Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
Index

Electricity.

The Conveyor Electric Switch. — An endeavour was made by the representatives of the Miners' Federation to trace the inception of this explosion to the sparking of the electric switch which controlled the conveyor in the North Plodder, and considerable time was occupied in investigating the condition of things at the top of Number 1 jig in the North Plodder on the day immediately preceding the explosion, and in examining and experimenting with the switch.

That the introduction of electricity does import possible additional danger into coal working because of the risk of improper apparatus being used or of laxity in supervision, cannot be doubted, and there was some indication of the existence of a feeling antagonistic to its employment in the getting and conveying of coal. With reference to the Electric Switch the evidence was of two kinds-that of witnesses who professed to have seen the switch spark, and that of the experts.

The evidence of the "eye witnesses" had reference to two occasions only, viz., the Thursday before the explosion, and a fortnight before the explosion, i.e., the 15th and the 6th December respectively.

The witness as to the 15th December had only come into the pit the day before, he had never worked at a coal-cutter previously, and "it was the first switch he had ever worked against or seen in a pit." He stated that he had come off the conveyor face to get a drink and was in the roadway about four yards from the switch, which was on the opposite side of the road. Whilst he was there the signal was given to start the conveyor when he "saw a dull red spark just as it was falling from the switch." "He thought he saw two or three."

"Mr. Rushton, the undermanager, at that moment came up the brow-he was five or six yards down-and saw the sparks when I saw them. He could see them, the sparks blew towards him. He said, "I must stop this. We are going to be blown up.

The witness saw the conveyor stopped, and it did not spark when the current was turned off. He had seen the conveyor switch used to move the conveyor many times and had never seen it spark but that once.

The witness was very certain about the sparks. In answer to Mr. Gerrard's question, "What were the sparks like ?" he said, "Ordinary sparks ; that is as near as I can tell you."

Q. "Was it a flash ? — No, not exactly a flash."

Q. "You say it was a spark ? — Yes."

In order that there might be no misunderstanding I asked him-"Was the impression you got that you saw sparks or saw the light from things which might have been sparks ? Did you see sparks come out of the box ? — Yes, from the direction of the box."

Q. "Then it was sparks you saw and not a light or a reflection of a light ? — No."

Q. "You know the difference between seeing a spark and seeing a light shine up in a box ? — Yes."

Q. "It was sparks you saw ? — Yes, Sir."

Without laying too much stress upon this description of the alleged sparking it is remarkable that the conveyor was started to work again on the Monday without Mr. Bull, who was the responsible Electrical Engineer, having the matter reported to him, and without his being called upon by Mr. Rushton to do anything to the switch. So far as could be ascertained nothing was done to the switch.

The same witness, however, worked there on the Monday, and so far as he could say, there was no sparking then.

The witness as to the 6th December, describing what he saw, said: "When they started the conveyor I saw the sparkle. I did not see it when he stopped the conveyor, how should I. They were not like sparks in a smithy, I know what electric light is. It was a little bit of a flash-not a great big flash. I did not see the switch box, but I just saw a bit of a glimmer."

Whilst this witness has described the appearance of sparking in this particular switch very much better, his evidence as a whole was such that the Coroner felt justified, when summing up to the jury to say, with regard to him (mentioning his name), "if the case rested upon his evidence I really should advise you not to take much notice of it."

I may add that this witness said that he spoke about the sparking to a man named William Brindle who was there at the time, and added, "I spoke to all the lot about it telling them what they were." Brindle, who was alive, was called, and whilst remembering the man, denied the whole incident as far as he was concerned.

One further piece of evidence, though only hearsay, was given by a witness, who stated that his father-in-law (killed in the explosion) had spoken to him twice of the conveyor sparking, but he did not know what he meant, "the last time being on Sunday, the 4th of December."

As to the expert evidence. — It was agreed by all the experts that if the points of make and break were fully immersed in oil no sparking could possibly be seen, and no possible danger could arise.

There was, unfortunately, considerable controversy as to the depth of the oil in the switch box at the time of the explosion.

The first persons to see and examine the switch after the explosion were Mr. Nelson, His Majesty's Electrical Inspector of Mines, Mr. Bull, Electrical Engineer to the Colliery, and Mr. Tonge.

