(b) Accumulation of Firedamp
38. There were among the witnesses two conflicting schools of thought as to how there came to be in the workings an accumulation of firedamp at explosive point. The evidence is wholly circumstantial, but before I examine this in detail it is important that it should be realised that any explanation to be true must be consistent with the following facts
| | (i) |
The accumulation of gas was large.
|
| | (ii) |
It was brought about quickly, certainly in less than an hour, and most likely in about half an hour.
|
| | (iii) |
It was present at explosive point in the general body of the air current of the order of 15,000 cubic feet per minute, passing the meeting station when the relighter of the open flame lamp was operated there and started the explosion.
|
39. There was no suggestion at all that the seam was liable to outbursts of firedamp and no evidence of any such disturbance of the strata, e.g. in the wastes, as might have forced any large body of firedamp suddenly into the air current. The only considerable body of firedamp known to exist in the whole of the area concerned was a large accumulation in the Old North 1 District (see Plan No. 2), which finished in December, 1945. The one school of thought associated the explosion with this accumulation of firedamp: the other school with firedamp not known before the explosion but suspected afterwards to have bled oft very freely from the fault which formed the boundary of the South 2 District on the right-hand side up to the time of the ignition of firedamp which occurred there in June, 1947. I am in general agreement with the first school of thought and shall now examine the evidence and give my considered reasons.