Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
Index

III. The Explosion (cont).

(b) Discussion as to the probable point of origin and Cause of the explosion. — When I made my inspection of the mine on the Saturday preceding the Inquiry I came to a very definite conclusion as to the originating point of the explosion, and since hearing the evidence of witnesses I am able also to point out the probable cause of ignition. My conclusions in this respect are strongly supported by the evidence of the manager and that of several other witnesses. Mr. Leach, in particular, is almost precisely of my opinion.

The points of origin put forward by different witnesses, though some were later on abandoned, may be mentioned and briefly discussed

(i.) The Three Quarter Seam. — Somewhere at the face of the Three Quarters was given as the originating point of the explosion by Sir Henry Hall and Mr. Walker, and the positions in the mining world of these two witnesses renders it necessary that one should give very careful consideration to anything put forward by them.

Mr. Walker, upon first investigation, was of the opinion that the explosion had occurred at the No. 2 face of the North Plodder, and I find his argument in favour of this being the most likely place for an occurrence of gas in quantity most convincing. His difficulty in putting this as the point of origin is due to what he found in the Three Quarters. He said: "I cannot reconcile that with the condition of things in the Three Quarters." But I think what he found in the Three Quarters seam is quite reconcilable with the explosion having originated in the North Plodder. The explosive blast undoubtedly entered the Three Quarters by way of the road off the return at the point B on the Plan I., blowing in the doors D.D. and traversing the face. Owing to the circuitous line of face a certain amount of compression would occur towards the furthest in-bye part of the face, and if this had been so the fact would be demonstrated by indications of heat and much coked coal dust on props, and these indications were found there.

There were considerable indications of force in an out-bye direction along the haulage road of the Three Quarters.

A conclusive piece of evidence against the tenability of the Three Quarters theory, to my mind, is the fact that the positions of the steel girders supporting the roof in-bye side of the Three Quarters haulage-way end (A on Plan I.) pointed to a great display of force coming from the North Plodder-see Plan III. These girders are, in some cases, let into the side of the road at one end. Where that was so, with that end as a pivot, the girders were blown in an out-bye direction.

Sir Henry Hall, who was called by Mr. Ellis, said

"I felt all along that there was a possibility of an explosion from the North Plodder going through these doors and travelling by the intake into the Three Quarters, but I quite expected to find that the men along where the flame entered the Three Quarters would be burnt, but apparently they were not. With regard to the workings of the Three Quarters you will notice in the doctor's evidence, in speaking of the men, he uses a different word from the word he uses in speaking of the burnt men in any other part. He says that the men in the Three Quarters, several of them, were extensively burnt. He uses the word 'extensively.' I do not need to say anything more about the Three Quarters, except that I feel I am compelled to hold the same opinion now as I did at the time of the inquest."

Sir Henry summed up his opinion thus

"I think myself, if it did not happen in the Three Quarters then No. 2 is more likely than No. 1. It may be that we have not got on the right spot anywhere."

(ii.) Rowland's Tunnel. — This tunnel was, as has been said, ventilated with return air, and return air which we know was, at times, contaminated with gas to an appreciable extent, yet shot firing was allowed at the face of this tunnel. There was, however, no evidence to show that anything other than the greatest care had been exercised in the firing of shots, either here or elsewhere.

Professor Galloway, who was called by the representatives of the men, put Rowland's tunnel forward "as a possible site of the origin of the explosion worthy of being inquired into." Professor Galloway came to the conclusion that shots had been fired at the face of the tunnel on the morning of the explosion. He said he found that one of the shots had blown out, but I found later that there was evidence of several shots at the face which had not completely done their work.

Against this theory may be put the following facts

(1) Shot firing was only carried out during the afternoon, and no evidence was forthcoming at the Inquiry that the shot firing rules had been contravened in this respect.

(2) No remains of shot-firing apparatus were discovered in the tunnel.

