Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
Index

II. Conditions Prevailing At The No. 3 Mine On The Day Of The Explosion And For Some Time Prior Thereto.

(b) The occurrences of gas in different parts of the mine immediately prior to the explosion. — In this respect the most important factors are the occurrence of gas under normal conditions and the liability to the sudden issue of gas. It has already been stated that the part of the mine most liable to the occurrence of gas was the Top Yard, owing largely to the proximity of a large fault cutting off the face, and that the men who were sent back home on account of gas worked at that face. The small district in the Three-Quarters seam gave trouble for a time until a "tunnel" had been driven through the fault, giving a more effective airway to the district. In the North Plodder gas was often found in Eccleston's and Brown's places, and these were reported as "fenced off for gas" on several occasions.

At the time of the explosion Brown's place was not being worked for coal as there was a fall in it.

Taking the month of December, I give in Appendix A the entries in the reports of the firemen. Unfortunately I am only able to give complete entries up to 2.45 p.m. on December 8th owing to the succeeding pages being torn or missing. The hook was found, after the explosion, in the Under-Manager's Office near the shaft in the No. 3 pit, and it had been subjected to both heat and violence. I understand that a most rigorous search has failed to disclose the missing pages.

There was only one official report*of a man having been gassed. and that was in the heading at the North Plodder No. 1 face. This certainly was the place in the No. 1 North Plodder most likely to contain gas. It was 12 yards wide and was usually kept 17 yards in advance of the face. A fall of roof took place in this heading on December 4th, and it was not until about a week before the date of the explosion (according to the evidence of Shaw, the afternoon fireman in charge of Nos. 1 and 2 faces, North Plodder) that it was quite cleared away, which points to its having been of considerable extent. Two men were engaged in clearing away this fall and in improving the airway at the side of the heading. Covering timber had been put up, and the men were engaged in packing stones on this, and so filling in the cavity caused by the fall. Whilst engaged in this work one of the men, George Houghton, was, about a fortnight before the explosion, gassed and rendered unconscious for a short time. The cavity would be an extensive one, seeing that the fall was 3 or 4 feet thick and 5 or 6 yards long, and the filling had proceeded for half the distance. Houghton put his head into the hole whilst packing and got gassed. The fireman Shaw knew there was gas there as he had warned the men about the accumulation. He said, "If they had worked to my instructions they would not have been in gas, because they were on the intake side." But the gas should have been removed by hanging a canvas sheet (a "jump cloth" as it is called) across the place and forcing the air up into the cavity to clear out the gas. No one should have been allowed to work in the place until the gas had been removed. It is not sufficient to say that the datallers, inasmuch as they were filling in the cavity, were there for the purpose of removing the gas.

* i.e., "official" in so far as it is stated to have occurred by a fireman in charge of the district, but whether it was entered in the Report Book or not I cannot say, as the page which would contain the entry if made is missing. The Report Book had been subjected to both heat and violence, and I have no doubt whatever that the explosive blast which killed the Under Manager (Rushton) whilst he was sitting in his office, also tore out the missing pages of the book and swept them away.

Clarence Boothroyd, a dataller, working usually in the cross-heading (East level) and Nos. 2 and 3 jigs of the North Plodder, was once up the No. 1 face, the occasion being 8 or 9 days before the explosion. When going into that part of the district, and when 8 or 9 yards before reaching the point at which the conveyor delivers into the tubs, he entered gas which put out his lamp and the lamps of others that were with him in the main body of the return air. He was working in the East level when he and Paul Garswood were ordered to go and "help Jack Winrow at the top of the North Plodder (i.e., No. 1 face), so it would be perhaps between 11 and a quarter past, I daresay" when they got to the spot named and their lamps went out.

