Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
Index

Part VI

Lessons And Recommendations (cont.)

Recommendations

285. The problem of ensuring safety in tips arises in relation to:

(a) tips owned by the National Coal Board, whether now in use or disused:

(b) tips not owned by the National Coal Board; and

(c) the siting and control of tipping operations for all future tips.

286. The Tribunal have had to consider a large number of recommendations put forward by different parties. They have varied from the simple to the extremely complex, and in our view it is the simplest that would be most likely to be successful. The team of experts instructed by the Treasury Solicitor to assist the Tribunal begin their recommendations by insisting on all colliery tips being treated as engineering structures. They therefore suggest that the site investigation for a new tipping area or for the extension of an existing tip complex should be under the direction of a civil engineer experienced in soil mechanics. This approach (with which we entirely agree) is of fundamental importance. From this it would follow that:

(1) Maps prepared by Ordnance Survey and Geological Survey should first be looked at;

(2) A site investigation by using borings, soil-testing and observations of ground-water level should be carried out by a civil engineer, in consultation with a geologist and mining engineer or surveyor (regarding subsidence) where necessary;

(3) On the basis of this data, engineering proposals should be made by the civil engineer for the tip, including (where necessary) drainage and compaction;

(4) While the tipping process is continuing, the stability aspect should be under the control of a civil engineer;

(5) When tipping has been completed, inspection by a civil engineer should continue thereafter and routine measurements and observations made and recorded;

(6) The basic information so obtained should be placed on permanent record and be available to the local authority or to any person reasonably requiring it.

287. Professor Bishop and his colleagues make the important point that, "The present investigation has been concerned primarily with the causes of the failure of one particular tip, rather than with the examination of the possible hazards involved under other geological conditions, with rubbish or tailings of different geological origins, and placed by other methods". They therefore recommend that a National Tip Safety Committee be set up by the appropriate Minister to report on (inter alia):

(1) the standards of safety to be called for in circumstances varying from large tips near inhabited property to small tips in remote areas;

(2) which of the observations and investigations begun during the present Inquiry should be continued, whether under the sponsorship of the National Coal Board, the Science Research Council, the National Environmental Research Council, or otherwise;

(3) What other lines of investigation should be followed up, involving field observations or laboratory investigations relevant to the safety aspects of both old and new tips;

(4) What hazards (if any) are involved in the present methods of disposing in bulk of industrial waste products of every kind.

288. Professor Bishop further recommended that, in order to ensure that only suitably qualified engineers are employed for site investigation, a Panel of Approved Engineers should be established on lines similar to those set up under the Reservoirs (Safety Provisions) Act, 1930, as amplified in a Report on Reservoir Safety by the Institution of Civil Engineers in 1966. We place on record this latter representation, but we do not ourselves either endorse or reject it. We had described to us a little of the operation of the 1930 Act, but not enough to justify us in inviting Ministers to follow it as a precedent; indeed, we were told that the Act requires amendment in a number of respects and that the 1966 Report just referred to contains provisions for its revision.

289. Nevertheless, it is to be observed that both Professor Bishop's team and the National Coal Board concur in advocating the establishment of a National Tip Safety Committee upon or before which all interested parties could be represented. We too recommend that the appropriate Minister should consider appointing such a Committee to advise him in the exercise of his responsibility for the safety and inspection of all tips, whether or not they are connected with mines or quarries. We do so for the following reason: The problem of tip stability is not by any means confined to coal-tips or even to coal-tips in the ownership of the National Coal Board. We have read that there are some 16,000 acres of derelict land in Wales alone, and that privately-owned tips comprise more than one half of this wasteland. And, as Mr. Philip Wien, Q.C., observed ". . . as regards tips not in the ownership of the Board, there may be several categories; (1) tips belonging to other mining and quarrying interests; (2) tips belonging to industries not concerned with mining at all — for example, electricity authorities, steel works; and (3) the abandoned tips in the ownership of local authorities or private individuals". The proper constitution of the proposed National Tip Safety Committee would fall to be decided by the Ministers concerned after due consideration of the variety of interests involved. No doubt they would draw upon the fund of experience available in the Building Research Station and the Road Research Laboratory and the professional Institutions.

290. Nevertheless, we strongly favour that the National Coal Board should continue to have prime responsibility in respect of all tips in its ownership. It has within its own organisation men of sufficient experience and qualifications to take all steps necessary for securing tip stability. Such dangers as arise are almost invariably in respect of active, working tips, and to take responsibility for their day-to-day management from the Board and vest it in any other body seems to us undesirable and even charged with dangerous possibilities. As the expert witness called on behalf of the Parents' and Residents' Association (Mr. Wardell) said:

"The disposal of refuse and the consequent problem of tip stability cannot be dissociated from the many other problems involved in the production of the nation's coal. The National Coal Board is fundamentally involved, firstly, from a policy point of view, because it has to assess the economic consequences of alternative methods of refuse disposal, and, secondly, from a technical point of view, in that it has to provide essential information about the nature and quantity of materials which have or may have to be disposed of and (because of possible statutory and Common Law liabilities) to make its own investigations and judgments about refuse-tip stability".