(3) The fact of there being found a heap of rubbish-which was the result of a shot-is quite consistent with the shot or shots having been fired on the previous day.

(4) The position of the men shows that those who were working in the face of the tunnel had walked out a considerable distance, and, further, they died of carbon monoxide poisoning.

(5) There were indications of considerable inward force.

(6) The air-pipes were considerably flattened, which is explicable by the fact that the tunnel, constituting a complete cul-de-sac, the compressive force due to the explosion would be very considerable therein.

Professor Galloway did not inspect Nos. 2 or 3 jigs of the North Plodder.

(iii.) Sparking at the Jig wheel No. 1, North Plodder. — The manager at one time-prior to the Inquiry-held that sparking due to friction at the wheel might have caused the disaster by igniting coal dust. Against this theory is the fact that there was little or no indication of heat on the woodwork of the frame, certainly nothing indicative of the wheel having been the originating point of the explosion. The direction of the explosive force also is opposed to this having been the point of occurrence.

(iv.) The Conveyor Switch. — A good deal was said, both at the inquest and Inquiry, as to the heading in the North Plodder having been the point of origin of the explosion, and the igniting cause sparking of the conveyor switch which was stationed there. It is necessary, therefore, to examine as closely as possible into the facts. Mechanical coal cutting was carried on at night time, and the conveyor did not work, under normal circumstances, except during the coal filling shift the next morning. Under normal circumstances, therefore, the conveyor controller switch would not be worked at night.

There were witnesses who maintained that they had seen sparking from the conveyor switch; and there were others who said that they never knew that sparking had taken place:

Shaw, fireman in the afternoon shift, North Plodder, said he had never seen sparking: "the first time has to come yet."

Q. "So far as you are concerned ? — A. Yes, and I think we did as much rough and tumble work at that conveyor as anybody to cause it to spark."

J. Basnett worked at the North Plodder as a dataller; but three weeks before the explosion he was dismissed. He said he saw a flash at the switch on the 6th December, but he did not tell anybody-"I kept it to myself." He denied that he had said at the inquest that he had told Brindle about it; but I find that he said on that occasion, in answer to the coroner: "I saw this here switch spark, but when I am asked whether anyone else did of course, I am only one and I answer for myself."

Q. "Did you speak to Brindle about it ? — A. I spoke to all the lot about it, and I started cussing and swearing and telling them what they were."

R. Cowburn, collier in morning shift, working in the No. 1 conveyor face, North Plodder, said the switch sparked on the Thursday in the week before the explosion when the conveyor was being started, "and Mr. Rushton came up and he stopped the conveyor and put a brattice across where the conveyor emptied itself, so that would turn the air into the straight heading, and when the air was turned into that straight heading, it turned the gas down and it put the lamps out, only three."

That is the lamps of those in No. 1 jig.

He was at the end of the conveyor, and Rushton said "he saw the sparks, and I saw them, and he said he must stop that sparking or we should be blown up."

Now, I asked this witness what the sparks were like, and he said: "It was, when I saw it, it was a dull red spark, just as it was falling.

Q. "A dull what ? — A. A dull red spark just as it was falling from the switch."

which proves clearly to my mind that whatever he saw it was not an electric spark, such a spark could not fall from the switch.

This witness's evidence was very confused. He says that when Rushton saw the sparking he withdrew the men from the conveyor face where the air was good and placed nine of them in the return out-bye side of the switch, which, supposing the switch was sparking, and supposing the heading contained gas, would be the most dangerous place in which to put them, whilst the brattice was being put up to ventilate the place. About 25 minutes after men went into the heading to work at the coal. Apparently no one came to examine the switch. My difficulty is to understand how, even if the switch did spark, the witness could see it if the lid was on; though there was certainly a small round hole in the side of the box about five inches above the bottom, and at the top of the box was an aperture covered over with copper gauze.

