Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
Index

V. Comments (cont.)

(b) On the Relationship between the Planning Department and the Colliery Management and their Responsibilities in respect of Development Plans.

During the course of the Inquiry a great many questions were directed to discover the functions and precise relationship between the Planning Department, with its planning engineers and planners, and the Colliery Management, with its Agent and Manager, and to find out their respective responsibilities in regard to development plans prepared for the guidance of the Manager. The functions and precise relationship between the two departments were not very clearly defined and in some respects were differently regarded by some of the people concerned. In view of the importance attached to this question, I feel justified in quoting at length from the evidence given at this Inquiry.

In this connexion Mr. A. Gardner, the Sub-Area Planning Engineer at the time of the accident, when examined by Mr. Houston as to his duties, had the following to say :—

Q. As Sub-Area Planning Engineer what were your duties?

A. As far as planning was concerned, when the Agent and Manager had come to some definite development in connexion with a colliery, the planners prepared a plan and it was submitted through Mr. Mackinnon to me and I looked over it, and if I agreed with the development I took it into Mr. Stewart, who was Sub-Area Production Manager; and if we agreed on the lay-out, signatures were appended.

Q. That is, it was subject to agreement between you and Mr. Stewart, the Sub-Area Production Manager?

A. Yes.

Q. So that any projection, or any plan, which was passed was part of your responsibility?

A. Yes.

Q. If a plan was put forward with which you did not agree, what happened?

A. It was sent back to the colliery, or taken back to the colliery.

Q. By you?

A. In some cases, yes.

Q. In all cases?

A. No.

Q. Who would take it in the other cases?

A. It was passed down through to Mr. Cairns, who gave it to the planner who dealt with the colliery the plan appertained to, and he in turn told the manager and agent what we thought.

Q. So that the planner told the manager or the agent that he did not agree?

A. Not that he did not agree — that we did not agree; and he gave our recommendations to see if they fell into line with them. If they did not, their proposal was adhered to, if we could not get the sanction of the manager and agent to alter them.

Q. If you could not get the sanction of the manager and the agent?

A. To alter their line of development.

Q. What happened?

A. We adhered to the manager's and agent's proposals.

Q. If there was complete disagreement, the agent and the manager got their way?

A. Yes.

Q. I take it then that you did not insist on having your way?

A. No.

Q. Was the planner merely employed as a message-boy then?

A. No, I wouldn't say that.

Q. Could he say to the manager: "I think you would be better to do something differently" ?

A. No, he had no power to say that.

Later, Mr. Gardner said that, although disagreement was not frequent, he was not always able to go personally to see the manager on such occasions because "I had other duties to attend to and it was not always convenient". He also said he had nothing to do with the development plan prepared in April, 1950, for the No. 5 Heading Section because the tracing was never submitted to him. The reason why it was not submitted to him appeared to be that the "plan" was only a tracing in draft form. The final development plan was generally finished in cloth before it was submitted to him for approval and, if agreed, for the signatures of Mr. Stewart and himself. It does seem strange that the particular development or progress plan for the No. 5 Heading Section — which had been prepared by the Planning Department — should have been sent out to the colliery in draft form without the usual approval and signatures, and that the No. 5 Heading should have been worked to the outcrop before the Sub-Area Planning Engineer had even seen the projection.

Mr. Mackinnon, Assistant Sub-Area Planning Engineer, was also questioned on these matters by Mr. Houston.

Q. What are the functions of the Planning Department?

A. Well, the Planning Department is really there at the service of the management. If they have any ideas towards development or winning coal, then the Planning Department is at their service to put their ideas on paper and give them all the necessary information before they finally determine on their Scheme.

Q. Is it necessary that this should be done by someone other than the manager?

A. That what should be done?

Q. To project the workings?

A. No. It is really the manager and the agent who determine how it is to be done, and the Planning Engineers are just there to find all the information for them before they finally conclude on the system they are going to work.

Q. Is this information not available to the manager?

A. In many cases it is. If he cared he could look up the plans of previous workings in many cases. In other cases he could be working a virgin seam, where there is nothing to guide him.

Q. Is there anything to guide the planner in that case?

A. Oh, yes. They may have access to old plans, and they certainly have access to geological sheets.

Q. Has the colliery manager not got access to the old plans or the geological sheets?

A. If there are old plans, yes. The geological sheets — I would say No. There is generally one kept in the Planning Office.

