V. Comments (cont.)
(c) On the Examination of the Surface
There was ample evidence at the Inquiry to show that, before the disaster occurred, Mr. Bone, Mr. Halliday, Mr. Mackinnon and Mr. Brown, the Agent, Manager, Assistant Sub-Area Planning Engineer and Surveyor, respectively, had walked over the surface at and in the vicinity of the place where No. 5 Heading reached the outcrop. Mr. Halliday and Mr. Bone had done so on more than one occasion before the heading reached the outcrop, and they, together with Mr. Mackinnon, had not only walked on the ground but had also "examined" it. Both Mr. Bone and Mr. Mackinnon had previous experience of working under moss. In answer to Mr. Moffat, Mr. Mackinnon said he had considerable experience of working under moss in Lanarkshire and that when he walked over the surface on the day after the No. 5 Heading reached the outcrop, moss was one of the matters to which he directed his attention. To quote his words : "Well it was the first thing that came to my mind to make sure that there was no moss or anything that we would need to take precautions against". In addition, most of them were country-men as opposed to townsmen, yet all of them contended very strongly that the surface presented the appearance of good agricultural or grazing land. None of them noticed any feature that would raise even a suspicion of danger in their minds. They based -their opinion not on "examination" of the ground alone, but also upon their knowledge of what the nature of the surface was proved to be when the new ventilation drift was set away from the surface, when a ditch was dug by a mechanical digger for a pipe-line for the pit-head baths and when a bore-hole was put down several years before to prove the existence of the coal seams. These things were approximately 310 yards, 160 yards and 500 yards distant from the point of origin of the inrush (Fig. 3). In each of these instances the material above the rock-head was said to consist of a foot or two of soil and then firm boulder clay.
Dr. C. W. Herd, a consulting chemist, and Mr. D. H. Gwinner, a consulting geologist, who appeared on behalf of the National Union of Mineworkers, visited the site five weeks after the disaster occurred. Mr. Herd was examined by Mr. Moffat :—
Q. Have you walked over the remaining portions?
A. Yes.
Q. What was your reaction?
A. Of course, the crater had collapsed at that time but I went as far back from the crater as possible in my examination and I found the ground springy and buoyant.
Q. Would this suggest to you peat or moss?
A. Not necessarily peat or moss. it would suggest that there was a particular nature of soil but I would need to make further examination of such a piece of ground before concluding that it was peat or moss.
He was cross-examined by Mr. Morison on this matter :—
Q. When you say you walked over the remaining portion of the ground, do you mean the remaining portion of the ground near the crater?
A. Yes.
Q. But you were not prepared to say whether the spring and buoyancy indicated the presence of peat?
A. No, I could not say so. I would want further investigation.
Q. Would you say it did not indicate the presence of peat?
A. I would not say it did not.
Q. And you would say it did?
A. No, I would want further investigation.
Q. Are you speaking as a scientist?
A. Yes.
Q. Have you any reason to suppose that to a layman the ground before the disaster presented the appearance of reasonably good agricultural ground?
A. It might superficially, but the grass was coarse, and there was evidence of moss in it.
Q. Aren't you speaking as a scientist and not as an ordinary man looking at the ground without special scientific knowledge?
A. Well, I am not a botanist.
Q. And you did not see the ground before the disaster?
A. No, I did not.
Q. That surely is a most material consideration, isn't it?
A. Obviously, but I did examine what was left as far as I could.
Q. I suppose that when the surface of the field was broken, as it was, by a large subsidence, different indications might form?
A. They might do, but I was very impressed by the fact of the way the remaining portion of the field did hold, and appeared as far as one could judge to hold its character. I should have expected a much bigger change.
Q. The drainage system of the field had obviously been upset, had it not?
A. Yes.
Q. And wouldn't you expect that in five weeks, depending upon rainfall, the characteristics of that field might change to a certain extent?
A. I should expect that better drainage than any before would occur. in other words, the drainage would .
Q. It would drain towards the cavity?
A. Yes.
Dr. Herd, of course, knew of the presence of peat or moss before he walked across the remaining part of the field, and whilst he agreed it was very difficult not to let such knowledge colour his views, he felt his knowledge of the fact did not influence his view that he found the ground in the vicinity of the crater springy and buoyant and that it was of an unusual character. I put some further questions to him.
Q. But would you be surprised if the pitmen, walking across this ground, did not come to the conclusion that this ground was of a very unusual character?
A. Well, I should imagine that most of those men had walked over that ground a good many times. They knew its nature, they knew, possibly subconsciously, that it was springy and buoyant, and they might not have made a comparison between that and other portions of the ground thereabouts. It was a kind of habit with them. But I think that anybody, if they gave it thought, would decide that that was different from some of the other ground over which we walked at the time of the examination.
Q. I take it really your evidence amounts to this, that in your view you do not distinguish between peat and moss?
A. No.
Q. And your view is that anyone walking across this ground would have noticed, or should have noticed, that there was something very special about it?
