Questions For Jury.
1. When did the explosion take place?
2. When did the men die?
3. Are you satisfied with the evidence of identity given in the cases of the several persons as to whom such evidence has been given?
4. What other persons were killed by or in consequence of the same explosion?
5. Do you accept as correct the list compiled of the several places where the bodies of the deceased persons were found ?
6. Do you accept as correct the evidence given by Dr. Hatton as to the causes of death?
7. What was it gave rise to such causes of death, e.g., an originating explosion of gas, or gas and coal dust with or without a larger consequent explosion of coal dust ?
8. In what district of the Mine did the explosion originate?
9. At what place in such district did it originate?
10. What was the cause of the ignition, (a) Safety lamp, with any observations as to its character; (b) Electricity, with comments ; (c) how otherwise ?
11. Was the explosion attributable to the gross neglect of any persons or person, and if so, of whom and in what particulars were they or he grossly negligent, or was it due to accident?
12. Was the explosion in anywise due to the non-observance of any statutory obligation, and if so, on the part of whom?
13. Were due care and reasonable precautions taken in the following districts, viz. :-South Plodder, North Plodder, Top Yard, Down Brow Yard, East Jig, and Three-Quarters in respect to all and each of the following matters
(a) The examination for and the removal or adequate dilution of gas.
(b) For preventing workmen from working in places where gas was present.
(c) In keeping all working places supplied with a quantity of air adequate to render them safe and proper to work in, and to render harmless all noxious gases.
(d) With regard to the use and supervision of any part of the electrical plant, and
(e) In other respects by the Manager, Under-manager, Firemen and other Officials in their respective departments of supervision and control?
14. Does blame rest upon anyone in connection with the explosion? If so, upon whom, and in respect of what acts of omission or commission?
15. Do you desire to make any recommendations upon any of the following or any other points
(1) Dealing with coal dust in mines.
(2) Safety lamps.
(3) The use of electricity, and particularly as to the gas tightness of switch boxes.
(4) The appointment and instruction of firemen.
(5) The nature of the tests and reports to be made, (a) by firemen; (b) as to ventilation, and as to the duplication of such reports.
(6) The definition of "return airways."
(7) As to any other matters.
The jury retired, and, after an absence of six hours, returned their verdict in the following form :-
THE FOREMAN: "On behalf of my colleagues and myself I tender this as our verdict :- That on the 21st day of December, 1910, at the No. 3 Bank Pit, commonly known as No. 3 Pretoria Pit, Westhoughton, in the County of Lancaster, an accidental ignition of gas and coal dust occurred on the conveyor face in the North Plodder Mine in some manner to the jury unknown, but probably from a defective or over-heated safety-lamp, and produced an explosion. That upon such ignition and explosion followed a large ignition and explosion of coal dust affecting the whole of the coal mines working in the said pit. That the said (here followed a list of names of the men killed by the explosion) were with others at the time of the said explosions employed in the Yard Mine of the said pit, and in consequence of such explosions and resulting after-damp died there the same day, so that they came by their deaths by accident and not otherwise. That, Mr. Coroner, is the verdict of the jury."
The other points desired by the jury to be presented are as follows :-
(1) They are satisfied with the evidences of identity given in the cases of the several persons as to whom evidence has been given.
(2) That the other persons (whose names are set forth in a schedule herewith) were killed by or in consequence of the said explosion.
(3) That the jury are satisfied of the correctness of the list compiled of the several places where the bodies of the deceased persons were found, and of the evidence given by Dr. Hatton as to the causes of death.
(4) That there is no evidence proving that the explosion was in any wise due to the non-observance of any statutory obligation.
(5) That the evidence and the experience of the jury satisfy them that such headings as Bradley's in the South Plodder Mine and Brown's and Eccleston's in the North Plodder Mine are undesirable, unless provided with adequate ventilation by means of bratticing, pipes or otherwise, in that they are calculated to be injurious to the health of the men working in them and likely to collect gas. They are also of opinion that the carrying forward of the heading at the top of the North Plodder Jig to the extent it was carried up was unnecessary and calculated to produce danger from gas.
(6) That there seems some doubt upon the evidence as to the fitness of the men who have from time to time removed the switchbox, and as to the sufficiency of the instructions given to them, and the jury are of opinion that every dealing with electrical plant should be under the direct supervision of a skilled electrician.
(7) The jury are of opinion that the apparent failure of the fireman in the North Plodder Mine to make his statutory report on the morning of the 21st December is some evidence of laxity of supervision.
(8) The jury desire to add the following recommendation
(a) That it is a matter of immediate importance that the fullest investigation should be made into the dangers incident to coal dust in mines and the best methods of removing or minimising them, and also as to the character of the safety-lamps, the use of which is to be permitted, and desire respectfully to represent to His Majesty's Government that these matters merit their attention and call for financial and other assistance.
(b) That Electricity Rule 33 should be amended, so as to provide that the switches, &c., referred to in the latter part of such rule shall be enclosed in gas-tight boxes and break under oil.
(c) That firemen's reports of gas should specify the exact place where found, and the quantity found, together with similar particulars regarding the adjacent places likely to be affected by it. That all firemen's reports should be forthwith duplicated and one copy preserved above ground.
(d) That full ventilation reports should be made at least monthly upon each and every airway in the mine.
(e) That the attention of the Royal Commission on Mines be called to the desirability of a definition of the term "Return Airway."
A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.