Q. Why is the geological sheet not available to the manager?

A. It is available, but it has never been the practice, in my experience, for the manager to have the geological sheet.

Q. Surely it is a matter of some concern to him as to the geological conditions on his colliery?

A. I quite agree; but usually it has never been the practice for the manager to have a geological sheet.

Q. Then it is the duty of the Planning Department to keep the manager informed of the geological conditions?

A. No, I would say that when the planner is doing his duty of putting on paper the manager's ideas — if there is anything that he detects or knows about, you put it on the plan for the manager.

Q. So that the manager is, to a very large extent, depending on the information supplied by the planner, or on the decision come to by the planner, on information which is not available to the manager?

A. I wouldn't say that the manager is depending on any decision that the planner may come to: The planner can only give him the information which he can find.

Q. The Planning Department have no authority over the management?

A. No, that is the position.

Q. On the other hand, the manager can say: "I am having nothing to do with your planning" if he chooses to?

A. Of course, you have got to be careful when you talk about planners and planning engineers. There is a difference. If the planner submits a plan he is only submitting a plan which has been asked for by the manager. If the planning engineer comes and puts anything on that plan then the manager could differ with it.

Q. Before the manager can really differ, isn't it essential that he should have all the information that the planning engineer has?

A. Yes, definitely.

Q. So that it is the planning engineer's duty to supply him with all that information?

A. Yes.

Q. And amongst that are the geological conditions?

A. Yes.

Q. In front of him?

A. Yes.

Mr. Mackinnon was examined by Mr. Houston in regard to the development plan for the No. 5 Heading Section as follows :—

Q. We have had some evidence this morning to the effect that the development plan was not complete — it was not finished — and that was why the planning engineer was not aware of it. Is that correct?

A. The actual tracing was complete, and so far as that tracing was concerned it was made away back in April. It was made to show in block form the periods over which we got output. It was really prepared for that.

Q. Yes; but surely the actual working here in this case has been ahead of the plan, if the plan was not finished and completed?

A. Oh, the tracing was complete.

Q. Well, why was it not submitted to your superiors?

A. Well, it may have been that I have omitted to submit it to my superiors; but so far as the tracing is concerned that is actually something that is prepared for the manager, and a copy is kept in the planning department. When we speak about a plan we mean a cloth plan — not paper.

Q. But it would convey no more information, would it?

A. No.

Q. So that to all intents and purposes it is the plan. The plan was finished?

A. Yes.

In regard to this tracing or plan I questioned Mr. Mackinnon as follows :—

Q. But does that tracing, then purport to give any guidance to the manager at all as to how far he was to go with this main heading, as to where he was to stop with it, or as to what the likely cover was to be when he got to a certain point? Has it anything to do with these things at all?

A. No, practically, nothing; it has nothing to do with it — nothing more than when we fixed the last contour that is shown, the manager would stop after that.

Q. When the manager got that tracing was he told when he reached the 3,600 contour he must stop?

A. No, I wouldn't say that. What we actually agreed to was this, that we would stop short of the big fault. That was verbal.

Q. There is no indication of a big fault on that tracing. When would he know he was to stop short of it?

A. I can only say the same thing again; that is this, that the manager knew when we struck this 3,600 contour they had sufficient cover lying on the surface beds. If he wanted to go beyond that he would come back and ask us.

Q. Did somebody tell him when you reach this 3,600 contour underground, you have reached a point where you now have a certain amount of cover and you must stop?

A. Yes.

Q. Somebody told him that?

A. At the start.

Q. Who told him that?

A. Perhaps I would tell him myself. He would understand that.

Q. Can you say how much (cover) the manager was supposed to have — or (there) was supposed to be — from that 3,600 contour line?

A. We had figured it, there would be 100 feet at least.

Q. Well, how did you figure it out?

A. When this was made in April it was really rising at 1 in 4. On the geological map it shows the Diamond Coal outcropping in that area. Taking the position of the outcrop for the Diamond Coal and bringing the Main Coal exactly below it, there are 75 fathoms of difference on depth between the Diamond Coal and the Main Coal. If you take 75 fathoms vertical, continue it at 1 in 4, you will find when you strike the fault you have that cover of 100 feet.

