VI. Observations On The Course Of The Explosion
56. As we have seen, evidence of the passage of flame in various places was given by Mr. Rees, Dr. Tideswell, Dr. Willett and others, Dr. Tideswell's conclusions being aided by his examination of samples of dust and other materials under the microscope. It is clear that flame had been present on the South 2 face and in most of the intake and return airways to that face, including at least South 3 on the intake and the 1 in 7 Drift on the Evison Bord outbye the meeting station in the return haulage road. In the intake, flame did not travel far, if at all, outbye South 3. In the return, outbye the 1 in 7 drift in the Evison Bord, coked dust and charred ends of string provided evidence. that flame had actually travelled to within 200 yards of the junction with the South Ending. The evidence of Dr. Sutherland that the bodies of the victims found in the 1 in 7 Drift were burnt and that death had been immediate or almost immediate strongly confirms the presence of flame in the drift. But the fact that he did not find burns on the four bodies recovered at the outbye end of the drift may be thought to throw some doubt on the presence of flame there. It is possible, however, that these men may have been partly buried by a fall caused by the "pioneering wave" of the explosion before flame reached them, or that the flame had missed the exposed parts of their bodies in some way as, for example, by flame passing above them as they lay flat on the floor.
57. Taking the source of the ignition as the opened lamp at the meeting station on the Evison Bord — and no one was able to suggest any other point of ignition — I visualise the course of the explosion as follows
| | (a) |
First, flame travelled in both directions along the Evison Bord, the outbye flame travelling not only with its own natural speed, but being forced in addition by the blast of air projected backwards from the flame advancing towards the dead-end provided by the several coal faces inbye.
|
| | (b) |
Flame was projected immediately after the ignition a short way down both gates of Old South 1.
|
| | (c) |
The doors and stopping in the two slits between the intake and return, and opposite the two gates of Old South 1, were blown when the pressure on them became great enough. This was not necessarily while the flame was still in that vicinity but may have been a second or so later during the passage of the flame farther inbye. The door which was hung in the intake to divert the air into Old North 1 was destroyed when the blast first entered the intake airway through the outbye slit.
|
| | (d) |
The flame penetrated into South 3 by blowing the brattice sheets and doors in the Evison Bord between South 2 Conveyor Gate and South 3 face, and into South 2 face along the South 2 Conveyor Gate. In its passage along the South 2 Gate, the flame branched into the Gledhill Crossgate and travelled along South 2 intake tail gate to South 2 face.
|
| | (e) |
Part or all of South 2 face was traversed by flame which came from either the Conveyor Gate or the intake tail gate or from both.
|
| | (f) |
Flame from South 3 travelled outbye along the intake and died out somewhere near the junctions of the entrances to Old North 2. It did not travel further outbye along the intake, either because insufficient inflammable gas was by that time coming from old North 1, or because the atmosphere coming from it contained such a high percentage of firedamp that, even after dilution with whatever air was mingling with it on the main road, there was more than 14 per cent, of firedamp present and the air was therefore non-inflammable.
|
58. The evidence that can be derived from the "lines of force" of an explosion has been valuable on many occasions as an indication of the direction of travel of the explosion. Despite the fact that careful records of all such signs had been made in this case by various witnesses to the inquiry, nevertheless their significance was ambiguous. Dr. Willett argued that the "lines of force" radiated from the vicinity of the transfer point on South 2 Conveyor Gate. and not from the meeting station on the Evison Bord. This led him to suspect the former as the starting point of the explosion, but he was unable to point to any possible source of ignition there, or indeed, anywhere else than the opened lamp at the meeting station. On the other hand Mr. E. S. Rees considered the evidence of direction of force was consistent with the explosion starting at the meeting station.