Frank Garswood, employed during the night shift, was instructed by the fireman how to work the switch, on which occasion, viz., during the night before the explosion, he said he saw a bit of a flash the second time I used it (the switch) coming from somewhere near the centre." This was on the day of the explosion, at about 5.40 a.m. When describing this incident he spoke of the switch making a "jarring din" (humming). This the switch could not do. He called no one's attention to the sparking. It is remarkable that at the inquest he never alluded to the switch as having sparked. He says he did not do so because he was not asked about it. He says he knew there was gas in the corner of the heading but as he never went up to see I do not see how he can have known. He knew of the vital importance of no flame being near where there was gas, but he did not think the sparking of the switch a fact of sufficient importance to mention it to the fireman who was with him.

J. Winrow, a dataller, working in North Plodder during the night shift in return air road and at No. 1 face, said he had never seen a spark.

Paul Garswood, a dataller, usually employed in Nos. 2 and 3 jigs and East level, but who had worked up at No. 1 face, knew where the switch was, but had not seen it spark.

W. Singleton, assistant in charge of the coal cutter, working in No. 1 face, and who went down the pit at 10.15 p.m., knew where the switch was-about three or four yards in-bye side of the conveyor face, placed in a recess made for it- never saw any sparking and never heard anyone say that they had seen sparking.

J. Miller, dataller, working at No. 1 face of the North Plodder on the night before the accident-his work being to put the floor right for the cutter to travel along the face-said he had never seen sparking at the switch and had never heard anyone say they had seen it.

G. Ratcliffe, in charge of the coal cutters at the Nos. 1 and 2 faces, remembered the occasion of the conveyor being stopped on the Thursday, but did not hear any remarks passed as to there having been sparking.

I find it easy to come to the conclusion that there had been no sustained sparking from the conveyor switch. On the other hand, I feel that it is not possible completely to reject the evidence of those witnesses, three in number, who stated before me that they had seen sparks, each on one occasion, making in all three separate occasions. It is true that the evidence of two of the witnesses, Brindle and Cowburn, was confused and indefinite, and that the most straightforward and plausible account of visible sparking was not produced until the Inquiry, although the same witness, Frank Garswood, appeared at the inquest; and it is also true that there is no corroborative evidence in any one of the three cases; but, nevertheless, I have great sympathy with men honestly endeavouring to remember events which occurred prior to a great calamity. One's recollection of events to which little or no importance is attached at the time is apt to be indefinite. In my view, taking all the circumstances into account, sparking at the switch cannot be held to be disproved. I am assisted in this conclusion by the evidence given by Mr. Nelson, who said:

Q. "But when the switch was moved during Kinsella's shift Kinsella moved it; that was his evidence, I think, and if it had been sparking during one shift, assuming the same conditions exist, the next shift, if it was then used, you would have expected it to again spark ? — A. I see no reason why it should not continue to spark, but I would like to say something in connection with this question of sparking. I was very interested to hear Mr. Bull say this morning that he thought it was possible there were two kinds of oil in the switch at the time, and that rather confirms the impression I had when I first saw it, namely, that the oil was thinner the first time than it was when I subsequently experimented with it. If the oil is thin, we have tried experiments recently, and I have seen, looking at the oil, 1½ inches deep, or even two inches deep, I have seen a flash in the oil. Now, it is possible we may have had this condition, the thin oil on the top, still covering the contacts, flashing under the oil, the cover perhaps not tightly screwed down, and a glimmer underneath the cover; I mean that is a possibility.

Q. "But what you say could not be described as a dull red spark shooting out of the box ? — A. Not out of the box."

There is also this further possibility: oil covering switch contacts by not more than two inches might conceivably be so agitated if the switch handle were frequently operated backwards and forwards as momentarily to bare one of the contacts, and thus cause the current to be wholly or partially broken in air. It would be impossible for this to happen with the great majority of oil switches I have examined, but the conveyor switch contacts were mounted on a barrel which displaced in its movement a relatively large quantity of oil, and they would thus disturb the oil surface to a considerable extent.

