(b) On the Use of Lead Rivet Locks on Flame Safety Lamps
69. As I have already stated, the source of ignition in this explosion was the operation of the relighting device, which was probably considered by the operator not to be functioning properly, of a flame safety lamp after the lamp had been taken apart by the cutting of the lead rivet by which the lamp was locked. It may be recalled that an exactly similar action was believed to be the source of ignition in the Explosion at the Harrington No. 10 Colliery, Cumberland. on the 9th December, 1946 (Report Cmd. 7222). Because of the ease with which a flame safety lamp locked by a lead rivet can be opened, the question of the prohibition of this type of lock is worthy of careful consideration. There is no doubt whatever that a lamp secured by a lead rivet is much easier to open than one secured by a magnetic lock, although it is not unknown for even a magnetically locked lamp to be opened illegally underground. On the other hand, if the lead rivet is properly squeezed by a rivetting device which leaves a distinctive mark, and if the lamps are properly examined, as they should be, when they are returned to the lamproom the chance of the offender being detected is much greater with the lead rivet than the magnetic lock. But I am afraid these safeguards, without which the lead rivet is hardly a lock at all, are by no means always taken — and even if they were it must not be forgotten that there are circumstances in a mine when the temptation to open a flame safety lamp is very strong, even at some risk of subsequent detection. When a flame lamp has been extinguished or the relighting device is not functioning satisfactorily, to have the lamp relit or to secure another lamp may mean in certain circumstances travelling a long distance outbye, or a long wait for another lamp to be brought from the surface that may seem to the person concerned a waste of valuable time, more especially in an emergency when he may be in difficulty or danger. Human nature being what it is, the easier it is to do a thing one is tempted to do, the more likely is one to succumb to the temptation. There is, therefore, some justification for the prohibition of the lead rivet lock. In present circumstances, with all the difficulties of supply, I do not, however, feel justified in recommending its prohibition forthwith, but I do suggest that the policy in this matter should be to eliminate the lead rivet lock and replace it by an efficient magnetic lock, as circumstances permit, and that the changeover should be effected in all cases where existing flame safety lamps, fitted with a lead rivet type of lock, are due for substantial reconditioning or complete replacement.