Comments
On The Cause Of The Explosion And Its Development
41. There is no mystery as to the cause of this explosion. It was entirely one of firedamp. The question as to whether or not coal dust played a part does not arise in a shale mine. The firedamp was, in fact, seen to be ignited at the acetylene cap lamp of Thomas Reid. The working place was about 9 ft. high and with Reid standing his full height, it is clear that a layer of gas was inflammable at a height of not less than 3 ft. from the roof. It is probable that at the point of ignition the firedamp-air mixture was just a little below the upper limit of inflammability. Again, judging by the lack of violence and the fact that neither Reid nor Todd was burned, it was probably little more than a "trail" of gas of similar composition until the flame reached the fringe of the larger accumulation in the waste when it produced what seemed, in effect, to be a second explosion. Because the inflammable mixture was now more extensive, rather than more explosive, the report of this second explosion was louder and produced greater physical effects, as is shown by the fact that Todd and Reid were blown off their feet, while McGarty, in the place lower down, was knocked off his balance (as a result of the blast) and fatally injured, probably by his head violently striking a rigid, sharp object such as shale on the side of the roadway.
42. The initial explosion must have been relatively small, as none of the three men in its immediate vicinity was burned. The second and larger explosion seems to have extended over a wider area mainly confined to the waste or waste edge. It is highly probable that this was followed by a series of relatively light explosions or "pops" around the waste edge, due to the expansion of gases during the explosions and subsequent contraction, which would result in constituting a series of weakly inflammable mixtures. The evidence points to relatively slow burning as distinct from sharp explosive mixtures and suggests that flame persisted for some time, otherwise it is difficult to account for the more or less simultaneous occurrence of the subsequent fires in several places adjacent to the edge of the waste.