Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
Index

Management.

By Section 20, sub-section 1, of the Coal Mines Regulation Act, 1887-" Every mine shall be under a manager, who shall be responsible for the control, management, and direction of the mine, and the owner or agent of every such mine shall nominate himself, or some other person, to be the manager of such mine, and shall send written notice to the Inspector of the District of the manager's name and address."

Sub-section (2) "A person shall not be qualified to be a manager of a mine unless he is for the time being registered as the holder of a first class certificate under this Act."

By Section 21, sub-section 1-" In every mine required by this Act to be under the control of a certificated manager, daily personal supervision shall be exercised either by the manager or by an under-manager nominated in writing by the owner or agent of the mine."

Sub-section (2) "Every person so nominated must hold either a first or second class certificate under this Act, and shall, in the absence of the manager, have the same responsibility, and be subject to the same liabilities as the manager under this Act; but the nomination of an under-manager shall not affect the personal responsibility of the manager under this Act".

The Hulton Colliery consists of a group of four distinct collieries with seven winding shafts, employing, at the date of the explosion, some 2,400 persons above and below ground, the whole of which collieries were under one general manager, Mr. Alfred Tonge, as the certificated manager within the meaning of Section 20 (sub-section 1) above. Under him, for each mine, there was an under-manager, holding either a first class or second class certificate. In the case of the No. 3 Bank Pit where the explosion occurred the under-manager was Mr. Edward Rushton, who held a first class certificate, and assisting him were eleven firemen.

This arrangement (which it should be observed is not peculiar to this colliery) came under some criticism, first of all, as arising out of certain questions put by myself on the second day to Mr. Tonge with reference to his personal acquaintance with the firemen's daily reports made in accordance with General Rule 4 in the Daily Report Book. The questions were as follows

(Mr. TONGE, 1709-1720.) "The Daily Report Book was kept in the office at the bottom ? — Yes."

"There was no copy, I understand, made of it and sent up for the information of the management at the top ? — No."

"How often would you see it ? — I saw that; I should say, three times in a month."

"Do you think that is often enough, Mr. Tonge ? — I think so; I was practically in daily communication with the under-manager."

"What it would amount to is this, that you would be relying upon the conversation with the under-manager and accepting from him his interpretation and reading of the firemen's reports ? — Yes."

"In other words, you are putting him into your shoes; that is to say, you are accepting his mind when it is your mind which should be dissecting and considering these reports, is that about it ? — Well .

"You see what would happen is this, the under-manager has this book daily before him and his duty would be to see that the firemen's reports were regularly and properly entered ? — Yes."

"And he would draw certain conclusions from the entries there as regards the conditions at different parts of the pit ? — Yes."

"It is quite possible you might draw conclusions which were not quite the same as his, isn't it ? — Yes.

"That is to say your wider experience and education might cause you to draw from a series of reports different conclusions from what he drew, isn't that so ? — That is so, but you might carry that further and say someone above me would have a different opinion again. I think Rushton was quite qualified to pass judgment upon those firemen's reports, and it would be impossible for a man in my position to see those reports as often as Rushton himself."

"Don't mistake what I am on. This is your daily guide to know how things are going on underground and a glance at it is what you want ? — Yes."

"That is the object with which it is made. Now if you leave the conclusions to be drawn by somebody else and take an oral report from him as to what is going on underground, you are not giving yourself the fairest chance are you? You are not getting as much information as you, in fairness to yourself, are entitled to have ? Have you ever thought of it in that way ? — Yes, it all depends upon the amount of responsibility you put on the under-manager. I think you cannot have an under-manager and treat him as though he were an ordinary fireman, say, or something lower than a fireman."

