Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
Index

V. Comments (cont.)

(d) On the Condition of the Peat or Moss in the Field before the Moment of Inrush

In putting forward his theory — the only theory advanced at the Inquiry — to account for the sequence of events immediately prior to and at the time of the inrush, Dr. Murray Macgregor expressed the view that the deposit of peat was not in a liquid or fluid state prior to the inrush. It was, he said, "as one would expect, firm and stable at the surface, where it was drained ; at lower depths where it was 10 or 12 feet thick the peat must have been, considering its position and this whole piece of ground, very completely water-logged, in a position that very little would turn it into a fluid or a liquid state". He also thought that, at or near the moment of inrush, with the first subsidence brought about by the fall of roof underground, the gravel, sand and silt gave way and, at that point of time, the field drains — which were running excessively full because of the record heavy rainfall of the previous day — broke, allowed a heavy flow of water into the peat which brought it over the plastic limit, made it liquid and so started the inrush.

Based on this view, Mr. Morison suggested that Regulation 29 of the Moss Regulations applies only to liquid matter and that unless it is proved that the peat was liquid matter before the moment of final disaster there was no breach of the Regulation. To use his own words: "My second point is this, that in any event it is not proved that the peat was liquid matter before the moment of final disaster and it seems plain that the regulation only applies to liquid matter. It begins: 'Where coal is being worked under moss, quicksand or other liquid matter'. . .', that is to say, implied in the Regulation is the view that moss or quicksand is liquid matter because of the word 'other' which precedes 'liquid matter' in the second line of the Regulation."

The experts called by both Mr. Moffat and Mr. Morison spoke about the nature and properties of peat. It is worthy of note that all agreed that the words ' peat 'and' moss 'were synonymous. Dr. Herd, speaking as a chemist, described how there was an ' upper plastic limit ' in soil work which meant that, provided there was a certain percentage of moisture in peat (above 72.96 per cent. in this case) it was a liquid. He gave results of analyses of samples of peat which showed that it does not readily increase its moisture content, and said that because of this he would not expect even heavy rain to increase the water content of peat in a bog. He produced figures to show that the peat taken from the sides of the cavity was above the upper plastic limit and that it would still be so even were allowances made for several times the amount of water which might have come from exceptionally heavy rain. Even large quantities of water suddenly flowing into a peat bog could not instantaneously convert dried peat into a liquid. On this point he was cross-examined by Mr. Morison :—

Q. If you assume from me there was a sufficient collapse which resulted in large quantities of water flowing into, let us assume, peat which was not liquid matter before, might that peat be converted into liquid matter?

A. Not instantaneously. The inhibition is a slow process.

Mr. Gwinner, when cross-examined by Mr. Houston, agreed that a deposit of peat is naturally wet and that it is naturally in a liquid state until it is dried or drained.

A. If it were not, no peat would have formed.

Q. So that peat does not have to be wetted in order to became liquid; it is rather the other way round, that it has to be dried in order to become solid?

A. Yes.

Dr. Macgregor, on the other hand, expressed the view that peat in its natural state was in a relatively solid or non-fluid condition and that it required an accession of water to make it fluid, In the present disaster, as already indicated, his view was that this accession of moisture came suddenly from the ruptured surface drains which turned the water-logged peat in the deposit into a liquid or fluid state. But is it necessary to presuppose that a sudden incursion of water from the ditches was necessary in this case to render the whole of the deposit liquid ? When it was put to Dr. Macgregor that the distance from the face of the heading to the western edge of the cavity or crater was about 200 feet, he agreed that the peat must have been very liquid to have drifted that distance. This edge of the crater was a considerable distance from the field drain which could have had little or no effect upon the fluidity of the peat at that particular side of the cavity. Further, the horizontal distance from the face of the heading to the ditch was about 55 feet. If we assume that the depth of the peat above the heading was 12 feet, then I think it is reasonable to conclude that any subsidence into the heading which would break as far over as 55 feet must have consisted of fluid matter and that, here again, it was not necessary to presuppose that water from the ditch was needed to liquefy the peat and cause it to flow.

In this connection, I questioned Dr. Macgregor as follows :—

Q. On this question of whether peat is liquid matter or is not liquid matter, would I be correct in saying that in your view, down to the height at which it is drained, either naturally or by artificial drains, it is not generally liquid?

A. No; that is how I read it.

Q. But if you get below the point of natural drainage or artificial drainage then clearly you are in a danger zone?

A. Definitely, yes. That is quite correct.

Both Mr. Gwinner and Dr. Macgregor agreed that the water, which ran from the holing down the heading for several days before the inrush, probably came from the gravel deposits and that it did not originate or pass through the peat deposit ; and there was little difference between them in their estimation, 13 to 14 feet, of the maximum depth of the peat in the deposit. Both also agreed that the line of the maximum depth ran very close to the line of outcrop of the Main Coal.

The degree of acidity or alkalinity of the water — known as its pH value — in the field drains on the surface and in the underground workings of the mine, both before and after the inrush, were given by Dr. Herd. These figures, which were not challenged, showed that the water in the surface ditch was acid while that in the mine was alkaline and indicated that the water in the surface ditch was not concerned in the inrush of peat to any material extent.

After careful consideration of all the relevant information and evidence on the matter, I can only conclude that the peat in the deposit at the site of the inrush before the disaster took place was relatively stable and non-fluid above the level of the field drains, which were from to 2 feet below the surface, and that, below this, it was in a fluid and dangerous condition.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page


mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z