The Evidence.
Although it was known at the opening of the inquest that the Secretary of State (in response to representations to that effect) had directed a formal investigation to be held by Mr. R. A. S. Redmayne, His Majesty's Chief Inspector of Mines, in accordance with Section 45 of the Coal Mines Regulation Act, 1887, into the causes and circumstances surrounding the explosion, the jury nevertheless desired to hear all the evidence which could assist them in arriving at their verdict in this serious and responsible inquest. One hundred and twenty-nine witnesses attended and gave evidence before the jury, including Mr. John Gerrard, His Majesty's Inspector of Mines, and Mr. Robert Nelson, Electrical Inspector of Mines, and the following Mining Engineers :-Sir Henry Hall, Dr. John Cadman, Messrs. Albert Mayon Henshaw, John Knowles, Arthur Henry Leach, John Howard Walker, and Jesse Wallwork, on behalf of the owners of the colliery, and Mr. William Galloway and Dr. Thornton (Electrical Engineer) on behalf of the Miners' Federation. Messrs. Thomas Greenall and Henry Roughley also gave evidence. The list of witnesses and the order of their being called is shown in the Appendix.
My report is based upon what transpired before the jury at the inquest, and is confined, in accordance with the instructions contained in your letter of 10th January, 1911, to the legal aspect of the case, as presented at the Coroner's inquest. I have, however, had the privilege of receiving a copy of the shorthand notes of the inquiry conducted by Mr. Redmayne, and so far as the evidence taken before him amplifies or enforces points which arose at the inquest, I have made use of it in the preparation of this report.
For all general particulars as to the description of the colliery, its staffing and system of working, and the condition of the mine prior to the explosion, I must refer to Mr. Redmayne's report. These matters do not come within the scope of my report save in so far as they were investigated at the inquest as having a possible bearing upon the accident.
It will be seen that the jury as the result of their investigations did not connect the explosion with any proved act of negligence, but they have felt themselves able to fix the point from which he explosion started upon its devastating course and also to indicate that the ignition was probably due to a defective or overheated safety lamp.
The mining engineers before mentioned, some of whom had taken part in the rescue operations, and all of whom had examined the colliery after the explosion, found it impossible to agree as to the point of origin. The nearest agreement that could be reached was that the starting point was either in one of the two districts of the North Plodder or in the Three-Quarters Mine. There were in fact four main theories.
The jury adopted the view of Mr. Gerrard, His Majesty's Inspector of Mines for the district, who was supported by Dr. Cadman and Mr. Henshaw.
I refrain from discussing the theories, although exceedingly interesting, and leave what must be problematical and uncertain, in order to direct attention to matters, the consideration of which may tend to prevent, or to mitigate the extent of such calamities in the future.
In the course of the investigation various points were raised bearing on the question whether the mine had been conducted in a safe manner and whether all statutory and other precautions necessary to guard against such an explosion occurring, had in fact been observed.
The first of such matters is the question of the ventilation of the mine.
A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.