III. The Explosion And Events Leading Up To It
15. The explosion occurred in the No. 2 South District of the Wheatley Lime Seam on Tuesday, 9th September, 1947, at 11.15 p.m. during the first hour of the night shift. The number of persons normally employed during the 24 hours in this district was 105 but, owing to a wages dispute, the No. 2 South Face had not been filled off since the previous Friday and, in consequence, the normal sequence of work was interrupted.
16. On the day shift of the 9th September, men other than the usual colliers were employed filling coal oft the face and boring shot-holes in the coal as the filling proceeded. At the end of the shift, however, there were 30 to 40 yards of face still to fill off. Other workmen were employed in enlarging the intake airway near to, and on the outbye side of, the Gledhill Crossgate (see Plan No. 2), and one man was attending the pump in the intake tail gate. Apart from a broken belt, which was repaired, in the outbye conveyor in the South 2 Conveyor Gate, the shift was uneventful.
17. On the afternoon shift, five men were at work erecting bars at the face of the South 2 Conveyor Gate and one man was again attending the pump. Seven others were engaged enlarging the intake at a point near Old North 2 District, The deputy on this shift said he made tests with his flame safety lamp for firedamp at numerous points in the district but found none. He ascended the shaft at 10.30 p.m. with the five men who had been working in the South 2 Conveyor Gate, leaving the district, so far as he knew, in perfectly normal condition and certainly not anticipating danger of any kind, let alone the disaster which was to follow so soon afterwards. The remainder of the men on the shift had left the mine about an hour before the deputy.
18. The night-shift for the South 2 District consisted of 13 persons, 12 of whom perished in the explosion. The one survivor, Jesse Clarke, a shot-firer, was discharged from hospital on 5th November, 1947, apparently fit and unharmed, apart from the scars of bums, but unfortunately suffering from a loss of memory and quite unable to remember anything of the events of the tragic night. Had he been able to recall what happened, he would have been a most valuable witness and would undoubtedly have shed light on many points which arose at the Inquiry when various witnesses were endeavouring to explain the course of events that night.
19. The night-shift deputy, F. W. Pearson, two shot-firers, Bernard Hewitt and Jesse Clarke, and two beltmen, Arthur Wilson and Clifford Howarth, descended the mine at 10 p.m. This was half-an-hour before the normal time for the descent of the night-shift proper. At 10.5 p.m., before proceeding inbye, Pearson consulted with his opposite number on the afternoon shift. About 10.15 p.m. workmen on the afternoon shift, while on their way outbye from the No. 2 South District, met Pearson and his men at the outbye end of the Evison Bord on their way inbye to work. The beltmen, Wilson and Howarth, had been instructed to run the conveyor belts and, after the explosion, their bodies were found in the position they would have occupied had they been performing this task. The switch in the switch-box controlling the conveyor motor was found in the "on" position but a pilot switch alongside one of the dead men was in the "off" position. It is possible that the men may have had time to open the pilot switch. On the other hand, the conveyor may not have been started up. What exactly happened will never be known, but, in my opinion, the question is not material.
20. The dead bodies of deputy Pearson and shot-firer Hewitt, and the unconscious Clarke, were found after the explosion at the deputies' meeting station near the top of the return drift. The time required to walk from the shaft bottom to the meeting station was 25 to 30 minutes so that these three officials may have arrived there about 10.30 or 10.35 p.m. Their movements after arrival are a matter of deduction and to some extent of surmise. It is unfortunate that this is so, since these movements are vital to the correct explanation of what happened on the night of this explosion. It is known, however, that deputy Pearson telephoned from the meeting station to the night onsetter, Herbert Collomosse, in the shaft bottom at a time which Collomosse put at 10.50 p.m. It was an inquiry as to the number of persons on the regular night-shift, which descended the shaft at 10.30 p.m., and who were coming to work in the No. 2 South District in the Wheatley Lime Seam. The conversation, however, extended to general topics and did not conclude until 11.5 p.m. Collomosse said Pearson sounded very cheery and certainly not like a man who had any thought of impending danger. Immediately after his talk with Pearson, Collomosse received a telephone call from a deputy in another district who also inquired about the number of night-shift men likely to proceed to his district. This conversation finished about 11.10 p.m.
21. What followed soon after that is best described in the words Collomosse used at the Inquiry. "Well, at 11.15 p.m., there was a thud. That was the time it happened as far as I can say. I went out of the office and looked round the pit bottom, and I could see there was something unusual had happened. There were clouds of smoke and things coming into the pit bottom which should not have been." After unsuccessfully trying to get into communication with the inbye districts, he then telephoned to the surface to raise the alarm.
22. Four night-shift byeworkers were travelling the South Ending when the explosion occurred. They had reached a point about 350 yards from the upcast shaft, where two doors led into an intake airway along which they customarily travelled to their work in the Beeston Seam. One of these byeworkers in giving evidence at the Inquiry said he saw "a terrible flash" and heard a report, and he was thrown a distance of 5 or 6 yards. He described how the air became so thick with smoke and dust that he could not see his hand before him as he stood upright. It was very hot but it was clearer and cooler near the floor. After that, he and his mates pulled themselves together and assisted each other through the doors into the intake where the air seemed to be stagnant but quite clear. They then travelled outbye along the intake and through the separation doors to No. 2 Shaft. A deputy, who was at West Bord 3 in the Beeston Seam intake 480 yards inbye from the junction of the Evison Bord with the South Ending, said that at the time of the explosion he noticed a "swell of dust" which blew open separation doors between the intake and return. This deputy also stated that he parted from deputy Pearson and his two shotfirers at the junction of the Evison Bord at 10.15 p.m., as they proceeded on their respective ways, thus establishing the time when Pearson and his mates left the junction of the Evison Bord with the South Ending.
23. The night-shift proper for No. 2 South District in the Wheatley Lime Seam descended the shaft about 10.30 p.m. and consisted of eight persons. They were still on their way inbye and were travelling up the 1 in 7 Drift, but had not reached the meeting station, when the explosion occurred. They met its full violence and were all instantly killed by it. This brought the toll of the explosion to twelve killed and one injured.