The Coroner on the last day of the evidence again reviewed the matter with Mr. Tonge, who frankly answered all questions. Mr. Tonge said with reference to his visits underground in No. 3 Pit that his visits, speaking from memory, during the last six months up to the explosion would aggregate a dozen, or including just popping down the pit and coming out again, double that number, on which occasions he had opportunity of seeing the Report Book; that he did not get any written reports from Mr. Rushton detailing the firemen's reports ; that he relied on oral reports to himself, and that there was in fact no systematic daily report from the under-manager to the manager at all. This led the Coroner to ask (Q. 13,296) "Would it not be a great advantage if these reports were duplicated and laid before you each day ?"-"It would, sir, but I do not think it is quite necessary. I mean to say that Rushton was a thoroughly capable man ; he had a first class certificate." "If the detailed reports varied very considerably, and if we were accustomed to having serious outbursts of gas, I think it would be a very great advantage and. very necessary, but in the whole of those reports there is no serious outburst."

(Q. 13,301.) "But supposing morning after morning those reports were laid on your desk, and it became a matter of daily routine to go through them, don't you think it would have impressed itself more seriously upon your mind than occasional visits to the pit impressed it on your mind ?"-"Of course you cannot quite, I think, take the responsibility from Mr. Rushton. I think his qualifications should be considered, he was a man who had no difficulty whatever in getting a first-class certificate by examination."

(Q. 13,307.) "Would you change the system now after your experience ? — I probably would if I were technically responsible (as I really am, I suppose, in this matter, I am the certificated manager), I would change the system, but I do not think it is necessary for a general manager to have those reports brought to him daily."

"Don't you see, Mr. Tonge, let me point it out to you, the importance from your own stand-point, you are actually responsible, theoretically and practically if it came to a question of penalties, you are actually responsible ; what written document is there in existence that could relieve you from any responsibility ? — I do not know that there is anything, if those books had been destroyed by the fire."

"You tell us of oral communications from Mr. Rushton, that is all you got ? — Yes."

"Isn't it, for your own protection, a matter of the greatest importance you should have all these reports in black and white in your own possession ? — As technical manager I should say yes to that, that is to say, if I were holding the certificate for that mine as well as being the general manager, I should say that in future I should have that."

"Are you not in that position ? — I am in that position now, yes.

In answer to later questions Mr. Tonge said, "I think if there had been anything in these report books that was out of the ordinary, that was serious, I should have been acquainted with it straight away." To which the Coroner replied, "Don't you think it is very important that the selection of the extraordinary, at all events, some choice in the selection of the extraordinary, should rest with the man who has to take penal responsibility ? — I agree that it would appear to be better, but I do not think that is the system in the country."

"If we have got bad systems, let us try to root them out. I want to know what your opinion is, in your extremely responsible position, Mr. Tonge, to yourself and to the directors. I want to know what your opinion is with regard to the burying of reports underground and letting the general manager see them when he just chances to see them ? — I quite agree that it would be better to have a duplicate set of these reports."

The impression left upon my mind was that the exercise of the "daily supervision" was committed in very full measure to the under-manager, Mr. Rushton, and in the circumstances it was desirable, I think, that the general manager should have had some system of daily reporting, preferably in writing, from his under-managers.

It also seemed to me, upon hearing the evidence, that in some degree there had crept into the mind of Mr. Tonge such a sense of security in connection with the colliery, as was likely, if not carefully guarded against, to lead to some slackening of discipline and supervision.

I am able to record, however, that there was not a single complaint from any witness that the under-manager was seldom seen by them in their working places or that there was any lack of supervision on his part. There was no ground for saying that the under-manager was not fully acquainted with all the conditions underground and in full possession of all facts of importance whether recorded in the Daily Report Book or orally reported to him by his firemen.

The details of working in various parts of the mine were investigated and criticised, but the jury by their verdict brought no charge against the management that there was any general state of laxity throughout the mine. Nor did they find evidence of any specific carelessness or neglect of duty upon the part of any person that contributed to the cause of the explosion.

After carefully considering all that was said at the Inquest, I became completely satisfied that there was no justification for any suspicion remaining in one's mind that the working arrangement at this colliery and the manner in which it was carried out had any bearing upon the cause of the explosion.

