsman, Donibristle Colliery, John Jones, mining contractor Hill of Beath Colliery, and John Sheddon, miner, were in turn lowered down the heading by a rope, and five of the imprisoned men brought to the surface. While Jones and Sheddon were down the heading along with Alexander Bauld, the only man not brought up, the moss again began to flow into the hole in large quantity, the movement being no doubt helped by the weight of the large crowd, which eagerly pressed forward, and could not be kept back. The improvised shaft was wrecked, and here were some narrow escapes from being carried down the hole. An attempt was again made to get down the heading by James Richardson, of Hill of Beath Colliery, but he was unsuccessful, and Operations were suspended until the following morning, when the hole was again examined from the carriage, and found to be much increased in size, and a clear opening still available.

Two beams, 41 feet long, 12 inches broad, and 6 inches deep, were brought forward and laid in the moss across the hole, parallel to each other and 6 feet apart, and nearly at right angles to the line of the heading. Two smaller beams were laid parallel to each other and 6 feet apart, on and at right angles to the larger beams, and to each side of the square thus formed iron hangers were suspended, and barring bolted to them formed a shaft, which was carried down to the pavement of the seam, and the space between the barring and the sand and moss roughly packed with brushwood. About 2 a.m. on the 29th, Robert Law, miner, Cowdenbeath, having volunteered, was lowered down the heading at the end of a wire rope, to which, at intervals of a few feet above him, three short lengths of hemp ropes were attached, as it was thought prudent to bring up all together. Law had a hemp rope fastened to his arm, by means of which he signalled. He was successful in his journey, and the three men were brought to the surface shortly after 2 a.m.

During the course of the rescue operations at the hole in the moss, and after these were concluded, several parties explored the underground workings, in the hope of rescuing Rattray and his party, but no trace of them was found.

The distance the moss had flowed from the face of the heading to the dam erected on the level is 684 yards.

When moss ceased to enter the hole the lower part of the upper heading was examined ; it was found that only a few yards of it above the short level was filled. The upper heading down to this point was clear, but a considerable quantity of moss still remained in the faces and level roads above. The air-way within 16 yards of its junction with the lowest working level on the west side of the upper heading was choked with moss. Moss extended 56 yards up the inside Parrot mine, and the two old headings, nearer the shaft than the working heading, were filled with moss for some yards up from the level.

Mr. Gemmell stated at the inquiry that the area of the subsidence was 2.378 acres, the quantity of moss and water that had entered the mine he calculated at 21,100 cubic yards. and gave the greatest depth of the subsidence as 17½ feet.

When the hole in the moss could be thoroughly examined it was found that 13 feet 9 inches of sand mixed with gravel near the bottom (the rotten rock of the bore) lay directly on the pavement of the seam, then 3 feet of peat moss so firm that it overhung the sand for a foot or two, then came the soft moss and surface crust, together about 20 feet thick.

Comparatively little of the sand and gravel or tough moss had entered the mine; the inflow was almost entirely soft moss of about the consistency of cow dung.

When Dick probed the moss from below he may not have penetrated the tough stratum, and even if he did this bed would close as the rod was withdrawn, much the same (to use Mr. Gemmell's illustration), as a sheet of india-rubber would close after a pin was withdrawn from it, and so prevent the flow of soft moss or water.

After the accident steps were immediately taken for the recovery of the bodies. The hole in the moss was permanently secured by a wood-lined shaft, backed by concrete, and up it the bodies of Smith and Forsyth were brought to the surface. Operations were also commenced at the dam on the main level, the moss was filled into hutches and sent to the surface, and in the course of this work Hutchison's body was found. On the 11th November 415 yards of the level had been cleared of moss, as well as the inside Parrot mine and parts of the old headings.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page


A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z