I am therefore not disposed altogether to discredit the statement that the conveyor switch sparked, on one occasion, or on more than one occasion, but whether it sparked on the morning of the explosion or not, I am satisfied that No. 1 heading, in which the conveyor switch was placed, was not the point of origin of the explosion.

(v.) The Conveyor face. — The theory, placing the point of origin at the conveyor face, was to the effect that the coal dust occasioned by the filling, conveying, and emptying of the coal formed, with an atmosphere containing a small quantity of methane, an explosive mixture which ignited at a safety lamp, in respect of which it is held that there are indications of excessive heating. Against the validity of this theory there must be advanced the fact that the indications of explosive violence do not support the conveyor face as the point of origin; furthermore, the theory is rendered untenable, in my opinion, by the following facts

(1) Other lamps which I inspected showed what could be described as strong signs of heating.

(2) We have it in evidence that the No. 1 face was free from gas-in so far as the safety lamp is an indicator-when the night-shift men left it on the morning of the explosion, and (with the exception of the heading) gas had never been seen there.

(3) Mr. Pickering, H.M. Inspector of Mines for the Yorkshire and North Midland Division, submitted lamps from the pit to a series of tests under conditions similar to those which might be supposed to have existed in the mine, the coal dust used having been prepared from coal from the North Plodder district. The conditions of the test were, in my opinion, much more severe than those a lamp would have to sustain in use at the No. 1 face of the North Plodder. Quoting from Mr. Pickering's very interesting evidence

"In the first test we made, the gauzes of a Wolf lamp, one of the Pretoria lamps, were sprinkled a little with dust after the lamp had been warmed by burning it for a few minutes, the lamp was then placed in a current having a velocity of 1,000 feet per minute, and dust was dribbled in from a funnel in the gallery. It was an unknown percentage of dust, but the current was made explosive by 6 per cent. of benzine gas, that would just be about the lowest explosive.

Mr. REDMAYNE: "Just in passing, one might get from you, Mr. Pickering, the effect of the benzine gas, would be to all intents and purposes the same as firedamp ? — A. Yes, the same as firedamp to all intents and purposes. We ran that for three minutes with a current of 1,000 feet per minute. The gas burned at the bottom inlet only and burned for the three minutes. Then the gas was increased up to 8 per cent., there was no perceptible change, the gas continued to burn at the bottom inlet only. That was continued for three minutes and then the gas was increased to 10 per cent., there was no perceptible change, and then we gave a shock to it by hitting the gallery underneath with a hammer. The glass then cracked-the glass cracked down and the burning gas appeared to increase a little, apparently from the dust that was shaken from the gauzes above. Then we shook the lamp with a wire passed underneath the gallery.

Q. "A broken lamp ? — A. A cracked lamp, it was only cracked. It would not pass any flame. We shook the lamp with a wire passed from underneath, and finally it was knocked over and extinguished, and the total duration of the test was 8 minutes, and we noticed that whenever dust was dribbled in sometimes the dust stopped-it was not satisfactory, but whenever the dust was dribbled in the size of the flame appeared to increase, but whether that was it became more luminous with the solid particles of carbon or whether the flame actually increased in size I am unable to say. My impression is that it increased in size with the dust going in through the gauzes. The lamp stood that test. Then we tried the next test under the same conditions as regards velocity and dust, but the percentage of gas throughout was 10. The gauzes were sprinkled with dust as in the first test. For a quarter of a minute dust was not dribbled into the current.

