Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
Index

II. Conditions Prevailing At The No. 3 Mine On The Day Of The Explosion And For Some Time Prior Thereto.

(c) The weighting of the Roof and the occurrence of a tall at No. 2 face, North Plodder. — Mr. Tonge said that on the morning of the explosion, and for some days previous thereto, a man, Richard Wild, and his two sons were engaged in working at a fall at the top of the intake to the No. 2 face, making the inlet to the face larger and clearing a fall that had been there. The cutter had never cut right across the face to the end. He explained the reason of this as follows: "There was," he said "a bit of face here that had been got before, and up to the time of the explosion it had always been slightly in advance of the working face, and it had been worked from this road. The working place of this road, so to speak, was slightly in advance of the coal, and they were engaged in just ripping out there in order to enable the cutter to go right across to the side." He could not tell me how high the fall was. He did not think gas had been found at the fall. He had not heard that it had, but he would not be surprised if gas had been discovered there.

The evidence of Alfred Teasdale, a dataller, who was working up the No. 2 and No. 3 jigs on the afternoon of the day preceding the explosion, bore out in large measure what Mr. Tonge had stated. He said a fall took place there on the Sunday night of the week of the explosion. He did not see it himself as he was working on the right side of No. 2 jig, but he heard that it was about 20 yards long, and the fact that a fall had taken place was common knowledge "right through the mine." It occurred at the far end of "No. 2 face coming towards the airhole." Teasdale was "working underneath the same place on the Thursday night before it happened, and the roof was very bad then; we didn't venture to go in. We had to push our spades as far as we could and then fill it (the fallen stone).

Paul Garswood, the dataller who was down the pit the night before the explosion, received orders to go and put up timbering at the top of Nos. 2 and 3 jigs, No. 3 first, as it was "on weight"; but as they could not find the tools for the purpose, the fireman I Ratcliffe, said they had better leave it, and he would see the day fireman "about getting the bars (timber) at the top of both jigs for you in the daytime," so Garswood went on to the face. After working on the face for some time Garswood said that he and others were ordered to roll up the cable in No. 3 jig before they went out, the subsequent proceedings are best recounted in witness's own words

"I said: 'I will show you.' So I pulled my lamp down and held it up about on a line of my chest, and it was plain to be seen there (i.e., the gas). I said Come on, we will be getting out.' So we came on the level, and was discussing things in general, came down the jig and on to the East level, and out to the main jig, No. 1 jig, the No. 1 brow, North Plodder brow. And just as we turned into the brow there was several fellows dropped in behind us that was coming down from the top of the brow. They was discussing the gas that had been up there all through the shift, and of course I do not know whether it was Cunliffe or whether it was Wigglesworth, it was one of them, but the voice appeared to be Cunliffe, saying like about how many lamps he had had put out, and how many times he had had them put out, and about Isaac Ratcliffe leaving him the keys at the finish.

Q. "So there was gas, you saw gas up the face of No. 3 jig ? — A. Half-way up No. 3 jig.

Q. "Half-way up ? — A. Against a caunch, like, a caunch there.

Q. "Did it fill your lamp ? — A. Well, it was right above the glass, a streak upwards, practically almost the width of the light. The light was low, you know, but almost the width of the tube, and, of course, I mentioned to Houghton when we were going past Eccleston's level. I said: 'Whatever you do Jim, never go on there."

Q. "And you came along the East level? Where did you get out of gas, what point did you get out of gas ? — Out of gas.

Q. Yes ? — A. We came away from it, in fact we got out of it as we came past Eccleston's level, I should say, or as we got to the bottom of the jig. Probably there would be a little against the roof as far down as the brattice cloth.

Q. "And then you came along and went up into the No. 1 jig, and there you saw the men coming out ? — A. They was coming down, they was coming down from the North Plodder, from the direction of the heading."

According to this man's evidence there must have been a quantity of gas coming off, due, in all probability, to the weighting. He had worked at the top of the intake to No. 2 face nine or ten days before the explosion, when he described it "as a bit broken at the left, up in the corner, the roof was a bit broken, and on the weight a little bit . . . it was kind of breaking itself up, you see, so he (Ratcliffe) sent me along to clear this so that the cutter could come along to get towards it." There was no gas there then. He agreed that it was not unusual for gas to be given off when any roof was on weight.

On the morning of the explosion Garswood went to the top of the intake of No. 2 face and saw, so he informed me, that the datallers who were working there would have to remove the pack-wall in order to straighten the road " in order that the intake can be got right into the corner of the face." Such removal of support would be conducive to a fall taking place if temporary supports were not put in to keep up the roof.

The probable presence of gas at Eccleston's place on the morning of the explosion was borne out by the evidence of Peter Gallagher, a collier, who would have gone to that place on the morning before the explosion, but for the fact of there being some "dirt" in it-about eight tubs. It had gas in it which had not cleared out by morning, because when he left the fireman, Thomas, told us it was just "the same." Gallagher was not at work on the morning of the explosion because of a domestic event. An expression attributed to I. Ratcliffe by Gallagher is ominous, if true: when Gallagher told him "there was some dirt down" in Eccleston's place. Ratcliffe, he says, remarked "we are in for it." The fireman very properly prohibited Gallagher and Eccleston returning to the place.

To sum up: It is clear to me that there was gas in Eccleston's place on the morning before the explosion and probably on the night before the explosion, and that it was this gas which Paul .Garswood encountered in coming out by No. 3 jig. Eccleston was at work in his place and was killed therein on the day of the explosion-whether there was then gas in it or not no one can say.

It is clear that, not only was the roof near the top of No. 3 jig weighting, but it is extremely likely that roof at the top of the intake to the No. 2 face was in like condition. I lean to the view that the roof right along the No. 2 face was in a very unstable state, and that heavy falls took place there immediately prior to, and subsequent to, the explosion.

Mr. H. Roughley, the local Miners' Agent, who paid a visit to the No. 2 face of the North Plodder about three weeks before the date of the explosion, said "it was very nice, I thought, a cross the face."

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page


A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z