Ventilation
For the technical matters under this head I must refer to Mr. Redmayne's Report.
There are but two matters to which I need refer, viz. : (1) the question of the underground fans as the active means of carrying on the ventilation of the mine during the working hours ; and (2) the manner of measuring and recording the air.
(i.) Ventilation by underground fans. — There was a complete set of ventilation fans-
(1) A system of four underground fans, one for each mine or seam, being worked.
(2) A large sirocco fan on the surface 98 ins, in diameter.
All the fans whether on the surface or underground were electrically driven.
The practice was to employ the underground fans during the working week to produce the necessary ventilation, and to work the surface fan each week-end, when the underground fans were stopped.
Mr. Smillie contended that this method of ventilation was not in accordance with the Act of Parliament, because, although there was a main ventilating fan on the surface capable of serving the whole of the mine, it was not, in fact, the main ventilator, because it was not ventilating during the working week, but the general ventilation of the pit was produced by underground fans. Mr. Tonge contended that he was well within the requirements of the Statute, and went beyond it, in that he had two separate and complete means of ventilating his mine, and employed them alternately so that both were constantly in sound working condition. It was not disputed by Mr. Smillie that the ordinary ventilation of the mine had been good.
The rule under discussion was General Rule 3 of section 49 of the principal Act. "Where a mechanical contrivance for ventilation is introduced into an y mine after the commencement of this Act, it shall be in such position and placed under such conditions as will tend to insure its being uninjured by an explosion."
The following points may be noted :-(l) The underground fan, in the mine where the explosion occurred, was in fact completely wrecked by the explosion, and notwithstanding certain arrangements which were intended to preserve it from injury.
(2) The surface fan was capable of producing without delay an adequate amount of ventilation for the whole of the mines on any stoppage of the underground fans.
The evidence was that the surface fan could be brought into use in five minutes, with due notice, or, in about ten minutes without previous notice, as the men were practised every week-end in making the change.
(3) Consequently in the event of any disablement of the underground fans the ventilation of the mine was still assured by the surface fan.
It was stated by Mr. Tonge that the natural ventilation of the pit was such that there would not be much show of gas until the fans had stopped for an hour or two.
(4) The surface fan was started after the explosion as soon as the experts had. decided that it was safe to do so. Several fires had been found, and these were extinguished before the responsibility was taken of starting the fan.
In consideration of these points I do not think it is necessary to discuss the singularly indefinite wording of the rule, which no one defends. It is sufficient to say that I do not feel justified, in the circumstances of this particular case, in supporting Mr. Smillie's contention and reporting a breach of the statute.
This much at any rate is clear, that this explosion demonstrates and emphasises the great importance of having the main ventilating appliance on the surface, because, but for the duplicate surface "stand by" fan, the work of rescue and recovery of the mine would have been crippled or very seriously delayed.
I respectfully submit that in any amendment of the statute it should be explicitly laid down that the appliance by which the main ventilation of the mine is produced should be placed upon and worked from the surface.
(ii.) The manner of measuring and recording the air.
Whilst Mr. Gerrard in his evidence said that he had every reason to believe that the mine was well ventilated, it was found impossible to obtain really accurate information upon many points. The air reports contained in the ventilation book were characterised by the Coroner in his summing up, "to be as little informing as it is possible for any reports to be."
Mr. Tonge was at some difficulty to give us the information as to the quantity of air serving the different parts of the underground workings, as the man who took the measurements was killed, and the entries in the ventilation book reported "totals" from which the quantity of air available for different districts or different parts of the same district could only be ascertained by calculation.
Thus, the total quantity of air for three districts, viz., the Top Yard, the Three-Quarters Mine and the South Plodder, was entered as 20,000 cubic feet, but in the book there were no separate entries for the Top Yard and the Three-Quarters.
Mr. Tonge, speaking of this, said that he certainly thought the splits into each mine ought to have been in the book, and added, "that again, I am sorry to say, is not quite up to the full letter of the law I think."
So also the total quantity of air going into the North Plodder was entered as 15,000 cubic feet, but how much went to ventilate the No. 1 (or conveyor face portion of the North Plodder) and how much went to the No. 2 district of the North Plodder there was nothing in writing to show, and Mr. Tonge could only arrive at it by a calculation which was admittedly an estimate only.
The explanation was that it is the customary thing in mines to take the main splits of the mine. The result of which practice often is that the splits are measured a long way from the face. In these circumstances there is no certain indication of the quantity of air arriving at the workings where there is possibility of loss by leakage.
At the inquests I have been privileged to attend there has always been much dispute as to the quantity of air available in the working places, chiefly because of the absence of any figures to show what amount of air was reaching the respective places ; and the evidence of the men on the one hand and of the officials on the other has frequently been in serious conflict upon the matter.
It is quite true that the present Mines Act gives no directions as to the place of measurement, but seeing that General Rule 1 enacts that an adequate amount of ventilation shall be produced to an extent that will maintain the working places in a fit state for working, it seems reasonable to require that the splits should be measured nearer to where the air is going to be used, in order that there may be more certainty that the rule is being carried out.
The working interpretation put upon the phrase used in the present Act (i.e., "the quantity of air in the respective splits or currents shall be measured") is, I submit, not in accordance either with the wording or with the spirit of the rule. The need for the most complete detailed information, not only as to the main, but as to all subsidiary air courses, where men are working, is strongly indicated by the evidence given both here and in connection with the disaster at Whitehaven.
A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.