Q. "All your lamps ? — A. Mine and my mates.

Q. "You came back in the dark ? — A. Yes, Sir.

Q. "Where did you get to ? — A. We only went a few yards down when Jack Winrow shouted to us. He said: 'Who is that there ?' and Paul Garswood, my mate that night, he says: 'It's me and my mate. We 'have both lost our lights.' 'Hold on,' he says, 'I will come and show you your road.' He came down to us. He says: 'Whoever sent you up here Paul Garswood said: 'Why, Isaac Ratcliffe.' 'Well,' he says, 'this is a caution. He won't come this way himself. He knows I fill this brow with gas every night.'

Mr. ELLIS: "Who said this? — A. Jack Winrow.

Mr. ELLIS: "He is alive, Sir.

Mr. REDMAYNE: "I see.

THE WITNESS: "So we went up again. Of course, Jack Winrow had come down to us then.

Q. "Where from ? — A. From the conveyor bench.

Q. "From the conveyor face ? — A. Yes.

Q. "He had come through the gas ? — A. Yes, he had come down to us.

Q. "He came through the gas with his light out ? — A. No, he had his light in.

Q. "But he came to you through gas that put your lights out ? — A. He had put a brattice down before he came to us. When we were coming up he had just fixed the cloth up.

Q. "Where were you when you met Jack Winrow? How many yards would you be back from the conveyor face ? — A. We would be,. I daresay, about 14 or 15 yards below the conveyor face.

Q. "There you had the full current of air that was coming round that face on you, all the air that goes round that conveyor face would come on to you ? — A. Would come down the brow, yes.

Q. "And brought down the gas that put your lights out ? — A. Yes." Paul Garswood bore out this statement. He said

"I got my orders to go to No. 2 Jig and I had two men with me that night, my brother and Boothroyd. We got fresh orders to send my brother Frank at the back of the cutter and take Boothroyd and go and help Winrow up this big fall. We were going up and got very near the conveyor bench where the conveyor comes out and I heard someone-of course, I guessed who it was-knocking. As a bit of a joke I said: 'You need not start knocking,' I said, 'because someone is coming.' Then my light went out. I turned round. I said: 'Go on, keep down your head, go on down the brow.' His light went out next. I says: 'Go on, never mind, keep your head down, 'chuck the spade away,' and I was carrying the pick and put it down. He says: 'There are tubs here, I cannot get on.' ' Go on,' I said, 'I can smell this gas,' it was that strong."

Q. "You can smell gas, can you ? — Oh! certainly, yes.

Q. "What is the smell like ? — A. I do not know whether you have ever handled new brattice cloth ?"

Q. "Yes ? — A. Well, it is similar to that to me.

Q. "All right ? — A. A tickling sensation in the nostrils, especially when very strong, as this was, so Winrow commenced shouting. He says: 'What's up? Stop there, I will come and fetch you.' I should think he was about a couple of minutes before he came down. He came down with his lamp low; he turned it fairly low, not as low as he could have turned it, but fairly low. He said: 'I did not know you were coming up there.' I told him we had fresh orders to come there. 'Well,' he said, 'had you been a few minutes 'later you would not have got past the East level, it fills the brow to there'; so we came back on the bench. This here brattice was down then.

Q. "This is Winrow who said all this ? — A. Winrow said this. We came back on the bench to where he had pulled this brattice cloth down again and I lit my lamp and I lit Boothroyd's lamp, and he said: 'Well, you had 'better send Charley down the pit. Charley had better go on to the face with the other fellows, getting bottoms up, and you and me will put this brattice up again, and then we had better go on for half-an-hour or so so as to give it a chance to shift this gas out.' So I sawed a prop so that we could fasten this brattice up. There was a prop on the lower side and a prop on the higher side of this conveyor bench, so I sawed a prop to go into the middle of it and we put the cloth up, and we went on for about half-an-hour. When we had been getting bottoms up for about half au-hour, he said: 'We will go and see how the place is.' So Winrow climbed under the brattice cloth and I went after him and got under, and Winrow tried his lamp and there was still a little gas to be seen, so we sat there for about five minutes on out-bye side of the brattice cloth. Then we got down on the brow again and eventually got on again to the bottom of the fall to where it has tapered down to a feather edge like, so Winrow turned his light very low and commenced to climb up in front of him up this fall, and there was too much gas up there still, so we came back again towards the bench for a minute or two, but eventually we got up to the top of the fall. We turned our lamps low, close to where this small amount of air was coming through the coal, close to the face, and our duty was throwing the coal on the top of this pack, and we had to come out several times to have better air.