Q. "What would be the amount of dust ? — A. We had no means of knowing. We had to improvise this thing. It was simply a funnel, we had no means of taking the percentage at all. We could not even guess. It was an absolutely rough, unscientific test altogether. We could not see the dust pass the lamp. We could see it go into the lamp, but it was not a dusty atmosphere to the eye, looking through the glass windows, but we could see the dust, before the explosive mixture was put in, come into the lamp and dull the glass. For a quarter of a minute the dust was not dribbled into the current. Then we dribbled it in for 4¼ minutes. The gas during the whole of this 4¼ minutes was burning, both at the top and bottom gauzes. That was quite different from the previous test. Occasionally the gas would stop burning at the lower gauze.

"It would burn at this gauze (indicated). In the first test it burnt entirely there, it did not burn at the top at all. In the second test it burnt both at the top and the bottom. Occasionally this would go out for about three seconds, and then the flame would spring down again from here and light at that place (indicating). Well, we continued that for 4½ minutes, 4¼ of which dust was being dribbled in. The admission of dust apparently increased the flame as before. At the expiration of 4½ minutes the gas ceased to burn in the lamp, and the lamp was darker. In about ten seconds the lamp was relighted in the explosive current by the internal igniter, and the gas ignited and continued to burn as before for two minutes, when the supply of gas was cut off. Then the wick relighted itself when more oxygen--

Q. "From the flame ? — A. The last thing the gas did was to relight the lamp when it was cut off, and it burnt with a flame about three inches long, right up into these gauzes, right up out of sight, an enormous long flame. The gas was then admitted again, and it fired at the bottom gauze, but ceased to burn after a few seconds and the lamp went out. It put the flame of the lamp out straight away, but it continued to burn just few seconds and then it went out. Then we tested the lamps in a still, explosive atmosphere five times. In all cases the gas ignited at the bottom gauze, but ceased to burn after the expiration of a few seconds. This was quite contrary to previous experiences. As a rule, in a still atmosphere the gas will go on burning in the top gauze any length of time, and why it did not burn in this case I do not know.

Q. "It burnt at the bottom gauze instead ? — A. It burnt at the bottom gauze for a short time and then went out. We did not succeed in getting it to burn for a long time in the still atmosphere, but we had not time to do the experiments properly. I had to come away by the evening train, and we had not time to repeat or make the experiments in any sense exhaustive.

Q. "So far as they went they were negative ? — A. So far as they went they were negative. The lamp passed some very severe tests under these conditions, but I should not like to say that the evidence was conclusive in any way, because we had neither the proper conditions of dust, and we had not gone thoroughly into the question."

(4) The positions in which the bodies were found points to workmen at the supposed point of origin not having been in any state of alarm, and renders it very doubtful whether the conveyor was in motion at the time of the explosion. Thus, the men found near the conveyor (one in front, another at the side, with a spade underneath him, and the day fireman) had all died of carbon monoxide poisoning. They showed signs of scorching, which one would expect to find from the inrush of the heated explosive blast, which would occasion a state of momentary compression at this point due to its being a partial cul-de-sac.

Evidently these men were quickly overcome by the effects of the afterdamp. Those nearest to the east end of the face tried to make their way out-bye by the intake, those towards the west by the return. Some had abandoned their lamps, which points to these having been extinguished either by the concussion due to the explosion (it was given in evidence that the shock occasioned by shot firing was frequently sufficient to extinguish Wolf lamps, the flame of which is "delicate") or by afterdamp-most likely the former.

A point difficult of explanation is the fact that Isaac Ratcliffe, the night-shift fireman in charge of the North Plodder district, did not apparently come out to the shaft to make his report on the morning of the explosion. The morning shift was allowed to go in-bye to the workings although they had not seen the fireman.

Ratcliffe's body was found in the North Plodder return not far from the face at a time when he should have been at the surface. He may, of course, have come out and recorded his report-the pages of the report book containing the last few days' reports are, as I have already stated, missing, and have not been recovered- and Rushton's initials are visible on the fragment of the last page, which would seem to point to Ratcliffe's having entered his report; but against this must be put the fact that he made no entry in the datallers' book for the night between the 20th and 21st December, whereas, according to records prior to the morning of the 21st December it was his custom to make such an entry.

