III. The Explosion.
The explosion occurred at 7.50 a.m. on Wednesday morning the 21st of December. For a narrative of the earlier events I cannot do better than quote direct from the Proof of Evidence handed in by Mr. Tonge.
(a) Mr. Tonge's Narrative: "I was in my house and heard the report at about ten minutes to eight and was informed shortly after that there had been an explosion. When I got to the pit, I found smoke coming up the upcast shaft. I saw that a portion of the casing of the upcast shaft had been wrecked. I went forward to the downcast pit, and was informed by the mechanical engineer that one of the cages was fast in the shaft as the result of the explosion. There was no damage to the engine, and as the No. 3 shaft was quite out of the question for travelling purposes, we set to work to liberate the cage in the downcast. Fortunately, one of the cages appeared to be free, but it could not be brought up because the other cage was fast; we had to disconnect the rope of the cage that was fast from the drum, and after that the free cage was brought to the top. I got to the pit about ten minutes past eight, and the cage was free about nine o'clock.
"When we got the cage working, I took five men in the single cage and went quietly down, calling at the Trencherbone mine. Llewellyn Williams, the Under-Manager of the Trencherbone mine, was at the mouthing, and I asked if all the men were right there. He said, 'Yes. They had suffered from fumes, but everything was clear then.' I took him with me in the cage and then went further on. On our way down, we encountered obstacles in the shaft-broken signal-wires and bearers-and we were in considerable alarm as to whether the cage was going to stick or not. But it kept freeing itself and broke through all the obstacles. We got to the Yard mouthing, and, on going in, saw the underground fan blown inwards towards the downcast pit. Going forward through the electric haulage house, which was on the main route to the upcast shaft bottom, we found great wreckage, and got through into the No. 3 pit-bottom shunts, where we found a boy. There was afterdamp and it was hot, but we went forward. We picked up the boy and sent him back up the pit. Going forward, we found a man (Byers) struggling, and we carried him to the cage. I looked about and found more dead bodies lying about, and then decided to go down and see how the Arley men were. We first took the injured man up to the top and then set out immediately to go to the Arley mine. Having passed the Yard mine, I heard a shout: 'Send the cage to the Yard mouthing!' which was repeated mechanically over and over again. We had been at the Yard mouthing and I could not understand it, but I remembered that it would be at another Yard mouthing, about eight yards lower than the proper mouthing, where we had a travelling road to some pumps. I knocked the cage up to this mouthing, and found the source of the noise. It was a lad from the workshops-Staveley. We got out and lifted him up, and asked him what he had been doing, and were there any more. He said there was a lad close to him, dead. We took him to the top and then went down to the Arley, again having difficulty, as the cage kept sticking and freeing itself. We called at the Three-Quarters mine going down. Some of the men had made their way to the Three-Quarters mouthing in the shaft, which is not used, instead of going down the tunnel and getting to the Arley mouthing. We asked if they were all right and they replied that they were and wanted to go up. I said there were others in a worse position than they, and they must be patient.
"When we got to the Arley, we found a regular pandemonium. Men were crying to come up and crying because they were ill with the fumes. Men were waving their comrades' arms about; some were worse affected than others, and the Under-Manager, John Bullough, was amongst them, calling upon them to be men, and doing what he could. Do as we would we could not get quietness. I shouted to those round about: 'Put those men who are ill in the cage, and the strong keep back!' I feared a panic and that the men would rush to the cage and seize the ropes or anything, but fortunately they did not. The men who were ill were put in the cage and taken to the top.' I went with the cage back to the Yard, taking others with me, and sent the cage to the Arley to fetch another load. The Arley and Trencherbone men were all got out safely and we soon had a fair number of men down in the Yard mine rescuing.