One other matter suggests itself in connection with this evidence. Mr. Tonge, by reason of the system under which he worked, obviously had not the complete information as to what was going on underground which Mr. Rushton could have supplied. The death of Mr. Rushton and the whole of the day firemen belonging to the seam in which the explosion occurred, deprived us therefore of much important evidence.

How far ought a responsible manager to have this intimate knowledge ? It is clear that it is impossible to expect it, where you have one general certificated manager for a number of collieries.

Under the developments taking place in modern collieries there is so much requiring attention and supervision that the burden upon the best of managers must be very heavy, and it becomes impossible for him to give the personal service to each mine he might otherwise give. Whilst recognising that Mr. Tonge possesses high qualifications and experience as a manager, the circumstances of the explosion impressed me with the view that it is desirable that there should be power to limit the number of mines for which a manager may be responsible.

Underground Officials. — There were no intermediate officials between the undermanager and the firemen-following the Lancashire custom. The appointment of the firemen rests with the manager under the Act. He has to appoint "competent persons" for carrying out the duties prescribed by General Rule 4.

A number of questions were asked of the manager, both at the inquest and inquiry, as to what steps he took to find competent persons to do this work, because complaint had been made at the inquest that young men with little or no experience had been selected for firemen's work.

It appeared that the ages of the firemen for the mine affected by the explosion ranged from 23 to 52, and that the man in charge of the North Plodder district on the night before the explosion was the youngest of these, viz., 23 years of age. The manner and reasons for his appointment were fully explained by Mr. Tonge, both at the inquest and at the inquiry. He said: "He was the son of a fireman, he had been attending classes, he had been down the pit from a lad, he had asked me (which I gave considerable weight to) years before to consider him and to give him a chance as fireman whenever I thought him ready. He was an exceptionally intelligent and able man." Mr. Tonge also said, in answer to Mr. Redmayne, that "he did not think that he was a man that would be unduly pressed to do anything that was not his duty to do by older men in the mine."

Mr. Tonge further said: "We appointed no one as a fireman who had not had underground experience of as varied a kind as we could get. Colliers we gave special preference to, but we had not many applications from colliers. Failing colliers we selected from amongst the datallers. We even went to the collier in preference to the dataller when we had no applications in, and often have persuaded a collier to become a fireman who did not care about it-I mean to say who had not made any application, but who yielded to our persuasion.

Having heard the evidence of the next youngest fireman (age 27) and of three other firemen, I must report that each appeared to me to be familiar with every part of the district of the mine under his charge and fully acquainted with his duties.

The only further criticism that was directed against their age was that years bring experience and knowledge of human nature, and that a fireman must be capable of dealing effectively with men. I think the under-manager must be taken to be the best judge of their qualities in this respect, having the opportunity of seeing the men at their work amongst their fellows.

Firemen's Reports. — General Rule 4. — I am satisfied that the firemen were instructed to report the presence of gas wherever found. I am satisfied also that the matter of instructing the firemen in the detection of fire-damp had received consideration and was having attention given to it. Charts had been prepared for the use of the firemen, and posted up in each underground office, showing in pictorial form the different sizes of caps on the lamp flame and the percentages of fire-damp in the air indicated by each. Mr. Tonge also spoke of many a chat with the firemen in connection with the charts and that he had had on order for some time before the explosion an apparatus for testing the caps, and had arranged to give practical illustrations by a lecture at the school when his firemen could attend.

The character of the firemen's reports which were actually entered in the book were the subject of criticism both at the inquest and the inquiry, and I must say a word as to the carrying out of the provisions of General Rule 4.

The Daily Report Book was kept in the office at the bottom of the shaft and there are many reasons why it should be kept there. It is, however, important that there should be a duplicate of the entries furnished from day to day to some office above-ground, not only to keep the management at the top fully informed, but in order that the record may be preserved. As previously shown no copies of the entries made by the firemen were sent up to the surface.

The book was partially destroyed by fire and violence in the explosion and the record was lost for the entries from 10th December till the date of the explosion.