Mr. J. H. Cairns, the Sub-Area Senior Planner, who was formerly the Chief Surveyor for Bairds and Dalmellington, Ltd., said he had four planners under his supervision — one being attached to each of the four colliery groups in the Sub-Area. The planners had a monthly meeting with the agent and manager of each colliery at which the chief matters discussed related to the prospects of maintaining the day-to-day output. Mr. Cairns said he knew that the inclination of the Main Coal Seam in No. 5 Heading Section had increased from 1 in 7 to 1 in 4 in the early part of 1950 but was unable to explain how the underground contours on the development tracing were obtained for that part of the seam ahead of the working places. He was aware that there was a very big rise fault — The Southern Upland Fault — somewhere ahead of the No. 5 Section but he did not go into that matter. He left that to his assistant. When questioned as to whether the planners took steps to see if their forecasting had been correct, he replied: "Well, I cannot tell you what actually happened at Knockshinnoch because I was not there."

Mr. R. McLean, the Assistant Sub-Area Planner for the Dunaskin Group of collieries, was questioned by Mr. Houston as follows :—

Q. What does your work involve; what are your duties?

A. Preparing plans in connection with Areas that are to be developed and showing on them the contours and known faults and any other things that are likely to interest or concern the management. These plans are submitted to the manager and agent and they decide on how they think they will work that area. I then prepare a plan showing in a more detailed form their proposals, and if that is agreed upon by the management — the manager and agent and the planning engineer and sub-area production manager — the final copies are made and signed by all concerned and used for the purpose of development of that area.

Q. Have you ever seen the geological map of the Knockshinnoch District?

A. Yes.

Q. Had you seen that there was an indication on that map showing that there was peat just to the South of Knockshinnoch Castle Colliery?

A. No, I had not.

Q. Had you looked for it?

A. No.

Q. Do you know that peat is a fairly common occurrence in this district — in Knockshinnoch and the neighbouring colliery, Bank?

A. I did know that there was peat in parts of the district.

Q. Did you mark the contours for the information of the manager and the agent in this No. 5 Section — in the area of No. 5 Section in the Main Coal?

A. Yes.

Q. What did your contours indicate?

A. They indicated that the coal would be rising at approximately 1 in 4 until the coal struck that Southern Upland Fault.

Q. When were these contours worked out

A. About April this year.

Q. And in April this year was the No. 5 Heading just rising at 1 in 4?

A. Yes, at 1 in 4.

Q. Did you get to know before the accident. that the inclination was increasing?

A. No.

So much for the views of members of the planning department. The views of the management and the chief production officers were to the effect that the planning department was there to give service to them and nothing more. The manager, Mr. Halliday, confirmed that it was customary to hold a meeting about once a month at the colliery to discuss the question of planning and the future development of the colliery, at which the agent, the planner and himself were always present and, frequently, the Assistant Sub-Area Planner and sometimes the Chief Sub-Area Planner. When asked by Mr. Houston what actually transpired at these meetings, Mr. Halliday replied: "Well, if we are interested in any area of the colliery for future development, we'll ask the planners to draw a tracing of that area showing the known faults, the contour lines and anything we think necessary to plan the work in that area." The final acceptance of any plan prepared as a result of these discussions was the responsibility of the agent and himself. No pressure was ever brought to bear on him to accept a plan. But although there was a planning department, he nevertheless seems to have spent considerable time on planning for in answer to a question he said.: "I can tell you quite frankly, I spent the whole of the Fair Holiday week when the men were idle just drawing out new plans". Mr. Halliday's evidence on this matter was confirmed by Mr. Bone, the Agent, as regards the development plan received in April for the No. 5 Heading Section. Both agreed that it indicated that the main headings would reach the approximate position of the Southern Upland Fault and that the headings would then have about 100 feet of cover to the surface. But they also agreed that very soon after April they knew, because of the steepening of the gradient, the headings were bound to reach the surface long before they got near to the fault. They also said that by noting the difference in levels of the underground workings and those of the surface they always had a very fair idea of the thickness of cover between the face of No. 5 Heading and the surface and an approximate idea as to where the face of the headings would be when they reached the outcrop. They admitted, however, they had no precise knowledge of the thickness of soil and sub-soil down to the rock-head at the outcrop, and that they had no knowledge of the actual nature or character of the intervening material.

Mr. A. M. Stewart, the Sub-Area Production Manager, was questioned by Mr. Houston, on the duties and functions of the planning department and planning engineers.

