Comments
On The Practice Of Stooping In The Centre Of A Ventilating District
34. It was suggested at the Inquiry by Mr. Nellies, representing the National Union of Shale Miners and Oil Workers, that it was not in accordance with good mining practice to commence stooping in the middle of a ventilating district and that steps should be taken to avoid it in future. Accordingly, during the course of the Inquiry, Mr. Nellies, quite rightly, closely examined several of the witnesses on the official and management side on this point. It will be seen from Plan No. 1 that the air current in the ventilation split concerned, first traversed some "whole" workings, then coursed the workings in the stooping section and thereafter ventilated the working places in the narrow workings to the east of No. 3 Dook — the section where the men were trapped — before finally passing to the return airway. It is highly probable that in the circumstances of this particular case the death roll would have been confined to one person, McGarty, had the stooping section been at the return end of the district.
35. Although it is more or less the general practice, both in oil shale and coal mining, to commence stooping at the return end of a ventilation split, the stooping of areas otherwise than at the return end is by no means rare or even unusual in the long history of oil shale mining, nor indeed of coal mining. For example, it is normal practice in some coal mines and especially in mines relatively free from inflammable gas, to extract pillars in one panel simultaneously with the opening out inbye of the next panel to be stooped. It so happens that in this Burngrange case, the stooping would almost certainly have been at the return end of the ventilation split had it not been considered necessary, for the purposes of support of property on the surface, to leave small pillars in the area on the return side of the stooping section. After all, Burngrange was a mine considered to be relatively free from inflammable gas, where naked lights were in use, and where prior to this explosion, there was nothing, in my opinion, which would lead the management or anyone else to anticipate any special or increased danger from the method of working or the system of ventilation in use at the time of the disaster.
36. The occurrence does, however, clearly indicate the greater possibility of a major explosion in workings alongside a goaf area compared with "whole" or pillar workings which, in the physical conditions obtaining at Burngrange, normally remain open and accessible for the purposes of examination and ventilation. The suggestion was made that the practice of stooping in the centre of a ventilation split should be prohibited by law, but I am unable to subscribe to this view because of the variation in circumstances, and I am in agreement with the views expressed in evidence by Mr. J. Stein, the Agent, under examination by Mr. Nellies and Mr. Crichton
Examination by Mr. Nellies
Q. Now that the dangers have presented themselves you will agree that there ought to be some modification or supplementation of the Regulations covering stooping in such circumstances?
A. All future stooping has got to receive special consideration in the light of what has happened here.
Examination by Mr. Crichton
Q. I don't think you can lay down any special regulations in connexion with stooping? I am afraid that every section would need to be considered on its merits?
A. Yes.
Q. And I don't think that, due to this occurrence, you can lay down any hard and fast rule?
A. That is what I think.
Q. And when this plan was arranged for — when we agreed to start stooping here — I think we were all quite satisfied that it was perfectly safe, or it would never have been started?
A. That is so.
Q. And therefore the matter could not possibly receive more consideration than in any other stooping area?
A. That is so.