"Six of the Trencherbone men, five of whom had been in the cage at the Trencherbone mouthing when the explosion occurred, were raised to the surface after the suffering Arley men and the other Trencherbone men were all got out last. It was all done with the one cage, signalling by knocking on the cage, as the proper signalling apparatus was broken down. There was no mishap whatever in getting the whole of the 545 men out, and we had them all out in about 3½ hours
"After getting down into the Yard mine again, I took a few men and went on the East level, where we found a fire at the air-crossing. I left instructions for the fire to be put out, and went forward with two men to the down brow. I also instructed Turton and Stott, two reliable men, to proceed a short distance up the Plodder tunnel to see if there were any fires, and if so, to report. I then went forward down the down-brow, and at the bend of the brow, after calling out, heard a man respond. This man was able to give me his name as Devonport. I gave him a drink, and sent a man back for the stretcher and a doctor. Doctors Lee and Russell had come down with us in the cage. Devonport was carried out on the stretcher and taken to the surface. As the falls were so bad further on in the down-brow I decided to return to the pit, and it was there reported to me by Messrs. Turton and Stott that they had found a fire and had not put it out. I asked them to return to it to do so but to be very careful of the fumes. I returned to the air-crossing on the East Level where the men were still engaged in putting out the fire. By this time, Mr. Gerrard, H.M. Inspector of Mines, and several mining engineers had arrived at this spot. It was decided to restore the air-crossing. At about this time news was brought to me that Turton, the fireman who had been sent to put out the fire, had been overcome by the fumes. We did what was possible for him and he was sent to the surface. The next operation was the restoring of the air-crossing over the No. 1 East Jig, with a view to getting the air circulating in its former courses into the North Plodder, Top Yard, and Three-Quarters districts. After restoring this, the air-crossing over the North Plodder Jig was restored. The only ventilation that was being effected in the mines was a natural ventilation combined with a little assisted ventilation, due to the continuous running of the Trencherbone fan, all the rest of the fans having been put out of operation by the force of the explosion. The stand-by surface fan was intact, but the casing on the pit top was damaged and was being put right. This was completed early and the surface fan was ready to run in 9¼ hours after the accident. After restoring the air-crossing over the North Plodder Jig, which gave the ventilation a chance to get into three important districts, I went along with the inspectors and other engineers to consult with a Consultative Committee on the surface. It was decided not to put the fan into operation as there was still some doubt as to whether there was any fire in the mine. Returning down the mine, we again went into the down-brow and fixed a tight cloth stopping in the brow with a view to forcing the air into the down-brow workings. The finishing touches to this operation were effected by the men with the 'rescue' apparatus. Shortly after this, Mr. Gerrard, myself, and a few others decided to make an inspection of the Three-Quarters mine thinking it possible that a few of these men, being near the shaft, might be still living, and that it would be possible to bring them relief. We went in at the in-take end and were able to get into the workings and out by the haulage road to the pit, having found about a dozen bodies and having become convinced that there was no one alive in that mine. Shortly after this we returned to the surface, and it was decided to start the surface fan. The fan was actually started at 5 minutes past 6, and after allowing it to have about half-an-hour's run we again descended the mine."
Having been informed that men trained in the use of breathing apparatus had arrived on the scene at an early hour, I failed to see why their services had not been requisitioned for extinguishing the fire at which poor Turton lost his life. For the purpose of further probing this matter, I, towards the end of the Inquiry, recalled Mr. Tonge. His explanation was as follows
"I remember now, and I have checked it by one or two friends who were able to tell me, the exact time that the rescuers got down to the pit, which was between half-past 9 and 20 minutes to 10-I mean to say the men with the rescue apparatus. At that time I had already been into the Arley and into the pit where Staveley was, and I had been on the top to take Byers or one of the other men, and I had also been down into the down-brow. I remember quite distinctly now that instructions were given to Turton and Stott the second time while I was in the down-brow, they came to see me in the down-brow, and that I then told them to go back to the fire to put it out. I remember I did not see the rescue men until I got back to the air-crossing where Mr. Gerrard and other managers were, so that that was the first time I had seen the rescue men; therefore it was impossible for me to send the rescue men to do that work before that time, and I may just say further that I am very much inclined to think that Turton himself did not die from after-damp. The doctor has often asked me what I really thought he died from, because there was little symptom, if any, of carbon monoxide poisoning, and I am inclined to think it was more from shock and exhaustion, and that really the danger just there was not quite so great as might be imagined.
By Mr. ELLIS: Q. "Just arising from that, what had Turton been doing the previous night ? — A. I could not say.
Q. "Had he been working the previous night?"-A. "He did not work in the night.
By Mr. REDMAYNE: Q. "I think we had it from the other men Stott was overcome also ? — A. Yes, I recognise that, but I think it came in pushes there. I do not think the air was quite always the same, and when they went in I do not think it was as bad as after they had been in some little time. It was just that little explanation I wished to make.
Mr. ELLIS: "I think Mr. Tonge means Turton had been working the night before.
Mr. SMILLIE: "I would like to call your attention to the fact that Stott was further in, nearer the face, and Turton let the lamp fall first, and then Stott in fact gave his own lamp to Turton, and Turton let it fall, proving that it was not having the effect in Stott which it evidently had on Turton.
Mr. REDMAYNE: "I have known a man fall beside me overcome with afterdamp, and I have not felt the slightest effect.
Mr. TONGE: "I think the doctor's evidence is that Turton did not show carbon monoxide poisoning."
This is the first time that squads of men trained in the use of breathing apparatus have been available for colliery rescue work on short notice. In this case their services were available within one hour of the occurrence of the explosion, and from then onwards they worked unremittingly; and though, unfortunately, they were not the means of saving the lives of any of the entombed miners, it is quite probable that they were the means of preventing loss of life during the work of reclamation of the mine.