Q. What is the purpose of this Department? What are the duties of the Planning Engineers and the Planners?

A. Well, the Planning Engineer is a man with mine-management experience and he is in charge of the Planning Department as such, acts as a consultant and also controls to some degree the planned or programmed development of the collieries. He has under him the chief planner with his, in turn, planners, and we have at the moment one planner for each group. The organization starts with the planner and his visits to the colliery. As you have heard, there are meetings once per month with each manager, with the agent and the Planning Engineer in attendance as required. The manager and agent go over the developments that they have in mind and the planner, if we take some area first, his first job is to collect all the information he can get relative to that area. That is put on paper and is usually sent back to the colliery to allow the manager and mining agent to give consideration to the system of development. If this is a major development involving a fair amount of capital expenditure then an approach is made by giving the full details of the working plant that has to be put in, and that is submitted, after discussion, for approval at Area. I submit that for approval at Area. If it is a development which does not involve a great deal of capital expenditure but is something which is major in the mine, then the planning engineer will have discussed it with the mining agent, and usually I also have a discussion with the planning engineer and the agent and the manager probably too. There may be some different viewpoints arise and various opinions are expressed in an effort to get a scheme determined which is jointly acceptable to everyone concerned as being the best practice.

Q. The planning engineer is a qualified man with a colliery manager's certificate?

A. Yes.

Q. And he is in a position to differ or argue with the colliery manager. Is that right'?

A. He is in a position to argue or differ, expressing different viewpoints on how something should be tackled.

Q. In the event of a difference who has the final say?

A. I have never had this yet, but the arrangement was laid on that in the event of a difference in some matter which I had not come into, I should come in as well and try to resolve what the difference was.

Q. Would not there naturally be some reluctance on the part of the colliery manager to differ with the planning engineer if he knew that the matter would be referred to you?

A. No, because right from the start it has been made very clear that no scheme will be put into operation so far as sub-area is concerned unless the manager and the mining agent are in agreement with it.

Q. And have you told your managers and your agents that that is the state of affairs?

A. Yes.

Q. You say major schemes. Just where would you draw the line between a major scheme and another one? In particular, to save time, in what class would this No. 5 Section in the Main Coal come?

A. Taking it from where it was standing round about 1948 it would not be considered as a major scheme. It is a continuation of a working which is going without any change in system.

Q. Was it in fact brought to your notice at all?

A. No.

Mr. A. B. MacDonald, the Area Production Manager, also said the planning department was entirely a service department. In his evidence he made a distinction between a planner and a planning engineer, gave his views on the status of the planning engineers in relation to that of the manager and expressed the opinion that the planning engineer was not an "Agent" within the meaning of the Coal Mines Act, 1911. When examined by Mr. Houston, he said :—

Q. But are special arrangements in force to ensure that the manager does know that this is simply a service department, that it is in no way superior to him; it cannot give him instructions?

A. The manager knows that quite well. There can be no instructions from the planner.

Q. Have they ever actually been told that that is the state of affairs?

A. Well, I won't say it has actually been told to my knowledge but I would say it is bound to be understood.

Q. It is to be assumed that they simply know this without having been told?

A. Yes. After all, the planner is normally an experienced surveyor.

Q. Are you drawing a distinction between planners and the Planning Department?

A. No.

Q. The planning engineers, I take it, are qualified men with first-class colliery manager's certificates?

A. Yes. A planning engineer is in a different status entirely from a planner.

Q. You were using the word "planner"?

A. Yes.

Q. And I was asking you about the Planning Department?

A. Well, the planning engineer is responsible for the Planning Department.

Q. Yes, but as a qualified man it might be taken that he has authority to interfere with the working of the mine. He is a qualified colliery manager?

A. Yes.

Q. Is it made clear that the manager is the man who has to say what shall be done and not the planner — not the planning engineer?

A. The planning engineer in his duty may make a scheme for a colliery — a scheme of reorganization — but that scheme he knows and his instructions are that he must take that to the colliery manager and agent to discuss with them.

Q. Then, I take it that it is simply a matter of assumption on the part of the colliery manager that these people are not his superiors?

A. The planner is not his superior.

Q. Or the planning engineer?

A. The planning engineer may in certain cases be.

Q. He may be his superior?

A. Maybe.

Q. Surely this is a matter which is of some importance and ought to be very definitely established whether or not the planning engineer is in any circumstance superior to the manager. Is the planning engineer appointed as an agent?

A. No.

Q. Within the meaning of the law?

A. No, they don't appoint the planning engineers as agents.

Q. Are their appointments notified to the Inspector?

A. No.

Q. And if they are not notified to the Inspector then they have no authority to interfere with the manager?

A. Yes, that is correct.

Mr. MacDonald was questioned by Mr. Moffat in relation to the status of the planning engineer and the colliery agent :—

Q. Now, with regard to this question of the planning engineer and the colliery agent, outside of any regulation or anything of that kind, seeing you are Area Production Manager, will you tell me which is the highest in status . .

