VIII. Additional Comments
(a) On the Presence and Removal of the Accumulation of Firedamp in Old North 1 District
67. It was known to the management that the abandoned workings in Old North 1 District contained a substantial body of firedamp. It must also have been known that when these old workings filled with firedamp, the "make" would almost certainly find its way into the intake air current entering the working districts of the Wheatley Lime Seam. It does appear, however, that the "make" was small because, prior to the explosion, there was no history of any appreciable fouling of the intake air entering the working district, while the results of air analyses showed that the normal firedamp content of the air in the return airway from the working faces was about 0.6 per cent. Nevertheless, the position with respect to this Old North 1 District was such that it is disturbing to find that no positive steps were taken to deal with the firedamp made in the old workings: it was bounded by faults and its entrances joined the intake airway as the air entered a working district in which electricity was extensively used and shotfiring extensively practised. Either the old district should have been stowed, importing material for the purpose, if necessary, or the district should have been sealed off by efficient stoppings, or steps should have been taken to maintain the circulation of sufficient air round the old workings to prevent an accumulation of firedamp and ensure that the firedamp swept out was diluted and rendered harmless. As I said in my recent Report on the Explosion at the Whitehaven "William" Colliery, Cumberland, "a reservoir of inflammable gas anywhere in a mine is always a potential source of danger; but it becomes a lively hazard if it is near, or may react upon, a working place, or near any possible source of ignition." When it is known that a substantial accumulation of inflammable gas exists anywhere in a working mine, the matter should receive the careful consideration of the higher management, who should decide what is to be done about it and the agreed policy should be made clearly known to the under officials in charge in the area and efficient steps taken to see that the policy is carried out.
68. Where a large accumulation is known to exist and steps have to be taken to sweep it out, the operation should only be done on a well-considered plan and under the close supervision of a superior official. Clearing away a large accumulation of gas is not a simple and easy operation, and unless it is done very carefully it may easily lead to serious trouble. Clearly, such an operation should not be done during a normal working shift and the means for doing it should not be so handy that it can be applied by any junior official without the knowledge of the higher management. It should certainly not be so easy as it was in this particular instance, where for a year or more all that was necessary was to place a door on its hanging post — an operation that could be performed by anyone in a few minutes and without attracting much notice.