The fact of Ratcliffe's remaining in-bye so long beyond his proper time is most suspicious. If he did come out-I do not think that he did-and returned in-bye, the suspicion of something having been wrong in the North Plodder would be strengthened. As to what kept him in-bye at the face can only be a matter of surmise; nothing was wrong with the conveyor, as I have shown. Gas may have come away in the heading in the No. 1 face, but, if so, why were the bodies of the men at the conveyor end found in the position they were? My own belief is that he had had trouble in the No. 2 face which had delayed him in getting round to the No. 1 face when making his final inspection before coming out by the return.

(vi.) Eccleston's place. — No one advanced this place as the possible site of the explosion, but inasmuch as during the sitting of my Inquiry, a lamp was found in this place in a defective condition (there were two small holes in the *bottom ring of the gauze) and presenting certain features in the way of discolouration which might have been indicative of excessive heating, added to the fact that this was a most likely place for the occurrence of gas, I deemed it necessary to investigate closely the possibility of its having been the originating point of the explosion. The lamp was, therefore, subjected to very severe tests, kindly carried out, under Mr. Pickering's direction, at the Leeds University.

* The bottom ring of gauze is a peculiarity of the Wolf lamp.

The tests were as follows

1. The lighted lamp was put into a still atmosphere containing 8 per cent. of Leeds town gas. There was a feeble explosion inside the lamp. The wick flame was extinguished, but the gas burned in the top gauze for a few seconds and then went out. This test was repeated eight times, with the same result.

2. The unlighted lamp was put into the same atmosphere and lighted with the internal match. The gas exploded sharply and audibly. It fired in the top part of the lamp first, but the flame immediately jumped to the bottom inlet gauze, where it burnt for three seconds and then went out. This test was repeated a second time, with the same result.

3. The unlighted lamp was put into a still atmosphere containing 10 per cent. of Leeds gas, and lighted with the internal igniter. The gas exploded sharply and audibly. It fired in the top part of the gauze first. The flame then jumped to the bottom inlet gauze and then back to the top gauzes. This repeated four times, and the flame then went out. The duration of the test was five seconds.

4. The lighted lamp was put into an air current having a velocity of 900 feet per minute and containing from 8 to 9 per cent. of benzene gas. The gas exploded in the lamp and continued to burn at the bottom inlet gauze for 4½ minutes. During this period, the air current was three times cut off and started again after an interval of 2 seconds. The current was then increased to 3,000 feet per minute. The gas burnt at the bottom gauze and the vapour from the oil vessel also fired. This was continued for 3½ minutes, and the test was then stopped. Thus the total duration of the test was 8 minutes.

5. The unlighted lamp was put into a current having a velocity of 900 feet and containing 8 per cent. of benzene gas. It was lighted by the internal match. The gas exploded inside the lamp and first burned at the bottom inlet gauze. The flame then jumped to the top gauze and jumped between the top and bottom several times. The lamp was then jerked with a wire. The gas continued to burn after several jerks, but eventually went out. The test lasted two minutes.

6. The lighted lamp was hung in the same current. The gas exploded in the lamp and burnt at the bottom inlet gauze. The flame occasionally jumped to the top gauze. The lamp was swung backwards and forwards twice, and a third swing was started with a jerk, when the gas went out. The duration of the test was 1½ minutes.

Mr. Pickering, in forwarding to me the accounts of these tests, remarks

"Everyone present was surprised that a lamp with such an obviously defective gauze should have passed such severe tests."

The position of the body of Eccleston would seem to negative the possibility of the explosion having occurred in his place. He had evidently left his lamp and walked a considerable distance away from his working place. Further, had the explosion occurred in Eccleston's place it is most improbable that the indications of force would have been such as they were.