Accordingly, subject to the further recommendations which we hereafter set out, we consider that the public interest is best served by prime responsibility for National Coal Board tips remaining with the Board, which would at all times have available to it the advice of the National Tip Safety Committee. The Board could in return render valuable assistance to that Committee in relation to tips outside their ownership or control and (according to Hansard, Vol. 747, 6 June, 1967, col. 173-4) they already "have arranged courses of instruction in soil-heap management which are now being held throughout the country, and have offered specialist advice and assistance to local authorities and private owners in regard to spoil-heaps which are not the Board's responsibility".

291. We are attracted by, and recommend adoption of, the suggestion made by Sir Andrew Bryan that the National Coal Board should prepare for consideration by the National Tip Safety Committee, with a view to its thereafter being issued publicly, a Code of Practice giving guidance on (a) features and factors that may give rise to or reveal instability in a tip, and (b) standards of safety called for in particular locations or circumstances. We attach in Appendix F Sir Andrew Bryan's suggestions as to the topics which should be covered by such a Code. But the vexed question remains: Within the National Coal Board itself, what organisation should in future be responsible for tip safety and stability? We were told that during the Inquiry the lay-out of Board administration had been drastically altered, that Divisions and Groups had already been abolished and the whole country divided into 17 Areas, each headed by its own Area Director, and that the old South Western Division had become two Areas. And it was said in Parliament on June 6th last (Hansard Vol. 747, col. 173-4) that the Minister of Power had ascertained from the National Coal Board that, "A procedure has been established by the Board for technical and operational control over spoil heaps which includes frequent and regular investigations by specialists to ensure safety and stability". Furthermore, Mr. Wien, Q.C., told the Tribunal that in South Wales:

". . . . we have recently established a Tip Control Unit under the direction of Mr. Gareth Jones, the civil engineer, and he has got a complete team with independent experts to be consulted about old tips. They will give technical guidance to Areas on active tips or on the selection of new tips, and I daresay that when the Tip Safety Committee comes into existence this will be a matter that will be carefully considered by that Committee . . . The Coal Board has been proceeding assiduously with training courses which have been held quite recently and all kinds of people (from Area Directors downwards, and including Area Civil Engineers from the rest of the country and Her Majesty's Divisional Inspector of Mines) have attended, dealing with tip stability. And in due course instruction will be given down to a very much lower level, to chargehands and foremen".

When these assurances are implemented, the whole attitude in relation to tip stability should soon become dramatically altered. To ensure this, urgent consideration should be given to the appointment of civil engineers to the Inspectorate.

292. Viewing with considerable sympathy, as we do, the difficult position in which the Merthyr Tydfil Borough Council has found itself for many years in its dealings with the National Coal Board, we recommend adoption of the suggestion advanced by Mr. Wardell that, should a local planning authority be dissatisfied about the stability of an existing or proposed tip after consideration of all the available information, the matter should be submitted to the Minister of Power with a request for a special investigation and report. Mr. Wardell continued:

"If the Minister were satisfied that a prima facie case had been made out for further enquiry, it is suggested that the Minister should appoint an independent expert to conduct such an enquiry. The independent expert would require full authority to obtain access to all documents, plans, surveys and other information in possession either of the Board or the Local Authority and to any of their officials or employees concerned with tipping. He would also need to have authority to make his own inspection of the tip site or sites concerned and to require the Board or its agents to carry out additional investigations such as boreholes, trial pits, surveys, soil tests, etc., which he may require.

In making his report the appointed expert should include recommendations as to whether:

(a) refuse disposal on an existing tip should cease permanently or be suspended until satisfactory investigations had been completed;

(b) in the case of a proposed new tip, whether the site was suitable for a tip or could be made suitable provided that certain specified precautions were taken; and

(c) in the case of an inactive tip, what action, if any, should be taken to render it safe".

293. However well qualified and diligent the higher ranks of officials may be, the ultimate control and management of coal tips must rest upon the shoulders of those employed at Unit level. Never again must there be officials and men in a colliery as ignorant of the basic elements of tip stability as Mr. Wynne (manager), Mr. Vivian Thomas (Unit mechanical engineer), and Mr. Leslie Davies (tip chargehand). We therefore recommend adoption of the following suggestions made by Mr. Lynden James on behalf of the National Union of Mineworkers regarding their future education and training:

(1) Present managers and surveyors should as soon as possible receive training in ground-water conditions and the rudiments of soil mechanics so as to be able to appreciate the significance of the reports of, and opinions expressed by, the experts in these subjects.

(2) The statutory qualifications for managers and surveyors should in future include awareness of the elements of soil mechanics and hydrogeology, in addition to the geology which is already comprised in the syllabus.