The opinion of some of the mining engineers who gave evidence may be quoted :-
Mr. Leach said
"Oh! it is beyond all conception their advantage. I am bound to say I was a little bit sceptical about their use, but they have been of immense use in this instance. You cannot calculate what advantage they have been; they may not have saved lives, but they certainly have saved an enormous amount of time, and they saved a good deal of men being gassed. There is no doubt about that. I cannot speak too highly of their work. On the first day, on the Wednesday, I went down the pint with Mr. Walker, Mr. Tonge, and Mr: Gerrard, and at that time we were very much afraid of an underground fire, and we tried to get up the Jig towards the South Plodder, and it was crammed full of after-damp. Two rescue teams came up, and, under instructions from Mr. Gerrard and Mr. Tonge, went right to the top, travelled on each side as far as the fall, and came back and reported all right. That was an enormous relief to the minds of the management, because, as you know, if there had been any fire it would be very unwise to put on the fan; we might have had another explosion. That is only one instance of the work they did.
Q. "Although they were not unfortunately able to save life, because there was no life to save, we do not know, do we, but what they were able to prevent loss of life ? — A. I think it not at all unlikely, and I am certain they saved a good many men from being gassed and they saved a tremendous loss of time. This mine has been opened out in almost unprecedented short time, and it is very largely owing to the valuable help of the rescue men.
Q. "Then you would advocate an extension of rescue teams ? — A. Undoubtedly, I am a great believer of it now.
Q. "I am very glad to hear that ? — A. They have been very much more valuable in this work than I thought they would have been. I do not look to them so much for rescuing lives in many places, but I think they will be valuable in preventing loss of life, and be a great help in fires and explosions like this.
Q. "Always provided, I suppose you would say, always provided that they are properly organised and properly captained, and not allowed to do anything foolish ? — A. Well, I think the Howe Bridge Station is an example to the rest of the Kingdom in the method in which they have trained their men."
Mr. Walker said
"I agree entirely with what Mr. Leach said. Practically I made the same remarks at the Inquiry before the Coroner, and I can speak from having had to re-open a mine where the explosion was quite as disastrous as it has been in this case without the aid of a rescue team; and it is a most difficult matter in restoring the ventilation, men constantly having to go into the gas getting the bratticing and getting the pipes in, constantly being overcome by the gas, and, of course, that delayed the recovery tremendously. I think every colliery district should be provided with a rescue team.
Q. "I am very glad to hear that ? — A. They are invaluable in cases of this kind."
Sergeant-Major Hill, who was in charge of the Howe Bridge Rescue Station, heard of the disaster by telephone at 8.5 a.m. He at once telegraphed to the motor garage at Leigh for a motor which arrived at the Rescue Station at 8.17 a.m.; at 8.25 a.m. he had left with sets of the emergency apparatus and supplies, and arriving at the colliery at 8.40 a.m., found and reported himself to Mr. Tonge at 8.45 a.m.
At the colliery a team of five had qualified in the use of the apparatus; of these one was killed in the explosion, one was on the sick list, and two were in the Arley mine, the only man immediately available being John Hunt. He was at home, but proceeded to the mine and reported himself at 8.55 a.m.
About 9 a.m., Mr. Clement Fletcher, of Fletcher, Burrows and Company's Collieries, a qualified member of this rescue team, arrived with two others from his colliery; these at once put on the apparatus and descended the colliery at 9.20 a.m. These men were used to help to extinguish fires; first, a fire in the haulage engine house near to No. 4 (the downcast) shaft; secondly, a fire near to the main air crossing, east of No. 4 shaft. It was whilst so engaged that two members of the party were called upon to fetch out of the noxious fumes William Turton-afterwards found to be dead-who, with Abraham Stott, had been engaged in extinguishing a third fire near the top of the South Plodder tunnel.
About 40 men, with breathing apparatus, had arrived at the mine by 11 a.m. During the day there were altogether about 148 trained men at the mine. A room set apart for their use was called the Rescue Station, and Sergeant-Major Hill, with whom was his assistant, J. G. Huskisson, was in charge. Dr. Arnold Green, Medical Adviser, constantly advised and rendered help, and Mr. Arthur Ellis, the secretary to the Rescue Station Committee showed untiring zeal in arranging details. Mr. Charles Pilkington, the Chairman, together with members of the Committee, were constant in their attendance in the early days following the explosion.
It was arranged, as far as possible, that the rescue squads should not be underground for periods of more than two hours. It was difficult, however, to keep within this limit. Every team had with it a bird in a cage.
Of the 345 persons who descended the mine only two survived, so that, with Turton, who died in the rescue operations, the death roll amounted to 344. The positions in the mine in which the bodies were found are shown in black lettering on the Plan II. Where the persons so found have moved, their position at the time of the explosion are indicated by the same numbers in red.
The cause of death of each person, with name and tally number, is given in Appendix D.
A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.