It was thought important that Mr. Nelson should inspect the electrical apparatus as soon as possible, and also, if possible, before anyone else. At the date of his inspection he was unable to reach the switch to inspect it in situ, owing to gas, and on the suggestion being made that two of the rescue men (wearing breathing apparatus) might carry it out, Mr. Nelson agreed, and the switch was brought down out of the gas, a few yards along the roadway for inspection. Unfortunately the men were not warned that the switch contained oil and to take care that none escaped, nor had Mr. Nelson been told that it was an oil-immersed switch. Mr. Nelson had no idea that the switch was as big as it proved to be or that there would be the slightest difficulty in carrying it, much less did he know there was a hole in the side of the switch box through which oil could freely pass. That some oil was lost out of the switch box in the course of this removal is a fact which cannot be questioned.

The object with which this examination was made would be clearly in the minds of the three gentlemen then present. The mine officials knew that the safety of the switch depended upon its "breaking under oil." Mr. Nelson, as His Majesty's Inspector, would have present in his mind that such a switch box as this under the Electricity Rules must be either proof against gas or the contacts must be made and broken under oil.

Mr. Bull in his evidence stated that the oil then found in the switch box covered the points when contact was made-in fact it covered the controller drum, and that this was the first thing he looked to, because he knew it was the most important point.

Mr. Nelson, without pledging himself to the height of the oil, was satisfied at the time that the three contacts he could reach did dip in oil.

All three gentlemen at that examination were satisfied that there had been no flame inside the switch box, and that the switch had caused no ignition.

Subsequent experiment and further investigation disclosed nothing which caused Mr. Nelson to change his opinion upon this point, but he became satisfied at a later date that with the oil at the height at which he believed it was, when he first saw the switch opened in the pit, the switch would spark. Whether or not the amount of oil which had spilt out of it when it was brought from its position by the rescue men, would have made the difference between sparking and not sparking, Mr. Nelson could not say, as it was wholly impossible to estimate the quantity of oil which had been spilt.

Dr. Thornton, who had examined the switch on behalf of the Miners' Federation and made numerous experiments, stated that he could not point to anything in connection with the switch box which proved to him that an ignition had taken place in the switch box.

This was the opinion of all the experts who examined the switch box before any experiments were attempted with it. There was no visible trace of flame inside the box or on the gauzes which were fixed in the lid, or upon a piece of paper containing instructions fastened on the underside of the lid, and the edges of which were sticking up when found, also the switch contacts were in perfect condition.

The only difference of opinion was upon the point as to whether the condition of the switch box when found left the question of ignition or non-ignition "perfectly open."

Dr. Thornton, from certain experiments he had made at Newcastle, argued that it did. Mr. Nelson and Dr. Cadman took a contrary view. As Mr. Nelson put it, he had not seen an experiment with the switch box which neither marked the gauzes nor burnt the paper. Every experiment he had seen had done one thing or the other.

Experiments also satisfied the experts that no arcing was visible in complete darkness when the lid was closed in the ordinary way and screwed down properly. It was only when the lid was raised at the front a quarter-of-an-inch that a very distinct glimmer along the edge of the lid was visible.

Finally, therefore, it may be said there was really nothing definite to lay hold of in. support of the switch having sparked.

There are certain lessons to be learnt from the experience in this explosion one of which I may refer to. It is the immense importance of the proper and systematic inspection of the electrical apparatus. "However well designed the apparatus, its safety may still be dependent upon constant supervision and efficient maintenance."

I am not wholly satisfied that the scrupulous care which was necessary with this switch to maintain it in safe working condition was always given.

The switch required to be removed at comparatively short intervals and required to be set level. The men who removed it, so far as we had their evidence, bad not been warned that it contained oil and that care was to be taken that none escaped.

Two of the men who assisted to move it to its position prior to the explosion stated that it was moved there on the night of the 14th, or the morning of the 15th, and that there was a little oil spilt in the removal.

Whether or not the switch was examined after each removal, before being put into use, to see that the oil was at its proper level, we had no means of ascertaining, as the electrician Hewit, who had the duty of daily underground inspection of the electrical plant, was killed in the explosion.

Hewitt, we were informed, had no particular instructions as to what the nature of his inspection of the switch was to be, because he was supposed to know his work.

But Mr. Bull stated that he did not suppose he would take the lids off the switches every day, because there would be no reason to suppose that the oil would get out.

Mr. Bull was surprised to find the hole in the switch box when he came to examine it after the explosion, and whilst it had no effect upon the safety of the box so long as the oil was kept at its proper height-still it did provide a ready escape for the oil, if the box in the course of removal was tilted on that side. The box required two men to lift it and was not easy to carry steadily.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page


A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z