(3) The Unit Mechanical Engineer and chargehand should be instructed in the significance of tip deformation and of the appearance or disappearance of water-courses. In addition, the chargehand should be trained to record at frequent intervals on a pro-forma a simple questionnaire dealing with such matters as toe-movement, crest-sinking, cracks and breaks. These records should be kept at the Unit Office and inspected regularly by the manager and mechanical engineer. They should also be produced to the civil engineer charged with tip responsibility and to Her Majesty's Inspectors of Mines on the occasion of each visit to the tip.

294. Finally, we repeat the view expressed earlier (paragraph 284) that the National Coal Board should forthwith examine afresh its lines of communication so as to ensure that essential knowledge passes easily and automatically to those whose business it is to become possessed of it and to eliminate those breakdowns and omissions which undoubtedly played a big part in bringing about the Aberfan disaster.

295. We turn to consider the amending legislation which is called for. We naturally refrain from doing more than indicate the topics which in our judgment need to be dealt with, for the best method of achieving what we think should be arrived at will need detailed consideration hereafter:

(1) The ambit of the Mines and Quarries Act, 1954, is restricted by its long title to "the management and control of mines and quarries and for securing the safety health and welfare of persons employed thereat; to regulate the employment thereat of women and young persons; to require the fencing of abandoned and disused mines and of quarries; and for purposes connected with the matters aforesaid". Apart, therefore, from s. 151, which requires a disused mineshaft to be "provided with an efficient enclosure, barrier, plug, or other device so designed and constructed as to prevent any person from accidentally falling down the shaft," there is no requirement on the owners or manager of a mine to have regard to the safety of the general public. It follows that there is no obligation on the Inspectorate of Mines, in the exercise of its powers of securing the enforcement of the Act, to have regard to the safety of the general public. Indeed, s. 146 (1) which gives power to the Inspector to serve a notice for prohibiting or changing "any matter, thing, or practice at a mine" which "is or is likely shortly to become dangerous" repeats the limitation to the safety of persons employed at the mine. We recommend that this limitation in the Act be removed and that the owners and managers of mines, and also the Inspectorate of Mines, should be required to consider the safety, health, and welfare of all persons going about their lawful business in the vicinity of a mine, including the safety of their property. We have already indicated (ante paragraph 74) our view of the civil liability of mine owners to pay damages under the rule in Rylands v. Fletcher, but the disaster at Aberfan clearly indicates that substantially more is required to give that protection to the public which it is every citizen's right to expect.

(2) Section 86 of the Mines and Quarries Act, 1954, ("All buildings and structures on the surface of a mine shall be kept in safe condition") should be amended so as to eliminate any doubt whether tips are "structures" within the meaning of the Section.

(3) A duty should be imposed upon the manager to take such steps to obtain necessary information in relation to the tipping process as Section 48(2) of the Act requires him to take in relation to matters pertinent to the support of working places.

(4) Using the power vested in him by Section 117(1) of the Act, the Minister should make an Order extending the Mines (Notification of Dangerous Occurrences) Order, 1959 (S.I. 1959, No. 2117) to tip slides and fires, "whether death or serious bodily injury is thereby caused or not", thereby ensuring that they are reported in accordance with Section 116 "forthwith . . . to the Inspector for the District . .

(5) In order to ensure compliance with Section 86 in the amended form which we have suggested in (1) above, statutory provision should be made for regular inspections of all tips by persons competent to judge of their stability and safety and for the due recording of the nature, extent, and result of such inspections.

(6) In addition, all tips (whether active or disused) should be subject to regular inspections by Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Mines and Quarries, whose resultant detailed reports should be published or otherwise made freely available to the local authorities concerned.

(7) A statutory obligation should be imposed upon the owners and managers of mines to maintain and keep at the mine office an up-to-date plan of the surface area of the undertaking, to include the tipping area and contoured once the tip exceeds a height to be prescribed — say, at 20 feet.

(8) The starting of a new tip or extension of an existing tip complex should be prohibited unless preceded by an adequate site investigation (i.e. in accordance with the normal Civil Engineer Code of Practice or the proposed new Code referred to earlier) and the submission to and approval by Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Mines of a tipping plan.

(9) The existing Town and Country Planning Acts require to be amended so as to vest local planning authorities with greater control over the starting of new tips or the extension of existing ones. As to new sites, we favour the suggestion made by Sir Andrew Bryan that these should not be started until a report as to the suitability of the tipping scheme has been submitted to and approved by the planning authority. As to the continued use of an existing tipping site, we recommend that the General Development Order, 1963, be revised by adding to Col. (2) of Class XIX (3) a condition that such continued use after a given date (say, January 1st, 1969) be subject to the production of a similar report prepared by persons professionally qualified and satisfactory to the planning authority. If an impasse arises, the dispute should be submitted to the appropriate Minister and he should be vested with power to refer to an independent expert in the manner set out in paragraph 292 above. Provision should be made enabling the Minister to exclude, in a proper case, any claim for compensation if in the ultimate result permission to tip or to continue tipping is withheld or refused on grounds of safety.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page


mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z