Mr. Tonge was examined as to the circumstances of the finding of the book, its then condition, and the steps taken to recover the missing portions. I feel with the Coroner who said in his summing up, "I am sure that we do not doubt the truth of what Mr. Tonge told us about his endeavours to find the missing leaves, but on the contrary accept to the full his assurances regarding this book."

The method of reporting employed. — There were no set questions printed in the book which the fireman had to answer. The whole of the entry was in the handwriting of the particular fireman. A few quotations from the evidence will illustrate the practice of the firemen in making their entries.

I examined fireman Bullough upon certain of his entries in order to ascertain what was the ordinary working practice of the pit. Q. "On the 7th December you make a report at 5.30 in the morning to this effect :-' Good and safe except Seddon's, Jolley's, and Yard tunnel giving off gas diluted as made.' Now, that is the entry. I want to know if that phrase, 'Giving off gas diluted as made,' means that there is no fence across any of those three places mentioned ? — No, there is no fence across."

"Then, does it mean that the men are not stopped out from those places ? — Yes, sir.

"Does it mean that the men can go there and work ? — Yes, sir."

"What indications of gas would in your mind make it serious enough to fence it off ? — From a half to three-quarter inch cap."

"And where would that show itself ? — In the higher points in the workings."

"Then, as a matter of practice in some of these places, it was found difficult to completely clear the air for the men, that is to say, the higher part of the working against the face ? — Yes."

"And it would not be a condition which would necessitate their being stopped out ? — No, if you came a few yards further back you would not find it."

"That is what I want to know. What was the working rule as regards that? How far back from the face would you expect to find it clear P--I would say a half inch cap at the face."

I also examined Fred Radcliffe, the young fireman of 27, upon his entries. "When you were taken on as a fireman you knew that you would have to make certain entries in the Report Book ? — Yes."

"Were you told by any one in what form you should make the entries P--No."

"Then how did you find out the way you were to make the entries ? — I saw it in the book, and I could see that it was the best way to put it in the book."

"You would see what the other men were entering when you looked at the book ? — Yes."

"Now, when you said 'Giving off gas diluted as made,' did you understand what it meant ? — Yes."

"What did you understand it meant ? — As that hole was making that gas, I had sufficient air to keep diluting that gas and rendering it harmless."

"Were you ever instructed by the fireman, from whom you had your tuition, as to the meaning of 'giving off gas diluted as made' ? — No. He never said anything to me."

I then asked with reference to a particular working place which he knew, "What conditions in that working place as regards gas would cause you to fence it off ?" He replied, "It (meaning the gas) always makes for the highest point. That is where it would be; and for 2 or 3 per cent. of gas it is sufficient to fence it off."

"What do you mean by 2 or 3 per cent. ? What sort of cap would that show ? — You get half an inch cap on 2½ per cent, of gas, and on 3 per cent. you will get probably three-quarter inch of cap, and when I get three-quarter inch of cap on my lamp I put it down from between 2 to 3 per cent. of gas there, and that is sufficient to fence it off."

I then asked, "In your ordinary daily work where do you draw the line between a place 'giving off gas diluted as made' and a place which you have to fence off or which you would fence off ? — I should fence the place off if it exceeds a quarter inch cap."

"If it did not exceed a quarter of an inch cap, what would you do ? — Well, it just depends where it is. That quarter of an inch cap was in a hole in the roof (referring to the fall and gas he found) where no man could get unless he got on tubs."

"Then you would not enter that ? — Yes, I entered it as 'diluted as made.' I should not fence it off."

The particular phrase "giving off gas diluted as made" was repeatedly under criticism both at the inquest and the inquiry, and different officials were examined upon their interpretation of the phrase, and several of the expert witnesses were invited to express their opinion upon it.

It was apparent from the evidence that each fireman interpreted it according to his own point of view, and that therefore there could be no fixed measure indicated by the phrase.

