Comments
On The First Warning Of The Explosion And The Failure To Appreciate Its Significance
30. The explosion occurred about 8 p.m. and the first message concerning it was telephoned to the surface about 8.20 p.m. The winding engineman who received it transmitted it at once to the manager, who was then discussing mine business with the overman, David Brown. The message was that "a doctor and an ambulance were wanted for McGarty, and that there had been an explosion". The manager's immediate reactions, in his own words, were :—
"I gave the message thought and I considered the word 'explosion' was wrong. I could not conceive of an explosion in McGarty's place, but I could conceive of a severe fall of roof giving a report like an explosion. On the other hand, had the word 'explosion' been right, I could not conceive of a big explosion being there".
31. It is clear that the manager, from his long experience in oil-shale mining, thought that there might possibly have been a small ignition of gas but thought it more likely that there had been a heavy fall of roof. He certainly could not, at the time, bring himself to believe that an explosion of a serious nature had occurred. And in this view he was not alone. Consequently, it never occurred to him or to the overman, to call for the services of the Mines Rescue Station. He did, however, send for the doctor before he and the overman went down the mine to investigate what had happened.
32. The significant point is that, had the manager realized there had been a serious explosion, he would have called for the services of the Mines Rescue Station at least one hour and ten minutes earlier than he, in fact, did, and the question arises as to whether lives would have been saved had the trained brigades been in action 70 minutes sooner than they were. This means that the first fully equipped team, wearing sell-contained breathing apparatus, would have left the fresh-air base at 10.5 p.m. and been at the top of No. 3 Dook or its vicinity about 10.15 p.m. By this time, the overman, Brown, had already made at least three, if not four, unsuccessful attempts to reach the men. On his first attempt at about 8.40 p.m. he was affected by the smoke and had to retire "for a breather". The conditions got worse as time went on. After careful consideration of all the circumstances, I am of the opinion that, had the rescue brigades been on the scene even at 10 p.m. they would still have been too late to rescue any of the trapped men alive, and I must conclude, therefore, that the initial failure by the manager to realize the full significance of the first warning did not affect the loss of life involved in this disaster.
33. Although I can understand the reason why the manager, as well as many others, had difficulty in believing the message to be true, nevertheless I consider that, if there is any doubt at all, it is better to err on the safe side. To have called for the services of the Rescue Station could have done no harm. As Mr. T. A. Rogers said at the Inquiry, in reply to a question put by me: "It is far better to send for a Rescue Brigade a dozen times and not use it than not to send once when it is really needed".