(vii.) No. 2 Face, North Plodder Seam. — After a consideration of the evidence given before the Coroner, it was clear to me-as it appears to have been to all concerned in the matter-that the explosion did not originate in any of the Yard seam districts nor yet in the South Plodder. The evidence of force, with the exception of such slight indications as could be accounted for by the backlash which follows, but in a reverse direction, a wave of explosive force, pointed strongly to this conclusion. There were signs of burning extending for some distance into these districts, but both the evidence of force and that of heat declined the further in one went, until finally a point was reached where there were practically no such indications. The men engaged at work in the face had in some cases proceeded a short distance out-bye after the explosion, only to succumb to the deadly effects of carbonic oxide-others were found dead at the face.

I therefore directed my attention in particular to the Western side of the No. 3 mine, and on making a close inspection of the North jig, I was enabled, by mapping the indications of force still remaining, to trace the route followed by the explosive wave to its point of origin, namely, the point where the intake road for the No. 2 face of the North Plodder terminates.

The result of this investigation is set out on Plan III., and, with the exception of the positions of the bodies [the bodies had been recovered when I made my investigation], the indications are such as I witnessed. The position of the bodies I obtained from evidence at the Inquiry. It may be urged that when I visited the mine for the purpose named certain indications of force had been removed, and such may have been in a contrary direction to those set out in this Report. I would, however, reply that, from the evidence submitted to me-and I directed very great attention to this matter-such indications as had been removed were few in number, and the evidence I heard showed that they were not incapable of being used to support the indications which were left and which are shown on the plan.

The following facts are presented as tending to show that this point on No. 2 face was the place where the explosion originated

(1) A fall existed on the morning of the explosion at the in-bye end of the intake to No. 2 face, North Plodder (point 0 in Plan I.).

(2) Datallers were found at this spot in the positions shown in the sketch, Plan III. At the time of the explosion these persons were evidently engaged in clearing away ("ridding") this fall or the pack wall.

(3) The second fall, discovered after the explosion, may have been caused by the removal of the pack wall.

(4) One man buried by a fall was not burnt. The others were burnt.

(5) Evidence was given at the Inquiry that the roof up both Nos. 2 and 3 jigs showed signs of "weighting" the night preceding the explosion.

(6) When falls occurred in the North Plodder roof gas usually came off.

I do not, however, think the fact that after the explosion the No. 2 face of the North Plodder was the most difficult to approach on account of the great quantity of firedamp in that district should be adduced as an argument in favour of the explosion having been initiated in that district. It is the place where one would expect to find firedamp after such an event.

The great falls along the No. 2 face occurred, I think, after the explosion, and buried many of the workmen there, nearly all of whom showed signs of burning.

As to the cause of the explosion, I am of opinion that this was a safety lamp, either burning in gas and getting overheated, or being smashed, either by itself falling or by a fall. In support of the latter probability I would point to the incident mentioned by Mr. Pickering in his evidence at the Inquiry. He said, in answer to my question

Q. "Now, in the course of your experience Mr. Pickering, in investigating accidents and so on, which has been very extensive, have you ever heard of the case of an explosion of firedamp from a broken safety lamp ? — A. We had a case in my district last year at the Rotherham Main Colliery. It is worked a longwall-it is a longwall working, and in one of the working faces a goaf had broken down behind the working face, forming a very high cavity. There were three men working in the place, and one of them had just set his lamp on a prop close to the edge of the cavity. A large stone fell from the top of the cavity. It came down and knocked the prop out and smashed the lamp, and immediately an explosion followed. These three men were all burnt and they all died, but they were able to tell their mates what had happened, and the evidence was quite conclusive that the lamp had been broken and the explosion followed immediately. There is no doubt that the stone in falling brought down some gas out of the cavity. That place had been examined very shortly before by a deputy, and he had not found any gas. Of course, that is quite possible in a cavity in the goaf. It is not always safe for a man to climb up or get far enough in to find the gas, or it might be in a long, thin break in which he could not get up to do so.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page


A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z