Q. "That is the whole episode ? — A. That is all that we did that night."

This was the Paul Garswood who relit lamps without being authorised to do so. Neither of these men could give definite dates nor name the day on which the incident happened; but John Winrow, the dataller who worked at timbering behind the conveyor in the No. 1 North Plodder face, to whom they both alluded in their story, explained that it was about three weeks or a month before the explosion when the tall took place; and that, whilst the fall was there, in order to keep the place clean he used to hang up a brattice cloth so as to force the air over the fall and clear the gas out into the return, and in the morning he used to pull the brattice down again.

The effect of the bratticing was evidently to drive the gas in a body on to the incoming men and to put their lights out. Winrow went to them "and brought them back to this brattice and Paul Garswood stopped for about ten minutes or a quarter of an hour, or happen twenty minutes, on the conveyor bench, and then he comes off and gets on to the top of the fall and starts chucking the dirt on to the timber behind it, and we stopped there all that night, me and Paul did, and his brother went on to the cutter." Since the fall was removed and the packing completed Winrow said he had never seen gas in the place.

The packing of stone on top of covering timber is a usual and effective method of filling up a cavity in the roof. Gas would still lurk in the interstices of the packing just as it would in the crevices in the roof where there had been no fall. Gas would undoubtedly occur in this heading, given off from the coal, and its amount in that place would depend entirely on the extent of the ventilation. Judging from my inspection of the place after the explosion I should say there would be very little indeed in the "body" of the air, as what air current there was was sufficient to dispel it.

Shaw, the afternoon-shift fireman, said that on the Friday night before the "explosion" (i.e., five days before the explosion) there was a "slight trace" in the covering timber. He stated also that there was not a canvas sheet across the delivery end of the conveyor on the night preceding the explosion. At the same time, seeing that he had fired shots in the floor in the heading that same night (which he had not done whenever there was gas) it would seem to point to its being clean at that time.

Several persons working in the No. 1 North Plodder spoke as to there having been gas in the heading on the night before the explosion, but on close investigation I find their statements do not hang together. George Ratcliffe, the man in charge of the mechanical coal cutters, whose manner of giving evidence favourably impressed me, was the last man who left the No. 1 face on the morning of the explosion, viz., at 6.40 or 6.45 a.m. He said that he had not heard of complaints from anyone as to there being gas there then, and that he would in all probability have done so if any complaint had been made owing to his position on the face-there were men working in the heading-neither did he know of any lights having been put out, with the exception of Cunliffe's. He went to his supper at the heading at 5 minutes past 2 a.m., no lights were put out then and no complaints made as to gas; all the men who worked on the cutter face (or in the heading) were sitting having their supper in the heading, where they always partook of it.

He put his clothes on in the heading prior to going out-bye-he was about 4 yards into it-he saw no gas, "it was quite clear," and there were three colliers further in nearer the face of it, and he observed that their lights burned all right, they were taking off their clothes preparatory to commencing work.

It was pointed out that from the Thursday night the week before the explosion until the following Monday morning the conveyor was not in operation. I have satisfied myself that this fact cannot be attributed to there having been anything wrong with the electrical connections, for when W. Singleton came out on the morning of the explosion there was "nothing wrong at all." Jos. Miller, who made the road for the cutter, also said all was right on the face that night.

G. Ratcliffe said he was unable to cut on No. 1 face from the Thursday until the Monday, because he understood the conveyor had broken down. The conveyor would not, of course, under normal circumstances be operated until the coal filling in the morning shift, but it worked on the Tuesday and it appears to have been in order for working on the Wednesday.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page


A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z