Comments
On The Development Of The Fires
43. The occurrence of the fires presents unusual features. There seems little doubt that in this case flame had continued long enough or recurred frequently enough to ignite dry timbers at the waste edge and that the pieces of burning timber ignited fallen shale. The roadways were not heavily timbered but the roadway containing most timber was probably the first upset from No. 10 to No, 11 Levels on the inbye side of No. 2 Dook. It will be remembered that it was here the largest tire occurred. This fire probably originated at the waste edge but by the time it was discovered all the timber in this roadway had probably been burned, thus allowing the 3 ft. of oil shale which formed the immediate roof to fall. There was evidence to show that this roof shale had collapsed in thin slabs which stood on edge and thus presented easier conditions for being set alight. In one part of this roadway near the junction with No. 11 Level, which had to be recovered to allow of rescue operations, no less than 160 cubic yards of shale were burned to ash and the adjacent sides of the solid shale pillars had been set alight.
44. Fortunately, the provision of fire-fighting materials and appliances and the arrangements for using these effectively, as required by the Coal Mines General Regulations of 8th August, 1938, were made, while it is apparent from the evidence that effective arrangements had been made to ensure the assistance not only of the general fire-fighting services of Scottish Oils Ltd., but also to ensure the assistance and services of the National Fire Service organization. Nevertheless there is room for a first-class common fire-fighting service for mines of all classes, whether operated by the National Coal Board or not, based on or co-ordinated with the Mines Rescue Service. I should add also that events in this disaster emphasized the need for an efficient mobile scientific service for the prompt analysis of samples of mine atmospheres and the interpretation of the results of analyses — particularly where fires have developed — during the actual progress of rescue and recovery operations. This scientific service should also be based on or co-ordinated with the Mines Rescue Service.