Comments
On The Occurrence Of Inflammable Gas (Firedamp)
37. As already indicated, although the mine was relatively free from inflammable gas, the presence of gas was not unknown and certain precautions were taken to safeguard against danger from it. An examination of the records shows that firedamp had been reported on 11 occasions during the year 1946. In all cases the gas was found in small quantity and in nearly every case at the face of rise headings in the solid or "whole" workings. It was readily cleared in a few minutes by the ventilation, following the erection or extension of brattice. Contrary to what one might have expected, inflammable gas has never been detected in any of the stooping places or at the edge of the adjoining goaf or waste.
38. Firedamp is given off to some extent in almost every mine, and because of this, Section 29 of the Coal Mines Act, 1911 (which applies to Oil Shale Mines), contains stringent requirements regarding the amount of ventilation to be provided. In this case there was no evidence of the ventilation, prior to the explosion, having been at any time inadequate within the meaning of this Section.
39. It is obvious, however, that when the initial explosion occurred, there must have been an accumulation of inflammable gas in the unventilated and inaccessible waste, which covered an area of about three acres adjoining the stooping places. There maybe difference of opinion as to where this gas came from but the point is relatively unimportant. It may have come up through breaks in the five fathoms of strata between the seam being worked and a seam below, about 2 ft. thick, which had been proved by bore hole. There is, however, no need to postulate such an origin, as the firedamp may easily have been given off steadily over a relatively long period of time by small feeders from the Dunnet Seam itself or from the strata immediately associated with it.
40. This accumulation of firedamp, whatever its origin, was normally in the higher cavities within the waste area, but its presence was not detected at the waste edge. So long as it was thus confined, the gas would not present any danger. How, then, did it come to be expelled and thus create a danger? Firedamp in quantity can exude from a waste when there is a fall in barometric pressure or it can be forced out suddenly by roof movements in the waste and particularly by a heavy fall. Whilst there was a falling barometer at the time, I think in this case the gas was suddenly expelled by a heavy fall in the waste shortly before the initial explosion. There was evidence of crush in James Todd's working place before the mealtime interval on the afternoon of the explosion and evidence of excessive crush after the meal-time when Todd and Reid returned to work. In other words, the conditions at the time were such as were likely to lead to falls in the waste. That the gas must have been expelled quickly is apparent, from the evidence that a naked light was used within a few minutes of the explosion at the face of the split near the waste edge immediately above and to the rise side of James Todd's working place. I conclude, therefore, that the inflammable gas present in Todd's place when Reid and Todd returned to work after meal-time, about 8 p.m. on the night of the explosion, was part of a larger body of gas expelled from the waste by a fall which occurred in the waste towards the end of the meal-time interval.