Concluding Observations.
This explosion has received a more exhaustive and searching investigation than any similar disaster of recent times. Whilst there was some failure to carry out, in their entirety, certain statutory rules as hereinbefore indicated, there was no breach of specific statutory duty which, in my opinion, should form the matter of summary proceedings under Section 62 of the Coal Mines Regulation Act of 1887. The jury have set out in their verdict (point 4) "that there is no evidence proving that the explosion was in anywise due to the non-observance of any statutory obligation," and with this I agree. Further there was no breach proved to have occurred within the short time limit imposed by the Act.
The great question of responsibility for the deaths occasioned by the explosion is of far higher importance. To justify proceedings against anyone on this graver ground it is necessary to be satisfied that a reasonable case is made out that it is his gross carelessness or neglect of duty which has caused or brought about the deaths in question. In the investigation of the explosion no expert or other witness has indicated an y act of negligence as the cause of the ignition. The nearest approach to anything of the kind was the attempt to establish that the ignition was caused by the sparking of the electrical switch controlling the working of the conveyor in the North Plodder, by reason that some one had negligently omitted to see that the protecting cover of oil in the switch box was kept at its proper height.
The official whose duty it was to make the periodic inspection and attend to this detail was killed in the explosion, and in addition the attempt to establish that the original ignition was caused by the switch, in my view, failed. The jury by their verdict also arrived at the same conclusion.
The jury have specifically found that the several persons came by their deaths by accident and not otherwise, and that there was no evidence to prove that the explosion was in anywise due to the non-observance of any statutory obligation. But although the original ignition was the result of a pure accident, the responsibility in law for the deaths admittedly due to the subsequent coal-dust explosion, which travelled throughout the mine, has to be considered. Were these deaths preventable by the exercise of precautions which the ordinary careful manager should, and would, have taken ? What is the standard of duty in such a case ? Was there gross negligence in connection with the known danger of coal dust, of which a manager using reasonable diligence, would not have been guilty ? I think affirmative proof at least would be required that the precautions would, in fact, have preserved life in this case.
I have given much thought to this very grave question, which is a large and difficult one, and bringing to it the best consideration I can, it is my opinion that a charge of manslaughter could not be -here sustained, and should not be attempted, and I do not recommend any prosecution.
I have the honour to be,
Sir,
Your obedient Servant,
Samuel Pope.
The Right Honourable Winston Spencer Churchill, M.P.,
H.M. Principal Secretary of State for the Home Department.
A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.