A. Outside the Coal Mines Act?

Q. Forget about the Coal Mines Act, because I am anxious to know who is the highest in status .

A. The planning engineer.

The planning engineers did not make any claim to superior status.

Although this evidence on the relationship between the management and the planning department was a little confusing and contradictory at times, it does, I think, indicate that there was a considerable measure of co-operation between the management, the planners and the planning engineers, and that the accepted view was that the planning department provided only a service to the management with no powers to enforce its views upon it. Nevertheless, I got the impression that this was more true in theory than in fact. It was admitted that the planning engineer for the sub-area was of higher status than the agent of a group of collieries. In such circumstances it is difficult to believe that there would not be a tendency for the agent and manager at a colliery to accept the views of the planning engineer more readily than they would otherwise have done.

But whatever the ambiguities of the organization, there was no doubt that, in relation to any development plan for a colliery, it was the job of the planning department to collect and supply to the management all available information relating to the mining and natural conditions, including all geological features likely to affect the safe working of the mine. The planning department did prepare the development plan for the No. 5 Heading Section, with its underground contours, which indicated that the workings would not reach the surface. it does seem to me that these contours were marked on the plan without much thought. After all it was known that the steeply rising workings were approaching a major upthrow fault and a glance at the levels of the existing workings would have shown that the gradient of the workings had been steepening for some time. I think a mining engineer should have anticipated that the gradient would steepen still more as it approached the fault. Had the contours been marked on the plan with these things in mind, then it is almost certain that the planner would have seen that the No. 5 Heading would reach the outcrop long before it got near the approximate position of the major fault. This might well have led him to make a closer examination of the geological sheet and to his observance of the presence of the peat deposit shown on the sheet. It is tragic to think that the geological survey map indicated the presence of peat in the area concerned and that this information was overlooked and was unknown to the colliery agent and manager. Had there been an indication of the surface peat deposit on the development plan for the No. 5 Heading Section, it would have led to a much closer inspection — or should have done so — of the surface at the place where the heading was likely to reach the surface. I cannot, therefore, agree with Mr. Morison's observation in his submission that because the management knew the exact position of the face of No. 5 Heading for a week before the accident, and knew exactly where they were in relation to the surface that, therefore, he was unable to see "what plans and planning have to do with this accident at all".

The geological survey map for the district was available at the sub-area office. It should be available at the office of the colliery manager. There are many occasions on which a thought may strike a man and if he has the necessary document to hand he will refer to it at once, whereas the thought may escape him if the opportunity has to be deferred. Because of the very valuable information which such maps contain, a copy should be provided for every colliery manager.

But although, as I have just said, there was evidence of a considerable measure of co-operation between the planning department and the management at the colliery there is no doubt that there was a lack of effective liaison between planning engineers and management and between planning engineers and surveyors. The planners seemed to think that once having planned the lay-out and got it agreed, they had no further responsibility. Thus, although, as Mr. Mackinnon said, the development plan for the No. 5 Heading Section was really prepared to show what output was expected from the Section over a given period of time, the planning department apparently saw no reason to inquire whether things were going according to plan or whether some change of conditions might necessitate a change of plan. Mr. McLean, the planner mainly concerned, attended meetings at the colliery at least once a month but does not seem to have inquired what was happening in No. 5 Section. On the other hand, it does seem odd that the management, when they realized and well knew that the main heading would reach the outcrop before reaching the fault, did not draw the attention of the planner or of the planning department to this fact. And it is perhaps even more odd that they should have been prepared to work right through to the outcrop in view of the probable effects the holing might have on the pumping capacity and the ventilation of the mine.

At one time, it was customary for the colliery surveyor to prepare plans of future underground developments for the manager. As the same surveyor was also responsible for making the quarterly surveys of the underground workings as they progressed, he was readily able to check whether any changes in underground conditions were happening which were likely to upset his projections. This useful check does not exist when the planners and mine surveyors are organized as two separate departments under which the surveyors merely make surveys of the existing workings and plot them on the working plan of the colliery, while the planners prepare the development plans and have also the duty of keeping the management informed of changes and features likely to affect future developments. There was no evidence of close liaison between surveyors and planners nor to show that development plans were checked against the working plans following each quarterly survey to note if any changes were taking place which might seriously affect the accuracy of the planning engineers projections or forecasts. If planners and surveyors must work as separate branches of the organization, the liaison between them must be close and effective.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page


mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z