Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
Index

Coal Dust And Watering.

The seam in which the explosion took place produced a fair quantity of coal dust in working which was augmented in those districts where the coal cutters were used and the conveyor. Much dust was deposited on the roadways by these means in addition to the ordinary dust incident to the haulage.

Mr. Tonge said of the conveyor, "Just at the time when the conveyor was delivering into tubs it was very dusty. It was uncomfortably dusty, if you stood in it. If you stood on the return side of the conveyor it was dusty, but immediately you stood away, within a foot of the delivery, on the higher side of the conveyor, it was quite clean and comfortable. I mention that to show it did not spread all round about. It went away with the wind very quickly. I do not think it would be noticeable by the time it got down to the cable level. I do not remember meeting a cloud of dust, as it were, any where lower than the cable level." And of the coal cutter on another face where a conveyor was not used he said, "The cutter face was, I should say, equally dusty. I would not differentiate as between the one or the other (meaning as between the conveyor and the cutter). The dust in both cases was fine, and would be almost pure coal dust. There would be about 10 or 12 per cent. of ash in the coal. It was dirty coal."

Precautions. — As to the steps taken to deal with the danger in case of an explosion arising from presence of fine dry coal dust in the roadways the following account was given by Mr. Tonge to Mr. Redmayne :-Q. "What sort of means did you take to clear it out ? — We filled it into the tubs and sent it out of the pit."

"Did you brush it up ? — No."

"Just shovelled it up ? — Just shovelled it up. We disturbed it as little as we could, and put it into the tubs and sent it out."

"But that adhering to the sides and the tops of the baulks you did not touch ? — No, we did not touch that."

"That would be the finest and the purest dust ? — Yes, it would. But wherever we had electricity, wherever we had the electric cables, once a week we had the whole of the cables brushed, which included just the side of the road where they were hanging."

"And just in the immediate vicinity of the cables would be practically dust free ? — That was so."

"But the sides and the tops of the baulks, they would be dusty ? — Yes, they would." "Then had you water mains laid along your haulage roads ? — Yes, we had water mains along all the main haulage roads"

Mr. Tonge described the position of the water mains which went to show that they extended from the shafts to a considerable distance inbye, but left some 200 yards, more or less according to the district, unwatered, e.g., in the North Plodder district. the pipes extended not quite to Rowland's Tunnel.

Mr. Tonge frankly admitted to Mr. Redmayne (Q. 737) that he did not think the same means that they took near the pit would be sufficient to act as a zone inbye, i.e., the roads were not sufficiently well watered to create a safety zone against explosions. He agreed that even more radical measures than they took were necessary to secure a safe zone if they only knew what they were.

The watering was done twice a week as a minimum, but the evidence of one of the firemen went to show that the temperature and the circulation of the air quickly evaporated the moisture.

In addition to watering they had commenced the use of chloride of calcium, a deliquescent salt, in the shunts and in places where fire was a possibility, but Mr. Tonge was not greatly enamoured of it except more for the prevention of fire, as he thought it took the moisture out of the air and left one with drier air and dust.

The influence of coal dust in the explosion. — It was the unanimous opinion of all the experts that coal dust bad been the dominant factor in the devastation caused by this explosion.

Sir Henry Hall, in answer to Mr. Ellis, said, "If fire-damp alone had been implicated, the explosion would certainly have ended when it reached the shaft and only the district where it originated would have been affected instead of the whole mine." And in answer to the question from Mr. Ellis, "I gather that you think that coal dust has formed an important feature in this explosion." Sir Henry said, "Oh yes, it is to the coal dust that all the loss of life is due, there is no doubt."

Later in my cross-examination recalling these answers to Sir Henry Hall, he said, "Well, one would not say all the loss of life, but all the loss of life outside the particular district where the explosion originated."

I then replied, "Yes, I accepted it with the qualification, but it does raise a very serious question as to the measure of responsibility upon managers, where men, far removed from the originating point of an explosion, may lose their lives owing to the failure to meet the dangers of or to render harmless the coal dust in the mine ? — Oh yes, of course it brings a tremendous responsibility upon the managers and owners of collieries; there is no doubt,-the fact that from such a small beginning the disaster will spread through the colliery."

"Well, it is the coal dust which has enabled the small beginning to propagate itself into a vast explosion ? — That is so, yes."

"And, in effect, therefore, the presence of the coal dust has brought about the death of men far removed from the original point of ignition ? — Yes, undoubtedly."

"Now, you have considerable acquaintance with mining in Lancashire ? — Yes."

"Do you find that fine dry dust in mines is common in Lancashire ? — Yes, quite common."

"Do you find that managers are alive to the dangers arising from fine dry dust ? — I do not think, in Lancashire, they have taken steps to alleviate the danger of the dust directly, but they have always selected the best explosives, what they considered to be the best and safest explosives, to be used."

"That is to say, they put their trust in the explosive, and rest their precautions there ? — Yes, I think they have, to some extent."

"So far as the presence of coal dust was concerned in this pit, it would not differ, therefore, from many other pits in the Lancashire district ? — No, I think it is on all fours with many other of the mines."

"And no greater blame could be placed upon the management here than could be placed upon the management of many other pits in the Lancashire field ? — No, the position is entirely the same. Of course there is no Government regulation specially requiring them to treat the dust in any particular way, either here or in the other collieries."

"That is what I wanted to ask. Has science yet determined what is the right or even the most effective method of treating coal dust in the varying circumstances found in daily practice ? — No, not yet, but I think we shall soon know the best course to adopt, but up to the present there is nothing definite which has been discovered, nothing that would be practicable, that is the difficulty. Up to the present we know of no method that would prevent these coal dust explosions except keeping the mine entirely free from coal dust, but how that is to be done remains to be proved. The nearer that you approach to rendering the mine dustless I think the mine will be so much the safer, but at present the majority of experts think that it is impracticable to keep the mine clear of dust."

It is probably correct that in a coal mine which produces a fair quantity of fine dry coal dust, perfectly dustless roads will not easily be obtained, but that much remains to be attempted in this direction is beyond contradiction. When the responsibility is universal, in those cases where it is required, to -give serious attention to the coal dust problem, a greater success may be achieved than many seem willing to admit the possibility of at present. Experiments on a very considerable scale have been and are being carried out, not only in this country but abroad, and much valuable information has been obtained.

There is certainly ground for believing that ways of circumventing-at least of circumscribing-these extensive and disastrous coal-dust explosions will shortly be discovered which can be regarded as of general and practicable application.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page


A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z