A. Yes.
Q. Would you say that they ought to have at the same time come to the conclusion that it was of a dangerous character?
A. Well, I find that a little difficult to answer, from the point of view of the danger, but I think that I would be prepared to say that I would know if it was different, and if I had anything to do with that field I should want to find out more about it.
Mr. Gwinner had this to say about the appearance of the ground when he was examined by Mr. Moffat.
Q. Now, there is this important question about the walking over the field that you have heard discussed. I want to put it to you as a geologist: If you had walked across the land now occupied by the crater before the subsidence occurred would it have been obvious to you that you were walking on a deposit of peat or moss?
A. No.
Q. Would you have noticed anything at all?
A. Yes, I think like the last witness, that I would have noticed that the turf was springy. During my visit to the inspection of the site I was standing near the surveyor who was taking levels with a dumpy level, and I noticed if I stepped, or anyone came very close to the instrument, which was set up on the turf, that the turf was sufficiently springy for the bubble in the dumpy level to oscillate violently from one end to the other; and the surveyor who was with me commented on that point at the time. But if I had merely walked across that field without doing anything except walking — without examining the turf or without digging a hole in it, or anything of that kind — I could not have said it was obviously peat or moss.
The field in which the subsidence occurred was on the lands of Knockshinnoch Farm, of which Mr. Andrew Wilson had been the tenant for fifteen years. He had cattle grazing in the field on the day of the disaster, as they had been all the summer. The field had never been cultivated by him. As regards the nature of the land in the field he was questioned by Mr. Moffat as follows :—
Q. As a farmer was the moss visible to you in this field?
A. Oh, yes.
Q. Did you see it quite easily?
A. Oh, yes.
Q. Could you give me any idea at what point the moss was visible in this field that you could see'?
A. Walking right across the field you could easily see the moss in the field, but it was more visible where the wettest part of the field was, that is really where the crater is. It was more visible there because there was very little grass there — more rushes.
He was further questioned by Mr. Moffat about the reason why this particular field was not cultivated and about his views on peat and moss, as follows :—
Q. Why didn't you cultivate it?
A. After I inspected the field... you will get tree stumps in it, big tree stumps, and then one part of the field was very soft. It is low-lying, and you couldn't get right drainage of that. I even tried it, the soft part, and you could get . . . You know, it was a bit of a fork shaft I had, and you could put it down into that peat with no bother, just shove it right down into the soft stuff. But it has been cultivated and ploughed, I have got to know, nearly 70 years ago.
Q. Was that quite near the crater that you have described?
A. Oh, yes, I am describing near the crater.
Q. But, so far as you are concerned, you have never cultivated that ground?
A. No. There has been part of the field cultivated in the last tenant's time, but not where the moss was.
Q. Not where this hole was?
A. No.
Q. Therefore you never had any intention of cultivating it?
A. Oh, no, it was impossible.
Q. Just one other point. Do you consider there is any difference between peat and moss?
A. Yes, there is a difference between the moss that is in yon field and peat.
Q. What difference is there?
A. Well, the moss in yon field is very brittle, and what I would term a rotten moss.
Q. That is how you would describe it?
A. Yes. The peat has more of a body in it and a fibre through it; it holds together more. You will cut peat like cheese. But yon was brittle.
Q. So in your opinion this was rotten moss?
A. That is my opinion. I would term it a rotten moss.
Dr. Murray Macgregor, formerly Assistant Director (Scotland) to the Geological Survey of Great Britain, when examined by Mr. Morison, had this to say about the appearance of the ground in the vicinity of the crater.
Q. Did you make careful investigations at the site of the subsidence at Knockshinnoch?
A. Yes.
Q. What have you to say generally as to the appearance of the ground which surrounded the crater?
A. Well, as the Court knows quite well, there was part of the old surface had disappeared into the cavity, and one of the points I tried to keep constantly in view was this fact that it was an old drained area of pasture land, and the fact of the cavity might induce some changes in the drainage, and I tried to choose situations where something of the original nature of the ground would remain on the surface. The old main drain that crossed the field from north to south had been fed by a spring on the slopes beyond, and I noticed very carefully that the water for this spring could no longer, of course, go along the main drain and was flowing just over the surface of the ground and altering its character for a considerable distance on the flat ground. I was very careful to avoid that area and to take areas which I thought generally as little affected as possible by the subsidence and the effects of the alteration of surface drainage by the subsidence.
Q. I understand you to say that because of the breaking up of the surface drainage there were areas of ground round the crater which would present an appearance which they did not present before the accident?
A. That is so.
Q. That is to say, they might appear wet?
A. Much wetter.
Q. Or more springy to the foot?
A. That is so.
Q. But, having chosen some areas which you thought had not been affected by the subsidence, how would you describe their condition?
A. I would describe the condition generally — and I would like to say that I also examined the surfaces of the large masses of slipped material that were still, the last time I was there, visible in the cavity, and the surfaces of those and of such ground as I could get access to seemed to me quite reasonably stable, firm pasture land.
Q. Did it present in your opinion, to an observer, any of the surface features that may be taken as diagnostic of a sub-strata of peat?
A. None at all.
Q. So what conclusion did you come to as a result of your examination as to the appearance which the whole of the field would present to somebody who was not a trained scientist or geologist before the subsidence occurred?