Mr. Tonge said that he knew what the firemen meant by "diluted as made," and he knew what all his firemen would describe as "diluted as made." I am prepared to agree that Mr. Tonge gave a fair summing up of the effect of the evidence when he said: "I think they all agreed in this that at a short distance away you could not find a trace- they might vary slightly as to how much of a cap they would describe as being unsatisfactory, but they were all of one mind in saying and in meaning that if it was 'diluted as made' it meant that you could not find gas a short distance away."

The material point is that the "presence of the gas" was recorded and under the wording of the present General Rule 4 there is no statutory requirement to do more. That is to say, as I read the present rule, it is "the presence of gas," without reference to its quantity (whether great or small), which must be reported.

In this particular, therefore, it was not shown that there was any breach of General Rule 4.

The reports in question were said to be more ample than is frequently the case. As to this the answer of the jury (8 c) was to the effect that the firemens' reports of gas should specify the place where any show of gas is found and give some clear information as to the quantity shown to be present. With this I agree and I respectfully submit that there is need for further and more specific detail being required by the statutory General Rule, seeing that the safety of human life is so largely dependent upon the faithfulness and care with which the firemen discharge their duties of inspection, and report, for the guidance of their superiors, the conditions which they find.

Withdrawal of Men. General Rule 7. — A proper book for recording occurrences of danger in accordance with General Rule 7 was in existence, but from the commencement of 1910 to the time of the explosion there were only two withdrawals recorded, and neither of them were for gas, but were entered as "roof on weight."

According to the book there was one entry in 1908 of a withdrawal for gas, but none in 1909 and none in 1910.

The entries in this book were more fully examined into by Mr. Redmayne at his Inquiry.

I need only record that the evidence made it clear that the book was not properly kept and that the full requirements of General Rule 7 were not carried out.

"Continuous Shifts."-There also came up for discussion the construction to be put upon the proviso to part i. of General Rule 4, which is as follows :- "For the purpose of the foregoing provisions of this rule, two or more shifts succeeding one another without any interval are to be deemed one shift." The practice seems to have been in certain cases for the outgoing shift and the incoming shift to meet at the pit bottom. The working places, consequently, were vacant for the interval taken by the men in making their several journeys, and there was no inspection "immediately before the commencement of each shift" as required in the earlier part of the rule, because "where the men going in and the men coming out meet each other at the bottom of the shaft that is a continuous shift-the shift includes the going in." As one of the expert witnesses put it, "The shift begins when the men get down the pit, it has nothing whatever to do with changing at the face." To the suggestion that it is the continuous occupation by the shift of the place, which supplies the reason for relaxing the inspection rule at the place, the answer was, "if you accept that view, every time the men went out for their dinner, which occupied twenty minutes, you would have to get a fireman to go and inspect the places before they went in again." The witness was then invited to apply his interpretation to the conditions at the William pit at Whitehaven where the men travel five miles into the face and five miles out, and he was asked whether he would call that a continuous shift, seeing that there would be an interval of three hours between the men leaving the face and the other men getting to the face ? The reply was instructive. "Well, that is rather a different case. If the Whitehaven men leave their places at 12 o'clock and get to the shaft at 1.30, I say the following shift ought to have come down the pit at 12 o'clock and arrived at the places by 1.30."

Q. "And if the places were idle for an hour and a half you still would consider that a continuous shift. — Certainly."

I cannot myself see how two or more shifts meeting at the pit bottom can be said to succeed one another "without any interval," except upon the interpretation that "the shift includes the going in." But if it is to be said that a space of one and a half hours can elapse before the succeeding shift arrives at the place to which the rule of inspection for safety applies, I cannot see the object of the proviso, and it does not appear to me to be a reasonable interpretation to put upon the rule.

In my view this practice (which is not confined to the Hulton pit) is contrary to the true intent and meaning of the rule.

I respectfully submit that a rule of safety of this kind should be cleared of any charge of indefiniteness and a specific direction be given, which will determine the practice under the proviso, in accordance with the best mining opinion.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page


A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z