|
Lighting. The mine was worked throughout with safety lamps provided by the Company. The description of lamp in use was the "Wolf Lamp" with two steel wire gauzes, fitted with bonnet, and provided with air admission from below, having an internal re-lighter, and a magnetic lock, and burning benzine or naphtha. The only point to which I wish to refer is the matter of re-lighting by means of the internal re-lighter. This arrangement consists of a paraffin strip, provided with phosphorus caps, fed through a friction igniter, which was operated by what was called a key The object of the arrangement is that every miner may re-light his own lamp should it become extinguished whilst in use. It was given in evidence that the German and Austrian Governments have enacted that no lamp is to be used without being provided with an internal re-lighter which can be operated by every man. The lamp had been introduced into the No. 3 and 4 Bank Pits about six months before the explosion, but it was not introduced with the intention that every man should re-light his own lamp, as that would have been in contravention of the English law. The provisions of the Coal Mines Regulation Acts as to the examination and lighting of safety lamps are contained in General Rules 10 and 11 (section 49 of the Act of 1887). General Rule 10 (iv) "A person shall not have in his possession any lucifer match or apparatus of any kind for striking a light, except within a completely closed chamber attached to the fuse of the shot." General Rule 11 "Where safety lamps are required to be used, the position of the lamp stations for lighting or re-lighting the lamps shall not be in the return air." Then the Special Rules as regards re-lighting made in pursuance of this Act to be used at this colliery were as follows :- "The manager shall from time to time fix lamp stations at such points in the mine as he shall think fit, not being in any return air-course, at which stations lamps shall be lighted and re-lighted. All such lamp stations shall be indicated by a board with the words 'Lamp Station' legibly inscribed thereon." "Any electrical apparatus used for re-lighting safety lamps shall not he stationed in any return air-way, and shall be kept securely locked and be used only by authorised persons. "Every person using a safety lamp is strictly prohibited from unlocking, opening, or interfering with it in any way whilst in use, beyond the necessary trimming of the wick with the pricker or wire, but this shall not preclude a shot-lighter or other authorised official from raising the shield (if any) of a lamp for the purpose of igniting a shot or testing for gas." "Should any person in charge of a safety lamp lose his light, he shall take or send it to the station to be re-lighted, re-examined, and locked by some authorised person before being again used." "In any mine or part of a mine in which safety lamps are required by the Act or by these Special Rules to be used, no person, other than a person duly authorised in writing, shall have in his possession . . . - any means or apparatus for obtaining a light . . and if there be any ground for suspicion he shall be subject to be personally searched for the same, but their clothes shall not be searched in their absence." It is clear that if every collier who carried a lamp could re-light it himself when it went out, it would abolish all necessity for lamp stations. It was also obvious when one saw the so-called "key" and the mechanism of the igniter that it would be a comparatively simple matter for anyone so inclined to imitate the key or re-light the lamp by other means, by the exercise of a little ingenuity. The evidence showed that this unauthorised re-lighting had taken place to some extent. What precautions were taken on the introduction of this lamp? It appears that in the lamp room there were posted the instructions issued by the Wolf Lamp Company for the guidance of persons using the lamp, and for underground there was a rule established by the management in regard to re-lighting, which was also posted. Certain persons only were authorised to re-light and were entrusted with keys for the purpose. The firemen, by the nature of their office, were authorised to re-light, and certain persons other than firemen were also authorised, and these were selected from the most intelligent haulage men about the particular shunt, where it was intended the key should be used. The principle of giving out these extra keys was that there should be one key for every important shunt in the mine (i.e., the junction of roads where the haulage is concentrated). The notice said to have been in force as to re-lighting is as follows :- "A fireman, on satisfying himself that it is safe to do so, may re-light a lamp at any suitable place that is not in the return airway. All other authorized persons shall re-light the lamps at the appointed stations. By Order. General Manager." The firemen had no power to delegate the right of re-lighting to other people. The former lamp in use was an electrically lighted lamp, and the lamp stations appointed when that lamp was in use were taken as the stations for re-lighting Wolf lamps. I pointed out to Mr. Tonge that his practice and his Special Rules were at variance, and his answer was, "Of course the rules are very old; they refer to the old form of lamp and the old form of locking apparatus." Without commenting on that reply I must point out that section 54 (1) of the General Act*provides a method by which alteration can be made in the Special Rules, and the proper course for Mr. Tonge to take if he desired to change the arrangements was to have proposed such an alteration to the Home Office. It will be observed that both the general and the special rules are directed to secure safety in the matter of re-lighting lamps by providing that the extinguished lamp shall be taken or sent to the station to be re-lighted, that this station is to be situate in fresh air (i.e., "shall not be in the return air"), and that the lamp shall be "re-examined and locked" (apparently intending that the lamp shall be unlocked and examined, and not merely externally examined and re-lighted) before being again used. The permission to the fireman to re-light, where in his discretion it is safe to do so (not being in the return air), is at variance with the rule. Further, nothing is said about re-examination in the management's notice, in which respect also it falls short of the rule. The importance of this re-examination was emphasised by Sir Henry Hall, in answer to myself. (Q. 10,283.) "Generally, the English mine managers are very much against the miners being allowed to re-light their lamps in that way, they think it would give rise to lamps being re-lighted which had been injured, and which were not safe that is the argument against it, that having lost their light through their lamp getting a blow and possibly at the same time getting an injury, then the man might re-light it without a proper examination, and use his lamp again when it was not in a safe condition" This view coincides with the findings of the Royal Commission on Mines at page 141 of their second report, where they go so far as to say that to allow re-lighting without examination is open to grave objection, and that they are unable to recommend any alteration of the existing practice in this respect. Mr. Tonge was frank to confess that he was rather sympathetic to the men re-lighting their own lamps, and did not think there was any necessity to have authorised persons, but he said he had not allowed his feelings to run away with him, and he did not think there had been a larger number of keys found than there ought to have been in the mine. * Section 54 (1). — After special rules are established under this Act in any mine, the owner, agent, or manager of the mine may from time to time propose in writing to the inspector of the district, for the approval of a Secretary of State, any amendment of the rules or any new special rules, and the provisions of this Act with respect to the original special rules shall apply to all such amendments and new rules in like manner, as nearly as may he, as they apply to the original rules.
A copy of this report was kindly donated by
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||