A. I think anybody of such a nature as you describe, any interested person, looking from one of the higher pieces of ground in the vicinity, and walking down the slopes of one of the little hillocks round this flat ground, crossing the flat ground and going up the other side on the other little ridge on the other side, would have no hesitation in coming to the conclusion that the whole area formed one large area of agricultural land, partly pasturage and partly arable.
Dr. Macgregor when questioned by Mr. Moffat had this to say.
Q. Now, you said in reply to a question that the land surface didn't indicate peat?
A. Oh, not me. I was saying it in reply to a question put to me as distinct from a field naturalist or a field geologist.
Q. I think you will agree with me that the original map did indicate peat?
A. Yes ; perfectly justifiably, too.
Q. And that could be ascertained by any person?
A. Yes, I quite agree with that.
Q. Being a layman would you assist me? Would it be possible for an ordinary person to observe peat or moss in the ditches?
A. Definitely.
Q. Definitely?
A. Yes.
Mr. W. R. Flett, Senior Lecturer in Geology at the Royal Technical College, Glasgow, who heard all that Dr. Macgregor had to say, agreed with his evidence in all essential details.
That, then is the evidence of the main witnesses in relation to the surface conditions before and after the disaster. Of those who had seen the field before the inrush, the only one who had no doubt whatever that there was moss in the field, and especially at and near the site of the crater left by the inrush, was the farmer. This is perhaps not surprising since an intimate knowledge of soils is part of his stock-in-trade.
From their inspections of the field, coupled with their knowledge of the ground as revealed by the borehole, the new surface drift and the pipe-line, the Manager, Agent and Assistant Planning Engineer were unanimous in sayin8 that the surface appeared to them as good agricultural or grazing land. The Group Surveyor also held this view.
As for those who walked over the ground after the inrush of moss and with full knowledge of it in their minds, Dr. Herd, a chemist but not a botanist, found the ground springy and buoyant. That, however, did not necessarily suggest to him the presence of peat and he agreed that the ground, superficially, might well appear to a layman as reasonably good agricultural ground. Mr. Gwinner, a geologist, said if he had merely walked across the field without closely examining the turf or digging a hole in it, he would not have said it was obviously peat or moss. Mr. A. H. Steele, former Divisional Inspector of Mines, thought that the ground was obviously peat or moss.
Dr. Murray Macgregor, a very experienced field geologist, thought that, to an observer who was not a field geologist or a naturalist, there were no surface features that might be taken as diagnostic of peat ; but he did agree that it would be definitely possible for an ordinary person to observe peat or moss in the ditches. He also agreed, as did Mr. Gwinner, that the condition of the neighbouring field to the north-east should have attracted the attention of a layman as a water saturated deposit and that, as it was on the same level, it should have given rise to suspicion as to the safety of the ground above the No. 5 Heading.
A field which is covered with green grass and has a surface firm enough to allow persons to walk over it and cows to graze in it without sinking into it, would probably be accepted by most laymen as evidence of ground where there was no peat or moss present and certainly as evidence of ground that was neither in a liquid nor in a fluid state. I believe most laymen think of a moss as something which is readily noticeable at a glance, as a place where one could not walk freely without danger of sinking into it.
The Manager, Agent and Planning Engineer had walked across this grassy field, had seen cows grazing in it, and had the additional knowledge that the borehole, the surface drift and the pipe-track — all of which were at no great distance from the ground above the No. 5 Heading — did not disclose any sign of peat or moss, liquid or fluid matter, in the ground at these points. Thus — and not from any examination of the nature of the ground — it seems to me, these officials came to the conclusion that there was no peat or moss present and that the field was ordinary agricultural or grazing land.
Before the inrush, of course, none of them knew that the 6-inch geological survey map for the district did, in fact, indicate the presence of peat or moss at that very place. I am of the opinion, therefore, that on the occasions when they did walk across this field they had little thought of peat or moss in their minds. The main object of their visits was to study the lie of the land rather than to look for peat or moss and, as a result, I consider that either they made no examination of the actual character of the ground or, if they did, the examination was casual and cursory. There was no evidence to show that, for example, they dug holes in the ground or probed it in any way, examined the exposures in the sides of the ditches, or had given any special consideration to the geological features of the ]and surface, as would have been necessary in any serious examination to discover the nature of the ground in the field. And they admitted they had not consulted the geological map of the district for information on this point. The simple and, I think, the true explanation of this failure to make a proper examination of the ground is that, for the reasons given in the preceding paragraph, they felt so convinced that the ground in the field could not possibly be dangerous that further examination was neither justified nor necessary.
In his submission, Mr. Morison suggested that the Moss Regulations applied only where there are visible indications of moss on the surface, where the presence of moss is known or can be ascertained from surface examination.
But to consider that generalization in its application to this case, the fact stands out that the presence of peat or moss in this area was known. It was noted by the geologists of the Survey many years ago and was indicated on the geological map : and it was well known to the farmer. I am convinced also, that if a proper surface examination had been made prior to the approach of the underground workings the presence of peat would again have been observed.